Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

NFL Week 10

Featured Replies

Can we play Beck now?

Lemon actually had an awesome day. It's Marty Booker I'd be bitching.

But there's no reason to start Lemon, and every reason to start Beck. The team needs to know if he is viable.

 

My gut is telling me that Cameron doesn't want to start Beck because he knows that in-game experience will prove that he's not NFL capable. Then, he'll come under even more fire for wasting the first two picks of last year's draft.

Can we play Beck now?

Lemon actually had an awesome day. It's Marty Booker I'd be bitching.

But there's no reason to start Lemon, and every reason to start Beck. The team needs to know if he is viable.

 

My gut is telling me that Cameron doesn't want to start Beck because he knows that in-game experience will prove that he's not NFL capable. Then, he'll come under even more fire for wasting the first two picks of last year's draft.

 

Tis my feeling, too.

Can we play Beck now?

Lemon actually had an awesome day. It's Marty Booker I'd be bitching.

But there's no reason to start Lemon, and every reason to start Beck. The team needs to know if he is viable.

 

My gut is telling me that Cameron doesn't want to start Beck because he knows that in-game experience will prove that he's not NFL capable. Then, he'll come under even more fire for wasting the first two picks of last year's draft.

If Beck started that game, our touchdown doesn't happen. 90% of Lemon's passes were right on the money.

We still lost, besides, who are we kidding, I really dont care if the Dolphins win or lose, this season is done. I want to see our future.

Can we play Beck now?

Lemon actually had an awesome day. It's Marty Booker I'd be bitching.

But there's no reason to start Lemon, and every reason to start Beck. The team needs to know if he is viable.

 

My gut is telling me that Cameron doesn't want to start Beck because he knows that in-game experience will prove that he's not NFL capable. Then, he'll come under even more fire for wasting the first two picks of last year's draft.

If Beck started that game, our touchdown doesn't happen. 90% of Lemon's passes were right on the money.

Who the hell cares if 90% of Lemon's passes were on the money? We need to know if Beck's passes will be on the money. By next season he will be 27. At that age, if he's not immediately productive, then picking him was a waste. We need to know whether that's the case, so if it is, we can pick someone else this draft.

If you think Beck isnt good enough to get the team a TD, then you need another new QB

Our QB was good enough to win that game today. Its our receivers who were not. Look past the first dimension.

 

Can we play Beck now?

Lemon actually had an awesome day. It's Marty Booker I'd be bitching.

But there's no reason to start Lemon, and every reason to start Beck. The team needs to know if he is viable.

 

My gut is telling me that Cameron doesn't want to start Beck because he knows that in-game experience will prove that he's not NFL capable. Then, he'll come under even more fire for wasting the first two picks of last year's draft.

If Beck started that game, our touchdown doesn't happen. 90% of Lemon's passes were right on the money.

Who the hell cares if 90% of Lemon's passes were on the money? We need to know if Beck's passes will be on the money. By next season he will be 27. At that age, if he's not immediately productive, then picking him was a waste. We need to know whether that's the case, so if it is, we can pick someone else this draft.

While I agree with you that Beck should be starting, if he comes out and sucks in his first game, that doesn't mean we automatically need to get Brohm. Still, we should be trying to get as much of a read as we can in the second half of the year. But on the other side of the coin, it would be pretty unfair to bench Lemon after that kind of outing.

If you think Beck isnt good enough to get the team a TD, then you need another new QB

Our QB was good enough to win that game today. Its our receivers who were not. Look past the first dimension.

:banghead

 

Why care if we win this game? The only way your stance makes sense for the future of the franchise is if you think Lemon can be a long term option at quarterback. Don't tell me that's the case...

that was a tough game, the browns looked like a real rival for once.

 

ben was in a position to bring his team back and he did just that, with a QB like that and a team like this we have a good chance of competing against the pats.

If you think Beck isnt good enough to get the team a TD, then you need another new QB

Our QB was good enough to win that game today. Its our receivers who were not. Look past the first dimension.

:banghead

 

Why care if we win this game? The only way your stance makes sense for the future of the franchise is if you think Lemon can be a long term option at quarterback. Don't tell me that's the case...

Read up a post. How many times did you hear Cameron say he's going to play the guy that gives him the best chance to win, whether it's right or wrong? Right now, Lemon gives this team the best chance to win, meaningless or not and you don't take the starting job away from a guy after he does everything right, no matter if you have the next Dan Marino waiting in the wings. So I'd get used to Lemon behind center for the rest of the year. Beck might play against the Bengals but I highly doubt we see him before then.

 

Beck aside, Lemon had an excellent day throwing the ball and I really wish we would have given the guy more of a chance. He has starting QB potential.

If you think Beck isnt good enough to get the team a TD, then you need another new QB

Our QB was good enough to win that game today. Its our receivers who were not. Look past the first dimension.

:banghead

 

Why care if we win this game? The only way your stance makes sense for the future of the franchise is if you think Lemon can be a long term option at quarterback. Don't tell me that's the case...

Read up a post. How many times did you hear Cameron say he's going to play the guy that gives him the best chance to win, whether it's right or wrong? Right now, Lemon gives this team the best chance to win, meaningless or not. So I'd get used to Lemon behind center for the rest of the year. You might see Beck against the Bengals but I highly doubt we see him before then.

If that's the case, then Cameron needs to go. As impressed as I am with the work he's done with the offensive line, we can't have someone who will continue making bad decisions for the future of the franchise. Gambling with the future so he can choose a mediocre option now that might give the team an extra win in an irrelevant season is unacceptable.

If you think Beck isnt good enough to get the team a TD, then you need another new QB

Our QB was good enough to win that game today. Its our receivers who were not. Look past the first dimension.

:banghead

 

Why care if we win this game? The only way your stance makes sense for the future of the franchise is if you think Lemon can be a long term option at quarterback. Don't tell me that's the case...

Read up a post. How many times did you hear Cameron say he's going to play the guy that gives him the best chance to win, whether it's right or wrong? Right now, Lemon gives this team the best chance to win, meaningless or not. So I'd get used to Lemon behind center for the rest of the year. You might see Beck against the Bengals but I highly doubt we see him before then.

If that's the case, then Cameron needs to go. As impressed as I am with the work he's done with the offensive line, we can't have someone who will continue making bad decisions for the future of the franchise. Gambling with the future so he can choose a mediocre option now that might give the team an extra win in an irrelevant season is unacceptable.

He's becoming a more reliable option with every snap. For evidence, see our TD drive. But I digress. He has no future with us because we were too stupid to get him this kind of playing time a few years ago.

  • Author

If you think Beck isnt good enough to get the team a TD, then you need another new QB

Our QB was good enough to win that game today. Its our receivers who were not. Look past the first dimension.

 

Can we play Beck now?

Lemon actually had an awesome day. It's Marty Booker I'd be bitching.

But there's no reason to start Lemon, and every reason to start Beck. The team needs to know if he is viable.

 

My gut is telling me that Cameron doesn't want to start Beck because he knows that in-game experience will prove that he's not NFL capable. Then, he'll come under even more fire for wasting the first two picks of last year's draft.

If Beck started that game, our touchdown doesn't happen. 90% of Lemon's passes were right on the money.

Who the hell cares if 90% of Lemon's passes were on the money? We need to know if Beck's passes will be on the money. By next season he will be 27. At that age, if he's not immediately productive, then picking him was a waste. We need to know whether that's the case, so if it is, we can pick someone else this draft.

While I agree with you that Beck should be starting, if he comes out and sucks in his first game, that doesn't mean we automatically need to get Brohm. Still, we should be trying to get as much of a read as we can in the second half of the year. But on the other side of the coin, it would be pretty unfair to bench Lemon after that kind of outing.

 

You said if Beck started the TD doesnt happen. Did you mean that TD, he wouldnt have run for a TD or if Beck was in they would score ZERO TDs because thats a big difference. Saying your QB was good enough to win the game has nothing to do with my question.

If you think Beck isnt good enough to get the team a TD, then you need another new QB

Our QB was good enough to win that game today. Its our receivers who were not. Look past the first dimension.

 

Can we play Beck now?

Lemon actually had an awesome day. It's Marty Booker I'd be bitching.

But there's no reason to start Lemon, and every reason to start Beck. The team needs to know if he is viable.

 

My gut is telling me that Cameron doesn't want to start Beck because he knows that in-game experience will prove that he's not NFL capable. Then, he'll come under even more fire for wasting the first two picks of last year's draft.

If Beck started that game, our touchdown doesn't happen. 90% of Lemon's passes were right on the money.

Who the hell cares if 90% of Lemon's passes were on the money? We need to know if Beck's passes will be on the money. By next season he will be 27. At that age, if he's not immediately productive, then picking him was a waste. We need to know whether that's the case, so if it is, we can pick someone else this draft.

While I agree with you that Beck should be starting, if he comes out and sucks in his first game, that doesn't mean we automatically need to get Brohm. Still, we should be trying to get as much of a read as we can in the second half of the year. But on the other side of the coin, it would be pretty unfair to bench Lemon after that kind of outing.

 

You said if Beck started the TD doesnt happen. Did you mean that TD, he wouldnt have run for a TD or if Beck was in they would score ZERO TDs because thats a big difference. Saying your QB was good enough to win the game has nothing to do with my question.

I don't believe Beck would be able to sustain a drive like Lemon did numerous times today with that kind of pressure in his face. So to answer your question, no. If Beck started today, I don't believe we would have scored a touchdown.

Beck aside, Lemon had an excellent day throwing the ball and I really wish we would have given the guy more of a chance. He has starting QB potential.

If you think Lemon can be a starting QB, you're sentencing this team to mediocrity for as long as he sets up behind center.

If you think Beck isnt good enough to get the team a TD, then you need another new QB

Our QB was good enough to win that game today. Its our receivers who were not. Look past the first dimension.

 

Can we play Beck now?

Lemon actually had an awesome day. It's Marty Booker I'd be bitching.

But there's no reason to start Lemon, and every reason to start Beck. The team needs to know if he is viable.

 

My gut is telling me that Cameron doesn't want to start Beck because he knows that in-game experience will prove that he's not NFL capable. Then, he'll come under even more fire for wasting the first two picks of last year's draft.

If Beck started that game, our touchdown doesn't happen. 90% of Lemon's passes were right on the money.

Who the hell cares if 90% of Lemon's passes were on the money? We need to know if Beck's passes will be on the money. By next season he will be 27. At that age, if he's not immediately productive, then picking him was a waste. We need to know whether that's the case, so if it is, we can pick someone else this draft.

While I agree with you that Beck should be starting, if he comes out and sucks in his first game, that doesn't mean we automatically need to get Brohm. Still, we should be trying to get as much of a read as we can in the second half of the year. But on the other side of the coin, it would be pretty unfair to bench Lemon after that kind of outing.

 

You said if Beck started the TD doesnt happen. Did you mean that TD, he wouldnt have run for a TD or if Beck was in they would score ZERO TDs because thats a big difference. Saying your QB was good enough to win the game has nothing to do with my question.

 

Someone please explain to me how Cleo Lemon gives us a better chance to win a game than John Beck? Lemon has never won an NFL game and has looked medicore at the very best in his opportunities. I'm not saying that John Beck is even good, but how does anyone know??? This was the best possible game to start him, coming off a bye, at home, against an average defense. I understand that Booker dropped a bunch of passes today, but the bottom line is that he produced 10 points. If you take out the two points he gave up by double pumping in his own endzone, than his net production on the day is 8 points. For an NFL starting QB that is completely unacceptable. You drafted Beck with the intention that he was going to be the starter at some point....meaning you think he was going to be better than any other QB on your roster. To not start him at 0-8 coming off the bye week at home was moronic when the decision was made earlier in the week and looks even more idiotic now. Add to the fact that this franchise MUST find out what they have now to avoid making another mistake in April....I'm just at a loss for words to describe what a terrible decision this was....no matter how Cleo played today.

 

I hate this organization....most people complain about the Marlins and their cheap ways and trading their stars, etc. but at least they have a plan. This franchise is directionless and visionless and will continue to be the worst team in the league (by far with a widening gap) until someone in the organization realizes that just trying to fool the public into believing they are a couple of players away from the playoffs is the absolute wrong thing to do.

 

Okay, done ranting....

OK, I only watched the 2nd half because I was on call today, but you have to be kidding me with this Lemon stuff. He did next to nothing out there. We completed like one ball downfield. Not making any mistakes is NOT the same as having a great game. Besides, Lemon took a bad safety (why may have cost us the game), and later missed a wide open Ginn streaking downfield for what should've been a TD. Lemon is a big fan of the 4 yard pass, and that's why we average about 4 yards a pass when he's in there. Are we so hard up for good quarterbacking down here that we're willing to accept this mediocrity instead of at least giving our future a chance? Screw Lemon. We owe him nothing. I like the guy plenty, but the franchise has to come before Lemon, and putting Beck in there is what is good for the franchise. Lemon is a caretaker at best; he will never be a playmaker, and no one is winning in the NFL today with a caretaker at QB.

 

I'm with you fauowls. Right now the incompetence being displayed by this organization is making me angry. This decision to keep Beck off the field is just blatantly stupid.

OK, I only watched the 2nd half because I was on call today, but you have to be kidding me with this Lemon stuff. He did next to nothing out there. We completed like one ball downfield. Not making any mistakes is NOT the same as having a great game. Besides, Lemon took a bad safety (why may have cost us the game), and later missed a wide open Ginn streaking downfield for what should've been a TD. Lemon is a big fan of the 4 yard pass, and that's why we average about 4 yards a pass when he's in there. Are we so hard up for good quarterbacking down here that we're willing to accept this mediocrity instead of at least giving our future a chance? Screw Lemon. We owe him nothing. I like the guy plenty, but the franchise has to come before Lemon, and putting Beck in there is what is good for the franchise. Lemon is a caretaker at best; he will never be a playmaker, and no one is winning in the NFL today with a caretaker at QB.

 

I'm with you fauowls. Right now the incompetence being displayed by this organization is making me angry. This decision to keep Beck off the field is just blatantly stupid.

So Lemon didn't score that touchdown almost completely on his own? He didn't have pressure in his face all day long and still sustained drives and threw accurate balls? He doesn't execute Cameron's offense well? And Beck will? Right away? Please.

 

When Beck finally starts, you'll be screaming at your televisions, begging for Lemon.

OK, I only watched the 2nd half because I was on call today, but you have to be kidding me with this Lemon stuff. He did next to nothing out there. We completed like one ball downfield. Not making any mistakes is NOT the same as having a great game. Besides, Lemon took a bad safety (why may have cost us the game), and later missed a wide open Ginn streaking downfield for what should've been a TD. Lemon is a big fan of the 4 yard pass, and that's why we average about 4 yards a pass when he's in there. Are we so hard up for good quarterbacking down here that we're willing to accept this mediocrity instead of at least giving our future a chance? Screw Lemon. We owe him nothing. I like the guy plenty, but the franchise has to come before Lemon, and putting Beck in there is what is good for the franchise. Lemon is a caretaker at best; he will never be a playmaker, and no one is winning in the NFL today with a caretaker at QB.

 

I'm with you fauowls. Right now the incompetence being displayed by this organization is making me angry. This decision to keep Beck off the field is just blatantly stupid.

So Lemon didn't score that touchdown almost completely on his own? He didn't have pressure in his face all day long and still sustained drives and threw accurate balls? He doesn't execute Cameron's offense well? And Beck will? Right away? Please.

 

When Beck finally starts, you'll be screaming at your televisions, begging for Lemon.

 

And we probably will. But at least we'll know that we have to draft a QB with the first pick in the draft. Not playing Beck right now only hurts this team going forward. Lemon is not the long term answer. We all know that. We need to know if Beck is that answer and having him sit on his ass every Sunday is not what he should be doing.

I don't see why any of you are supporting Lemon.

 

Wow, he 'almost' completed several passes that were dropped.

Amazing, he was able to use his widdle feet to score a TD.

Outstanding, he handed the ball off to the person who was most productive today.

Great, he was under center when we ran off long drives thanks to his RB.

 

So Cleo Lemon isn't screwing up...but that isn't the same thing as him looking good.

 

Carrying it further, you can also highlight several things that he 'didn't do':

 

He didn't complete many easy passes, regardless of drops

He didn't personally make any 'big' plays

He didn't show anything more than average accuracy and pocket presence

He didn't lead his team to a victory, or even a tie.

 

And anyway, you look at all the definitively awful things he did today:

 

1) Pump fake a guy 4 feet away from him in OUR own end zone

2) Take a safety in said end zone when he could have done one of many things (spike it, roll out, throw it away, etc)

3) Tripped on multiple dropbacks.

4) Couldn't convert in the clutch, given three opportunities to gain six yards.

 

 

I'm not concerned whether Beck would have done better (or worse) than Cleo today. I'm concerned that Cleo is not showing any reason why he CAN be a productive starting quarterback in this league. Lack of mistakes does not equal quality.

OK, I only watched the 2nd half because I was on call today, but you have to be kidding me with this Lemon stuff. He did next to nothing out there. We completed like one ball downfield. Not making any mistakes is NOT the same as having a great game. Besides, Lemon took a bad safety (why may have cost us the game), and later missed a wide open Ginn streaking downfield for what should've been a TD. Lemon is a big fan of the 4 yard pass, and that's why we average about 4 yards a pass when he's in there. Are we so hard up for good quarterbacking down here that we're willing to accept this mediocrity instead of at least giving our future a chance? Screw Lemon. We owe him nothing. I like the guy plenty, but the franchise has to come before Lemon, and putting Beck in there is what is good for the franchise. Lemon is a caretaker at best; he will never be a playmaker, and no one is winning in the NFL today with a caretaker at QB.

 

I'm with you fauowls. Right now the incompetence being displayed by this organization is making me angry. This decision to keep Beck off the field is just blatantly stupid.

So Lemon didn't score that touchdown almost completely on his own? He didn't have pressure in his face all day long and still sustained drives and threw accurate balls? He doesn't execute Cameron's offense well? And Beck will? Right away? Please.

 

When Beck finally starts, you'll be screaming at your televisions, begging for Lemon.

 

Do you work for in the Dolphins front office?? Because this post is about as short-sighted as they are. I couldn't care less how bad Beck looks or how many games we lose this year. That isn't the point. It is about finding out how to proceed at the most important position on the team...the position the Dolphins have neglected for a decade. Cleo Lemon is not and never will be a good starting QB in the NFL. Beck has a chance to be. It's time to find out if he can or draft someone how can be next year. As it is, they are setting the franchise back YEARS by not finding out what they spent a 2nd rounder on. Keeping Beck off the field at this point is unacceptable.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.