Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Hermida may begin season on DL
When Hermida comes back (ever the optimist), if he comes back we can worry about who the right fielder is but right now, with a week left before the season opens give Borchard the job or trade for someone else and let them know it's their job until someone takes it away from them and let them play ball without looking over their shoulder every five minutes. This rant is addressed to Beinfest and the FO as much as anyone else. Just today, it was written again how LB and company still don't want to trade any of their young pitching prospects and for months I went along with that, thinking they would be worth so much more in the next off-season, it was better to wait. But that was before Johnson was injured, Garcia was injured, West was injured, etc., and positionally two-thirds of our outfield is underwater. And I won't even mention the closer situation. Well actually I will. Benitez is mouthing-off in SF feeling unloved, underrespected and daring the franchise to trade him, taunting the FO whenever he can get within a few feet of a microphone. Jason Ellison is out of options in SF as well. Without going through my list of the usual suspects there are solutions to our problems waiting to be addressed. I understand the issue confronting the organization at this touch and go time with the legislature. If Loria and company start spending (relatively) large sums of money (were the Marlins to offer to pickup $3-5 million of what Benitez is owed for example) those armied against the Marlins would use that to further their "billionaire owner/millionaire player" argument and point fingers saying there's another $5 million the Marlins could have thrown into the deal and implying if there's that $5 million there's more, etc. etc. and they really don't need our help or the rebate under consideration. (This argument by the way is a different one than Samson's comments about payroll generally so don't be confused by that, this is about perception, that was about protecting against government-demands leading to huge cost overruns) So where this leaves us is to Beinfest abandoning his no-prospect-trade mantra and as he did in 2003, going out and getting guys who can make a difference even if that means trading players who would seem untouchable. Hermida's dismal spring and injury has left us with little choice. It isn't ALL his fault and the boat iinn't sinking because of his actions. But there is a cumulative effect at work where each problem magnifies those preceeding it. For example, it's one thing to be without a bonafide centerfielder, it's much much worse when you don't have a bonafide centerfielder AND your rightfielder is playing like crap too. Every team has holes, heck the Yankees just lost Wang, the Cubs just spent a gazillion dollars and they have problems so big you could drive a tractor trailer through. Ramp seems to think we (being the Marlins organization) need to coddle Hermida because he's emotionally twelve years old and needs our love and the security of knowing the job is his. Too bad. You've lost the job, not because of your knee or your ankle or your hip flexor but because of your play. You want the job, you want to be a major league ballplayer, go out and win the job just like anyone else in any other profession from sanitation to astronuclear physics. You've used up all your rookie of the year/can't-miss superstar chips, go to the end of the line and work yourself back and while you're at it grow a backbone. Just this morning I was reading Ramp/Matt's recounting of the 2000 ML amateur draft and what a sink hole it turned out to be and it inspired a number these comments. Jeremy Hermida isn't the first sensitive guy to play the game. He isn't the first person to don a uniform who had to confront demons or difficulty. I grew up with Jimmy Piersall in centerfield, somehow if he could deal with his problems, Hermida should be able to deal with his. For this team to wait around for him to grow up no longer makes sense. Get him a shrink. Get him something. If we have to trade the equivalent of Adrian Gonzalez again to make us competitive so be it. People forget about Ryan Snare and Will Smith (who??? he asks sarcastically). Prospects don't always work out, in fact those who bemoan the Marlins trading AG are the same people who have forgetten a) how long it took him to make it in the MLs and b) the other guys involved who never made it, or c) we won a World Series in part because of it. Do you trade a Petit or a top ten prospect (or both or someone else, or others) right now for the help we need, I think the answer is yes. Games won in April are just as important as games won in August. Waiting until Johnson is back and Hermida has his head on correctly is not an option. We have eighteen games in the month of April against division rivals. Tell me we don't need to be at full strength when the season opens. Tell me you're willing to bet the whole season on Jeremy Hermida carrying this team down the stretch and into the playoffs. Either give Borchard the chance and get a centerfielder or go with Reed or DeArza or whoever and get a rightfielder or get a real closer, all three, two of three, at least one of three, but do something. Go look at our schedule and tell me we can wait. If you're honest with yourself I think you'll be hard-pressed to do so. The front office needs to find some solutions and do it now, as much for the fans, the franchise and the players as their own self-respect. Right now.
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
Ry, can't argue with that. Like you said, "who knows?". Like so many things with this young team we really won't know for a couple of years what was and wasn't the right move. Ultimately Beinfest pulls the trigger on a deal for someone or he doesn't, and it's not all together in his hands either. There's no right answers here. Just baseball talk.
-
Vote for MarlinBaseball.com on SI.com
Been there. Done that. :thumbup
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
RyDawg, just for the record, I tried to suggest most of this is fantasy and it wasn't me who first suggested Petit for Gathright, or started this thread, but once on the table I went along and tacitly see value in a potential trade. A couple of things. First, Gathright made a huge mistake going into 2006, thinking he should bulk up (figuratively) and hit for more power rather doing what he excelled at in the minor leagues. That failed and as things fell apart in Tampa his stock tumbled. Thankfully, he got out of there, went to KC, put his career back together and finished the season (August & Sept) posting some numbers I think most Marlins fans would find acceptable in a lead-off batter. So far this spring he's built upon how he closed out last season. If you're down on Gathright, your choice, no complaints here. I'm not suggesting he the next Henderson or even a 2003 Pierre, but at the right price, serviceable and an upgrade, with little downside if he turns out to be not the long term answer. And I'm not advocating Gathright over Ellison or Willits or whoever is the new CF candidate du jour, he's just a guy being discussed. As for Jacobs I threw that in for one reason which is remembering last season when in fact he did hit immediately ahead of Cabrera and was quite productive. And I do think Cabrera needs protection behind him and have for a long, long time. Among the candidates with the team now, I chose Ramirez. Again, don't like the idea, certainly you have every right to feel differently. I think Cabrera's numbers, as good as they are, get incrementally better with someone better than Willingham or Jacobs hitting behind him. My opinion. Take a look at Ramirez' line from last season, that may alter your thinking. One thing I would disagree with you on is that overall Gathright is not an upgrade over Reed or Sanchez. If you've seen them play this spring you might change your mind. I give Sanchez credit for working really hard on his defense and Reed at being more aggressive at the plate, but neither is as much "a" complete package as Gathright (which is not to say he is "the" complete package if you understand the difference). If Beinfest called and asked me to pick among the three I would go with Gathright every time. But let's be clear, that's as much because of the other two as it JG.
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
81 at-bats in '06 were pretty poor. He's had a terrific spring though. But consider that it was 81 at bats in 84 games which one could surmise were almost all late inning pinch hit opportunities. of which about eight or so games he started and/or had multiple at bats, the rest appear to be as a pinch-hitter. If I have a chance I'll check out his gamelog. **In June, fifteen games, 32 at bats. July, five games, 13 at bats. September six games, 7 at bats.** ** edit
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
Back. Rather than start another thread I'm just depositing a bunch of centerfield/outfield related stuff here. As noted above Gathright seems back in business and Costa may play today. In LA, Chone Figgins could be out for 6-8 weeks with not one but two breaks in his fingers, meaning at least in the short term it looks like both Willits and Murphy make the team absent a trade, with Evans (already down) and Gorneault next. Aybar replaces Figgins for awhile. The Red Sox sent David Murphy down. On the San Francisco thing - Jason Ellison. Below are three items, the San Jose Mercury story, baseballcube.com numbers and minorleaguesplits.com which at first glance look to be in error but in fact they aren't, yes he hit .482 with men on and .516 with RISP in 2006 @ Fresno. MLS.com, which usually is pretty tough on translating minor league numbers to equivalent major league ones offers Ellison's .406 ave at Fresno last season to a.365 MLB number. They use an interesting set of formulas to derive these things and no one (at least not me) is suggesting he'd do that well with 500 ABs, but as a trend they're indicating he'd be successful at this level. I know Sham looks at these, and I think Lou does too, I can't remember seeing numbers this high for a ballplayer before, perhaps they have. So, from the San Jose Mercury : Glove gives Ellison a shot Outfield defense key for Giants; Lowry uneven By Andrew Baggarly Mercury News Article Launched: 03/24/2007 02:02:26 AM PDT MESA, Ariz. - Jason Ellison smacked a double off Chicago Cubs right-hander Kerry Wood to bump his Cactus League average to .447 on Friday, but a diving, full-extension catch in center field might have done the most to help his cause. Even though Todd Linden is proving he can play a credible center field, Ellison's defensive skills are becoming difficult to ignore. And those who know Giants Manager Bruce Bochy say he considers defense a top priority. Outfield defense is particularly vital to the Giants, who just invested $126 million in Barry Zito, a flyball pitcher, and play in a park with ample dimensions. Matt Cain and Noah Lowry are two others who rely on flyball outs. Matt Morris is the Giants' only starting pitcher who got more outs on the ground than in the air last year. Although Barry Bonds is moving better this spring, he will be 43 in July and his range is meager. Scouts are also down on Dave Roberts, who will start as the regular center fielder for the first time in two years; he moved to left field for the San Diego Padres last year after they acquired Mike Cameron. Ellison can play all three spots and his cannon arm would stand out among other Giants outfielders, who don't figure to throw out many runners this season. Ellison is out of minor league options and seemingly squeezed out of the Giants' plans unless they trade Mark Sweeney or an injury befalls one of their position players. The Florida Marlins are among several clubs that have scouted Ellison, hoping he might be available on a waiver claim. But according to a source, interested teams have been told that Ellison won't be made available. The Giants are delaying the decision because an injury could change the dynamic. They don't want to trade Sweeney and then watch Ryan Klesko go down - which is exactly what happened in San Diego at this time a year ago. "We're discussing this every day," Bochy said. "Elly's had a good spring and he can do a lot of things." http://www.mercurynews.com/sports/ci_5512485 thebaseballcube.com http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/E/Jason-Ellison.shtml minorleaguesplits.com http://www.minorleaguesplits.com/pl/425/425533.html
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
like it or not the Royals already have a better shortstop than Robert Andino who they are trying to upgrade. you could argue that Andino has more upside than Berroa, he certainly has a much much much better glove for what it's worth, the Royals traded for SS prospect Tony Pena Jr today And many experts felt they overspent. Just my opnion but Andino > T.Pena Jr I'd agree. Regarding Pena, the compensation is a pitcher recovering from surgery who may not be ready until 2009 if ever so nobody got or gave much here. This is probably a stopgap. Couple of other things, have to run, Gathright in a rained-out game yesterday testing his sore hamstring, laid down a bunt single on the first pitch of the game. Also, Marlins have renewed interest in Ellison who is out of options with Giants. The story is posted all over the place easy to find. Gotta go.
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
Gathright hitting lead off? Are you out of your mind? Has he ever posted an OBP out of the .320s? depends where you look his minor league numbers say .315/.391, while his majors say .251/.319 And then there's his numbers once he gets away from Tampa Bay in August and Sept (albeit small sample size, all that stuff) roughly .300/340 which at least gives you some hope in the NL he can build on that. But one thing I would repeat (although I like Maier better) the price for a Gathright if it's Petit is not enormous, and if it doesn't work out, it isn't the end of the world. And not say we should be scrounging around looking to Rule 5 for our next all-star but this year's draft is going to be stocked with gangbuster talent because all the rule change did this year was put players off for one additional season and the next draft will feature alot of guys who are one year closer to being major league ready who escaped this year while there will be more and more guys coming up from the lower levels who need roster spots. I would think he who should remain nameless *cough*ramp*cough* might have a better handle on how actively the Marlins really are looking for outfield talent (yeah I said outfield, not centerfield) regardless of how it's reported they are content with what they have in-house. I'm guessing, perhaps incorrectly, but as I have all along, the next week brings us at least one new outfielder. I wouldn't under-estimate how important roster management is going to be for a lot of teams and some players we haven't even dared think would be available might be. I think throughout baseball it's going to be an interesting seven or eight days.
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
We have a whole season to see who's right and wrong. 162 games is a long time and since either the FO or Fredi has already mentioned moving Ramirez down in the lineup, I'd say my odds are*n't* that bad. Of course the whole thing is moot until the fantasy trade becomesa reality and there's a speedy lead-off guy at the top of the lineup. Gotta learn to walk before you run.
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
One man's idea (and that's all it is) of how to bolster Cabrera's protection in lineup. Ramp, you're certainly entitled to your opinion, but I'm bettin' (in the figurative sense) before the season is over Ramirez bats behind Cabrera.
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
Well they've been trying to boost Gathright's stock for a year and a half now. The guy probably won't start 10 games this year in center field for them. Its been told, clearly, that the Royals want to get rid of Gathright. I think Gathright for Petit is more likely than Petit for Maier but that's just my opinion, based off of following the Royals for a few years. We have no argument there. And frankly, it isn't a break the bank price for the Marlins, and certainly better than what was discussed with TB last off-season. Putting Gathright at the top of the lineup really gives Gonzalez a chance at reworking the lineup (and maybe being able to move Miggy down to cleanup where he belongs - perhaps Gathright, Uggla, Jacobs, Cabrera, Ramirez, Willingham...)
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
Because the team is very high on Maier. It would take more than Petit to get Maier. A lot more. Respectfully, I doubt that (Petit isn't enough for Maier) unless we're going down the AA/AAA outfielder is worth a major league starter with a winning record road. Maier was shocked when he was one of the very first players sent to the AAA camp this spring while others stuck around much longer. Moore sent him down (I believe) because he knew he just doesn't fit in the team's plans anytime soon. To me that translates into potential trade candidate. DeJesus is going to be there (CF) for quite a long time, Teahen is about to take over RF on a permanent basis and Butler is virtually unstoppable as he makes his way to the majors sometime this season or surely next. That's your Royals outfield of the future. I like Maier and have said so repeatedly and for months, but there's higher ranked OF prospects ahead of him and more coming through the system below him to where a case can be made he's in wrong place at the wrong time. He's 25 or almost, and it's either now or next season for him, and I ask this question without malice - how do you see him fitting into the Royals roster this year or next, except perhaps as a bench jockey, and even then at whose expense? Of course injuries occur, trades take place, but it's very telling that with DeJesus out they've moved their right fielder who's trying to learn that position, into center rather than either bringing up Maier from the AAA camp as a reward or playing Gathright/Costa. For me, I think (my opinion) Moore is signaling who is and isn't available for the right price. And I think Maier is among them.
-
Robert Andino and Nick Trzesniak reassigned
Crap, my mom is going to be upset. She loves Nick. BTW Ramp, you spelled Nick's name wrong... it's Trzesniak :thumbup Yeah c'mon Ramp, everyone knows that !!! LMAO :notworthy
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
You can't blame Moore for the sins of Allard, people seem to miss the importance of that transition.
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
This is like reading a Devil Rays messageboard. People, (1) like it or not the Royals already have a better shortstop than Robert Andino who they are trying to upgrade. (2) They need pitching, both in the now and in the future. (3) Dayton Moore (came from the Braves) is as smart as Admin Beinfest and this is a good thing. If there is a deal to be made here, those two individuals with their first class staffs will make it, unlike dealing with the lunatic fringe, the ravings and demands we're accustomed to from Tampa. (4) Kansas City has as much to prove in their division as we do in ours. We could be excellent trading partners for years to come. (5) The first player they will offer is Reggie Sanders who they desperately want to jettison. For Beinfest to make a deal for Gathright (if he's still interested in the guy) he has to politely say no to Sanders while keeping discusions alive for Gathright who legitimately has zero future with them unless a slew of injuries happen simultaneously. They just moved Teahen to CF (from RF where he went to makeroom for Gordon at 3B) while DeJesus is ill with a stomach virus rather than play Gathright or Costa I suspect to literally send up a roman candle so everyone notices "we have CFs coming out our butt over here" ! I still think our CF is likely to come from LAA or KC and it won't be cheap, but it will be fair.
-
Wake up all you wanna be managers
I knew clicking on this thread would be a mistake. And yet like some many here you couldn't yourself....evrrrrrrrrryyyyyyyyy intererstingggggggggggg.... :hat
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
Is there really a difference between Petit, and Petit and George? :blink:
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
...Maybe something like Petit and Chris George for him. That could work. Is there really a difference between Petit, and Petit and George? :blink:
-
Wake up all you wanna be managers
I'm impressed you're already drunk at 2:53 pm. Good for you. LMAO :notworthy God knows I luv ya Lou !!!!!!!
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
The thing is with Gathright is that now that he's in the hands of a sane general manager his value will be much more realistic, meaning that you won't be ponying up an Olsen or Johnson for him, and even if he doesn't work out (although he has a better chance this season of doing so) it won't have cost the team a fortune in talent. Shane Costa probably isn't making the team either.
-
Marlins should go back after Gathright
What the Royals need are some pitching prospects in their minor league system. They have position players of every description coming out their butts but their recent draft classes have been "largely" (there are exceptions) failures when it comes to pitchers. I've been posting all winter about the KC situation and hardly think Andino would be considered any kind of upgrade over Berroa. Petit for Gathright, if we're not using him to get Benitez makes some sense, but frankly Harvey Garcia or Jesus Delgado or someone not in the top five but better ranked than 20+ might be more appropriate. This is Gathright's last option I believe and there's so many guys coming up through the system they either lose/trade him this season or next. As for other outfielders, you aren't going to pry Butler away but Maier is probably the guy you want to target if you're willing to give him half a season to grow into the job. He's defensively ready and had a great AFL offensively.
-
Petit for Julio Rumors Serious
RFerry... I do think the overwhelming majority of relievers other than closers and set-up men are bad pitchers compared to the average MLB pitcher and if you disagree with this premise, as apparently you do, then there's really no point in continuing with this debate. I don't know if I'd use the word "bad" but I think anyone would have to admit if you're the fifth or sixth guy in the bullpen pecking order there's usually a reason.
-
Cody Ross
13 man pitching staff, 8 starting fielders, Boone, Borch, Amezaga, Treanor Fredi keeps flip-flopping on the 12/13 thing. He's been quoted both ways in multiple outlets in the last week or so. I don't think he really knows.
-
Cody Ross
Not going to be any room for him. Trade him to the Pirates Are they interested in him or was that rhetorical? I happen to agree though that there doesn't seem to be a place for him this season especially if we can something for him that we can use to package for someone we really can use.
-
No major moves made this offseason
"Plaything mentality"...there is no depth low enough is there? We all know why Lee was traded and it was the right decision at the time. You call it petty because let's face it you hate ownership. I call it the first move toward a World championship. Jettisoning Floyd was absolutely and without question the single best thing the Marlins did after taking over the franchise. That and dumping Johnson and Wilson, getting Pierre and saving net $28 million in the process. Floyd was a one man wrecking crew who used his "star" position to hold a gun to the head of the new owners and FO, setting himself above eveyone else. If they had folded and given him what he wanted, this team woyuld have been dead in the water for the next three years, only one year in three (2005) playing a full season. What I think soured Cliff more than anything else though was his fraud was exposed when he had to sign for what he was making with the Marlins the year before (the Marlins if I remember had offered him $ 8 million and he spit on that offer). As for Pavano, seems to me that worked out fairly well for the Fish and Carl Pavano is the perfect example of a guy who has always spoken highly of JL. As has Joe Torre, Todd Jones, etc. You can find the handful of haters, and not surprisingly you almost seem to want associate yourself with the underachievers in Marlins history, the malcontents, the me-first guys, why I don't know.