Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

yankeefan21

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by yankeefan21

  1. Soriano - If by "bidding war" you mean "non-drafted free agent," then you are absolutely correct... Bottom line, the Yankees were the only team that shopped Soriano - until he was a Yankee... http://www.baseballlibrary.com/baseballlib...ano_Alfonso.stm The Dominican-born Soriano was signed by the New York Yankees in September 1998 as a non-drafted free agent after spending the 1996 and '97 seasons in Japan. He quickly established himself as one of the premier prospects in a well-stocked farm system, and despite inquiries from other teams the Yankees steadfastly refused to part with him. Hitchcock - Granted, he isn't a TOP pitcher, but it would be tough to say that he's "horrible" considering he was the 1998 NLCS MVP and that teams are still interested in signing him away from the Yankees. His injuries have hampered him recently, but he has shown the stuff to be a solid #2 or #3 starter on most teams in baseball. Look at it this way, he's better than Ted Lilly - that's why the Yankees kept him instead - and Lilly's in the starting rotation of, arguably, the best pitching staff in baseball. Henson - He has a grand total of 1 year of minor league experience under his belt. Torre has been pleased with his progress. Every team that enters trade negotiations with the Yankees brings up his name. There has GOT to be a reason for all of that. I'll hold off for a season or two before calling this guy "horrible."
  2. im not going to even read all this trash info... I see. In other words - you read it, but you have no data to back up your theories. Well, as I have shown time and time again, I am very respectfull of other people's opinions. Of course, I would prefer that someone supports their ideas with facts, but that's cool. Not everyone has facts to support their ideas. Just do me a favor and let me know when you come up with a sentient thought on the issue. :thumbup
  3. yankeefan21 replied to a post in a topic in Sports
    i say Red Sox , he won 3 Cy Young with them , stroke out more than 2k with them , won over 200 games with them had best ERA with them he did all with red sox :mischief2 I have decided that Pudge07 will now be a Devil Rays fan. We, at the board, feel that he fits the demographic of a DRays fan better than that of the Marlins fan. He has more qualifications to BE a DRays fan than a Marlins fan. Sorry, Pudge07, we don't care what your opinion is - you are now a Devil Rays fan. Sound "fair?" :whistle
  4. Just as an aside - how many rings do Mussina, Mondesi, and Giambi have? Perhaps we should use OTHER players as evidence that the Yankees "buy" championships? :mischief
  5. yankeefan21 replied to a post in a topic in Sports
    The real numbers Fiedler: 2000 - 12-6 2001 - 11-5 2002 - 9-7 Total = 32-18 = 64% Win % Not that it really matters, but those numbers are off. 12-6 in 2000? there are not even that many games. jay missed 1 game that year, so his record was 10-5. in 2002, the team went 9-7, but 2-3 in the games Jay missed, so his record was 7-4. the records I put up were correct. My mistake - I missed out on the 2002 numbers. I was counting instead of looking at starts - as I did in the rest of the numbers. I also corrected for 1 game in 2000 - 11-6 not 12-6. I accidentally gave him credit for somebody else's win. I made an error that resulted in adding 3% points to Fiedler's numbers - still short of the others mentioned. http://www.nfl.com/players/playerpage/1236...3/gamelogs/2000 http://www.nfl.com/players/playerpage/1236...3/gamelogs/2001 http://www.nfl.com/players/playerpage/12363/gamelogs for 2002 The post above has been edited to reflect my errors and the changes mentioned above. And, as Ross pointed out, this results in a difference of two wins between Fiedler and Favre. However, as alluded to by the Brady and Maddux numbers, Favre has played in 5 more games [12% more] which means Fiedler's numbers are impacted greater by each win or loss. If he LOSES those 2 games, he'll be back down to 64%.
  6. yankeefan21 replied to a post in a topic in Sports
    Nobody can make a strong argument against that "Montana Magic." It's hard for me to decide between Montana and Elway b/c I grew up a Giants fan. I just revel in the fact that I watched Phil Simms beat them both... One for the NFC Championship and the other in the Superbowl :mischief But hot damn - you could NEVER count out the 49ers with Joe Montana behind center. 31 fourth quarter come-from-behind wins, including a 92-yard drive in the closing seconds of Super Bowl XXIII? That's insane... You can't coach that...
  7. yankeefan21 replied to a post in a topic in Sports
    The real numbers Fiedler: 2000 - 11-6 2001 - 11-5 2002 - 7-3 Total = 29-14 = 67% Win % Favre: 2000 - 9-7 2001 - 12-4 2002 - 12-4 Total = 33-15 = 68.75% Win % Brady 2000 - 0-0 2001 - 11-2 2002 - 9-7 Total = 20-9 = 68.97% Win % Tommy Maddux [you'll love this!] 2000 - out of football 2001 - 0-0 2002 - 7-3 Total = 7-3 = 70% Win % Just the facts. :thumbup
  8. Well, Danny, let?s look at the facts rather than make assumptions based on whatever misconceptions you may have about the team: Fact ? [1]Mariano Rivera, [2]Jorge Posada, [3]Nick Johnson, [4]Alfonso Soriano, [6]Derek Jeter, [8]Bernie Williams, [1]Andy Pettitte, [1]Sterling Hitchcock, [5]Drew Henson, and [9]Juan Rivera are all Yankee farm prospects [obviously, I?m not counting [7]Hideki Matsui as a ?farm prospect?]. Hmm - 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9... That looks like a lineup to me. That looks like it MIGHT be every position on the field. Do me a favor please. Name another team in baseball that can field an entire team of their own top quality prospects. It may be a more daunting task than you think? Fact - Arbitration is guided by success, the Yankees have been successfull, the Yankees players have been rewarded for their success by arbitrators, as a result - the Yankees have to pay to keep their own. Welcome to the world of capitalism. If you own a business and have talented employees who enjoy tremendous amounts of success, you better reward them because they have EARNED it and your business will not succeed without them. This is ESPECIALLY true if you KNOW that your employees would be wooed by your biggest competitors. Fact ? The Yankees have traded away more All-Star quality players than any other team in baseball in order to address pressing immediate needs. Ask any Twins fan how the Knoblauch-Guzman trade panned out. Ask any Marlins fan how the Ed Yarnall-Mike Lowell trade panned out. Are you catching all of this? But wait ? there?s more? Fact ? Mike Mussina was CHASED out of Baltimore. The Yankees would have been okay with Duque, but an inescapable opportunity presented itself and Mussina wanted a little revenge on his former team. Fact ? Jason Giambi WOULD have been an A except that they decided that they didn?t want to give their FRANCHISE player a no-trade clause. [and the Yankees would have been ?okay? if they were ?stuck? with Nick Johnson and Tino Martinez at 1st]. So don?t cry the financial game with me. Fact ? The retirement of Paul Oneill necessitated the acquisition of a rf with a good arm [being that Bernie throws like a girl]. Mondesi was the guy they ended up with [incidentally ? a HUGE downgrade from Paulie ? but I digress]. Fact ? The retirement of Scott Brosious necessitated the acquisition of a 3b. Robin Ventura is 147 years old, already has a house in NY, and no other team in baseball wanted him. If you are going to continue to cry the ?big market ? small market,? ?big money ? little money? song, check out a previous post on the topic here entitled ?The Price of Contention:? http://www.marlinbaseball.com/forums/index...wtopic=2754&hl=
  9. yankeefan21 replied to a post in a topic in Sports
    Where does it end? That's the point. The precedent has already been set. It doesn't end. If Wade Boggs wants to go down in history as the first DRay elected into the HOF, then so be it... I'm sure the DRays don't mind!
  10. yankeefan21 replied to a post in a topic in Sports
    Elway vs. Marino Wasn't this decided in a late December game in 1998 when Elway tore apart Miami's top rated defense and made Marino look so bad, he was benched early in the 3rd Quarter? :mischief2 All joking aside, that class of 1983 was insane. Who knows how good Jungle Jim Kelly would have been had he played on some better teams or had he not chosen a path with the USFL?? Back to Marino vs. Elway. Marino joined a team 1 year removed from a Super Bowl Birth. Elway joined a team with a history of futility - coming off of a 2-7 season. Marino was throwing to Pro Bowlers Mark Clayton, Mark Duper ["the Dynamic Duo"], and Nat Moore plus had Joe Rose as his go-to guy in 84 playing te. Later, he had Pro Bowlers Keith Byars, Irving Fryar, Keith Jackson, and Ferrell Edmunds... Elway [after sitting the bench for 5 games THEN splitting time with a HORRIBLE Steve DeBerg] was throwing to guys named Rick Upchurch, Steve Watson, and Clint Sampson plus had Sammy Winder in the backfield [who ran for over 800 yards ONCE in his career] and STILL got his team into the playoffs his first year. I'm sorry, but if you are going to try to convince me that Elway and Marino had equal footing and comparable tools to work with, you are fooling yourself. Marino was surrounded by Pro Bowl caliber players throughout his entire illustrious career. Elway didn't enjoy that luxury until the last couple of years of his career - and he has the ring to prove what he could have been doing all along. You can't on the one hand say that this is a TEAM sport then point at individual accomplishments and say look at what HE did. You are a product of your team and have to produce with the talent you have. If you produce at a comparable level with inferior product surrounding you? You have, in my eyes, surpassed your competition. Big picture - Elway was better.
  11. Jesus Christ. The man was so fast he could LITERALLY walk on water. And his stamina holding that "iron cross?" Rediculous. Not to mention all that water into wine stuff - he must have been a blast at parties... [sigh] I'm going straight to hell, aren't I...
  12. yankeefan21 replied to a post in a topic in Sports
    Okay - let me address any of the [sadly] very few salient thoughts posed on the subject thus far: Dave Winfield. Okay, as everybody and their mother knows, Winfield made his name as a Yankee. He went to 9 AS games in 9 seasons with the Yanks [2 in 8 with SD], won 5 of his 7 GG?s [including his last] with the Yanks, and went to his only WS as a Yank. Yet, he goes into the hall as a Padre. Why? Because the Padres offered him money and a job if he would wear their uniform into the hall. Steinbrenner ? ?the maniacal scourge of baseball? ? told Dave to go scratch when he was approached by Winfield about a matching offer. Bottom line, Dave did what was best for Dave [as he always did] and chose his uniform. That?s fine. He earned the right to choose. Reggie Jackson. What?s his nickname again? Oh, right, ?Mister October.? Let me ask you this, where did he get that nickname from? Oh right, the 1977, 1978, 1980, and 1981 post seasons with New York. Where does Reggie call home? Oakland California. Say what you want about Reggie, he had the right to choose to go in as an A and he deserved that right. It doesn?t matter that his best and most shining moments were as a Yankee. It doesn?t matter that he is remembered as a Yankee. Bottom line, he had earned the right to choose. Roger Clemens. There is no question that Roger made his name in Boston. Unfortunately, the name that Roger made for himself in Boston was as a loser and choke-artist. That?s why he was chased out of Beantown to begin with. Granted, Dan Duquette was the guy carrying out the sentence, but the jury that sentenced him was the media and fans of Boston. For a guy like Roger, that is a tough pill to swallow. It wasn?t until his post season success in NY that Roger felt like he was a pitcher worthy of being mentioned among the greats in the game. He EARNED that right in pinstripes. Personally, *I* will always think of Clemens in a Bosox uniform, but that?s not what matters. Roger Clemens has earned the right to choose. So let him do it, like others before.
  13. *Some* people are also about 12 years old and don't understand that the only reason soccer isn't big in the United States is because it doesn't have natural intermissions every couple of minutes like baseball, football, hockey, et all, which makes it impractical for creating the commercial breaks that television companies find so lucrative? So, take the time to explain things to these people, and the world will be a better place. This moment of zen has been brought to you by Yankeefan21. :hat
  14. Let's temper this discussion *just* a little bit... Lowell currently has, what, 21 home runs? The most he has ever had in an entire season before is 24. [clearly, he should break that pr] Now, let's look at some of the people within 2 or 3 home runs of him: Barry Bonds, Javy Lopez, Jim Edmonds, Albert Pujols, Andruw Jones... Then you've got your slow starters: Jim Thome, Jeff Bagwell, Todd Helton, Lance Berkman... Realistically, how many of you think he will remain in the top 5 or 10 for the rest of the year? He *could* have a freak season [a la Brett Boone], but I prefer to believe trends...
  15. Just to quell some rumors - Steinbrenner is NOT looking to fire Torre. He is, however, actively seeking Joe's replacement in the [unfortunately] likely case that Joe is done at the end of his contract - at the end of this season. The word around town is that he is talking to Bobby Valentine and Sweet Lou.
  16. yankeefan21 replied to a post in a topic in Sports
    My feeling is that you should honor the wishes of the player. If Roger wants to go to the HOF as a Yankee, he should go as a Yankee. He has great disdain for the Red Sox organization - for whatever reasons he may have. It would be an insult to him to put him in as the member of a team he dislikes so greatly. Also, you can argue that the Rocket has done as much for his career in pin stripes as he did in Boston - and maybe a little more. He has 11 Full seasons in Boston, 2 in Toronto, 5 in NY - Bos. He has an MVP award in Boston - Bos. He has a Cy in all three cities mentioned - wash. He is a 20 game winner in all three cities - wash. He has 8 of his 9 post season wins in NY - NY. He has 2 WS rings in NY 0 in Boston - NY. He won his 300th game in NY - NY. He passed the big names on the K list in NY - NY. He wants to go in as a Yankee - NY. He was abandoned by Boston, signed by Toronto, wooed by NY - NY. As usual, Boston comes up JUST a bit short.
  17. Good. Take Vlad. I want PITCHING!
  18. My final word on the subject: Here's one more way of looking at HOF voting; if you have to *think* about whether a player is deserving of enshrinement, then he is not. Period.
  19. Okay - here's my quasi-official 2-Step qualification criteria for deciding if a guy is a HOFer or not: Step 1 - Take 3 of the best guys in the HOF and say their name out loud. Step 2 - Follow that name with the name of the candidate under consideration. If you giggle or roll your eyes or have difficulty mentioning this person in the same breath, he is NOT a HOFer. If you can say the candidates name with pride and respect - shoe in. Example: Honus Wagner, Ernie Banks, Cal Ripken... Alex Rodriguez. Okay, it fits. Now Try this: Lou Gerigh, Jimmy Foxx, Mark McGwire... Rafael Palmeiro? To be honest, Don Mattingly is a better fit here than Palmeiro.
  20. Well, *my* IQ is a Billion, and *I* say Culpepper is one of the most over rated QB's in the NFL. Danny Wuerffel could have had the year Culpepper had in 2000 with Cris Carter, Randy Moss, and Robert Smith... To be honest, I think losing Robert Smith was the single largest contributing factor to the decline of the Vikes from 2000 to 2001 [drop of 15 points in QB rating!]. Losing Cris Carter hurt his numbers from 01-02 [loss of another 8 points in that QB rating]. Another fact that many people are missing - along with int's going up and QB rating going down each consecutive season - Culpepper has been running more and more [89 in 00, 103 {71/11)*16} in 01, and 106 in 02]. This tells me that he is not maturing as a passer AND is getting pressed into making mistakes more often.
  21. Wasn't Warren Sapp one of the original "Fat Boys?"
  22. The HOF is so watered down these days - Palmeiro is a shoe-in. It's sad, really, when you think about it... He has never really been one of the best players in the league [0 top 5 MVP finishes]. He has never started an All-Star game. He has never been the best player at his position. He has never been in the WS. Bottom line, he has never been considered one of the best players of his OWN time - never mind of ALL time. Numbers are all well and good, but there is a certain intangible that Palmeiro lacks. Oh well, let the case for Fred McGriff be made next... [sigh]
  23. Can you even IMAGINE if the Yankees got Tejada AND Vlad? :banghead Honestly, though, the Yankees need to focus more on healthy YOUNG pitchers than more bats. Let's look at our current lineup, shall we? Soriano Jeter Giambi Bernie Godzilla Posada Ventura Mondesi NJ Mondesi is a number EIGHT hitter in this lineup? That's pretty sick. How much would Tejada and Vlad REALLY help? Now look at this rotation: Clemens [retired at the end of the year] Mussina Wells [just turned 40] Pettitte Weaver Hitchcock [still on dl from surgery] Bottom line, we have 3 pitchers going in to next year. As great as Mussina is - Mussina, Pettitte, Weaver just doesn't sound like an intimidating 1-2-3. Oh well, maybe we'll grab Mulder or Zito or Hudson in a couple of years... :mischief2
  24. Granted - I'm one of the biggest "outers" of Pudge's many weaknesses. However, the fact that I had to take the time to LOOK for weaknesses in Pudge's game only goes to show how good of a ballplayer he is. Give the man some time.
  25. What quiz?

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.