July 10, 200818 yr Awesome game by Olsen and Hanley. Hanley should have been the second poll option...
July 10, 200818 yr Btw, why is John Baker on the poll? :confused He called a great game. so that gets him in over Hanley (3 hits and a HR), Jacobs (multi hit game...GW 2 run HR), or even Gregg...who got, basically, 4 outs in a situation where he was only called to get a 2 out save? I've never seen Matt Treanor up there when he "calls a great game."
July 10, 200818 yr Btw, why is John Baker on the poll? :confused He called a great game. so that gets him in over Hanley (3 hits and a HR), Jacobs (multi hit game...GW 2 run HR), or even Gregg...who got, basically, 4 outs in a situation where he was only called to get a 2 out save? I've never seen Matt Treanor up there when he "calls a great game." I didn't say Hanley shouldn't be there. But Matt Treanor isn't a rookie making is ML debut, calling a great game and bring in an insurance RBI.
July 10, 200818 yr Btw, why is John Baker on the poll? :confused He called a great game. so that gets him in over Hanley (3 hits and a HR), Jacobs (multi hit game...GW 2 run HR), or even Gregg...who got, basically, 4 outs in a situation where he was only called to get a 2 out save? I've never seen Matt Treanor up there when he "calls a great game." I didn't say Hanley shouldn't be there. But Matt Treanor isn't a rookie making is ML debut, calling a great game and bring in an insurance RBI. If Hanley, Jacobs, or Gregg don't even get their names listed...John Baker shouldn't be listed either for "calling a great game" and getting an insurance run on a sac fly...
July 10, 200818 yr Btw, why is John Baker on the poll? :confused He called a great game. so that gets him in over Hanley (3 hits and a HR), Jacobs (multi hit game...GW 2 run HR), or even Gregg...who got, basically, 4 outs in a situation where he was only called to get a 2 out save? I've never seen Matt Treanor up there when he "calls a great game." I didn't say Hanley shouldn't be there. But Matt Treanor isn't a rookie making is ML debut, calling a great game and bring in an insurance RBI. If Hanley, Jacobs, or Gregg don't even get their names listed...John Baker shouldn't be listed either for "calling a great game" and getting an insurance run on a sac fly... You gotta give some weight for it being his ML debut. But I agree that Hanley should have been on the list.
July 10, 200818 yr Scotty was on, let's put a few more of these starts together with JJ and Volstad. Freddi should of put him out for the ninth. The pen almost blew another one. Really?? The pen came out for one inning and had to get 5 outs. So how did they almost blow it??
July 10, 200818 yr Btw, why is John Baker on the poll? :confused He called a great game. so that gets him in over Hanley (3 hits and a HR), Jacobs (multi hit game...GW 2 run HR), or even Gregg...who got, basically, 4 outs in a situation where he was only called to get a 2 out save? I've never seen Matt Treanor up there when he "calls a great game." I didn't say Hanley shouldn't be there. But Matt Treanor isn't a rookie making is ML debut, calling a great game and bring in an insurance RBI. If Hanley, Jacobs, or Gregg don't even get their names listed...John Baker shouldn't be listed either for "calling a great game" and getting an insurance run on a sac fly... You gotta give some weight for it being his ML debut. But I agree that Hanley should have been on the list. Baker sure was looking to the dugout alot during the game. And it wasn't like Scotty was just taking what he was signalling all the time. Heck, at least once I saw Scotty signal to him. He went 0-3 with a sac fly. The best I can say about him is that he wasn't unimpressive. Looked better behind the plate than he did in ST, but Scotty isn't exactly the hardest guy to catch for. I'm going to hold out my opinion on what is basically our last option at catcher for a call up in an emergency situation. Let's see how he does when we need an octopus behind the plate with a guy like Miller pitching one of his off games. Or if he gets blamed on the boards for the passed balls like our other catchers have been blamed. I get the feeling he won't be.
July 10, 200818 yr Author Btw, why is John Baker on the poll? :confused He called a great game. so that gets him in over Hanley (3 hits and a HR), Jacobs (multi hit game...GW 2 run HR), or even Gregg...who got, basically, 4 outs in a situation where he was only called to get a 2 out save? I've never seen Matt Treanor up there when he "calls a great game." I didn't say Hanley shouldn't be there. But Matt Treanor isn't a rookie making is ML debut, calling a great game and bring in an insurance RBI. If Hanley, Jacobs, or Gregg don't even get their names listed...John Baker shouldn't be listed either for "calling a great game" and getting an insurance run on a sac fly... You gotta give some weight for it being his ML debut. But I agree that Hanley should have been on the list. Baker sure was looking to the dugout alot during the game. And it wasn't like Scotty was just taking what he was signalling all the time. Heck, at least once I saw Scotty signal to him. He went 0-3 with a sac fly. The best I can say about him is that he wasn't unimpressive. Looked better behind the plate than he did in ST, but Scotty isn't exactly the hardest guy to catch for. I'm going to hold out my opinion on what is basically our last option at catcher for a call up in an emergency situation. Let's see how he does when we need an octopus behind the plate with a guy like Miller pitching one of his off games. Or if he gets blamed on the boards for the passed balls like our other catchers have been blamed. I get the feeling he won't be. You have a feeling he wont be blamed? same. The guy showed the Marlins that he has the ability to make contact with the ball that in itself is better than what the rest have done. Now he's no Matt Treanor yet, but I have bigger expectations for this guy then I did Hoover... Rabelo is just a bust :|
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.