Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Should we sign Chapman or Jansen?

Featured Replies

  • Author

Sign Jansen

Sell high on Ramos

Sell high on Barraclough

Fill out the rest of the pen with stopgaps (Koji Uehara comes to mind). 

 

 

  • Author
what about the SP situation?

 

I'm not saying the team can compete next year. All I'm saying is, Ramos or Barraclough might net you a SP or 2 with upside, and I think both guys will never see their value be higher. 

 

Jansen is elite. If the team doesn't work out, you can trade him for a bunch of prospects.

 

Selling high on relievers is the easiest way to make a shitty farm system great again.

 

 

  • Author
That team would still suck immensely so why bother taking on contracts?

 

Jansen would have great trade value at the trade deadline. 

 

And you never know, it could work. 

 

 

I'm not saying the team can compete next year. All I'm saying is, Ramos or Barraclough might net you a SP or 2 with upside, and I think both guys will never see their value be higher. 

 

Jansen is elite. If the team doesn't work out, you can trade him for a bunch of prospects.

 

Selling high on relievers is the easiest way to make a shitty farm system great again.

 

good pts all around

 

 

  • Author
Not that much if the Marlins want another team to eat his salary 

 

Why wouldn't they want his salary? He might be the best reliever in baseball, and teams now see the value of a great reliever in the postseason. The Marlins wouldn't have to eat salary. Jansen is legit. 

 

 

Why wouldn't they want his salary? He might be the best reliever in baseball, and teams now see the value of a great reliever in the postseason. The Marlins wouldn't have to eat salary. Jansen is legit. 

 

Because his value in terms of prospects goes down a lot of the other team takes on several years of contract.

 

Elite relievers have a lot of value, I agree, but you are over simplifying the process. The Marlins aren't going to get a basket of prospects and money back for a guy who was a free agent just a few months prior, no matter how good he is. If that kind of acquisition of value worked liked you said it would, the Marlins wouldn't be the team that had a chance at signing him. 

 

 

  • Author
Because his value in terms of prospects goes down a lot of the other team takes on several years of contract.

 

Elite relievers have a lot of value, I agree, but you are over simplifying the process. The Marlins aren't going to get a basket of prospects and money back for a guy who was a free agent just a few months prior, no matter how good he is. If that kind of acquisition of value worked liked you said it would, the Marlins wouldn't be the team that had a chance at signing him. 

 

You're probably right, but he'd still have good trade value. I think it's worth the gamble. 

 

 

  • Author

The Marlins have also shown in the past that they're willing to eat money to get rid of a "bad contract." At least Jansen is elite at his role unlike the massive pile of crap they've signed since the opening of the new stadium. 

 

 

  • Author
That's not a positive gain. I think best case scenario is that the Marlins would have to spend $70 million or whatever Jansen costs to get a basket of prospects. Not worth the risk.

 

No way, I think you're wrong. Why would the Marlins have to spend $70 million of his projected salary to get quality prospects in return? In a world where Brett Cecil just got 4 years, $30 million. 

 

 

No way, I think you're wrong. Why would the Marlins have to spend $70 million of his projected salary to get quality prospects in return? In a world where Brett Cecil just got 4 years, $30 million. 

 

the cecil contract seems fine by me. His periphs are terrific

 

 

No way, I think you're wrong. Why would the Marlins have to spend $70 million of his projected salary to get quality prospects in return? In a world where Brett Cecil just got 4 years, $30 million. 

 

Because of that's his free agent value, that's what it would cost to get the elite prospects. he's much better than Cecil.

 

 

  • Author
Because of that's his free agent value, that's what it would cost to get the elite prospects. he's much better than Cecil.

 

Exactly, so why would the Marlins have to absorb $70 million to get quality prospects in return? 

 

 

  • Author
Bottom line is that the Marlins aren't going to get the elite prospects they want AND have the other team eat most of the contract.

 

That's not how this works.

 

I never said we'd get a bunch of elite prospects. Although, to be honest, that makes more sense than what you're saying. The Marlins wouldn't have to take on $70 million of his projected $100 million; that's absurd. 

 

 

What incentive does a team have to give up good prospects if the Marlins don't eat the majority of the salary?

 

Otherwise a team with much more money and a chance to compete will sign him this off-season. actually that's probably what will happen.

 

 

  • Author

1. The incentive is a potential World Series for contending teams at the deadline.

 

2. A free agent gets to choose where he plays. I'm sure many teams want Jansen. As a Marlins fan, I'm hoping he chooses Miami. Am I allowed to do so?

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.