Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Why don't the Marlins bring in another catcher?
Matt Treanor......career average .220 OPS .604 Those numbers trump whatever defense he's plays. he plays once, maybe twice a week...what do you want? mark mcguire behind the plate or someone to keep the kids in line? personally...ill take the latter...especially how once or twice a week he can shut down the opposing running game That's nonsense. Treanor's career CS % is 65%. The MLB average is 71%. Treanor is below par at throwing out baserunners. That can't be right. 71% CS just seems wrong...I'm not doubting you personally, butI think you should check that...it's hard to be believe 71% of all stolen base attempts failed. :mischief2 ????????? They need someone that can hit his way out of a paper bag and Treanor can't do it. The Marlins have no excuse not to bring in someone to compete with Treanor. Such as???? You're not going to bring up Alomar again I hope.
-
Why don't the Marlins bring in another catcher?
There is definately someone out there that can beat out Treanor. Why not give Sandy Alomar an invite to Spring Training? He's a better player than Treanor in every facet of the game and would really help out the young pitching staff. This is not about Treanor. It's about Alomar. The guy has had nine knee surgeries (at least seven on his left knee, at least one on his right, I think it's two), he's 41 years old, he can still hit lefties but hitting righties is only a fond memory. It's doubtful he can actually still catch an entire game, his best bet for staying in the major leagues is as third catcher/lefty DH specialist in the AL. Defensively, he caught five of 27 stolen base attempts in 2006 and that was with two relatively experienced pitching staffs. We all respect what the guy has contributed to the game and like old love affairs, time has a way of erasing the negative and leaving us with positive memories. The Ted Williams I remember never ever made an error. The Sandy Alomar we might want to acquire last played in 2002-2003, it's been downhill ever since. Take a dispassionate look at his offensive and defensive numbers the last five years and tell me there hasn't been marked decline almost seasonally. Even keeping his OBP above .300 hasbecome problematic. If we had a roster spot available for a third catcher and he could play some first base (ignoring the Boone acquisition for the moment), maybe, maybe there would be a place for him. But on this team we have Willingham as our emergency catcher and beyond that Jacobs, he can't challenge (health-wise) for number two and the roster spot will go to insure an position backup need. It's not by accident he remains unsigned.
-
Should the Marlins reconsider trading Dontrelle Willis?
...Very true. Speaking from experience, I view former Expos players with suspicion and don't even tell the more fervent Nats fans about anything dating back to Montreal. In this hypothetical argument, the Marlins will be supported by fans in a new city because it's baseball and it's new. While they'll be supported by the municipal officials by coming and their willingness to contribute to the project. I was actually thinking about it from a completely different perspective, that of financier or bond underwriter, and the franchise would be worth more, even though we (fans) look at Cabrera and Willis' contracts as liabilities, from an accounting standpoint (the way contracts are depreciated unique to MLB), the net effect is the franchise is worth more with them than not with them. I wasn't so much concerned about "fan" support as I was "voter" support to get what ever referendums would be needed to be passed to allow for municipal financing (tax-free bonds), and the franchise pledged against the bonds in case of default. What is keeping Miami at the table right now is one thing, their share of the distribution of the Professional Sports Franchise Tax, a subset of the bed tax on vacationers, which significantly closes the funding gap. The problem with Hialeah is they don't get a piece of this pie and its been accruing money for 10-15 years. Most other cities don't have this mechanism in place. While there are things Hialeah can do (as in the future) this $$ already exists.
-
Darin Erstad?
I'm not unhappy he's not coming here but my preference, for (their) roster reasons, would have been he stayed with the Angels. As for why I made that comment (Jacobs and Erstad) it's because a) Erstad played first base exclusively in 2004 and 2005, (2006 being only 40 games due to injury) and he's not a particularly effective hitter against lefties, an issue with Jacobs in 2006. Were he here, it's not inconceivable he might have seen some time at 1B.
-
Should the Marlins reconsider trading Dontrelle Willis?
I disagree. A city like Portland would jump on the Marlins no matter what names were on the back of the uniforms. I think now is the perfect time to deal Willis if they're going to do it. I wonder what teams have what the Marlins really need and would be willing to part with it. I would think that a young CF, C, Closer and more would be needed to get anything done. It probably is true in the case of Portland, but they were just a name used for example purposes. That said a stadium in Portland would be another $500 million retractable roof stadium because of the weather there and I don't care where it is, selling a community on financing $300+ million through bond financing is going to be an extraordinarily tough task because the per capita outlay is tremendous. But pick any of the cities, Vegas, San Antonio, Jersey, Virginia - big names help significantly especially if the scenario is that city "is getting what's left of the Marlins". But it's just an opinion, you don't have to agree. Generally I see it as a much tougher sell without them than with them. You're talking like you know the Marlins are moving to Portland. I picked Portland because an ESPN story (which I thought was BS) suggested the Marlins should move there so the Devil Rays could move to the NL East (and other moves involving realignment). And it's about as far as a team could move. I thought most people here had seen it. You have the wrong read if you think that Benched, not at all. Here's the link: http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/hotstove06/c...&id=2727901
-
Should the Marlins reconsider trading Dontrelle Willis?
I think if we get a stadium deal in the near future, both players should be kept, long-term. If we don't get a stadium deal, then both players should be kept for the next 2 years. But, as The Don says, it's crazy talk. If we don't get a stadium deal, I see both being traded. With this ownership group they're not willing to only make 10M a year, which they'd make if they kept both. They want to make 30-40M a year, like last year. Except that, consider this, if they don't get a stadium this time with MLB involved, they assuredly will be gone and the franchise worth more (to a new city) with Willis and Cabrera than without. If you were Portland (example) and you were the city fathers deciding how much they'd pony up for a new stadium, don't you think bringing in two stars like we're talking would be a driving force in selling it in the community? I do. Somehow, regardless of how good Olsen is, he just doesn't and probably will not have for several years the star power of DW. And Miggy, is about to become one of the biggest stars in the game. The franchise is worth more, in almost any scenario with them then not.
-
Inside Dish: Tons of Marlins-related stuff
Just think for a second...Marlins on the good end of a salary dump. Yeah, I chuckled, too. And they say nothing new ever happens in baseball...the irony of it That would argue for the Marlins to wait on any deal involving Rios and see how much the Jays want to dump Rios' contract. I doubt that they will get so desperate, but they might be willing to accept something not involving the big four. Very fair analysis. I don't think if would kill us to deal JJ (I know you are his super fan compared to the rest of us), but waiting for his arbitration is probably be a better course of action then just doing a deal now. I really like how Toronto potentially lines up with us with that AAA catcher. Acquiring someone going to arbitration this time of the season puts a strain on the relationship right from the get go unless the numbers are fairly close or the new team already has made up its mind to live with the player's higher request. Waiting certainly seems the wise course of action, although truth be told, I'm not enamored with him, and won't be until he shows he can he be productive for a full season. There's lots of ways of looking at this, I'm truly ambivalent.
-
Darin Erstad?
Free agent Darin Erstad still could return to the Angels as a backup first baseman and outfielder, but the Marlins and White Sox are offering him greater playing time, according to his agent, Greg Genske. Erstad, 32, is expected to make his decision this week, Genske told FOXSports.com. The 11-year veteran, who has spent his entire career with the Angels, is seeking both an opportunity to win and chance to play every day. The Marlins, who have failed in their attempts to land a young center fielder this off-season, want Erstad to be their regular in center. Erstad turned down a one-year offer from the A's, Genske said; other baseball sources say the A's withdrew their bid. The Angels, Genske said, have made a "competitive" proposal. But Erstad would get more at-bats with the Marlins or White Sox. http://msn.foxsports.com/mlb/story/6396994 Time to break out the party hats. :wee Only if he winds up in Chicago. :brigginbounce If Jacobs is healthy I'm wagering he outhits Erstad against lefties this season. And yes I believe the A's pulled their offer. But what's best for the Marlins is he stays in LA.
-
Darin Erstad?
Boy, I'm keeping my fingers crossed this is just a rumor.
-
Who do you want to see win the CF job?
You don't think you could have skewed that post any more against Alex Sanchez do you WildMarlinMan2003? In ignoring his major league career you rendered your post not credible in any way, shape, form or manner. When I think of all the time you wasted creating that piece of fiction, the mind boggles. :thumbdown Alex Sanchez is a very flawed ballplayer and human being with a giant question mark on his back. Funny you didn't mention his .350BA in the winter leagues or his MLB numbers, you purposely chose the worst possible scenario. Unbelievable. I hope everyone votes for Sachez just because...
-
Inside Dish: Tons of Marlins-related stuff
...The only scenario where I see one of them moved is if a Benitez comes in, proves himself capable of closing 40+ games in 2007 and either Garcia or Pinto (or fillintheblank) proves so dominating in spring training that he forces himself onto the 25 man roster. The earliest I think you'll see even a chance of moving one of them will the July trading deadline. If we're willing to move them for Armando Benitez, but not Alex Rios, there are serious serious issues. Re:, the "willing to move them" quote, perhaps I wasn't clear, I was speaking about a slim scenario playing out where Nolasco would be made available. Reading it again I could have been clearer but it was not my intention to suggest Olsen or Johnson or Sanchez would be put on the block. "One of them" was on my part a poor choice of words, I was really only thinking about Nolasco. But you never know. I don't think there is any question though that Olsen is the last one they'd think about trading. And may I add, Iwasn't suggesting any of them were being traded FOR Benitez, rather a Benitez comes in (assuming Nolasco winds up as the closer otherwise) and because Pinto or Garcia or someone else is doing tremendously well as a starter in spring training, the Marlins can consider moving RN. It's not trading one "for" Benitez, it's trading RN because Benitez is the closer and a true fifth starter emerges. I don't think SF gets more than a prospect or at worst Garcia or Pinto (and I don't really want to trade either) for Benitez. But first he has to be healthy enough to closer 40+ games. Also there's big difference between signing a Benitez for one season at minimal cost (although with a prospect going back), and Rios who will probably get his $3.1 million arb demand PLUS have to trade mutliple frontline prospects to get him. From my perspective it's comparing apples and oranges.
-
Inside Dish: Tons of Marlins-related stuff
Olsen has been attached at the hip to Beinfest through two years of fan appreciation/season ticketholder nights. He isn't going anywhere. Not for Delmon Young. Not for anyone. And every time Beinfest speaks publically Scott Olsen is the first of the baby Fish (read besides DW & Miggie) to be mentioned. I've been saying all off-season I doubted any of the starting rotation would be moved because if they even get through season two performing no better than their individual record in 2006, their market value will be twice what it is today. The only scenario where I see one of them moved is if a Benitez comes in, proves himself capable of closing 40+ games in 2007 and either Garcia or Pinto (or fillintheblank) proves so dominating in spring training that he forces himself onto the 25 man roster. The earliest I think you'll see even a chance of moving one of them will the July trading deadline.
-
Beinfest just barely makes top ten in GM Rating
Dayn Perry wouldn't know baseball if you hit him over the head with a bat and then clobbered him in the nuts with a ball! Have you read any of his other previous baseball columns? The guy just regurgitates whatever other columnists write in other hometown fish wrappers. He is sometimes truly clueless. Thank you for saving me the trouble :thumbup
-
In the "and It Really Doesn't Mean Anything But..." Dept
Alfredo is going to surprise a few people this year To the best of my knowledge he has not played a single game in the winter leagues in the outfield. I have to assume the FO has different plans for him, super utility infielder. Frankly, and I know I'm in the minority on this, I wouldn't have minded if AA went to winter ball and played the outfield exclusively in hopes of becoming our everyday CFer. Sixty-seventy more games to learn the position and I think he could of been decent player there. He has the instincts, the speed and guts. But obviously that isn't what Beinfest and company have in mind so what I'm left with is the belief they have something else planned.
-
In the "and It Really Doesn't Mean Anything But..." Dept
If y'all go to flamarlins.com there's another update the winter leagues, and our Alfredo is hot as a pistol. Hey AA, save some of that for spring training, please :thumbup http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/...sp&c_id=fla A couple of tidbits: Jose Campusano remains one of the hottest hitters in the Dominican Winter League playoffs for the Gigantes del Cibao. The 23-year-old infielder is 5-for-11 with two runs scored and one stolen base in his last five games. Overall, he is batting .529 (9-for-17) with five runs scored, one RBI and three stolen bases in eight postseason games. Campusano, who was signed as a non-drafted free agent in April 2003, hit .294 with 11 runs scored, two RBIs and seven stolen bases in 23 regular-season contests. ------------- INF Alfredo Amezaga -- Amezaga continues his torrid playoff hitting for the Yaquis de Obregon. He is batting .362 (17-for-47) with one homer, eight RBIs and eight runs scored in 11 games. The 28-year-old utilityman hit .297 with three homers, 24 runs scored, 15 RBIs and 14 steals in 39 games for the Marlins.
-
Shannon Stewart wants us...
You missed the point ... THEY ARE RUMORS ... sheesh.
-
Shannon Stewart wants us...
Anyway, back to the point. 2003, your contention is "I know very little personally, I'd rather let the experts decide." Am I correct? OK, good. Let's take that to the next step. Admin Beinfest is an expert. Admin Beinfest has tried shopping Jacobs and Nolasco for a centerfielder. Admin Beinfest has not come away with anything. Therefore, the "experts" have said that Nolasco and Jacobs have very little value, at least in terms of a meaningful centerfielder. Therefore, your stance that you know nothing and trust the experts, but you know that Jacobs and Nolasco have substantial value is in and of itself contradictory. And with that, I'm done. It's without doubt you know very little Swift and every time you post something like you just did above you confirm it...let's start by agreeing there. I'm always pleased when we can agree on something. But, as you said, "Let's take the next step". Since you're being cryptic regarding Nolasco and Jacobs being rejected in trades for a centerfielder and therefore have little or no value, you unwittingly became a prime example of an argument every budding young lawyer knows Post hoc ergo propter hoc . I assume you're talking about rumors of offers involving Tampa Bay and the Marlins for whatever player TB needed to tout that day. But regardless of the situation (and that's the only one that comes to mind in whch both were allegedly offer in the same trade at some time or the other) whether you mean individually or collectively it simply does not follow that because an alleged trade wasn't consummated (any number of reasons - it was a rumor and nothing else, the teams didn't match up, one side or the other got greedy, there was a better offer from someone else) says nothing about the value of the players involved. Post hoc ergo propter hoc. By that measure, the fact that Dontrelle Willis hasn't been traded to the Mets in the last year even though it's been the subject of articles about a hundred times if you want to believe the NY media, the only logical conclusion why it didn't happen is because Willis has "very little value" as you put it. In much the same way that just because you say it doesn't make it true, rumored trades are a dime a dozen. None of us know who was or wasn't offered for who. How many times was Mike Lowell going to be traded in 2003? Was he without value then in the middle of a wildcard race? I think not. In fact the opposite was true. As is the case with Willis. And Jacobs. And Nolasco. And with that, I'm done. (here's a better example of "Post hoc ergo propter hoc" http://www.cuyamaca.edu/bruce.thompson/fallacies/posthoc.asp )
-
Shannon Stewart wants us...
My opinions are based on minor/major league numbers as I posted. Evaluation of his actual tools are based on scout opinions not some random bloggers. Dont be insulted. The only I *think you missed is that just because I think his ceiling is solid #4/setupman doesnt mean Im down on him...it's just what the numbers/scouts suggest. I combine that with my own personal observation/experience leading me to agree with their assertions. The key point here is that we both agree that we dont know for sure what his future holds, which seems fair enough to me. Maybe homer is a strong word for your position, but it was hard for me not to go there when there's literally a Nolasco on every team (at some level) that people overrate the same way. I'll just restate and say that your position is optimistic, but certainly legit. One last thing....I could bring up scouting reports and the numbers, but I see MLou do it so fruitlessly that Id rather not. Nobody is changing any minds here anyway. :thumbup ditto...lol
-
Shannon Stewart wants us...
I didn't miss a thing btw, how #^%$& condescending of you Shamster. When you've seen as much baseball as I have you can start lecturing me then, until you do don't even try. If you bothered to read what I wrote Shamster I said: look at his minor league numbers look at the awards he won in the minor leagues research game summaries and articles from the opposing teams' perspective go through his major league gamelogs and while your at it see when he first showed signs of exhaustion and knee problems I'm not going to do your work for you. If you're too lazy or you don't have the computer skills to do it don't blame me. You've posted nothing that backs up your contentions but you want to hold me to a different standard. Sorry, won't play that game. Everything you present as fact is YOUR OPINION. Nothing more. You pass off speculation as truth. Rumor as fact. What's funny here is a few weeks ago you seemed so surprised I quoted some kid's MLE, I guess it was your mistaken belief I never look at stats. I always look at stats, and gamelogs and game summaries, and press releases from leagues announcing all-stars and awards, and newspaper articles from opposing teams. I look at everything not just a couple of numbers or some bloggers view of the guy from two years ago. And as for you Swift, no matter how many times you state things as fact, doesn't make it so. You keep talking about Stewart and ignore the body of evidence he's still not healthy enough that 29 major league teams won't even give him a minor league invite...sheesh. Try making your case in the abstract. It is much stronger that way. Move Nolasco and Jacobs, make Willingham available to move to first (leaving yourself the option of signing a first baseman) or a left fielder, whichever comes available. Much better case. Much more buy-in. You have obviously 100% given up on Jacobs. You've repeated yourself ad nauseum on him for weeks. I hope you'll understand when I say my guess is you are in the minority and certainly your belief runs counter to that of the front office. You said "We're in the middle of January, at a time when most rosters are set in stone until the end of Spring.". This idea that rosters are already set in stone, implying we're the only team left trying to flesh out our roster is simply incorrect. Almost every team is still looking for someone, some teams are looking for three or four players, some are looking to move players. Tampa dumped a guy this morning. The Mets are still talking to Weaver and others about pitching, the Orioles need everything, the Braves and Pittsburgh just a did deal in the last couple of days and then Atlanta signed Wilson yesterday, the Nationals don't have a starting rotation, the Rockies, Seattle, the A's, I could go on and on, this isn't a time when things are set in stone at all, these are highly fluid days. The only constant right now is change. What's wrong with both your posts is your belief you can see into the future. Let me break the news to you. You can't. You can't know what kind of pitcher Nolasco will turn out to be. Good, bad or in the middle. You can't know how Jacobs will do. You can't promise Stewart will be healthy enough to play or for that matter any player. You're not planning for contingencies. What happens if this season it's Willingham who twists an ankle the day after you trade away Jacobs? What happens if Mitre can never come back or Garcia blows out his shoulder or Benitez comes in, hurts his knee again? Why do you think every team in baseball are inviting all these fringe players to camp under the guise of minor league contracts? Because sh*t happens. Trading away guys like Jacobs and Nolasco now in hopes of getting a "+ centerfielder" may work on your Nintendo but not where it really counts, and certainly not at this time of year. Right now teams are trying to accumulate all the talent it can. If and when one of the prospect kids pushes his way into the starting rotation, or Pinto or Garcia "prove" they belong there, then and only then do you seriously consider moving a Nolasco. Until then its too dangerous. If you want to fault the Marlins FO for not bringing MORE guys in you won't find any disagreement in this corner. I was amazed they didn't sign Craig Wilson all winter with his LHP numbers and his ability at 1B. There's been five or six players who signed minor league contractselsewhere I think we should have at least been in contention for. But like I said, this is not the time to be giving up proven major league talent, this is the time to be garnering it. So you're going to say, what about a centerfielder? I believe, and I've been consistent on this, that the best way to find one is through a trade of equivalent prospects. Bring in a kid who fits with the rest of the team who can defend the position and has shown he can handle a bat at the major league level. They are out there. And they won't cost a Nolasco or a Jacobs. They may cost a top five or ten pitching prospect but for me, that is the way I would go. You (anyone) can fantasize about a Rios, I don't think it's going to happen. I still think before it's done a Maier or Willits (or a kid we've never discussed) like that is the right way to go. If he hits .270+ and gets on base .350+ that is such a quantum improvement over the first half of the season from 2006 it's almost immeasurable. I could go on and on but I have other things to do and no doubt you guys will want to explain to me why I'm wrong. Be my guest. But at least try reading what I wrote and if you can, between the lines.
-
Shannon Stewart wants us...
Did I miss the crystal ball give away at the stadium last year? It was a thursday night against the Pirates but you had to sit through four rain delays to qualify for one.
-
Shannon Stewart wants us...
People are mistaking "being down" on Nolasco with "recognizing his value/ceiling." I'm not saying it's impossible he eclipses being a solid #4, but it's highly unlikely. There are quite a few pitchers in his situation, having one very good pitch and 2 averagish ones, with the possibility that one of those eventually grades to way above average. It just doesnt happen all that often. So, am I being understood now? Speaking for myself I understood you the first time you said it, I just don't happen to agree. And btw I was referring more to the "let's break up the team so we can get Shannon Stewart in left" crowd than your comments. so you believe nolasco is already a #3 or has #3 or potential or above? if so please support with something. ....and btw I agree with your 2nd statement, but still, Nolasco is being homerized. My position is supported by many scouting reports and many hundreds of similar cases. If I get one more "omg, i feel it in my tummy" reason I'll give up rational discussion on this site. *Lately you seem inclined to pass off as "homerism" comments by anyone who has a higher opinion of player than you. Or who analyzes data at hand or stats and comes to a different conclusion than you as irrational*. Or subjective points of view after decades observing the game are what did you call it, "omg, i feel it in my tummy"? If you look at Nolasco's *performance* throughout his minor league career culminating in being *named* Pitcher of the Year in 2005 in the Southern League, he has been a dominant pitcher at virtually every level he performed at for any length of time. Or read opposing team game summaries. Then look at his work as a rookie in 2006 before tiring after sixteen of eighteen months straight pitching. The fact he may not be a three on this team is a product of the guys ahead of him. In Tampa he's a two the day his plane sets down, other teams he's a three, four like Pittsburgh or others. *I get the impression you seem to already know what the future holds for him. I don't know and I'm not afraid to say so. From my perspective we need at least another season to really get a grasp on how good any of these kids, Nolasco included, can be.* I think our disagreement is with his potential. In my mind it is way too soon to be determining his "ceiling" and pigeon-holing him. You have every right to do so if you wish, for myself I think it's premature and I reserve the right to do my research my way and come to any conclusion I come to as long as I'm not ignoring the body of evidence I think is important.
-
Shannon Stewart wants us...
People are mistaking "being down" on Nolasco with "recognizing his value/ceiling." I'm not saying it's impossible he eclipses being a solid #4, but it's highly unlikely. There are quite a few pitchers in his situation, having one very good pitch and 2 averagish ones, with the possibility that one of those eventually grades to way above average. It just doesnt happen all that often. So, am I being understood now? Speaking for myself I understood you the first time you said it, I just don't happen to agree. And btw I was referring more to the "let's break up the team so we can get Shannon Stewart in left" crowd than your comments. Since I'm assuming you're targeting me, please explain how continuing with a void in centerfield and Nolasco in the rotation (on the auxilary is Jacobs at first base) is beneficial for the team when the alternative I and others have proposed brings a good to great centerfielder in for Nolasco and Jacobs, sees Willingham slot in at first and Stewart in left. The question isn't that we'd be better, the question is would Nolasco and Jacobs be enough. Oh Swifty, your paranoia is showing again. Yeah, you made a comment about your head hurting but two people joined you in that opinion. It was a tongue in cheek retort to all of you. I would have said the same thing if you had been the second, third or not at all involved in the comment. The mistake being made here (in my estimation) is combining all these things into one. Needing a centerfielder doesn't mean we need to move Nolasco or Jacobs, and certainly doesn't mean we should be groveling to get a Shannon Stewart, who if news outlets are right has exactly zero interest from GMs in either league after two season-ending injuries in consecutive years. Texas is passing and Baltimore was really something conjured up by a columnist, right now the league sees him as damaged goods. One would assume he's probably working out here in South Florida and theMarlins have had scouts following his progress. If the Marlins aren't interest I have to assume there's a reason. You can not like Jacobs, you can not like Nolasco ("like" meant in the broadest sense) but thinking Shannon Stewart is the solution makes little sense, not to me, but to the decion-makers in baseball. They can all be wrong, I certainly can be wrong, but playing musical chairs with this young team, is for me not the way to go. I believe, in the end, Beinfest will reach out and trade one of our top pitching prospects for an equivalent top centerfield prospect, or perhaps find a third party to get involved to give someone like Washington the starting pitcher they need for a Ryan Chruch (example only), again with us offering prospect(s) to the team in the middle. Now if tomorrow Shannon Stewart gets a clean bill of health I might change partof my thinking on this, but until I see GMs showing interest I have to believe they all can't be wrong. Now you're just distorting what I said. SHANNON STEWART IS NOT THE ANSWER. Getting a good centerfielder is the "answer," and Shannon Stewart just makes the transition easier as we'd fill all 8 positions, instead of making a lateral move with Willingham going to first and creating a new hole in left. I'm not distorting anything...geez. I'm not implying you want Stewart in CF. I'm not even really arguing with you, except that you cling to Shannon Stewart who everyone in baseball seems think is still hurt. I would have less of a disagreement if you didn't name names (him) in your theory. Don't you understand that?
-
Shannon Stewart wants us...
People are mistaking "being down" on Nolasco with "recognizing his value/ceiling." I'm not saying it's impossible he eclipses being a solid #4, but it's highly unlikely. There are quite a few pitchers in his situation, having one very good pitch and 2 averagish ones, with the possibility that one of those eventually grades to way above average. It just doesnt happen all that often. So, am I being understood now? Speaking for myself I understood you the first time you said it, I just don't happen to agree. And btw I was referring more to the "let's break up the team so we can get Shannon Stewart in left" crowd than your comments. Since I'm assuming you're targeting me, please explain how continuing with a void in centerfield and Nolasco in the rotation (on the auxilary is Jacobs at first base) is beneficial for the team when the alternative I and others have proposed brings a good to great centerfielder in for Nolasco and Jacobs, sees Willingham slot in at first and Stewart in left. The question isn't that we'd be better, the question is would Nolasco and Jacobs be enough. Oh Swifty, your paranoia is showing again. Yeah, you made a comment about your head hurting but two people joined you in that opinion. It was a tongue in cheek retort to all of you. I would have said the same thing if you had been the second, third or not at all involved in the comment. The mistake being made here (in my estimation) is combining all these things into one. Needing a centerfielder doesn't mean we need to move Nolasco or Jacobs, and certainly doesn't mean we should be groveling to get a Shannon Stewart, who if news outlets are right has exactly zero interest from GMs in either league after two season-ending injuries in consecutive years. Texas is passing and Baltimore was really something conjured up by a columnist, right now the league sees him as damaged goods. One would assume he's probably working out here in South Florida and the Marlins have had scouts following his progress. If the Marlins aren't interest I have to assume there's a reason. You can not like Jacobs, you can not like Nolasco ("like" meant in the broadest sense) but thinking Shannon Stewart is the solution makes little sense, not to me, but to the decion-makers in baseball. They can all be wrong, I certainly can be wrong, but playing musical chairs with this young team, is for me not the way to go. I believe, in the end, Beinfest will reach out and trade one of our top pitching prospects for an equivalent top centerfield prospect, or perhaps find a third party to get involved to give someone like Washington the starting pitcher they need for a Ryan Chruch (example only), again with us offering prospect(s) to the team in the middle. Now if tomorrow Shannon Stewart gets a clean bill of health I might change part of my thinking on this, but until I see GMs showing interest I have to believe they all can't be wrong.
-
Shannon Stewart wants us...
People are mistaking "being down" on Nolasco with "recognizing his value/ceiling." I'm not saying it's impossible he eclipses being a solid #4, but it's highly unlikely. There are quite a few pitchers in his situation, having one very good pitch and 2 averagish ones, with the possibility that one of those eventually grades to way above average. It just doesnt happen all that often. So, am I being understood now? Speaking for myself I understood you the first time you said it, I just don't happen to agree. And btw I was referring more to the "let's break up the team so we can get Shannon Stewart in left" crowd than your comments.
-
Shannon Stewart wants us...
Somebdy better make a run to Walgreens for a giant economy bottle of aspirin because you're going to need it when this silliness is seen as just that. Spring training is going to be long and painful for the naysayers. What's funny is the guys who are so down on Nolasco now are the same one who jumped on his bandwagon last season when he was making fools of the NL with that curveball of his. The game threads have a way of being very revealing sometimes... :brigginbounce