Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins @ Braves 4/14

Featured Replies

​Hardly a disgrace. What's disgraceful is the fact that we've had four radically different offenses over the course of the past five years, and they have ALL relied solely on the success of Stanton. What is Redmond supposed to do if the offense scores 2 runs per game?

 

​He's supposed to trot out a lineup that gives us the best opportunity to score runs. He isn't doing that. He's also supposed to manage a game in a sense where scoring runs is more of a possibility. If we aren't hitting for power or hitting much at all especially at the bottom of the lineup which he knew was going to be a struggle going in to the season, he needs to play small ball, use bunts, steal, etc. Going all the way back to Opening Night, I've counted five different occasions in which he should have played small ball and didn't do it.

 

Then there's his bullpen management. I hope I don't have to explain that one to you.

 

Are we not playing up to our potential offensively right now? Sure. Is a lot of the reason we are hanging L after L partly Red's fault? Absofuckinglutely. The guy doesn't belong managing a baseball team. I really hope that if it continues this guy is on his way out in a few months

 

 

Redmond is an awful manager, @Hammerhead , but even the best managers when compared to the worst only improve a team by 2-3 wins throughout the course of an entire season.

 

​By my count, he could have improved us two wins already. Opening Night when he didn't bunt or play small ball with the bottom of the lineup when we had a guy on base and no outs but rather swung away with both Hech and Salty and a half a win each in two games after that with pen management.

 

 

Red is going to be canned if we don't turn this around within 2 weeks, I am really sure of that but don't think he should be.

 

​Tell me why not. Please. The guy has done nothing worthy of holding down a job. He sucked last year, he's sucked this year. It worked in 2003. It may work (to a point) this season. I'm not discounting the fact our offense is underachieving. But part of the reason it is is because of Redmond. There's no ignoring that.

 

 

​There is ignoring that. It's been 7 games, and the offense has played like a 100-loss offense. Having said that, Admin is right when he says that Redmond is going to get canned if we keep losing, no matter the cause.

 

​There's also last year when he also had no clue what he was doing. It has followed him in to this season. He isn't a good professional baseball manager.

 

 

​By my count, he could have improved us two wins already. Opening Night when he didn't bunt or play small ball with the bottom of the lineup when we had a guy on base and no outs but rather swung away with both Hech and Salty and a half a win each in two games after that with pen management.

 

​Yeah but if he pinch hits for Salty that's no guarantee that whoever comes up will come through. Same thing with the bullpen management, had he made the right move, things could still have gone poorly. I am absolutely on your side about Redmond: he's awful at the part of his job that we can see, but that being said, I don't want you to get your hopes up about someone new coming in and making much of a noticeable difference.

 

 

​I'm not starting an argument, but what would it take for you to get off of Hech's back? He's clearly improved as a hitter (despite his dismal average so far this year) and he's continuing to make incredible defensive plays. Frankly, I've been unable to see how anyone could consider him a bad player, so I'm just trying to understand where you're coming from.

 

​Honestly, while he has definitely improved as a hitter, he is still really, really, really bad at it. I am a huge fan of defense and have no problem with a no-hit all-glove shortstop (Adam Everett was one of my favorite guys to watch) so if Hech can continue his great defensive start, I'll be off his back for sure. That doesn't mean only making web gems and off balance throws though, it also means grading out positively in defensive metrics, which has has so far this year. (Hech is actually tied for second best in 2015 among all SS according to Fangraph's Def tool, which is flawed, but fairly reliable)

 

 

​Yeah but if he pinch hits for Salty that's no guarantee that whoever comes up will come through. Same thing with the bullpen management, had he made the right move, things could still have gone poorly. I am absolutely on your side about Redmond: he's awful at the part of his job that we can see, but that being said, I don't want you to get your hopes up about someone new coming in and making much of a noticeable difference.

 

​Sure things could have still gone badly if he would have made the right move. But making the wrong move doesn't help matters. If if Salty would have come through, I would say it was the wrong move because I don't play results. As a manager, you have to give your team the best shot at winning. If you do that and they still don't come through, cest la vie. Not your fault. But he isn't. So part of our failures are his fault. And that's not getting your job done as a manager.

 

 

​I gave up paying attention to nearly every defensive metric, considering they don't take many factors into account. Also, I still think it's unfair to say Hech is "really, really, really bad at [hitting]." He's a mediocre hitter, and he's still young. If he works on his pitch selection, he'll be a good hitter.

 

​He's really really really bad at hitting. There's no getting around that. Like SITA said though, there's nothing wrong with being a defensive minded player. As long as you aren't completely useless at the plate. Unfortunately, Hech is pretty close to that at the dish right now. I think he will improve a little bit but I don't think he's ever going to be even average at hitting the ball. He's probably going to spend most of his career as a defensive replacement.

 

 

​I gave up paying attention to nearly every defensive metric, considering they don't take many factors into account. Also, I still think it's unfair to say Hech is "really, really, really bad at [hitting]." He's a mediocre hitter, and he's still young. If he works on his pitch selection, he'll be a good hitter.

 

​Actually that's the thing about metrics, they do take ALL the factors into account. Perhaps you should do some reading: http://www.fangraphs.com/library/defense/

 

 

​That's just incorrect, and almost nothing backs up that assertion, but I'm not interested in talking about it anymore. I just want this team to win a game once in a while.

 

​His career .612 ops and 50% caught stealing rate completely backs up the assertion that he has a VERY below avg bat.

 

 

​I gave up paying attention to nearly every defensive metric, considering they don't take many factors into account. Also, I still think it's unfair to say Hech is "really, really, really bad at [hitting]." He's a mediocre hitter, and he's still young. If he works on his pitch selection, he'll be a good hitter.

 

​He was the 14th worst hitter in all of the sport in 2014, which was the best offensive season of his career. Stop looking at his batting average and look at literally everything else.

 

See for yourself here.

 

 

​He was the 14th worst hitter in all of the sport in 2014, which was the best offensive season of his career. Stop looking at his batting average and look at literally everything else.

 

See for yourself here.

 

​Listen I thought we had a talk about using facts to back up your claims.

 

 

I love how Preston has all the answers. I wonder if he's right.

 

​He's rarely ever right. He called Brignac a "kid getting called up to the majors" last night and used it as a reason not to PH with him.

 

 

I love how Preston has all the answers. I wonder if he's right.

 

​Stop wondering. He is almost always wrong. I am at work for another hour so I'm not watching the broadcast, but whatever he's talking about, he's wrong.

 

 

Red is going to be canned if we don't turn this around within 2 weeks, I am really sure of that but don't think he should be.

 

​i wouldnt doubt that. Loria WILL make a push for a big-name manager.

 

 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.