Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

MarlinsLou

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by MarlinsLou

  1. I didn't say that at all? I'm just suggesting here this is a bad landing spot for Chi Chi unless pitchers are moved out so maybe there is some writing on the wall here if Chi Chi thinks he has a path to the roster. Also check out statcast - https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/savant-player/chi-chi-gonzalez-592346?stats=statcast-r-pitching-mlb Scroll way down. 4th most similar pitcher - 2021 Zach Thompson. That's interesting and likely not a coincidence. They must have a pitch mix plan here and maybe he works out like Thompson did. It costs nothing to find out. Still need the big moves though, but this is a who cares and fine flyer. Every team makes these signings, it's just amplified because they have done nothing else as an organization besides pick up Chargois for the MLB roster.
  2. I hope this means Chi Chi sees a path to the bigs, i.e. multiple pitchers are about to be traded. Otherwise, this is a really terrible landing spot for him with a difficult path forward. But view it as it is - AAA innings and if 2-4 guys get hurt, maybe he sneaks on. Maybe they feel they can pitch mix a reliever out of him. Who cares, let's get to the meat instead of maxing out the AAA squad.
  3. Reyes would be a good flyer on a healthy MiLB deal and they should trade for Feyereisen and sit on him until September when he is healthy. He can pitch a few weeks this year and avoid being a super 2 (if that matters for a reliever) and have 4 more years of control. That would be some cheap and potentially radical RHP bullpen upgrades. Still would be good to get one more, but it would be some real progress and aligns with being cheap to a fault.
  4. It's Bruce. He's probably pissed Garcia/Soler cost some bucks so no radical money deals right now, and when they win 79 games doing nothing next year, Kim says look we were right and improved 10 games and the pitching is good - we should have you know, gotten those 8-10 more wins we talked about pre 2023 spring training. And maybe Bruce will let them do something then when there is more proof in concept. Of course, now we've wasted a year of control on that list above and who knows what is available via sign or trade next offseason, when we have this data readily available the team will be just under .500 right now doing nothing, but it is what it is. At least the pitching will be a year older and maybe Meyer/Bender are back? It's just time though and to stop kicking the can. Bruce needs to invest "something" and Kim needs to plant some trade flags to fit into their budget. And yea, maybe the SP is thin short term if you have to trade 2-3 of the top 6 guys to do it, but you're hoarding those farm arms so buck up and find another Thompson and Bender and conjure up another unexpected Garret performance out of Castano/Sixto and figure shit out. That's the job.
  5. It takes two to tango - we can all aggregate information from Fangraphs, Statcast, and make statistical trades that all make sense on paper given what "the industry" believes, but it's still an eye of the beholder scenario. Do these other teams like these players? Medical issues? Can this guy hold up defensively? Are they open to arbitration buy outs (Yelich), or do they want to bet on themselves (Ozuna)? etc. Basically, I think the FO is a lot smarter than it appears to be right now, but something is missing. I think this is a scared money thing. The Marlins are scared for making a mistake because the margin of error is so low - hence why the theme of everything is BRUCE SUCKS THE MOST. You can't make a mistake if you don't do anything as any other deal is hypothetical. Scared money don't make money and this is the Marlins. Whereas I would say, they need to operate like Billy Beane in his Oakland prime and wheel and deal, spend money when necessary (Oakland was always cheap but they did spend on random contending years here and there, etc.), and give the fans some hope. Even if that's only 4 out of every 10 years. Frankly, that's a big step forward IMO. And they are positioned right now to do it and options are dwindling fast.
  6. Why can't it BOTH. I choose all of the above.
  7. Well to be fair they did bring in 3 offensive upgrades last year, they just turned out to be downgrades. And Groshans was a smart trade. But yes much more is needed. TBH I kind of like that idea above and to expand: Ship out Pablo and Garret (and Scott and Rojas) and get Arraez and Jansen Ship out prospects for Rosario, which I just realized if they get Jansen could be Mack which is perfect, in addition to say Miller/Millbrandt and Burdick and Cleveland has got to be happy about that Ship out whatever guys for Michael Taylor and we deal with CF issues another year down the road And then sign Rodon. For a lot. I am thinking 8-9/$200 (yes), but it's effectively say a 3/$87 deal with a 6/$113 insurance policy (or maybe 5 years instead?). Basically, take the bet Rodon kills and opts out and shoots for a DeGrom deal when he is 33. It's the same bet you'd be making with Correa who will require an opt out, but at $100m+ less of longterm payroll if something goes wrong as he'd be $300+ as a player. This team is roughly $111m in 2023: Jansen, Fortes Cooper (Arraez) Jazz Rosario, Wendle Arraez, Berti DLC, Sanchez M. Taylor (Sanchez) Garcia Soler Sandy, Rodon, Luzardo, Cabrera, Rogers (Eury and Eder, and Fulton next year) _____, Floro, Chargois, Nance, "Club Controlled" (Sixto, and Meyer and Bender next year) Bleier, Okert, Castano (Nardi/Simpson) Extend Jansen for 5/$55m-ish (ages 28-32) Extend Rosario for 5/$65-70m (ages 27-31) Extend Arraez for 5/$65ish (ages 26-30, + maybe an option year very expensive) Extend Luzardo for 5/$35 + option (ages 25-29) Extend Jazz for 6/$70m (ages 25-30, if he'd take it. The other guys all would) What an offseason and everyone is good on cheap contracts and happy they got paid. Those all comp out to arbitration buy out comparables. And we fight the longterm CF battle again next year. It won't happen but how could any owner be upset with that team for $111m, and your club control on your starting lineup is: 5 (with two catchers) 1 (and then Berry) 4+ (if Jazz would do an extension) 5 (and then Watson) 5 (and then Salas/Cappe if he has to move) 5 (assuming DLC/Sanchez/Bleday work into a low end starter) 1 (need a CF still) 3 (Garcia) 1-2 (Soler) 5+ (Cabrera, Rogers, Eury Eder) 5 (Sandy) 3+ (Rodon) You have immense cost certainty and then for the love of god, your first two picks in 2023 better be college outfielders. You'd open 2024 with 23 guys signed for roughly $107m and need a starting 1B and CF, and a backup 2B/SS type. And still have 9 SP (Sandy, Rodon, Luzardo, Rogers, Cabrera, Eury, Eder, Fulton, Meyer) and four high end bats on paper (Berry, Salas, Cappe, Watson... plus 2023 picks) and there is certainly trade opportunities here for a CF, the backup 2B/SS is cheap, and 1B is likely a stop gap as we wait for Berry. Like how about we do this and have a cohesive plan?
  8. If I can do this while on hold on a call, I am optimistic they have minimal levels of creativity. That is, unless they really just value someone differently than prevailing wisdom which of course can be the case. Maybe Arraez can't play 3B? It only works if he can do that (or Jazz SS TBH and then replace Turner/Drury/Longoria with Rosario above).
  9. I don't know, but Toronto could use another SP and an OF upgrade. You know, like Braxton Garrett and Max Kepler. For instance, assuming the Twins don't get Correa (or even if they do?), Polanco/N. Gordon are heavy RHP splits guys and they can cover SS/2B and Farmer who they traded for, plays both and hits lefties. Rojas would be perfect for them to split everyone out in the infield (this is assuming Arraez is the Marlins trade target of course). Lewis could also take over SS in a year. Twins also need depth lefties - they could really use Bleier/Scott/Okert as a 2nd/3rd bullpen lefty and Nardi/Simpson/Reynolds would all be welcome AAA depth and future pen arms. I took a look and they have two on their 40 man. What I'm getting here is, in a world Larnach-Buxton-R. Lewis/A.Martin/Wallner cover the Twins OF (and N. Gordon and I believe Farmer and Kiriloff can pop out there also), Kepler isn't needed and he makes a lot of sense for the Blue Jays. Arms will always be appreciated for a contender So: Marlins - Arraez, D. Janson, Mid-Tier Twins Prospect Twins - P. Lopez, Rojas, Scott/Okert, Nardi/Simpson B. Jays - B. Garrett, M. Kepler Pablo and Garrett are steep here, but these are two longterm bat solutions (assuming Arraez can play 100+ games at 3B/2B) for their lowest control and lowest upside SP, and frankly, that Twins prospect may be more important than depth lefties which they are good at finding. And they can trade Stallings to recoup a depth lefty, so it's effectively Pablo/Garrett for Arraez/Jansen once the smaller guys and payroll net out. I think everyone is pretty happy here? Twins get a massive starter and depth options, Blue Jays two very useful guys to break up their catcher redundancy, and the Marlins two big bat upgrades + shedding payroll So now, the Marlins are sitting at $75 million-ish for this: Jansen, Fortes Cooper (Arraez) Jazz _____, Wendle Arraez, Berti DLC, Sanchez ______ Garcia Soler Sandy, Rogers, Cabrera, Luzardo, ______ _____, Floro, Chargois, Nance, Sixto/Brazoban/Whoever Bleier, Okert/Scott, Castano We're likely talking about signing a stop gap 1 year SP and maybe a bullpen longman/innings eater (unless they think Castano/Sixto can do that?) while we wait for Eury, Eder, Fulton, and then Meyer and Bender. All of whom are virtually untouchable given two SP were just shot out. Wade Miley? If we believe in the young pitcher, I say let's believe in the young pitching. And then I'd say, what does Cleveland want for A. Rosario which I imagine could be a prospect trade and avoid using Berry/Salas/Cappe/upper level pitchers for that. Maybe they'd go for something based on Miller and Peguro/Gerardo. This clears $8-9m for Cleveland so they could use that to sign someone more useful for them and take some HR prospect swings. I think the Marlins have the goods here to do it if Cleveland would take a longterm approach. They have other options so doesn't impact MLB team. And then figure out CF. This could even be Michael Taylor who is unspectacularly solid and wouldn't cost the top prospects again, and they could play Sanchez out in CF 60 games vs RHP. It's a band aid yes and I am CF cheerleader # 1, but if C/3B/SS are figured out with longterm options (I imagine a Rosario 5/$70 extension sort of thing), that is acceptable to me. So that's yea another hypothetical of the Marlins having an interesting team on paper that would stand a chance for under $100m. I'd like to say, push it to $115m and just sign Rodon and not a stop gap SP there, but let's not get crazy. Spending bottom 20th payroll after 20 years of being lowest in baseball is absurd.
  10. It's being reported DBacks are talking Varsho to Houston. Now that's the one where Kim/FO needs to put on their big boy and girl pants and muscle out every other team for a CF.
  11. I don't even know how they have the prospects to do this. This must indicate they are resigning Swanson (or Correa!) so they can make Grissom and Contreras available to the A's. This division is getting beyond ridiculous and I hope a large feeling of hopelessness is befalling Bruce so he immediately sells tomorrow.
  12. I think it's a larger competitive balance question. The Mets luxury tax is going to be higher than 8 teams opening day 2022 payrolls, and a stone's throw for 2 more. That's 1/3rd the league whose budget is, he's just paying a penalty on. Say what you will about Miami/Cleveland/Tampa/Oakland/Pittsburgh/etc. being cheap, but this is a big delta and Bruce spending $40m more dollars next year keeps Miami in this sphere. Mets 2023 payroll and luxury is currently 1.6x the top 2022 payroll. He's running peak Dodgers plus another $130m. Just for perspective, 12 teams ran $130m and under payrolls in 2022. Also are they even paying Bauer on suspension? So It actually may be more as Bauer's contract was enormous. So you outspend everyone, let's say it works and Mets win 3 of next 5 world series. What do fans of the sports think? Is this fun (even for some Mets fans?), just having some wealthy guy outspend teams by double or quadruple and overall radically lower interest and the product (which baseball is already in decline with younger audiences). Other fan bases aren't really going to care if there is no chance from day 1 - why should you? This could be half the league very quickly. Look at college football, I believe viewership in some of the premium games has been down way as everyone is really tired of Alabama/Ohio State/Georgia/Clemson and the Rose Bowl issued a press release that they weren't going to pick Ohio State if they didn't make the playoffs as their fan base (justifiably) wasn't selling their allotment because it was the same bowl over and over and over. Variety is the spice of life(?) and the league needs to maintain interest and not just have it be the Mets Mets Mets (which is what these payrolls will do). Basically, it's going to hurt the sport and that's not just a sad comment from a poor Marlins fan begging for some salary. The Dodgers spending $300m is one thing. The Mets spending $436m and counting is a whole different monster and really is knocking out half the league or more. Something is going to have to give here, so I do think we want to root for Steve to keep spending as that will only get us to a salary cap/floor faster. The union may oppose, but if the league suffers, they too need to take the longview of longevity.
  13. Yea totally. It's stupid. It's not fun. He can sign Ohtani for $50m next year and run a lower payroll. Just think about that. Other owners aren't going to put up with this shit if this is more than an enthusiasm blip (which I suspect it is not). I guess we shall see.
  14. TBH, if the Marlins got to a $325m payroll this offseason, I'm not sure how interested I would be. Like, this is comical below and was it a challenge to build this team? Is this doing it the right way under the rules or just throwing money at problems and highlighting in sports wealth disparity? Is this fun? I'm not sure this is fun. This is a video game lineup. Verlander ($42m) DeGrom ($42m) Correa ($34m) Rodon ($30m) Nimmo ($24m) E. Diaz ($21m) Contreras ($20m) Rizzo ($20m) R. Montero ($12m) Drury ($11m) And then trading the house for: Reynolds ($7m) and Bednar ($750k) - Cabrera/Rogers, Meyer/Berry, Salas, Eder/Fulton, send them back Stallings, and who cares Y. Diaz ($5.5m) - Pablo, send them Wendle back, send them Cooper, and juice them prospects if needed The $325m Marlins: Contreras, Fortes Rizzo Jazz, Berti Correa, Rojas Y. Diaz, Drury Reynolds Nimmo Garcia Soler (Top AAA - Groshans, DLC) Sandy, Verlander, DeGrom, Rodon, Luzardo, Rogers/Cabrera E. Diaz, Bednar, R. Montero, Floro Scott, Bleier, Okert (Top AAA - Garrett is kicked to AAA here and we actually kept Eury doing this shenanigans. I suppose we could use him to get an even better 3B maybe or use him as a Salary dump for Garcia/Soler) Would this be fun or is it just a bit much over the top?
  15. Also should any of us care when the Mets payroll + luxury tax this year is currently around $436 million dollars ($325 payroll, $111 luxury) and the Marlins payroll 2018-2022 was $350m.... meaning the Marlins might "barely" get over that amount for 6 seasons absent a real commitment coming out of nowhere. Six years of payroll for Bruce = 2023 for the Mets Mets luxury tax 2023 > Marlins 2023 payroll (probably.... only Correa/Rodon/Swanson would get them over this) I can understand the scorch earth philosophy of Bruce coming in to start over, so some of this is to be expected with lower payrolls as you trade out, build the farm, and then start going for it a few years later, but when will the faucet turn on even to CHEAP amounts? We're begging for $120m here after a 5 year average payroll of $70m which is exceptionally low? Mets have $225m committed for next year, and adding in Alonso/McNeil/Raley increases, they probably get to $250m throwing in some club controlled players (Alvarez, etc.) on top. Meaning, if Steve is OK with $325 + luxury, they can sign Ohtani for $50m a season and still have $25m to play with. At minimum. Should any of us care if the Mets are just going to do this with a guy 25-30x the net worth of Bruce, and then obvious characters like the Dodgers and Yankees follow suit? Atlanta's payroll is $193m. This is well over double than Atlanta who just gave up numerous record long term deals. The Dodgers are actually sitting on $160m right now. Atlanta and LAD are models of responsibility here compared to the Mets? Like, are Mets fans even going to be proud of their team if they do win because playing outside your weight class isn't fun? Are 10-15 fan bases in baseball going to stop caring soon because these top teams are just going to sign everyone? Are the other owners going to be happy with this? What a mess. Something will have to change here, so maybe we should champion Steve Cohen to keep doing this as his drunk spending may bring real change to the sport. Likewise, if/when the Mets lose in the playoffs, that is going to be hilarious.
  16. I will adopt this nomenclature
  17. Two thoughts: 1 - I don't think this is an independent thought from Das or I, many have suggested the Marlins doing a "Werth" acquisition is the necessary next step to telegraph to the league they mean business. So; 2 - No personal attacks
  18. Maybe they option Cabrera and Garrett to give the AAA bats the rotation they deserve
  19. Well I appreciate that, but this isn't really rocket science. It takes two to tango as we are just a bunch of assholes on a message board so maybe other teams are being jerks, but I can't imagine the Marlins over value EVERY one of their players versus trying to snag someone else. Case and point, there is -0- reason to not have an Arizona CF right now. Nimmo was always a dream and at that price, yikes. There are 4 of them and they are all lefties. One has to be traded. Arizona needs pitching. Like WTF? Eury/Carroll, Cabrera or Rogers or Luzardo or Meyer or Eder + someone else for Thomas/Varsho, or Garrett/McCarthy. The Diamondbacks cannot hate every arm the Marlins have here and the Marlins can't hate every CF here. Why is THIS one not happening? There are a lot more SS out there so I get maybe you wait our Correa (Swanson, Peraza, Rosario + all the Cleveland guys, J. Polanco, etc.), but center field? What magic do you think you can pull with literally any other player in baseball (as Reynolds/Mullins likely short term CF and get kicked to the corner) having some sort of problem. No major CF (absent Harrison Bader) are coming in free agency for two years. You need a center fielder now and long term. Move earth to get one and finally be done with this as you whiffed on Brinson AND Harrison AND Sierra AND VVM AND Misner AND Scott. Just call Arizona! Remind them how good Gallen is! That's where I scratch my head. Wait out Justin Turner market? Sure. Wait out Reynolds being traded in spring training? Sure. Wait out Correa and see if you can Minnesota deal him in February? Sure. But how in god's name is one of those Arizona guys not here already? Those guys make the minimum. It's not money. Over valuing your own players? Trigger shy and too worried about making a mistake rather than what can go right? I don't get it.
  20. 10/$326, opt out every year after year 3 (so he'd be a free agent at age 31 season) or at any time if you win the MVP or team wins World Series you can opt out. So go win the MVP and opt out. Who cares if that happens - it means you were good. How is he saying no based on Xander/Turner/Seager/Tatis deals? They got 11/$280, 11/$300, and 10/$325. Seager was also 28 years old. Tatis was 14/$340, so Correa valued higher. Is he stuck up on Lindor getting 10/$341 and has to get $342? Are we that vain? Defer the hell out of it and pay him $5m+ bucks for a decade years 11-20. He can take the pride he beat Seager deal. A $25m Correa + deferrals is an under $100m Marlins payroll today.
  21. I can see Swanson doing a "Correa" deal and taking a 3 year high annual value deal with a 1 year opt out. Run it back with Atlanta with some insurance and try again next year. He has this year again, he'll get what he wants next year. Next year is Ohtani, Devers, and likely Machado (opt out), and I have a strong feeling Devers is extended since they lost Xander. After that it's Bader/Happ kind of guys and all sorts of SP (Nola headlines) after that. Basically, Swanson could be in high high demand given Ohtani is an entirely different beast and he'd be the unquestioned next best bat after Devers/Machado. Correa must be so pissed off Trea/Xander/Seager/Judge have gotten their deals.
  22. That's actually potentially indirect good news as they may be very inclined to move Peraza for Pablo. They've shown interest in Gleyber also, I wonder if they would try him out at 3B? Could Gleyber be 3B/1B and fill that "Turner" role? If they then signed another SP for 1 year (plenty of reclamation projects out there + Castano/Sixto for the immediate), and traded another (Rogers or Cabrera) for Alek Thomas.... Peraza, Thomas, and Gleyber(3B) are not insignificant additions if the SP levels off (Sandy, Luzardo, Garrett, Rogers/Cabrera, + signing) with Eury/Eder coming fast and Meyer/Fulton next year. That isn't a bad off-season at all TBH. They may have to have a year of development for those bats to get their feets wet, but those two have Jazz upside and Gleyber (for all his faults) is no slouch and had a 2.7 WAR last year.
  23. Did Yelich trade set a precedent league wide? The Pirates are 2025 at earliest with their development/division, but yea they have some interesting guys. Big picture, Reynolds (unless resigned and doesn't appear he will), Bednar (relievers are volatile, etc. etc.), and Brubacker (innings eater effectively, not a contending pitcher for them) don't fit into their timeline AT ALL. And if you want to take Bednar out (because he may be a guy moved at the deadline this year for more in some real RP desperation moves), sure! Then let's get Reynolds and Brubaker for.....Rogers/Cabrera, Berry/Salas/Cappe, Meyer/Eder/Fulton/Miller (depending on first two guys sliding scale), Wendle (who they really could use as a bridge and clears some $$$ for Marlins), and pick an OF all of whom are a good flyer for them Sanchez/Bleday/Burdick/Jerar. Maybe a throw-in outside top 25 RP prospect too or who cares McCambley sort of guy. They aren't saying no to that. It's effectively 3 top 100 guys, or Rogers, 1 top 100, and 1 almost top 100 (Eder/Fulton). With excellent flyers and a stop gap solid MI who is cheap and will help Cruz, etc. And TBH, Brubaker is the real key here as you still have "6" SP so trade out the other of Rogers/Cabrera for Alek Thomas as that absolutely works for everyone. They could add Correa, Turner/Longoria, and a $3m "Bass" Reliever and pump a $120m team in 2023, which would decrease to $110m in 2024 given players living/arbitration projections, and need like maybe a catcher, platoon 1B/3B, and backup SS in 2024. They are set up to go for it and it speaks volumes to the cheapness if they don't.
  24. You set the team up to succeed and that's why you play the games. The Mets are very old and very injury prone. The Phillies got lucky last year and their signings are desperate as they know the window is closing and have no longterm shot at Atlanta. They both do have major star power, but the Marlins SP could quickly vault them over them if guys blossom and they have good hitters around them. Cleveland 2022 path. Maybe it's not enough, but the Marlins SP can take over in short series and you bet on that. Or like, you just never are going to contend so what are you doing.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.