June 3, 201016 yr all star voting should be like this... all the national league mangers vote in the national league starting lineups. all the american league managers vote in the starting line ups for the american league team, as well as the bench.. "THE FANS" should be able to vote in 3 players for each league ... 1 outfielder 1 infielder and 1 pitcher that way you get the right starters against each other and no players in there that come from a huge fan base but don't deserve to be in there.
June 4, 201016 yr all star voting should be like this... all the national league mangers vote in the national league starting lineups. all the american league managers vote in the starting line ups for the american league team, as well as the bench.. "THE FANS" should be able to vote in 3 players for each league ... 1 outfielder 1 infielder and 1 pitcher that way you get the right starters against each other and no players in there that come from a huge fan base but don't deserve to be in there. No Chance they take away fan voting for choosing the starters in the All Star Game. What they should do is control the voting. No more online voting and fans should be given a few ballots as they walk into the stadium or something like that where fans can't just pick up 100 ballots a game and vote for there teams players every game and the online factor should be taken away because you can vote pretty much infinite times with fake emails. It'll be really hard to control but fan voting needs to be put to a limit. I mean how can less then 2 months worth of voting result in over 400,000 votes for players?
June 4, 201016 yr all star voting should be like this... all the national league mangers vote in the national league starting lineups. all the american league managers vote in the starting line ups for the american league team, as well as the bench.. "THE FANS" should be able to vote in 3 players for each league ... 1 outfielder 1 infielder and 1 pitcher that way you get the right starters against each other and no players in there that come from a huge fan base but don't deserve to be in there. No Chance they take away fan voting for choosing the starters in the All Star Game. What they should do is control the voting. No more online voting and fans should be given a few ballots as they walk into the stadium or something like that where fans can't just pick up 100 ballots a game and vote for there teams players every game and the online factor should be taken away because you can vote pretty much infinite times with fake emails. It'll be really hard to control but fan voting needs to be put to a limit. I mean how can less then 2 months worth of voting result in over 400,000 votes for players? If this were the case, the high attendance parks would get the most vote-ins so it'd be pretty much the same as it is now.
June 4, 201016 yr all star voting should be like this... all the national league mangers vote in the national league starting lineups. all the american league managers vote in the starting line ups for the american league team, as well as the bench.. "THE FANS" should be able to vote in 3 players for each league ... 1 outfielder 1 infielder and 1 pitcher that way you get the right starters against each other and no players in there that come from a huge fan base but don't deserve to be in there. No Chance they take away fan voting for choosing the starters in the All Star Game. What they should do is control the voting. No more online voting and fans should be given a few ballots as they walk into the stadium or something like that where fans can't just pick up 100 ballots a game and vote for there teams players every game and the online factor should be taken away because you can vote pretty much infinite times with fake emails. It'll be really hard to control but fan voting needs to be put to a limit. I mean how can less then 2 months worth of voting result in over 400,000 votes for players? If this were the case, the high attendance parks would get the most vote-ins so it'd be pretty much the same as it is now. exactly that would make it even worse. if there were no online voting we'd probably never see a marlin start again. and like how it is now it would be like the worse all star game ever if all those phillies were starting.
June 4, 201016 yr I don't think fan voting needs to be eliminated entirely but they need to consider eliminating paper ballots at the stadium. The Phillies have been averaging attendance over 100% all season long, which leads me to think it's people showing up at the stadium stuffing the ballot. If you force Phillies fans to vote online, I suspect you wouldn't see people like Polanco leading in certain categories. So you want to punish teams that have good attendance? And/or are you saying fans of certain teams are too stupid to know how to vote online? I say just the opposite. Stop the online voting. And while we are at it.....Stop allowing online buying of playoff tickets (at the very least) for the first 6 hours or so of them going on sale at box offices. Again, something that dosen't affect me, but I don't think it's fair to those that actually go to the box offices early and wait in line only to be told the games have sold out. What? That logic makes no sense... it's not "punishing" them at all. Is the object of voting through the fans not to get the overall consenus of who the fans think should be an all-star? So if one fanbase has 10x the voice another fanbase has... then their opinions are weighted more. The idea would be to get everyones fair and balanced opinion. Because as a whole, the fans decide who starts at the all star game. Both are stupid. It is stupid that you can vote to infinity if you want as well. I dont see how that makes any sense. Vote as many times as you want? Okay.. so next presidential election... HEY EVERYBODY VOTE AS MANY TIMES AS YOU WANT!!! WHICHEVER POLITICAL PARTY HAS THE MOST DIEHARD FANS WINS!!! Retarded. Vote once. Period. Maybe once a day. Fine. It's not hard to stop people from multiple votes... unless of course that person wants to continuously use different computers, etc. whatever but for the most part 1 vote per day pretty much makes the majority of fans vote... only once. Like I said before though... fan voting should be limited. Give them only a portion of the overall ranking for the all stars. Yes it is. To think otherwise is just making excuses for our bad attendance. Or, probably more accuratetly, doing the AS voting on a curve to make up for our bad attendance. And you made no comment on the on line voting. Do you really think fans of the Marlins are so much smarter than fans of other teams when it comes to using a computer? It's a popularity contest. Always has been, always will be. Dosen't matter what it should be or is meant to be. This is what it is. So why should guys make the ASG when their own fan base could care in the least if they see them in person? Good attendance should have it's rewards. And bad attendance should have it's drawbacks. Marlins fans can change this by going to the extreme. Get up off the couch and go to the games. I have no idea how to stop fans from voting more than once in person. On line it can be done. And the Marlins even have a "rewards program" for turning in votes at the stadium. But once again, fans have to actually go the stadium. Probably not going to help very much.
June 4, 201016 yr In my opinion, online balloting should be taken away. I mean any old average joe can go on a computer use 50 different or fake emails and vote thousands of times for there favorite players. There needs to be some controlled way where fans can vote only once per game like giving them a ballot or a few ballots as they walk in the stadium and that being it because it is just getting out hand and the best player from their respective position should deserve to start in the All Star game. Maybe they should take voting away from the mix completely? Perhaps it should be based off of a performance score? I dunno... I really hate the idea of giving fans (a good 75% of which are ignorant) the right to vote. Oh wait... I made a funny . It shouldnt be email based. It should be IP based. The NBA at one point in time implemented this system where each computer has the ability to vote once per day. After voting you are unable to access the voting system for another 24 hours. This is not hard to get around if you are internet savvy, but for the most part it keeps almost all fans in check with voting. They probably got scared at the fact that they had significantly lower numbers than in baseball. Of the some 2 million or so balloted votes how many do you think are unique users? I'd guess less than 500,000... Maybe MLB fans should do something drastic... perhaps a "Vote for Rory" style act. Get Jorge Julio to the all-star game to show how stupid this system is. That's the only way it could be done without voting. But then it is completely stats based, something I am against because stats alone don't ever tell the whole story. Wouldn't bother me a bit to just do away with the ASG. I don't watch it anyways. I don't feel the need for an ego boost just because my team had more All Stars than another team. Or whatever. Still take the 3 days off. It's probably needed to re-energize. Maybe do a mid season FanFest or something. I like the "Vote For Rory" thing. At least it brought a smile to my face. But Julio wouldn't work. Pitchers aren't voted in. Maybe Jacobs.
June 4, 201016 yr Yes it is. To think otherwise is just making excuses for our bad attendance. Or, probably more accuratetly, doing the AS voting on a curve to make up for our bad attendance. And you made no comment on the on line voting. Do you really think fans of the Marlins are so much smarter than fans of other teams when it comes to using a computer? It's a popularity contest. Always has been, always will be. Dosen't matter what it should be or is meant to be. This is what it is. So why should guys make the ASG when their own fan base could care in the least if they see them in person? Good attendance should have it's rewards. And bad attendance should have it's drawbacks. Marlins fans can change this by going to the extreme. Get up off the couch and go to the games. I have no idea how to stop fans from voting more than once in person. On line it can be done. And the Marlins even have a "rewards program" for turning in votes at the stadium. But once again, fans have to actually go the stadium. Probably not going to help very much. How so? the whole idea of all-star voting is to get a fair bid on who the fans as a whole think should be going to the all-star game. While the Phillies voice should be in there a bit more than other fan bases (because more fans would vote) it should not be amplified to a level where it is 5 times as great as any fanbase because that's just not true. Since I love examples... pretend 50% of the Phillies fanbase voted while only 25% of the Marlins fanbase voted. Now pretend each Philly fan had an average number of votes of... 5. While the Marlins fans had an average vote of... 2. Now pretend there were 1000 Philly fans and 500 Marlin fans total. You'd hear the voice of 2.5 times the Philly fanbase and you'd hear the voice of the Marlins fanbase at .5 times the fanbase. You'd hear the already significantly larger Phillie fanbase at 5 times the amount you'd hear the Marlins fanbase. Because yes, we have more casual fans. That is the point though. This system only works for diehard fans who want to sit on their computer and create 15 emails and vote 25 times each. It's not making an excuse for our bad attendance either, it's rewarding the other team for having good attendance. That means they get more votes. But it shouldnt be that way because every single fan should only vote once! Why does it make sense that because more fans show up to their game the same guy can vote 7 times for Placido Polanco but since we have very poor attendance the Fish fan can only vote for Jorge Cantu once? Again, it's like throwing a presidential election and asking whichever political party can vote most gets their guy, even if the situation arose where everyone had only 1 vote were to occur it would have turned out the other way. Do you not honestly think that if every MLB fan had 1 vote Placido Polanco would not be leading his position? Or the entire Phillie infield for that matter? And no, it's not even a popularity contest. It's an attendance/test of fans contest. The Phillies fans showed up this year. Whatever fanbase can get the highest residual value according to their size wins it all! It'd be nice if it were a popularity contest. Because then every teams best player would go. Not the entire Phillies roster. Voting more than once is ridiculous, end of story. There are ways you can stop it, but the ASG would be much more serious if those methods were to take place. And I wish the ASG was more serious, becuase it's the only ASG in any sport that actually means something.
June 13, 201016 yr it's not even a popularity contest. It's an attendance/test of fans contest Actually, it's nothing but a rather large and rather bad joke. The politically correct idiocy of fan voting should be eliminated, as should, more importantly, ASG determination of WS home-field advantage. I won't hold my breath.
June 13, 201016 yr DICTIONARY DEFINITION: MLB ALL STAR GAME - a glorified exhibition game, completely almost meaningless but the fact of deciding home field for current year world series.
June 13, 201016 yr I don't see how the idiocy of ASG voting is any different than the idiocy of political elections, only in baseball you actually have stats for more astute voters to judge performances while in politics you have campaign promises. This is the American way.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.