I know this will open up a can of worms, but I had to ask, because i'm interested in getting some feedback from some people other than the few I talk outside the site boards.

Yes only if its at a reasonable price.

Yes only if its at a reasonable price.

Well yes, but odds are it's not going to be a reasonable price (ie talks of him wanting 5 years, 50 million dollars)

Yes, reasonable price and for no more than 3 years. Otherwise, bye bye

Yes only if its at a reasonable price.

Well yes, but odds are it's not going to be a reasonable price (ie talks of him wanting 5 years, 50 million dollars) And who's going to pay? He can ask for 100Million, but someone has to pay

yes-hes a great player-we should keep him-maybe even if its for 10 mill-but hes a player that you know for sure will give you results-and thats what you look for-so we should keep him as hard as we can.

Yes, I expect Pudge will quickly find that the way the market is there is no way he can get the contract he is expecting and will fall right back into the lap of the Marlins.

$10 mill a year for the next 5 years for a 32 year old catcher? no way, 2-3 year deal at about $15-20 mill

$10 mill a year for the next 5 years for a 32 year old catcher? no way, 2-3 year deal at about $15-20 mill

Boras said it, not me.

boras is wrong anyways...

he wont get what he wants...

pudge will remain a marlin!!!!

but for how much?

$10 mill a year for the next 5 years for a 32 year old catcher? no way, 2-3 year deal at about $15-20 mill

Boras said it, not me. i know, boras can burn in hell just for that contract he got Arod, and now with that sarcastic s*** about about giving the fans a home town discount

$10 mill a year for the next 5 years for a 32 year old catcher? no way, 2-3 year deal at about $15-20 mill

Boras said it, not me. i know, boras can burn in hell just for that contract he got Arod, and now with that sarcastic s*** about about giving the fans a home town discount What, you don't consider 5 years, 50 million bucks for a 32 year old catcher a hometown discount?

$10 mill a year for the next 5 years for a 32 year old catcher? no way, 2-3 year deal at about $15-20 mill

Boras said it, not me. i know, boras can burn in hell just for that contract he got Arod, and now with that sarcastic s*** about about giving the fans a home town discount What, you don't consider 5 years, 50 million bucks for a 32 year old catcher a hometown discount? only if Loria had some coupons he could pay it with

No.........I rather get benito to catch,and vlad to play rf!

Just pretty much what everyone else is saying...

 

I'd love to see him back as a Marlin now that he's familiar with our pitchers and has shown us his clutch hitting especially in the postseason. But if it's not at an affordable price, I'd rather see us spend the money on Mikey, Castillo, or Guerrero and use Castro/Redmond for catcher.

No. Only because we have other priorities (Lowell) and we could replace him with Castro who may not match his numbers, but will come pretty close. The key is money, Pudge is going to get at least $7M - I would rather spend that on a certain RF who played for the Expos...but that is just me.

No way. i have a feeling once he gets a multiyr deal hes gonna put on that weight and gonna hurt his back up again. no way! plus hes greedy

I think Pudge would resign for $27M over three years.

I say make a run at Vald and let Pudge test the market just to see run back to the Fish..

if you can land Pudge for $4,000,000 or less, then yes. if not, let him go the way of the do-do.

I say make a run at Vald and let Pudge test the market just to see run back to the Fish..

Marlins have until the first week of December to sign him or forfeit all rights to sign him until May.