Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. I sure wouldn't mind Wilson Valdez back in our organization again but I suspect the front office is high enough on Robert Andino that he's not a priority. 724134[/snapback] Not quite sure what your fascination is with him...was he out of options in Chicago? I'm surprised Ozzie couldn't find a spot for him in the organization. I'd rather have Wilson Delgado. 724137[/snapback] The kid always impressed me with his bat, is speedy and plays a terrific SS. I always thought he was the heir apparent to AGon and I was surprised when he was traded. I followed his career for two years in the minors. That said, he is where he is and is who he is. I'll defer to the FO on not re-signing him.
  2. I sure wouldn't mind Wilson Valdez back in our organization again but I suspect the front office is high enough on Robert Andino that he's not a priority.
  3. BTW, did anyone reader Kevin Baxter's piece in the Herald today? I'd reprint it here but if you read my post YESTERDAY from the Detroit Free Press on Tuesday you've already read it. As close to plageurism as you'll find.
  4. Sunday will be an interesting day as teams have to make hard decisions about personnel as they whittle their way down to a 25 man roster. While you're not going to find the next Albert Puljos available there's probably going to be a half-dozen players who would fit nicely in teal. I think the Higginson thing is Dombrowski just trying to get ahead of the herd, and the Marlins would be wise to wait. 723928[/snapback] Care to answer the questions I posted back a few pages? I don't think the Marlins can wait. Encarnacion is taking up valuable playing time from Aguila and Willingham and whatever player might be available Sunday. 723936[/snapback] You're assuming Detroit would be willing to take on Enc's $4.5 million contract, or absent that someone else would, whole or in part. I know I'm repeating myself, but I don't see how the $$$ works unless the Fish wait for Higginson to be cut, then pick him up for the MLB minimum - and then make a deal (or cut) Enc, and then cut the 25th player to make room for him. If the Marlins were to trade Enc and pay his contract (or assume an equal amount of Higginson's contract, then you are left with a $4.5 million platoon player. Not good. If The Marlins could trade Enc first, even paying upperwards of half his contract, and then subsequently pickup someone at the ML minimum (Higgy, Grieve, etc.) they would be much better off. As for questions - who knows what's in the heads of Grieve or Higginson and whether they would sign here if Enc was still in the squad? I'm not a mind-reader. Their decisions may be made on ego - wanting to remain on a MLB roster regardless of playing time. As for who's roster spot? I expect it would be Delgado's but that's just a seat of the pants guess. And lastly, no I don't think it puts the Marlins in a bad light to have Enc platooning or sitting on the bench, that's baseball.
  5. Sunday will be an interesting day as teams have to make hard decisions about personnel as they whittle their way down to a 25 man roster. While you're not going to find the next Albert Puljos available there's probably going to be a half-dozen players who would fit nicely in teal. I think the Higginson thing is Dombrowski just trying to get ahead of the herd, and the Marlins would be wise to wait.
  6. Time will tell but I don't see how the $$$ math works for either team.
  7. Smith looked good this spring. 723590[/snapback] I thought so too.
  8. Just to add a little something, from today's FREEP (Detroit Free Press): "Instead of releasing Higginson this weekend, the Tigers can designate him for assignment. He would then be off the roster, but the Tigers would have 10 days to trade him before they had to release him. Higginson might not reach the job market until the second week of the regular season. The Tigers owe Higginson $8.85 million this season, even if they let him go (and they would probably have to pay most of that contract even if they trade him)."
  9. Oh God, I hope this doesn't mean another season of Nate Bump and Ben Howard. :banghead
  10. It seems to me people are forgetting Encarnacion's $4.5 million contract for 2005. What would probably happen IF SUCH A TRADE were to take place is that the Marlins would wind up paying virtually all of Enc's contract and the Detroit Higginson's. So we'd wind up paying the $4.5 for Higginson instead of Enc. That being the case (because the Tigers are not about to pay both contracts - almost $13 million for the luxury of having Enc playing CF) I don't expect this gets done. Rather, as one article implied, the Marlins will slow play this and wait, probably until he's cut or moments from being cut, and offer a minor leaguer of minimal value, or if they really want the guy, sign him as a free agent upon his release. Enc for Higginson makes no sense. I only hope we don't offer a Chris Aguila or Josh Willingham. As for Greive, there may be better fish to fry. P.S. Nice post PhishPhan :thumbup
  11. It looks like Kelly Stinnet is being let go after a look-see by the Diamondbacks. While I realize the Fish have pretty much made up their mind on Treanor and I'm not second-guessing Beinfest, Stinnett is a guy who interested me at the end of last season, and still does. He can hit for (a better) average, is a good defensive catcher and might find a home on the Marlins 40 man roster, which is what he was looking for in Arizona, and unlike DiFelice would consider playing in the minors while waiting for another shot at the bigs. While things may be crowded at Albuquerque (I assume both Jorgy and Willy wind up there), I would be pleased to see the Fish show some interest in him.
  12. Now we have the worse backup catcher in baseball... 722920[/snapback] Maybe you do, I don't.
  13. I was out of town for a few days. Is Moehler still with the big club?
  14. I watched it on JetBlue flying back from Boston. Of course I have a Marlins cap on and I'm cheering every play. It made an otherwise horrendous flight (rough weather and turbulence all the way down) enjoyable.
  15. There may be more than one reason (JP's injury) for playing Encarnacion in CF yesterday. They could have played Aguila but chose not to. Perhaps the Fish want to see what Enc can do there (If I remember, he played CF for both Cincy and Detroit, so this may just be nothing more than an opportunity for him to get used to the positin again), but at the same time there are also several teams who are looking to upgrade their CF position and some of this may have been to showcase Enc for a trade. Am I concerned about JP? You betcha. Let's hope it's not a knee injury that's being disguised as something else. Boy, this screws up the top of the lineup.
  16. For over 50 years, kids around Miguel's age who have played shortstop their entire lives have succesfully moved to every position in the field. For over 50 years, many major league third basemen and shortstops have been moved to rightfield for their arms and have faired very well immediately or within short time with little to no loss to their teams. I just find it odd how Miguel's such a special case. Then again he is a special player on and off the field. Hope everything works out for the best. I also hope this experiment would have gotten off the planning room floor and put into practice this spring. Unfortunetly Conine's injury and someone or a few did not wish to invest much time or effort to the process didn't allow for that. What did you call it before, Marlins2003? Something about making anything seem true if you draw your conclusions before compiling the data. That seems to have happened in this experiment, wouldn't you say? 717954[/snapback] I didn't say that no one has made a transition from one position to another. I made the point that some have and some haven't.
  17. for all those who say Willingham should be traded, what would you want in return? 717935[/snapback] I think it's too early to tell. Let's see what he does in AAA. Let's see what we need at the break. Let's see if we want to keep him in the organization. Based on this spring the last thing you want to do is trade the guy now.
  18. Rferry, "efficiently run"? Let's take all the personality, all the humanity out of the game, that's what I hear you saying. It reminds me of Boog Sciambi's "Robot Baseball". A link is provided. http://www.790theticket.com/media/Boog%20R...%20Baseball.mp3 and then part two http://www.790theticket.com/media/The%20En...%20Baseball.mp3 (For all of you who haven't heard this, it's hilarious !!!!!!) The fun (or frustration) of baseball is that it's imperfect. It's a Bill Buckner ball through the legs event, a Bartman, a Chad Bentz, a Jimmy Peirsall playing next to a Ted Williams. The reason baseball is the game it is, is because it isn't efficient.
  19. This has been quite a strange case. A leftfielder who is incapable of playing the other corner outfield position. So strange in fact that it probably has little to do with his abilities, rather the whims of Cabrera and the team. Oh well. I hope Hermida has as good as an arm as reported by some, and that he blossoms into a starter in the Marlins' outfield. 717884[/snapback] I don't for the life of me understand why you would think that he should be able to play both positions and to characterize it as a "whim" is not, at least to me, well-reasoned. The landscape is littered with ballplayers who, for one reason or another, could not make the transition from one position to another effectively ending their careers. And I don't buy this notion that he's not a better left fielder than right. If you saw him as many times as some of us have at PPS, he always seemed to have that deer caught in the headlights look in right. Antedoctal evidence to be sure, but nonetheless after fifty+ years of watching this game, obvious. Each player brings with him certain strengths and weaknesses. Cabrera's entire baseball life experience has been on the left side of the diamond. Do I think if the Marlins were a perpetual fourth or fifth place team with no hope of winning for seasons to come they could force the guy into the position and have him learn it over a number of years regardless of winning and losing? Sure. But that's not the case. His strength is in left field, he's admitted as much. Winning every game is important right now, this season. I believe that making his defensive obligations less of a burden for him will mean better at bats, translating, if he's more comfortable in left he doesn't have to worry about the flyball he just misplayed in right, he may take better hacks. And over time he may turn out to be a very competent left fielder. There was a time when many thought Miguelito could play just about any position on the diamond. Left field, right, third, shortstop, second, even first. I hope that debate is over. He's our left fielder.
  20. It's difficult to balance Treanor's experience with the staff, a staff he knows and from what's been written, the pitchers respects, against DiFelice's longer major league experience. The latter is hitting better this spring and both are optionable back to AAA so this one is going to go down to the wire. I voted for Treanor but either one (from what any of us know as outsiders) seems capable of contributing.
  21. Time will tell who was wrong, but I'm in the camp that believes in a couple of years Choi will be a bonafide run-producing first baseman. I believe it's really too early in his career to characterize him as sucking or some of the other epithets thrown around in this thread. He may flop, we'll see, but with the right hitting instructor and a good lineup around him, my belief is he will turn out to be the cornerstone (for the Didgers) of that trade.
  22. There's a surprise. Not. Perhaps this will finally put to bed all the musings we've endured here suggesting Cabrera could and/or would be playing right field in 2005.
  23. First off thanks for the PM, Marlins2003. If you knew the site, you'd understand and possibly embrace the cynical tone. 717242[/snapback] When statheads are able to quantify guts, brains and instincts, courage in the clutch and meaning of team spirit and desire, perhaps then I will. When staheads can quantify the magic of Castillo and Gonzalez, the heroics of a Bryan Harvey or recognize that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts, maybe I'll embrace the theoretical world of baseball equationology. Until then I will continue to consider it all hockum.
  24. Sean Ransom's piece was the most boorish pile of crap ("look ma I really did use that thesaurus you gave me for Christmas") I've read in a long time, and only serves to remind true baseball fans (as opposed to stat-heads who seem more occupied with numbers than with the concept of the game or of teamwork) exactly why guys like this are always, predictably, 100% wrong.
  25. I checked out the box score just before coming here and I noticed Mecir was credited with pitching one inning and had three strikeouts. Struck out the side, not bad ! :mischief2

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.