Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Who should be the Marlins' Backup Catcher?

Featured Replies

I don't know who I would choose. Jorg seems to be doing pretty well with the bat and the glove, but he could still use some work in the minors. Treanor and DiFelice are both older, but they both are pretty solid and similar players.

 

All 3 are worthy, but who should get it?

 

(Note to Ramp and other Willingham lovers: Willy is more than a catcher and I think his future may be in the outfield rather than in catching)

Treanor is a AAA player at best, Jorg is good defensively, which is what the Marlins need out of their backup catcher. I'm not sure how much DeFelice has left.

*Boycott*

Willingham's getting some quality experience at catching this spring despite his lack of game action at the position.

 

 

I'm leaning towards Treanor, but with five new pitchers (and Mota, Valdez and Perisho), his status as the longest tenured Marlins catcher may not be of great importance.

Treanor proved last season he couldn't handle it (alone anyway)

Jorg is unproven

DeFelice is your only real option

I know 'Jorg' is a fan favorite on here, but he is far from ready to be on the Marls right now. They will probably just go with Treanor since he was here last season. I like Willingham, but DiFelice would be my choice since he is a veteran, and you pretty much know what you will get from him (although not much offensively).

DiFelice is the best choice, he's a proven vet. Willingham should be traded and trenor just simply should be a career minor leaguer he's not the answer, and Jorg is still a couple years away from it.

Treanor proved last season he couldn't handle it (alone anyway)

Jorg is unproven

DeFelice is your only real option

717786[/snapback]

I agree

Treanor proved last season he couldn't handle it (alone anyway)

Jorg is unproven

DeFelice is your only real option

717786[/snapback]

I agree

717839[/snapback]

same i agree with both

It's difficult to balance Treanor's experience with the staff, a staff he knows and from what's been written, the pitchers respects, against DiFelice's longer major league experience. The latter is hitting better this spring and both are optionable back to AAA so this one is going to go down to the wire.

 

I voted for Treanor but either one (from what any of us know as outsiders) seems capable of contributing.

Treanor proved last season he couldn't handle it (alone anyway)

Jorg is unproven

DeFelice is your only real option

717786[/snapback]

I don't see how Treanor has proven he couldn't handle it any more than DiFelice.

for all those who say Willingham should be traded, what would you want in return?

for all those who say Willingham should be traded, what would you want in return?

717935[/snapback]

 

I think it's too early to tell.

 

Let's see what he does in AAA. Let's see what we need at the break. Let's see if we want to keep him in the organization. Based on this spring the last thing you want to do is trade the guy now.

for all those who say Willingham should be traded, what would you want in return?

717935[/snapback]

A young power-hitter who can draw walks and play many positions.

 

Oh, nevermind.

 

A manager that isn't afraid to test his older prospects in key reserve roles would be great.

Treanor proved last season he couldn't handle it (alone anyway)

Jorg is unproven

DeFelice is your only real option

717786[/snapback]

I don't see how Treanor has proven he couldn't handle it any more than DiFelice.

717892[/snapback]

Treanor had a shot at it last year and didn't impress enough for Jack to name him the backup. Therefore DiFelice is the best candidate before Jack reverts to "Backup catcher by committee"

Why?

 

Because he's new to the squad? Because he hasn't failed with the Marlins?

difelice hit .120 last year and is a career .239 hitter.

i would rather let treanor, who knows the staff better, have the backup job

for all those who say Willingham should be traded, what would you want in return?

717935[/snapback]

Ken Griffey Jr. + the ability to let us DH

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.