November 10, 200322 yr I still can wait. I want Dontrelle to win, Its going to be hard to win over Podsenik but he can do it. 12-6 record with a 3.36 ERA. 14-6. Not 12-6.
November 10, 200322 yr it should be Podsednick, then Webb. Willis will probably win though because of all the hype.
November 10, 200322 yr it should be Podsednick, then Webb. Willis will probably win though because of all the hype. You say it like Dontrelle is this horrible player that will never be at the level of Scott and Brandon, but wins it because he started with a bigger bang. If Dontrelle wins, it's because he deserves it. Not because of the hype.
November 10, 200322 yr i think that in the Al it should be either Gerut or Matsui In NL i think it should be Podsednik but dontrelle is close behind Podsednik broke tons of rookie records this year!!! NO DOUBT IT SHOULD BE HIM!!!
November 10, 200322 yr webb nor willis deserve it Yeap, that 2.84 ERA and 180/172 innings pitched/K ratio is not worthy.. oh yea and 140 hits in 180 innings isnt worthy as well.
November 10, 200322 yr i think that in the Al it should be either Gerut or Matsui In NL i think it should be Podsednik but dontrelle is close behind Podsednik broke tons of rookie records this year!!! NO DOUBT IT SHOULD BE HIM!!! records? You mean Brewer records right?
November 10, 200322 yr it should be Podsednick, then Webb. Willis will probably win though because of all the hype. You say it like Dontrelle is this horrible player that will never be at the level of Scott and Brandon, but wins it because he started with a bigger bang. If Dontrelle wins, it's because he deserves it. Not because of the hype. Dontrell had an amazing first half, but he didn't have nearly as good a year as Webb or Podsednick As for the AL, it should go to Gerut
November 10, 200322 yr I refuse to recognize Matsui as a rookie, plus IMO Berroa or Gerut deserve it more. But Matsui will win because he plays in New York :angry I thought Matsui's going to win it because he's a Japanese player like Ichiro (who both Japanese player who has reputations of being good player in Japan), who won AL ROY in 2001 (I think for some reason Japanese players who come over to play MLB after they file FA, and they play that they get the favor to be ROY forAL/NL)?
November 10, 200322 yr I give Brandon Webb plenty of love but he had his great success and struggles like Dontrelle did, so if I don't choose D-Train...why should I pick him? :mischief2
November 10, 200322 yr Author I give Brandon Webb plenty of love but he had his great success and struggles like Dontrelle did, so if I don't choose D-Train...why should I pick him? :mischief2 he did? well in his 28 games started, 24 of them he went atleast 6 and gave up 3 runs or less as for Dontrelle.. in his 27 games started, 19 of them he went atleast 6 and gave up 3 runs or less but seeing that i cant change some of your opinion.... i give up
November 10, 200322 yr but seeing that i cant change some of your opinion.... i give up Ok first off: Chill out Second off, I think you are taking this a little bit too hard :mischief2 You like Brandon Webb? Good. I hope that he wins ROY just for you. But I don't share in your opinion and thats what I'm sticking to.
November 10, 200322 yr Author dude, im as chilled out as you can get... im not yelling or anything, just trying to have a good argument
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.