Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

MarlinsBaseball.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Giants/ Padres comparison

Featured Replies

C. Pierzynski/ Hernandez Giants

1B. Snow/ Klesko Padres

2B. Durham/ Loretta Giants

3B. Alfonzo/ Burroughs Giants

SS. Perez/ Vazquez Padres

LF. Bonds/ Giles Giants

CF. Grissom/ Long Giants

RF. Hammonds- Tucker/ Nevin Padres

SP. Schmidt/ Wells Giants

SP. Rueter/ Lawrence Giants

SP. Williams/ Peavy Giants

SP. Hermanson/ Eaton GIants

SP. TOmko/ Valdez Giants

Bullpen: Giants

Manager: Giants

Um, what about the Dodgers?

Um, what about the Dodgers?

I happen to think Arizona's gonna be pretty good myself.

 

C. Pierzynski/Hammock Giants

1B. Snow/Sexson Diamondbacks

2B. Durham/Alomar Giants

3B. Alfonzo/Hillenbrand Diamondbacks

SS. Perez/Cintron Diamondbacks

LF. Bonds/Bautista Giants

CF. Grissom/Finley PUSH

RF. Hammonds- Tucker/Gonzalez Diamondbacks

SP. Schmidt/Johnson Giants

SP. Rueter/Webb Diamondbacks

SP. Williams/Dessens Giants

SP. Hermanson/Patterson Diamondbacks

SP. TOmko/Fossum Diamondbacks

Bullpen: PUSH (Giants if Nen is healthy)

Manager: Giants

  • Author

Um, what about the Dodgers?

:lol they're offense is just as bad and now they're pitching has weakened as well

  • Author

Um, what about the Dodgers?

I happen to think Arizona's gonna be pretty good myself. not with a washed up Randy Johnson and not without Schilling

We'll see about that. Cuz you know the Giants suck.

  • Author

We'll see about that. Cuz you know the Giants suck.

the giants are only slightly weaker than last year. If schmidt's healthy we're going to be running away with the division again, especially considering that LA and Arizona have weakened much more than we have.

but it doesn't matter because we could have the best players at every position, the five best pitchers in our rotation, and we'd still lose in the playoffs

We'll see about that. Cuz you know the Giants suck.

the giants are only slightly weaker than last year. If schmidt's healthy we're going to be running away with the division again, especially considering that LA and Arizona have weakened much more than we have.

but it doesn't matter because we could have the best players at every position, the five best pitchers in our rotation, and we'd still lose in the playoffs Arizona is better than they were last year, not worse. Johnson is healthy, they added Sexson to the lineup without losing anyone there. Schilling hurts, but they're not exactly thin. Johnson, Webb, Dessens, Patterson, Fossum is pretty good in my book. It's deeper than San Francisco's rotation. Hermanson? Tomko?

 

Arizona's highly underrated.

We'll see about that. Cuz you know the Giants suck.

the giants are only slightly weaker than last year. If schmidt's healthy we're going to be running away with the division again, especially considering that LA and Arizona have weakened much more than we have.

but it doesn't matter because we could have the best players at every position, the five best pitchers in our rotation, and we'd still lose in the playoffs fool, look at the padres.

 

 

examine what they have.

 

 

 

get back with me.

 

 

 

the giants are not running away with dick this year.

We'll see about that. Cuz you know the Giants suck.

the giants are only slightly weaker than last year. If schmidt's healthy we're going to be running away with the division again, especially considering that LA and Arizona have weakened much more than we have.

but it doesn't matter because we could have the best players at every position, the five best pitchers in our rotation, and we'd still lose in the playoffs fool, look at the padres.

 

 

examine what they have.

 

 

 

get back with me.

 

 

 

the giants are not running away with dick this year. If I remember you told The Padres would suprise people.

 

Lawrence disappointed me and Wells is not going to make them drasitically better.

 

The Padre's are a success with a third place finish.

the padres are not done yet.

 

 

 

they have too many scary pieces to get blown out of the water by the giants let alone any team in that division.

 

 

giles, klesko, nady, burroughs (should be a lot better), greene (possibly), loretta, nevin, kendall/hernandez.

 

their biggest weakness really is that they have no speed and need a table setter.

 

 

their rotation is not that great, but aside from schmidt, what does the giants really have in their rotation? an older reueter? jerome williams? dustin hermanson who sucks, brett tomko who also sucks?

 

 

the padres find one/two pitchers on the market still and they will be fine.

Burroughs > Alfonzo

Loretta > Durham

Bochy > feces > alou

 

Everything else I can pretty much agree with except a couple of your pitching comparisons.

Padres projected roster, rotation, and batting order:

 

 

2B Loretta

3B Burroughs

CF Giles

1B Nevin

LF Klesko

RF Nady

C Hernandez

SS Greene

 

SP Wells

SP Lawrence

SP Peavy

SP Eaton

SP Valdes/Hitchcock

 

LHP ?

LHP/RHP Hitchcock/Valdes

RHP Howard

RHP Wiatsack

RHP Linebrink

RHP Beck

CLS Hoffman

 

C Ojeda

IF Cirillo

IF Vasquez

OF Buchanan

OF Long

 

according to an October Baseball Prospectus interview with Kevin Towers, about a week before Spring Training ends, they're going to fly Klesko, Long, Buchanan, Giles, and Nady to Petco Field, and have them play the OF in simulated games...due to the short RF there, Klesko is an option there. once they 5 outfielders determine wheather or not it's easier to play LF or RF, Klesko will be given that position. posted roster is also contingent based on singing another LHP for the bullpen (Mike Bynum may be put there) and trading Cirillo and Long to Pittsburgh for Jason Kendall.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...
Background Picker
Customize Layout

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.