August 8, 201016 yr Author Why does it always seem like at the end of year, we are switching out closers? Heck, it even dates back to 2003 when Urbina came in and sorta took over for Looper. This Fo just doesn't place that much priority on the bullpen when they have more to work with, much less when they have almost no payroll to work with. We did have Benitez in 2004 though, and he was awesome. That year, though, we had pretty much nobody at all to set him up, at least until we picked up Mota.
August 8, 201016 yr Edwin mentioned a possible switch at closer after the game, said they need to discuss it. It's good that they are discussing it, as it should be, but I need to clarify that the purpose of this thread is not to say that anybody else on this team should be closing. I honestly don't feel like there is a closer on this roster, much less a guy who would be much better than Leo. My criticisms of Leo are more because I don't think he is the guy long-term, and replacing him is one of the areas that this team should look at if it really expects a winner at some point. Musical chairs for the end of the year isn't gonna really fix that much. It's just an area that needs more consideration in the offseason, as we've seen what Leo's tendencies are in this role and they just aren't good enough to build a winner around. It's a matter of luck with the bullpen, really. A lot of people were against bringing in a Matt Capps or a Kevin Gregg in the offseason. That's pretty much the best you're going to find in free agency, and for that you might as well stay with what you have in the role, imo. Getting a good closer/building a good bullpen is probably done best, within the organization. I would also like to add that if you're taking Leo off the closer's role...he still has 26 saves, a solid ERA, solid WHIP, good K:BB rate...this would probably be a great time to put him on waivers, and see what you can get for him. Any team would want Leo Nunez in their bullpen. I'm not sure if the team has put anyone on waivers (they probably have), but putting the likes of Nunez, Cody, and a guy like Ohman on there makes some sense now.
August 8, 201016 yr Author Edwin mentioned a possible switch at closer after the game, said they need to discuss it. It's good that they are discussing it, as it should be, but I need to clarify that the purpose of this thread is not to say that anybody else on this team should be closing. I honestly don't feel like there is a closer on this roster, much less a guy who would be much better than Leo. My criticisms of Leo are more because I don't think he is the guy long-term, and replacing him is one of the areas that this team should look at if it really expects a winner at some point. Musical chairs for the end of the year isn't gonna really fix that much. It's just an area that needs more consideration in the offseason, as we've seen what Leo's tendencies are in this role and they just aren't good enough to build a winner around. It's a matter of luck with the bullpen, really. A lot of people were against bringing in a Matt Capps or a Kevin Gregg in the offseason. That's pretty much the best you're going to find in free agency, and for that you might as well stay with what you have in the role, imo. Getting a good closer/building a good bullpen is probably done best, within the organization. I would also like to add that if you're taking Leo off the closer's role...he still has 26 saves, a solid ERA, solid WHIP, good K:BB rate...this would probably be a great time to put him on waivers, and see what you can get for him. Any team would want Leo Nunez in their bullpen. I'm not sure if the team has put anyone on waivers (they probably have), but putting the likes of Nunez, Cody, and a guy like Ohman on there makes some sense now. Rafael Soriano. He was available, though his salary is probably out of our price range, theoretically we could have had him. Ideally I would have liked Leo in a setup role, where he is best suited. We've had him as closer for so long, though, that it's always awkward to demote a guy to a supposedly lesser role, and a lot of relievers don't respond well on the same team after being demoted. Maybe a trade would be whats best for everyone, but we still need guys like Leo in the bullpen (just not necessarily closer) because an entire bullpen of guys who can't touch 95 is bound to bend somewhere. Until Marinez and Ceda are ready, we don't have traditional setup/closer types anywhere in the pen if we deal Leo. I'd be happy for Leo if he got traded because I think he can be a great setup guy and could do well on a contender this year.
August 8, 201016 yr Edwin mentioned a possible switch at closer after the game, said they need to discuss it. It's good that they are discussing it, as it should be, but I need to clarify that the purpose of this thread is not to say that anybody else on this team should be closing. I honestly don't feel like there is a closer on this roster, much less a guy who would be much better than Leo. My criticisms of Leo are more because I don't think he is the guy long-term, and replacing him is one of the areas that this team should look at if it really expects a winner at some point. Musical chairs for the end of the year isn't gonna really fix that much. It's just an area that needs more consideration in the offseason, as we've seen what Leo's tendencies are in this role and they just aren't good enough to build a winner around. It's a matter of luck with the bullpen, really. A lot of people were against bringing in a Matt Capps or a Kevin Gregg in the offseason. That's pretty much the best you're going to find in free agency, and for that you might as well stay with what you have in the role, imo. Getting a good closer/building a good bullpen is probably done best, within the organization. I would also like to add that if you're taking Leo off the closer's role...he still has 26 saves, a solid ERA, solid WHIP, good K:BB rate...this would probably be a great time to put him on waivers, and see what you can get for him. Any team would want Leo Nunez in their bullpen. I'm not sure if the team has put anyone on waivers (they probably have), but putting the likes of Nunez, Cody, and a guy like Ohman on there makes some sense now. Rafael Soriano. He was available, though his salary is probably out of our price range, theoretically we could have had him. Ideally I would have liked Leo in a setup role, where he is best suited. We've had him as closer for so long, though, that it's always awkward to demote a guy to a supposedly lesser role, and a lot of relievers don't respond well on the same team after being demoted. Maybe a trade would be whats best for everyone, but we still need guys like Leo in the bullpen (just not necessarily closer) because an entire bullpen of guys who can't touch 95 is bound to bend somewhere. Until Marinez and Ceda are ready, we don't have traditional setup/closer types anywhere in the pen if we deal Leo. I'd be happy for Leo if he got traded because I think he can be a great setup guy and could do well on a contender this year. You've said that this team isn't going anywhere this year. I agree. If they plan on taking Leo out of the closer's role, why not trade him now while his value is probably at its highest? I think it makes sense now. At most, Leo will probably only be here for the rest of this year and next, if we decide to keep him. After that, I think he becomes a free agent, and we'd probably lose him for nothing. Leo's trade value is higher than Cody's, probably. We could get some young arms for these guys.
August 8, 201016 yr Blake Brewer is a kid with upside that I believe has been converted to reliever. Granted, he is still in the GCL but its something :lol Evan Reed, who the Fish got for Cantu, is a reliever, and I believe they are talking about turning the other player in that deal, Poveda, into a reliever as well as he is a ground ball machine. It has been alluded to that Rob Rasmussen, taken in the 2nd round this year, will be a power lefty out of the pen. There are also always players like Buente, Leroux, Parcell, Koehler, etc that have potential as relivers. This is above and beyond Ceda and Marinez and Tucker, etc.
August 8, 201016 yr Author There are also always players like Buente, Leroux, Parcell, Koehler, etc that have potential as relivers. These guys just don't really impress me. I think we'd be a lot better off as a team if some of these fringe bullpen prospects were able to help out, but guys like Wood, Leroux, and Buente just weren't able to do anything.
August 8, 201016 yr Financial move to remove Nunez from the closers role after a couple of recent struggles, to limit the amount of saves he gets which is a driving factor in regards to his salary for the 2011 season?
August 9, 201016 yr I like Chris Leroux a lot as a bullpen arm. That is all. me too. Guy has some really good stuff. In a short callup one or two outings can make you look bad, but I think over the long term he'll do quite well.
August 12, 201016 yr Although Nunez doesn't seem to have that closer killer instinct, he is somehow among the league leaders in saves. Although Kevin Gregg was total crap, he still over 30 saves his last season here(he has 25 this season and has only blown 4:blink:). Those two things lead me to the conclusion that saves are overrated.
August 12, 201016 yr Author Although Nunez doesn't seem to have that closer killer instinct, he is somehow among the league leaders in saves. Although Kevin Gregg was total crap, he still over 30 saves his last season here(he has 25 this season and has only blown 4:blink:). Those two things lead me to the conclusion that saves are overrated. Pretty much everyone can rack up saves if given enough opportunity. Having saves doesn't make a player good, though usually anyone picking up a good amount of saves would be better than your run of the mill reliever, a closer needs to be that good.
August 12, 201016 yr How many blown saves does Nunez have, 6? Billy Wagner and his 1.8 something ERA blew his 7th last night
August 12, 201016 yr Although Nunez doesn't seem to have that closer killer instinct, he is somehow among the league leaders in saves. Although Kevin Gregg was total crap, he still over 30 saves his last season here(he has 25 this season and has only blown 4:blink:). Those two things lead me to the conclusion that saves are overrated. Pretty much everyone can rack up saves if given enough opportunity. Having saves doesn't make a player good, though usually anyone picking up a good amount of saves would be better than your run of the mill reliever, a closer needs to be that good. That's not true, at all. A closer doesn't need to be that good. There are, at least, a handful of closers in the big leagues right now who are getting saves, and are just average, if not bad, relievers.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.