Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Brett Carroll

Featured Replies

He made 2 plays last night that Hermida almost surely wouldn't make.

 

 

 

 

Yeah and he's shown plenty of pop vs LHP, i wouldn't mind if Hermida and BC were a platoon in RF.

Ok. He may be able to match hermida's overall production, but his bat is gonna hurt if he plays full time. He'll

be a moderate improvement over boner, so if you want to realign stuff so he is in over boner that's fine, but he shouldn't be starting over coghlan or hermida when he's nothing but a glove. He's one of the few guys on our team being consistently put in a situation to succeed and lo and behold when he's not being asked to do far too much, he's succeeding!

I still love people who want Carroll over Hermida.

 

It feels good to be loved. It is worth repeating, Carroll saves more runs with his defense than Hermida provides with his streaky hitting. No way Hermy makes the catch Brett made and Hermy doesn't even sniff throwing out Wigginton. The game is lost if Hermy was out there.

I still love people who want Carroll over Hermida.

 

It feels good to be loved. It is worth repeating, Carroll saves more runs with his defense than Hermida provides with his streaky hitting. No way Hermy makes the catch Brett made and Hermy doesn't even sniff throwing out Wigginton. The game is lost if Hermy was out there.

 

+1 :thumbup

 

I agree 100%.

Hermida is nothing more than a slightly below average MLB outfielder........Time for some of you to accept it.

 

He's not though.

Among starting corner OFers he is slightly below average.

I still love people who want Carroll over Hermida.

 

It feels good to be loved. It is worth repeating, Carroll saves more runs with his defense than Hermida provides with his streaky hitting. No way Hermy makes the catch Brett made and Hermy doesn't even sniff throwing out Wigginton. The game is lost if Hermy was out there.

 

I prefer when people say things and have more to back it up than 'my opinion! lolzhermierda sucks'. You got anything for me?

 

It's possible that Carroll puts up a .700 ops, but even that might be expecting too much from him. Either way, at eat it's a wash. It's not a question of replacing hermida, who is far from the weakes player in our lineup. How are people even focusing on him when we've got boner? If Carroll is to replace anyone that's who it should be, with coghlan at 3b, but then you are putting coghlan and Carroll in position to fail, one in the field the other at the plate.

 

Brett Carroll is the Robert andino of the outfield, and until he gets the chance to play everyday and fail, people are going to harbor dreams based on tiny amounts of success that aren't sustainable.

Coghaln in left, hermida/Carroll mini platoon in rf, gaby at 3rd.

 

I would do this but according to the guy who pulls Fredi's strings benching Bonifacio is not an option because he's fast... not sure what a mini platoon is. Just do a platoon and see what happens.

there's already a platoon going on (carroll v.s. LHP hermida v.s. RHP

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.