Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Phillies interested in Hermida??
Erick, once again the fact that you don't know what you're talking about does not mean I have to lift a finger to assist you. Nor, unless you're calling me a liar, do I have to back up every word I say here when all of it is in the archives of this website and if you weren't so lazy you would have found all by yourself. There's no losing an argument on this kid. That's your usual gambit. Really you trot that out all the time and it's just not anyone's job here to be your mentor. Get off your a** and find it for yourself.
-
Phillies interested in Hermida??
Oh, enlighten me. It's not my job to be your research assistant. Try going through the archives, its been spoken about for years...start in 2002. Then you could go back through google new archives from 2002-2005. And yet, you're still missing my point. If you're too lazy to do a couple of simple searches not my problem. As for your ridiculous notion that somehow Cliff Floyd would ever be allowed back in this organization, it would require an ownership change. Yeah b/c Wes Helms NEVER said anything bad about the organization after his first departure. Who does he play for now, again? It's a business. *Unless if you actually know Jeffrey Loria and the gang personally...which I doubt you do.* Isn't it past your bedtime? There's no comparison between Cliff Floyd and Wes Helms. It isn't even close.
-
Phillies interested in Hermida??
Oh, enlighten me. It's not my job to be your research assistant. Try going through the archives, its been spoken about for years...start in 2002. Then you could go back through google new archives from 2002-2005. And yet, you're still missing my point. If you're too lazy to do a couple of simple searches not my problem. As for your ridiculous notion that somehow Cliff Floyd would ever be allowed back in this organization, it would require an ownership change. Or you could try backing your point up with statements. Oh really Rabb? All the kid has to do is simply search and learn for himself. In fact I think I mentioned one of his transgressions in this thread (or another I really don't care or remember). The rest are a simple search away.
-
Phillies interested in Hermida??
Oh, enlighten me. It's not my job to be your research assistant. Try going through the archives, its been spoken about for years...start in 2002. Then you could go back through google new archives from 2002-2005. And yet, you're still missing my point. If you're too lazy to do a couple of simple searches not my problem. As for your ridiculous notion that somehow Cliff Floyd would ever be allowed back in this organization, it would require an ownership change.
-
Phillies interested in Hermida??
Oh, enlighten me. It's not my job to be your research assistant. Try going through the archives, its been spoken about for years...start in 2002. Then you could go back through google new archives from 2002-2005.
-
Phillies interested in Hermida??
Lou, I just love the way you keep bringing up Cliff Floyd. It's such a joke. There is more chance I will push Cameron Maybin out of the way and back to the minors when I win the CF spot than Cliff Floyd ever wearing a Marlins uniform again. Why is that? The team brought back Wes Helms, no? You guys need to lay off the whole "he said, she said." At the end of the day, it's a business, and winning leads to better business. The Marlins will get the best available player that will fit their payroll limit. If that guy is Cliff Floyd...it'll be Cliff Floyd. You obviously have no idea what you're talking about in this case. No offense. Not a chance.
-
Phillies interested in Hermida??
Lou, I just love the way you keep bringing up Cliff Floyd. It's such a joke. There is more chance I will push Cameron Maybin out of the way and back to the minors when I win the CF spot than Cliff Floyd ever wearing a Marlins uniform again. I don't think I need to repeat the litany of things he did while he was here and said afterwards for multiple years every time he had a chance to stick the knife in as it regards the Fish, let's leave it at Cliff Floyd openly admitting to watching the 2003 World Series rooting against the Marlins. Not rooting for the Yankees, rooting against the Marlins. At least try to be realistic. I don't disagree with your "big picture" (although I'm not sure trading Cantu is a wise move) but bringing up Cliffie only undermines your case.
-
It's not all doom and gloom in South Florida
No conversation on this subject should include Fenway which is now shoehorned into what was a baseball dominated area and now, as is so much of Boston and most cities, totally overbuilt. I can remember as a kid parking outside the stadium or worse came to worse in a small parking garage across the street on Brookline Avenue. but then again those were the days when 4,000 people went to games there, before John Hancock and Prudential starting buying up every ticket they could for their use leaving the regular fan with few seats available. Even in the seventies and eighties you could still find a place to park on the street within a few blocks or take the T to Kenmore and walk the two blocks. The free market will assess the parking needs at the new Marlins stadium site and any vacuum will be filled. With today's depressed real estate prices I have no doubt corporations interested in servicing the venue are buying up distressed properties throughout the area for just that purpose. As for DS it's a pit, everyone knows it's a pit, customer service is non-existent, the food awful, what else would you expect from Wayne Huizenga who once opined after selling the franchise that baseball was destined to fail in South Florida. Between cozing up to the state Senate president to kill funding and lobbying anywhere necessary, not to mention just the stadium itself, he has been standing the franchise's airhose for a decade now doing everything in his power to prove himself right. I can't until we're out of there.
-
Four Added to 40-Man Roster
I thought I had explained to you twice Lou why he isn't eligible. And it's Rule 5, not Rule V.
-
slow offseason
Quiet before the storm
-
Four Added to 40-Man Roster
Lou, I mean this politely and respectfully but I believe you are over-thinking this. If what I postulated is correct for West, and you agree it is, then the same criteria applies to every other player. Eighteen and younger get five, older four, that first part season immediately after being drafted doesn't count in the Rule 5 because the clock starts with the first subsequent R5D. You go from there.
-
Four Added to 40-Man Roster
A general observation - people are suffering from Rule 5-itis and forgetting the purpose the 40 man roster serves most of the year in baseball. Things will get back to normal after the winter meeting, and new players come aboard via signings and trades, and spring training, and the active roster being set. edit: They didn't leave Sean West off because this is some circus act running the front office, they know what they're doing. That should tell you your theories are incorrect.
-
Four Added to 40-Man Roster
High school draftees from '04 & college guys from '05 are eligible. That is my understanding. I agree, that's how the rules should be interpreted. For Sean West, high school draftee 2005 Rule 5 draft to 2006 draft - one year 2006 Rule 5 draft to 2007 draft - two years 2007 Rule 5 draft to 2008 draft - three years (this year is the 2008 Rule 5 draft) 2008 Rule 5 draft to 2009 draft - four years (West is eligible for THIS draft) The time between when he was drafted and when the first Rule 5 draft after he was drafted does not count because it wasn't a year. A player's clock starts with the first draft after he signs and is measured in whole years. This method of counting matches up with everyone from Wikipedia to MLB to Cots to some Yankee fan with a blog.
-
Marlins win lawsuit
I don't the exact language in front of me but I particularly liked the last sentence which says the court retains jurisdiction to hear any claims for repayment of legal fees and associated costs arising from the suit. Which is a nice way of saying, "Mr. Braman, be careful how you proceed lest the defendants turn around and sue 'you'. Maybe if you just go away..."
-
Uh-Oh Pavano
I'm sorry but I still need some corroboration on this one. So far, a day+ later no one, I mean no one, has followed up on this "story". I would have thought if there was a shred of truth to it Capozzi would have reported something but not even in his blog. In the pure coincidence dept., the PBP ran a piece the day before this "story" that Donald Trump was hosting a PGA event. Wednesdays on the tour are usually Pro-Am days where the pros get to familiarize themselves with the course and the amateurs swing out of their shoes trying to impress the pros with how far they can hit a seven iron. It's not an unreasonable guess that the two guys were among the amateur players that day and there's your big meeting. But as I said, I'm just guessing.
-
Uh-Oh Pavano
Lou and i were talking about two different players. I thought he was saying we would go to arb with Pavano which didn't make sense to me but he wa talking about Nelson, and to make it more confusing while I was talking about Pavano he thought I was talking about Nelson. Is everyone on the same page now?
-
Uh-Oh Pavano
I would bet you (in the fugurative sense) the Marlins and Pavano do not go to arbitration. He may also chose to retire should he be unable to come back. There are a lot of options that aren't just black and white. My god, the guy hasn't been announced as part of the team yet. And I don't think he becomes part of the team without a contract favorable to the Marlins.
-
Uh-Oh Pavano
Why don't we wait to see what he's got before we pigeon-hole him. he might come back and be an effective starter worthy of a slot in the rotation, he may come back and be more useful in the bullpen and there's a strong likelihood he'll come back and not make this team.
-
Four Added to 40-Man Roster
If Rabelo clears waivers, does that impact this at all? Rabelo's spot on the 40 man roster has already been filled. The only question whether he remains in the Marlins organization or not.
-
Four Added to 40-Man Roster
The anniversary date does *not* make them free agents in June/July, it is the clock that controls Rule 5 draft eligibility and nothing else. You're painting with too wide a brush.
-
Four Added to 40-Man Roster
I found it quickly, or rather a reference to it. It is the number of drafts after the day they were drafted. The "year" refers to the time between their first draft and the next amateur draft. If you were for example drafted in the 2006 amateur draft your anniversary date is the 2007 amateur draft. I'm surprised it's not when they signed but it doesn't look that way. It may be because in exposing themselves to the draft in effect makes them professional ballplayers on that day. edit: So if a player was drafted in the 2006 draft only the 2007 and 2008 drafts have occurred and that would translate to two years as used above.
-
Four Added to 40-Man Roster
(It's the Rule 5 not the Rule V as an aside and) I'm not saying you're wrong but it's general practice when a number of years is used in a contract, for example a five year employment contract (in the corporate world) doesn't mean more than four, it means five full years. I find it hard to believe that lawyers on both sides drawing up the BA and CBA are going to step outside their normal definitions to write these deals. What that does is cause ambiguity and that's the last thing either party wants. When does four become five? When is five, five? But like I said there may a glossary that's attached that defines words like this. I say that because we have (not you and I but on this board generally) this argument every year and it seems to me in a year previous I found said glossary when I was researching Rule 5. None of which means you're wrong because I don't have an inclination to pour of a hundred pages of legalese again to get to the truth, so we'll probably have to wait until we get closer to the draft to know for sure. I also don't know what constitutes a start date, whether the short summer leagues in Upper State New York are considered a season or not, etc. And why those two players I couldn't say. BTW I agree with you on Mobley. He was something of a machine last season in Carolina.
-
Four Added to 40-Man Roster
I don't know the answer with any certainty but it seems to me in MLB lingo 5 years means five full years (as in 5 years and one day) and the Rule 5 is before the start of the 2009 season so they are still in their fourth year not fifth. Somewhere in the CBA has to be a glossary that defines words like "year" and "season" and how the clock works. But I'm pretty sure the end of the fourth season of play does no mean a player is in his fifth season of ballplaying when the next season hasn't begun.
-
Uh-Oh Pavano
Is there any other corroboration...I mean the "Bleacher Report"? If you read the whole article the writer seems to think the Marlins remaining rotation is a bunch of sniveling adolescents who probably need someone to point out where the mound is. "The leadership of Pavano would definitely go a long way in giving younger pitchers Chris Volstad, Josh Johnson, Anibal Sanchez, and Ricky Nolasco more confidence." Like Ricky Nolasco needs more confidence.
-
Uh-Oh Pavano
Is there any chance that Pavano bumps Anibal/Miller to AAA for a test run/more seasoning, and if Pavano has some difficulties and the other guy is doing well, then they could sub him in? Tune in tomorrow...it's kind of bizarre signing but Pavano and this franchise go way back. You have to wonder though if there's more to this?