January 14, 200422 yr that's ridiculous. You conveniently avoid obp and ops (especially when on base percentage is the single msot important statistic) and jeter's superior obp makes him a better player. However, you include inflated Fenway statistics. No matter how much you don't like it, Fenway heavily inflates Nomar's stats like Coors inflates Helton's stats. The difference is that Helton has I beleive about a .950 OPS and about a .430 obp away from coors, making him a great player. Nomar has a .28o something obp away from Fenway, which is worse than the likes of Mike Bordick. Nomar will probably not return to Boston after next season and when he plays elsewhere, he will look horrible. It's pretty simple. Put Nomar permantly in Yankee stadium where its horrible for righty hitters (the opposite of fenway), and nomar will put up the horrible numbers he already currently puts up on the road. So unless you believe Todd Helton's career slugging percentage of .618 (I believE) is legitimate even though he played in Coors, you CANNOT believe Nomar is better than Jeter unless you are a hypocrite. edit: Furthermore, look at the two's post season stats in 2003. If we were to consider the postseason a continuation of the regular season with better pitching, it shows that Derek can simply hit in away ballparks and better pitching more so than Nomar. At the very least, when one compunds last years Postseason and season statistics, Derek Jeter is clearly better (as if comparing the difference in away statistics is not enough...) another edit: When you include Jeter's postseason stats, Jeter's total 2003 OBP is .393 (that includes all 242 hits, walks, and HBPs divided by 616 PA.) Nomar's 2003 total obp is .343. No player with a .343 obp is better than a player with a .393 obp...and Nomar's overall statistics INLCUDE his inflated fenway numbers. Furthermore, Nomar's postseason slugging % was close to .330 while JEter's was .471. There's no question.
January 15, 200422 yr I like Nomah and i like Jeter ... thing about Jeter is that he brings the intangibles which makes him a great player ... im not gonna say better than Nomah but u know what i mean ... i still think hes the 2nd best in the league but Nomah is really really really close behind
January 15, 200422 yr But SorianoFanHFW doesnt wanna see that cause Jeter plays for his sorry ass Yankees..
January 15, 200422 yr ALL WHITE TEAM ~ great pitching ... not better than the spanish team though C- Varitek 1st - Helton 2nd - Boone SS - Derek Jeter 3rd - Rolen OF - Edmonds OF - Chipper Jones OF - Giles DH - Thome Bench: Sexson, Giambi, Bagwell , Walker , Huff , Marcus Giles, Pierzynski , Berkman. SP- Schilling , Zito, Mulder , Prior , Halladay, J Schmidt RP - Hudson , Randy Johnson , Smoltz, Billy Wagner , K Brown, Keith Foulke , Wood, Mussina. Manager Lou Pinella Coaches Joe Torre, Art Howe, Trader Jack, Tony LaRussa Stadium Great American Ballpark
January 15, 200422 yr All Latin team: C - Rodriguez 1st - Pujols 2nd - Soriano SS - Rodriguez 3rd - Lowell OF - Andruw Jones OF - Guerrero OF - Ramirez DH - Palmeiro Bench: Lopez, Martinez, Castillo, Renteria, Ramirez, Guillen, Ordonez, Cabrera, SP: Martinez, Loaiza, Zambrano, Sabathia, Santana RP: Escobar, Villareal, Benitez, Julio, Mota, Rodriguez, Urbina, Rivera Manager Tony Pena Assistant Ozzie Guillen Stadium Pro Player
January 15, 200422 yr i dont think DJ is white his dad is black and his mom is white. both of them are fat and ugly. I don't know how they had derek. Dude, you can't have Palmeiro over Edgar MArtinez! Look at their away statistics last year! (just so you know, I like both, they are both HOFers in my opinion.) Edgar MArtinez .339 ba .443 obp .594 slug (1.037 ops) (16 homers) Rafael Palmeiro .240 ba .337 obp .452 slug (.789 ops) (17 homers) Edgar plays at safeco and that kills his statistics, though he would still be considered a great player regardless. You can tell how Edgar is feared by opposing pitchers, he is one of the best hitters around.
January 15, 200422 yr Dude, you can't have Palmeiro over Edgar MArtinez! Look at their away statistics last year! (just so you know, I like both, they are both HOFers in my opinion.) Edgar MArtinez .339 ba .443 obp .594 slug (1.037 ops) (16 homers) Rafael Palmeiro .240 ba .337 obp .452 slug (.789 ops) (17 homers) Edgar plays at safeco and that kills his statistics, though he would still be considered a great player regardless. You can tell how Edgar is feared by opposing pitchers, he is one of the best hitters around. Edgar is great, but I'm sorry, Raffy is better.
January 15, 200422 yr 1st - Helton 2nd - Boone SS - Derek Jeter 3rd - Rolen OF - Edmonds OF - Chipper Jones OF - Giles DH - Thome Who's your catcher?
January 15, 200422 yr C:Pudge, Varitek 1st: Helton, Delgado 2nd: Boone, Castillo SS: Arod 3rd:Lowell, Rolen OF: Bonds, Guerrero, Ordonez, Giles, Pujols DH: David Ortiz Bench: Varitek, Delgado, Castillo, Garciaparra, Rolen, Giles, Ordonez/PujolsDH as well. SP: Beckett, Prior, Peattite, Wood, P. Martinez, D. Lowe, Colon RP: Gagne, Wagner, Smoltz, Mota, Benitez, Rivera, Escobar Manager: Mckeon (Old school don't hurt) Assistants: Guillen, Rothschild (sp?), Robinson Stadium: Pac Bell
January 15, 200422 yr Edgar is great, but I'm sorry, Raffy is better. No way in helll Raffy is a better hitter than Edgar ... dont get me wrong they are both HOF in my opinion as well... but edgar is the last pure hitter since Molitor/Boggs/Gwynn ... raffy was never in that group
January 15, 200422 yr I definitely agree. Out of the molitor, boggs, gwynn group, martinez has the best OPS by far. Edgar is unbelievable, if he didn't play in safeco he would of had the batting title yet again. Raffy should be a first ballot HOFer because he played so consistantly and without injury over the years. I think willy mays and hank aaron are the only other guys with 3,000 hits and 600 homers. That makes Raffy unbelievable. Edgar has had injuries over the years because of the kingdome making him a DH. Edgar has always been the better overall player (even though Palmerio's defense is good and Edgar is a DH), but Edgar never compiled an unbelievable amount of hits or homers over the years. He just takes a lot of walks, acted as protection for griffey and Boone, had a couple of batting and on base titles, and has been one of the most awe-inspiring hitters in the game. An article from my site: Edgar Martinez Should Retire A Hall Of Famer EDGAR MARTINEZ: HALL OF FAMER Sure, he?s a DH, but he could have been moved to first and do nothing defensively. His statistics are too great to ignore. Observe. Career stats: BA .317 OBP .424 SLG .528 Provided protection for Griffey and Boone, making them look great. Differentials with peers: Eras distort numbers. In this era, people hit more homers, in the late 20s to early 40s, RBIs were huge! So when compared to the average player of the time, how his Edgar different? BA. .050 better than average (16% greater than average) OBP .087 better OBP (21% greater than average) SLG .109 better SLG (21% greater than average) OPS .196 better OPS (21% greater than average) 2 batting titles (92 and 95) 3 OBP titles (95, 98, 99), most doubles (92 and 95), most RBIs (2000) How about compared to others in Hall of Fame? 68th highest career batting average 14th largest OBP 24th highest OPS 46th highest SLG 59th most doubles All below numbers derived from baseballreference.com statistics and league averages at time the player played in (era.) Now how about adjusted for era? Here are 1st basemen in the Hall of Fame that are comparable to Edgar: Jim Bottomley, 16 seasons Ba:.310 OBP:.369 SLG:.500 OPS:.869 Adjusted for era: BA .017 better BA (5% better than average) Edgar superior by 11% OBP .016 better OBP (4% better than average) Edgar superior by 19% SLG .083 better SLG (17% better than average) Edgar superior by 4% OPS .099 better OPS (11% better than average) Edgar superior by 10% Edgar Martinez is flat out better than this Hall of Famer. Roger Connor, 18 seasons Ba: .317 OBP: .397 SLG .486 OPS:.883 Adjusted for era: BA .047 better BA (15% better than average) Edgar superior by 1% OBP .070 better OBP (18% better than average) Edgar superior by 3% SLG .118 better SLG (24% better than average) Edgar inferior by 3% OPS .188 better OPS (21% better than average) Edgar is equal Edgar Martinez is very close to this Hall of Famer, and is just a bit better. George Sisler, 15 seasons Ba:.340 OBP:.379 SLG.468 OPS .847 Adjusted for era: Ba .052 better BA (15% better than average) Edgar superior by 1% OBP .023 better OBP (6% better than average) Edgar superior by 15% SLG .070 better SLG (15% better than average) Edgar superior by 6% OPS .093 better OPS (11% better than average) Edgar superior by 10% Edgar is superior to this Hall of Famer. One might say, ?this guy has a career .340 average!? Numbers can be tricky, because when compared to league average, his average is only 15% greater than his peers while Edgar?s is 16% greater, thus making Edgar the better hitter for average in his era. Furthermore Edgar got on base and hit for power more effectively. Johnny Mize, only 15 seasons. Career statistics: Ba.: .312 OBP: .397 SLG.562 OPS: .959 Adjusted for era: BA .038 better BA (12% better than average) Edgar superior by 4% OBP .052 better OBP (13% better than average) Edgar superior by 8% SLG .167 better SLG (30% better than average) Edgar inferior by 9% OPS .220 better OPS (23% better than average) Edgar inferior by 2% In his era this guy was definitely a superior power hitter than Edgar, but when it came to hitting and getting on base he was inferior. In fact if all categories are added together to gauge ?player greatness?, Edgar is one percent better. So Edgar is a DH. He can play 1st base. 1st base is not a intensive job on the field (that?s why Mantle played his last season there), and many players play there so they don?t get injured (for example, Mike Piazza will be moving there.) Edgar had bad knees because he played on Astroturf, something men of the past never had to deal with (that and 90MPH fastballs, sliders, and splitters.) Furthermore if Seattle didn?t have good defensive 1st basemen to take the 1st base position (like gold glover John Olerud, and great defensive 1st baseman Tino Martinez), than Edgar would be playing first anyhow. Should Edgar be in the Hall? Definitiely. The only thing stopping him is two letters: D-H. If you read this thing in its entirity, email me and I'll give you a prize. http://www.xanga.com/craigramblings
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.