Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Valid

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Valid

  1. To be fair, this is one example from 16 years ago. The exception doesn't make the rule. While I certainly don't think run differential is a be-all-end-all statistic, it is typically one of the best indications how good a team actually is over the course of 162 games. Just look at the standings from previous seasons. The teams with the best records almost always also have the best run differentials. Like I said: over the course of 40 games, it's a mediocre stat at best because the sample size is so small. But once you start really getting into the meat of the season in July and August, it will usually tell you which teams are contenders and which teams aren't.
  2. To be fair, if a guy is batting .200 for five years a in row, chances are, he's a .200 hitter. While nothing is 100 percent certain, past performance is absolutely the best predictor of future results and anyone who tries to deny it is kidding themselves. This is why certain free agents get paid significantly more than others. Because of what they've done in the past. As for the run differential argument, we are talking about a very small sample size here where a couple of blowout losses will severely skew the numbers. We are only 40 games into a 162-game season, so yes; the run differential is obviously subject to change, especially if and when guys like Segura get their heads out of their rear ends. It is also additionally subject to change if the Marlins acquire another player or two (as you already mentioned). That being said, the Marlins are also 12-0 in one-run games, which is not sustainable. So while the run differential is subject to change, so is the club's record in one-run games, which is a scary thought.
  3. Beckett is too high, in my opinion. I love him and he was definitely phenomenal in the 2003 postseason, but he was never as dominant as Jose, JJ, Sandy or Brown. I actually think Beckett was pretty disappointing, all things considered. Very good pitcher, but never became the bona fide ace everyone pretty much thought he would become after his performance in the 2003 World Series.
  4. I agree with everything you said except these two points. Outside of a short stretch between 2013 and 2015, the Pirates have been one of the worst franchises in baseball (probably the worst) since the early '90s. It's going to take a lot more than a decent start over 30 or so games to change their culture. Lol. Heck, even the Marlins have had some seasons where they've gotten off to pretty great starts and we see where that has gotten us. And as for things fizzling out in 2017, I would actually argue they fizzled out the moment Jose died in 2016. That group of Stanton, Yelich, Ozuna and Jose was actually really, really good on paper, and they were playoff contenders for a good portion of 2016. Jose's death pretty much put the kibosh on everything, both from a talent and an emotional standpoint. It completely took the air out of that group, and the only reason why 2017 was even all that watchable was because Stanton had arguably the most dominant stretch in MLB history.
  5. That was about to be his best season, too. He was untouchable that year. As great as Sandy has been and as incredible as Jose was, I still say that peak JJ was the most dominant pitcher to ever put on a Marlins uniform.
  6. We at least got a few fantastic years out of JJ. We have gotten what, 40-50 innings between regular season and playoffs out of Sixto?
  7. I would say they probably are a playoff contender (and I use that term loosely), but that's only because the rest of the NL just isn't very good as a whole and not because the Marlins are actually any good. Like, they could win 81 games and finish a few games out of a playoff spot.
  8. As if Derek Jeter was the first person in the history of the Marlins front office to do this. Lol.
  9. Perfect example of defensive metrics not being entirely reliable for catchers. He allows tons of passed balls, is bad at pitch framing, calls a terrible game and is lazy behind the plate. Pitchers don't even like throwing to him. Gerrit Cole in particular wanted nothing to do with him. Like I said: I watched him extensively throughout his Yankees tenure. The only saving grace of Sanchez is that he has a decent arm (and even his arm has actually declined rather significantly from his earlier days).
  10. He is one of the worst defensive catchers in baseball and has hit either at or below .200 in four of the last five years. If he were a Marlin, everyone would want him gone. Believe me: I live in NJ and watched a TON of Sanchez while he was with the Yankees. There is a reason why no MLB team wants this guy on their roster.
  11. 1. This doesn't even make any sense. 2. He has a biceps issue right now. 3. It's May 2.
  12. To be fair, most here liked the Segura signing at the time. I don't think anyone expected him to turn into a lemon. Plenty of time for him to turn it around, too.
  13. It would definitely help, but the chances of the Marlins landing a premier bat seem pretty slim. That's why I think they might have to settle for a couple of solid bats (think Nick Johnson types like in 2009).
  14. @GenderNeutralWog @SilverBullet I was referring more to middle-of-the-road guys (guys like Avi, Segura, John Buck, etc.); not so much All-Star caliber players like Pudge and Delgado. But even still, those guys were 20 years ago. Nuts.
  15. I'd say they need multiple bats. Of course it would help if Segura decided to stop sucking, but even if he returns to his career norm, this offense still isn't remotely good enough.
  16. Crazy enough, the only couple of guys I can think of off the top of my head who ever "worked out" in that sense are Cantu (which was a decade-and-a-half ago) and Aguilar (kind of). I have to be missing some, right?
  17. I'm willing to give Segura some time because he has been a consistently solid player for his entire career. He has obviously been beyond horrific so far this season, but I still have hope that he can return to his career norm. That being said, the Marlins have historically tended to have some pretty piss poor luck with these types of middle-of-the-road hitters, so who knows.
  18. To be fair, the Mets and Braves are also both clearly better teams than the Marlins.
  19. Not to mention that he is one of only like four hitters on this team who has actually managed to not suck.
  20. Definitely. The last genuinely "good" team we had was 2009 (hard to really count 2020 because of the 60-game campaign). Actually, between 2003 and 2009, this franchise was largely competitive and you can argue they probably should have made the playoffs a couple of more times than they did during that span. The Marlins have just been so bad since like 2011 that any glimmer of a competitive team is a breath of fresh air. I'll say it again: I absolutely think there is potential here. The FO better not screw this up. Wishful thinking, I know.
  21. One thing I will say about this team is that they may very well be the most interesting/bearable group to watch since, what, 2017? And that was only because Stanton went ballistic that year. Before that, you probably have to go all the way back to 2009. I really, really hope the FO actually takes things seriously and adds a couple of more bats either at the trade deadline or during the offseason (or both) because there is some potential here. Whether or not Sherman actually gives the go-ahead to spend more remains to be seen (lol I know).
  22. I mean it's pretty self explanatory. Our offense stinks.
  23. Still not getting my hopes up with this team because it has so many holes, but I will say it is nice to see the club not essentially be done for the year in late April for a change.
  24. Good thing they upgraded the offense this past offseason!
  25. You are grossly exaggerating. He owns a lifetime .736 OPS, which is very average. He also had three "good" years in 2017, 2019 and 2021; not two. Meanwhile, he OPSed .582 with the Marlins last year and is OPSing .453 this season. To sit here and essentially act like this is who he has been his entire career is just wrong. You really think the Marlins would have given him four years if these were the types of numbers he was typically posting?

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.