Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2015 mlb postseason

Featured Replies

It's bullshit. They suspended him because the media made a huge deal out of this. The slide wasn't exactly 'clean' but there have been worse; what angers people is the outcome.

 

My problem was that it was a dirty ass slide and some were saying it wasnt.

 

This would have been solved quickly this evening in the first couple of innings.  But then it was allowed to fester even more.  Makes sense.

 

 

My problem was that it was a dirty ass slide and some were saying it wasnt.

 

No more "dirty" than other slides that went without penalty. Just roll out a red carpet between the bases from now on and hand out participation trophies as well.

 

Shame to see you're a part of the pansy generation Das

 

 

No more "dirty" than other slides that went without penalty. Just roll out a red carpet between the bases from now on and hand out participation trophies as well.

 

Shame to see you're a part of the pansy generation Das

 

It was a dirty slide cause Utley didnt bother to fucking slide until he was on the base basically.

 

Pansy my ass, I am all for playing the game the good hard way.  

 

The only penalty Utley should have received was him or one of his teammates wearing one today.

 

 

My problem was that it was a dirty ass slide and some were saying it wasnt.This would have been solved quickly this evening in the first couple of innings.  But then it was allowed to fester even more.  Makes sense.

Many said it was clean not dirty and they were right, go watch ballerina basketball if you don't like how the sport is played.

 

 

The issue isn't so much with the players as it is with MLB not enforcing their own rules. I expect the players to push as much as they can to help their team win, but when rules are just fucking ignored for whatever reason, the punishment should be on those that do not uphold the rules.Baseball isn't a contact sport. What Utley did right there is basically a flag in football ffs.

 

The slide was dirty. He didn't give two shits about the base. The intent was to cause so much interference that a double play becomes impossible when the intent should be to reach the fucking base before being called out. 

Completely diasgree. Baseball is a contact sport maybe not as much as football but it is. Utley was COMPLETELY in the right to do what he did. I'd expect any player to do what he did.

 

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MhpuKsK_gk0If Phillips would not have moved and had his leg broken there, would this become a dirty play? I guess so even though it was clean. So here its perfectly acceptable to target a player for a Mets broadcaster stated "TAKEOUT SLIDE".

 

FYI, I find nothing wrong with this slide obviously but if we are going to play safety baseball, lets play it always

 

 

Completely diasgree. Baseball is a contact sport maybe not as much as football but it is. Utley was COMPLETELY in the right to do what he did. I'd expect any player to do what he did.

 

No he wasnt.

 

You dont start sliding when you are on the bag and then away from the bag.

 

The rule needs to be cleaned up, as of now it just states you have to touch the bag.  It needs to be cleaned up to say you have to start sliding in a reasonable manner of time to reach the base you are attempting to reach.  Not once you are on top of it.

 

Its a dirty play in a long line of dirty Chase Utley plays.  Not against the rules as currently written per say (unless MLB sent him a letter after the San Diego play in September), but nevertheless dirty as fuck.

 

 

what radio station is the Astros/Royals game going to be on in an hour? (palm beach county)

 

I flipped around the dial on Friday and couldn't find it.

 

 

No he wasnt.You dont start sliding when you are on the bag and then away from the bag.

 

The rule needs to be cleaned up, as of now it just states you have to touch the bag.  It needs to be cleaned up to say you have to start sliding in a reasonable manner of time to reach the base you are attempting to reach.  Not once you are on top of it.

 

Its a dirty play in a long line of dirty Chase Utley plays.  Not against the rules as currently written per say (unless MLB sent him a letter after the San Diego play in September), but nevertheless dirty as fuck.

Yes he was. The rule is fine the way it is. What you're asking for is to introduce the wonderful slippery slope known as "reasonable." No thanks. You can slide whenever you deem necessary or not ala Albert Belle to Fernando Viña. People should stop trying to mess with the sport. People get injured. Shit happens, move on.

 

 

what radio station is the Astros/Royals game going to be on in an hour? (palm beach county)I flipped around the dial on Friday and couldn't find it.

I believe it's on espn radio. Just not sure what station carries it in Palm beach.

 

 

You clearly haven't played sports if this what you think. Basketball is many times over a contact sport compared to baseball.

 

Its more contact but they also sell like crazy there. I don't know how often there actually is hard contact.

 

 

"Chase Utley's a great player. He's always played hard. I've always admired that about him. Unfortunately this time his playing hard, it just happened to have a bad result." - Torre.

 

So basically admitting he was suspended because of the injury. So in other words if the same thing happens but Tejada is fine, no suspension. That's bullshit.

 

 

You clearly haven't played sports if this what you think. Basketball is many times over a contact sport compared to baseball.

I've been playing baseball for over 25 years. Long enough to know how it's played. And evidently you haven't watched the disintegration of basketball from the days of the bad boys of Detroit when there were no fouls for getting punched in the paint. Now, you touch a player and it's a foul. Grab and it's a technically. Maybe there's more touching but it's evidently frowned upon and certainly can't be considered contact. Based on your statement though, you're clearly too young to remember what basketball used to be and what it is now.

 

 

Rule 5.09(a)(13) Comment (Rule 6.05(m) Comment): The objective of this rule is to penalize the offensive team for deliberate, unwarranted, unsportsmanlike action by the runner in leaving the baseline for the obvious purpose of crashing the pivot man on a double play, rather than trying to reach the base. Obviously this is an umpire’s judgment play.

That is why Utley shouldn't be suspended. The fucking umps should be disciplined because they just didn't enforce a rule. 

He was in the baseline, he forgot to touch the base. You make 0 sense. The rule has no basis for discipline.

 

 

Hard to respond to this when you think punching people in the paint is something the sport needs today and basketball has disintegrated because of things like that. Yikes.I don't think you've ever played baseball, tbh.

It's playing hard and playing to win. If you played, you'd know that.

 

 

I wish all LDS go to game 5. #EverydayPSlong

 

lol. Slong.

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.