Everything posted by MarlinsLou
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
Let's save you some time - there is no scenario they win 87+ games doing relatively nothing absent 3-5 mega breakouts to Sandy/Jazz level players and all the other subsidiary guys play to their 3-4 year average selves. So 10 things need to go right and really nothing go wrong. Or I guess they could go 40-10 in one run games and get lucky?
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
Totally, this is the defeatist attitude we all have if they do nothing. And I'll be checked out before opening day as even if they do start hot, there is no chance over 162.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
Sure, que rich hubris and missing the part of running a business, when weekday attendance is going to be 4,000 this year when they do nothing and keep playing 3-2 ball games. If this is a rich guy hobby/investment, why should we care?
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
I don't think any of us does. At least trading for Reynolds/Rosario and getting a stop gap Turner and maybe a SP would be *something* though if they fail to move to bottom 22nd territory in payroll. Can they even accomplish that? I think they best thing that can happen this offseason is Bruce realizes he bit off more than he can chew and he has to sell as he will never compete with owners with more money than him and that care. We can hope.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
It's Correa, Swanson, or bust at this point. I guess they could sign Rodon and then use Rogers very easily to get Alek Thomas/Bryan Reynolds and Pablo to get A. Rosario/X. Curry. Past that, is their sell to us hey look, we won 81 games. That's a 12 win improvement. We're going places! As we then look at them at a $90m payroll and Correa just had a 5 WAR season, Reynolds a 4 WAR season, and Justin Turner a 2 WAR season, and those guys would effectively be replacing 3+ WAR worth of players on Miami meaning the team could have easily been 88 wins if they had just spent $120m to be bottom 20 in the league. Have it all make sense.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
And why would he come here even if the Marlins give him $1-2m a year more than someone else (which they won't). (I know you know this). He's 38, wants to win, and has career earning at $90m so what kind of accounting mishap happened where he needs an extra buck or two versus being happy on a good team? He doesn't give a shit about state income taxes. Hence why, the Marlins need to do the Jayson Werth deal as they won't get ANY of those veteran guys until they show them they mean business.
-
Three Front Office Additions
She's supposed to trade Meyer/Berry, Salas/Cappe, Fulton, I. Lewis, and 2-3 good throw-ins (Burdick, McCambley, etc.) for Reynolds, Bednar, and Brubacker, and then move Pablo for A. Rosario, X. Curry, and prospects. Then sign Turner/Longoria and Kiermaier
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
I think this offseason may change some attitudes, as ultimately, the product suffers if only NYY, BOS, LAA, HOU, ATL, NYM, PHI, CHC, STL, SF, SD, and LAD are big spenders, with sometimes TOR, BAL, CWS, TEX, WASH popping up, and rarely DET, MINN, and SEA. This is 1/3rd the league throwing in the towel before the games start, and at least half of the "sometimes" bracket isn't going to be on a contending cycle. So half the league is effectively out day 1 and praying to pull off a playoff miracle ala Tampa/Cleveland have done to advance a few rounds last decade. The product suffers, the union suffers. I am all for these guys getting paid, but like you said, when the Mets lose again (as they will as the team isn't as good as a few other NL teams or impressive for what they are spending), does he just add Ohtani and Devers next offseason and run a $500m payroll and doesn't care about a luxury tax as he is worth $14b, he doesn't care, and the Mets still produce TV/gate money as their fan base will be rapid if they do that so how much is he in fact losing? And then Soto becomes a free agent the next offseason when they lose again and he balloons more? It's comical. It's becoming like Vanderbilt being in the same division as Alabama. They could boost MLB minimum spending (both with a floor and maybe league minimum shoots way up to $1.5-2m which will have a massive impact) and hard cap the top. Still let Steve spend, but spread the love. I'd be very concerned if I were the union at alienating half the fans in the league, but maybe I am mis-reading the room after being bludgeoned for years from this franchise who is dead last in spending over the last 20 years.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
That ends the ownership group as no one will ever trust them after coming in, scorching earth, doing nothing, then scorching earth. Also they would get a ton for Sandy, Jazz, Pablo, Rogers, Luzardo, and the subsidiary guys (Cooper/Berti/Wendle/Floro/etc.) if they did pull the plug and say traded everyone with less than 4 years of control Not that that is going to happen, but I mention because the Marlins have A LOT of talent despite the spending going out there. If the choice is to not spend right now, it's not blowing it up now, it's just keeping everyone and kick the can to 2024 (queue always moving goalposts). Imagine this staff: Sandy, Rogers, Pablo, Luzardo, Eury Cabrera, Meyer, Sixto, Bender Garrett, Eder, Fulton, Scott I don't know how they will hit (effectively, they will have Fortes, Jazz, Berti, Groshans, DLC/other LFers, Garcia, and Soler, so they will need 4-5 bat upgrades), but that team is going to PITCH and outside of Sandy and Pablo, no one is likely facing a third time through the order as they can just throw waves and keep everyone fresh. And then we get to the same offseason, 4+ offensive upgrades and the team has 20-22 players on the roster for approximately $70m dollars (or $60m with no Pablo!). And then I guess the insanity position is as we want Correa now, we want Machado/Devers next year, to trade Salas/whoever for another upgrade, and sign stop-gaps to bridge the gap to Berry, Cappe, Mack, and presumably a college bat taken first round 2023 draft. I suspect none of us will be here at THIS point, but maybe with THAT staff they'd finally care. I would not hold my breath. And to expressly state, I am not advocating this so no one yells at me, suggesting what they may be thinking. Just saying, we're a long ways from a blow up and the Marlins shouldn't worry about what other teams are doing. They just gotta plug their holes, figure out how to get that last wild card, and let Sandy and the pitchers take over short playoff series. Phillies had no business being in the World Series and the Guardians were pretty close. Position yourselves for that. Get in and catch fire.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
And a floor so the union can't say players are losing money
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
Seems like agents can leverage an extra 2-3 years on a lower annual (see Xander also especially). Crazy times. 2/3rds the league has no chance
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
And people think I'm crazy! That's too rich for me though.
- 2022-2023 Offseason Thread
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
Ones who post 8 WAR over their last 150 games, are 28, a below market salary for years, and beyond a Marlins position of need Trading Pablo for Buxton would be insane FOR THE TWINS. We could only be so lucky.
-
Three Front Office Additions
It's the Jayson Werth signing. Werth got 7/$126m in 2011(!!!) which made no sense at the time for him at 32 years of age even if he was very very good. But, it was the Nationals telegraphing to everyone, we mean business. After years of sucking, you have to pony up to get over the credibility gap. Nimmo is just as good (yes when healthy PA to PA), and 2 years younger. Chalk up a year less on the deal and a little more money for inflation, the Marlins need to buy credibility. If he's not for you, that's cool, but insert Correa, Swanson, Rodon, or doing an insane trade here for a legitimate veteran and not A. Rosario or A. Thomas. They need this. It's cultural to an extent.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
Royce Lewis
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
The Marlins should do backflips to get Buxton if he is made available. And it's his offense also. Arraez (who I like a lot) doesn't work for me unless they move Jazz - thats via trade or to SS if they think he can do it. Arraez loses a lot of value not at 2B. But if Jazz has to stay at 2B and Arraez can play half the time at 3B (I don't know this answer) and get the Jazz off days at 2B, that becomes a lot more interesting if 1B/LF time is limited.
-
Three Front Office Additions
Opportunity cost - he's the only FA CF available this cycle, NEXT year is Bader only and he isn't as good, and the FOLLOWING year we're looking at Victor Robles and other assholes. It's that bad. No one is available, so the price for Nimmo or trading for those Arizona lefty CF is the perfect "Jayson Werth" acquisition. CFers do not exist right now so if you are going to splurge, it's here as you can't otherwise get one. He may not end up in CF the whole time, but he has excellent plate discipline and should age gracefully in a corner. Frankly, MLB is littered with SS if this is an either/or scenario. You solve CF first. That's my -long standing- position regardless of other holes on the team. Even if that solution is only for a few years (same thing with Reynolds here, who is a much worse defender but you could fake him out there part time for a year or two). 6/$132 for Nimmo? LFG. Seriously. If Taillon and Tajuan walker are getting 4/$70 and Joc Pederson $19 million a season, Nimmo is quite frankly, a steal at that amount. He is really really good and you always accept risk with any contract. I also wanted the Marlins to sign BJ Upton a decade ago and Didi Gregorious more recently, so don't take me as gospel here as duds happen, but this team has gotta do something and he makes sense to me.
-
Three Front Office Additions
Just a joke. Either is great
-
Three Front Office Additions
If Fernandez didn't die, I think Jeff would have gone all-in and done something on top of Chen with that core. Eventually maybe they all get traded, but some more back-loaded deals and tell the FO - you got this year and until trade deadline next year but here's the juice to win the whole damn thing. But we'll never know. Bruce has this exact same game board in front of him. Blow it out for 2023-2025 and firesale it July 30, 2025 if it isn't working out. Take a page out of the Jeff playbook I say. Let's make Nimmo our Bobby Bonilla. Do it.
-
Three Front Office Additions
I don't think them having a 15 game swing matters if they don't make some moves. Like, I can see pitching and health getting this team to .500 (+12 wins). They should be better, but while that may validate some "luck/health" arguments, the "getting over the top" problem will never go away unless they spend. They are never getting much higher than that absent they draft Stanton and Realmuto and Fernandez and Yelich again back to back. Until they devote some real assets (money or prospects) to radically getting some big name improvements, and then keep it going for 3 years as this franchise has never had a consistent contending run beyond "2004 and part of 2005," nothing will change. It's culture, winning cures all, but they also need consistency and to be able to convince the casual sports talk radio fans they mean business.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
But then we care about that depth in May when Erik Gonzalez shows up, so let's take a top-level approach. The small moves are all fine and make sense, but yes they need to make the big ones in the next 2.5 months or this place is going to get *very* quiet.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
The AAA depth for "injury call ups" has historically been extremely low (as Das will pop up and agree with as that has been his shtick) in recent years. It started getting better last year, but we still got 250 PA from Gonzalez/Astudillo/Hamilton/Williams. You can make arguments Lewin/Burdick, even if not great, are worth the time at the MLB level because there is hope tied to them so keeping them out of this PA tally here, but that's another 300 PA they gave out to this AAA group. LeBlanc and Groshans would add even more. So yea, this group of players DOES get some legitimate playing time. To note, Williams was OK here also, but there is something be be said about having to make trades to fill that role when you *should* have this internal depth already built up. He *really* bailed them out by being competent and it could have gotten much worse (especially if Dunand didn't hit that one HR too!). Ultimately, they SHOULD have this depth so they don't have below replacement level players in the wings and there is a legitimate hope there is some prospect that can give a "Fortes" or "LeBlanc" surprise. That entire grouping above fits this bill IMO - there is real talent on that AAA position core across all position groups (except SS) and frankly you could see any of them on the bench. We shouldn't have Gonzalez/Astudillo/Hamilton situations this year, nor have to rely on Williams in a desperation move, nor keep giving Lewin those PA if he's terrible after 50-75 PA as there is someone else in the wings they can swap him with, etc. So saying you don't give a fuck about depth is respectfully, just being an angry Marlins fans because they are sitting on their hands for the MLB roster. I think we can both objectively see progress in AAA and still (enormously) criticize them for the lack of movement/effort at improving the MLB squad. I'll give a tip of the hat to getting Groshans, Edwards, Mangum, Allen, etc. for relievers and nothing, but trust me, I am still pissed the OOMPH MLB deals aren't coming and these moves alone aren't giving them anywhere near a passing grade. I'm going to be really annoyed, but not get to PISSED until it's spring training. They got time but it's infuriating they aren't doing the "werth" move to set the tone. Also, Eury, Berry, and Salas would be considered top 100 prospects if we aggregate the scouting services, and Meyer and Eder are right on the cusp and likely would be in if healthy. Cappe is probably close but not there yet, and Sixto/Fulton/Watson/Mack probably have the pedigree to get there with 2-3 strong months. Farm is solid even if not a top 10 unit because of graduations and yes, they absolutely have depth here to make a trade (or two) and they SHOULD. We are all on the same page there. It's time to cash in when your top 6 + Eury SP average years of control is 4.7 years (and that's with Pablo bringing the weighted average down and not including Meyer/Eder/Fulton), and there are some MLB bats with years of control around.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
They got a CF - the PTBNL in Hernandez deal with Mets - https://www.fangraphs.com/players/jake-mangum/sa3011255/stats?position=OF I believe he has been mentioned here as a Rule V option. This is even better as he doesn't have to go on the 40 man. Mets fans were surprised he was unprotected on their 40 as they were anticipating him being their 5th OF soon. TLDR - defensive guy, might hit a little, best CF in Marlins organization right now which is still sad Love this for what it is and maybe he's a future backup, but go get a MLB one now (and a SS, and some other bat upgrade presumably a 3B/1B) Say what you will about Kim/FO also, but they are building some really nice depth in AAA. This whole team is extremely interesting with potential. This is a big change from former years. Now if they can just do the MLB roster...... C - Allen 1B - Johnston/LeBlanc/Jerar 2B - Edwards/LeBlanc SS - ?/Groshans 3B - Groshans/LeBlanc LF - Sanchez or Bleday (other MLB absent more moves) CF - Mangum RF - Burdick/Jerar DH - Jerar/LeBlanc
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
Yes. Hence we all keep going back to the Werth signing (or it could be a trade). Plant the flag. If you build it they will come.