Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

July 21st Lineup?

Featured Replies

Anyone want to make predictions about the position players that will be starting for the fish from 7/21?

 

My guess is:

 

C: Baker

1B: Logan Morrison

2B: Uggla

3B: Cantu

SS: Ramirez

LF: Hermida

CF: Maybin

RF: Ross

 

And look the f*** out.

C: Baker

1B: Cantu

2B: Uggla

3B: Bonifacio

SS: Ramirez

LF: Hermida

CF: Maybin

RF: Ross

 

Book it.

C: Baker

1B: Morrison

2B: Bonnie

3B: Cantu

SS: Ramirez

LF: Hermida

CF: Maybin

RF: Ross

 

How 'bout it?

C: Baker

1B: Morrison

2B: Bonnie

3B: Cantu

SS: Ramirez

LF: Hermida

CF: Maybin

RF: Ross

 

How 'bout it?

If the Marlins trade Uggla, it basically signifies that the season is over and they aren't contending (especially a week and a half before the deadline as this hypothetical says), so you'd expect Ross to be shipped out also and another OF slot to be given to Raynor/Carroll/Jai/maybe Cousins or Petersen to see if any of them bring anything to the table for 2010. Also, they would ABSOLUTELY NOT be wasting Morrison's arbitration clock in a non contending situation, in the unlikely event he comes up with the team this year for an extended period.

 

Longterm payroll obligations basically show the Marlins can afford Hanley + 2 arbitration cases in 2010, so you'd expect Cantu to be one as the team has a black hole at 3B with Dominguez projected for mid 2011-2012 in a best case scenario, and McPherson now gone. The other is one of the outfielders for sure (as Uggla is going to make over $7 million and we have Coghlan/Bonifacio in the wings). I say this because I took out Ross in the first paragraph, but it could be Hermida in a team falling apart situation. It would probably come down to 'smartest deal,' but I just naturally defer to Hermida's upside in hypotheticals.

 

If that happens, I'd suspect this was the positional lineup. Amezaga would certainly be traded in addition to the ones mentioned above.

 

C - Baker

1B - G. Sanchez

2B - Bonifacio/Coghlan

SS - Hanley

3B - Cantu

LF - Hermida

CF - Maybin

RF - Raynor/Carroll

B - Bonifacio/Coghlan, Raynor/Carroll, Helms, Gload, Paulino (if the team could trade Gload or Paulino they would, and call up probably Jai Miller for his last hurrah or Brett Hayes for the backup catcher slot)

 

----

 

I expect the team to be what Rabb said. Sanchez at 1B.

Anyone want to make predictions about the position players that will be starting for the fish from 7/21?

 

My guess is:

 

C: Baker

1B: Logan Morrison

2B: Uggla

3B: Cantu

SS: Ramirez

LF: Hermida

CF: Maybin

RF: Ross

 

And look the f*** out.

 

 

I actually have it the same exact way. Emilio sucks at third, Logan tears up Double A, slide Cantu back to third and it's on....I can also see the scenario of us being out of it and moving Uggla + Cantu or Ross.

If the Marlins trade Uggla, it basically signifies that the season is over and they aren't contending (especially a week and a half before the deadline as this hypothetical says), so you'd expect Ross to be shipped out also and another OF slot to be given to Raynor/Carroll/Jai/maybe Cousins or Petersen to see if any of them bring anything to the table for 2010. Also, they would ABSOLUTELY NOT be wasting Morrison's arbitration clock in a non contending situation, in the unlikely event he comes up with the team this year for an extended period.

 

Given the current economic climate, I could see a contending Marlins team still shedding salary, but promoting from within and making a couple of minor acquisitions to stay in it, similar to what Billy Beane has done at times in Oakland. With the positional talent in the organization, a contending Marlins team could move one of Uggla/Ross/Cantu/Hermida and still stay in contention. It's also possible that Uggla or Hermida could bring MLB-ready talent in return, so a trade might not be a salary dump.

 

So, even in the unlikely event that everyone in the lineup is healthy and performing well in a few months, I doubt we will see the same lineup.

Maybin

Baker

Ramirez

Cantu

Uggla

Ross

Morrison

Hermida

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.