Everything posted by EricWiener
-
Current lineup
Eric- you are killing yourself throughout this thread. How accurate do you really expect to be able to project a guy's minor league stats into MLB reality when he has a total of six games above A ball? As for "he will at least catch balls," I saw him play in the AFL and he runs a skinny post to just about every ball. He will be thrown out there, and he will struggle, because he has 'a total of six games above A ball." His primary qualification is that he looks like he should be good. I am inherently suspicious of "can't miss" prospects that have not played much, and have yet to show the earmarks of a major league hitter. Funny thing is, once he's on the team I might be in a position of liking what I see and have to read a million "ZOMG he sucks!" threads because he didn't walk on water right away.
-
Ladies and Germs... Cameron Maybin
Awesome. Someone that self absorbed is definitely going to love playing in front of 200 people. You say that like it is a bad thing. You say that like there's 200 fans to play in front of. As long as there is no rain delay there will be at least 1300 fans of the other club present.
-
Current lineup
I don't see how have a low MLE in A ball, which every single player does, correlates into being a AAAA player. It doesn't. He is just not ready. My fear of the AAAA player is due to his merits being speculative and physical and his flaws being measurable. His best asset is that you cannot teach somebody to be as great of an athlete as this kid obviously is, and if the skills develop he will be great. But he has a big swing and the complaints about him deal chiefly with his lack of instincts for the game, which tossing his ass out there (which we will almost have to do) may harm his development. The Tigers already rushed him before he was remotely ready and he struggled. I expected MLB-ready players (and we were offered some) for our top 2 guys, and I think that, at best, Miller might be, and that Maybin isn't.
-
Will HanRam convert to 3B?
Andino isn't a bad hitter for a shortstop, but people's expectations of how shortstops should hit has changed greatly with the outbreak of young offensive shortstops. Andino blows.
-
Ladies and Germs... Cameron Maybin
Reggie Abercrombie 2.0 Of all the bad statements I have seen made today... I think this takes the cake. If you like that one, I've made some whoppers in another thread... though I can't imagine he could be as craptastic as the garbage man. If nothing else he will be able to play CF reliably.
-
Don't Quit on the Marlins
I do look forward to these two guys who are supposedly can't miss. Sigh
-
Current lineup
...Maybin was in A ball in 2006. It's kind of hard to have a large MLE when you're in A ball. Hence my point about not being ready. We are going to put a pork chop around his neck and toss him to the wolves.
-
Current lineup
Except he has produced! Just put the Millar (sent to Boston for a bucket of warm spit) numbers at ages 27-31 side by side, and tell me why we kept Encarnacion? I want to be wrong about Maybin. I hope to be wrong about Maybin. But I am skeptical about that very kind of player where the descriptions of his positives are abstract emotional phrases and his flaws are measurable and manifest.
-
The prospects we got back
I'm not sold on Miller, to be honest. His MiLB K rate isn't so hot. But I suppose he'll be good if he can keep that HR rate that low, which isn't a given, but shouldn't be difficult in DS. Tigers definitely rushed him, he only got 85 IP in the minors after being drafted 18 months ago. The low WHIP and BAA was there though, and sometimes K/9's can be overrated. K/BB is more important, but isn't he better than 7k/9ip? That is not in a danger zone.
-
Current lineup
His point was also that Hanley had put up minor league numbers that were impressive, something Maybin hasn't. He also said Maybin is a AAAA player. He is wrong. Impressive? No. Worthy of moving up the line, yes. MLEs are not raw looks at numbers, and are often not representative of what the player will do at the ML level, look at Uggla for example, another player I was skeptical about. Funny thing with Uggla is that all of the problems I anticipated him having are all problems that he has, but he produces despite them. Maybin certainly has that potential, but breaking the mold should not be expected. Maybin is a pure athlete, and that cannot be learned. He has an upside, but he is not ready, and will be put in the lineup regardless. He is also the kind of player that everyone will just expect to be the greatest thing since canned beer and will keep getting chances despite not being a MLB-caliber player. He looks like a ballplayer, he runs like a ballplayer, and when he gets the barrel on the ball he knocks the sh*t out of it. He is the kind of body (think Juan Encarnacion vs. Kevin Millar) that will get playing time over a superior hitter because of looks / "tools".
-
Current lineup
Dude walked at 13.4% clip in the minors.... Did you just invent a stat? The BB/PA%? His 2006 MLE OPS was .600, I can't find a 2007 figure yet, but looking at what he did and where he played it would likely be about .725. As for comparison to Reggie, Maybin may actually put something together, he is young and he will at least catch balls.
-
Current lineup
Maybin reminds me of Hanley Ramirez x2. Good contact, decent amout of power for a young prospect and great speed. Dosen't sound too bad to me. Just call them the new Juan Pierre and Luis Castillo. With alot more power. This kind of talk bothers me as well. I am also wary of next year about hearing that Maybin is 'disappointing' because he isn't Hanley #2, despite his being successful (potentially). Hanley was 2 years older, and had already put up MLEs worth looking at and has the potential to be the best player in the game. I don't think Maybin is remotely ready, I think that he will be thrown into the breach regardless.
-
Current lineup
Am I alone on this board in not being impressed with Maybin? He looks like a AAAA player to me, with a Juan Encarnacion upside. Miller and de la Cruz are the only guys that get my interest here. AAAA player? Seriously? He's young, so its hard to know how he'll develop, but he has a huge swing and a nose-to-toes strike zone. I don't think he is the kind of talent that Howie Kendrick represented, and that deal would have left us with Willis to deal separately. Maybin is also the same kind of frustrating player that some scouts and GMs seem to love because of 'tools' and keep trying to work into the lineup despite performance. The fact that the Tigers ran him up to the ML level too soon is not a recommendation of the player.
-
Current lineup
Am I alone on this board in not being impressed with Maybin? He looks like a AAAA player to me, with a Juan Encarnacion upside. Miller and de la Cruz are the only guys that get my interest here.
-
Ron Paul wins Virginia Straw Poll
I have a better chance to win a primary than Ron Paul , i am not opposed to some of his ideas but on the stage he seems like a senile one trick poney Ron Paul supporters seem to me to be largely Libertarians that don't just register with that party. There is little wrong with his principals and much askew with his conclusions.
-
Needs: 3B, C
If the team goes with Andino, then Uggla is going to play 3B
-
Developing Prospects
I am sure that there are some folks in line before Hanley.
-
How big are these "ifs"?
Well all the speculation is done, and I think we took the worse deal You just said the same thing in a different thread. One time will suffice, chief. Once will not suffice any more than it does for the 30 threads about how Loria sucks
-
How big are these "ifs"?
Well all the speculation is done, and I think we took the worse deal
-
Cabrera, Willis traded to Tigers
This is by far a worse deal than Anaheim
-
How big are these "ifs"?
I actually feel Willis bouncing back and Scott Olsen coming into his own are two very likely scenarios. The defense is yet to be determined, considering we don't know who will be playing two of the most important positions (CF, C) or maybe even two more (2B, 3B). Cabrera Staying is probably a 15% likelyhood. If Anibal could make 25 starts with successful numbers I'd bust a nut. The team may very well keep Cabrera because he is only going to climb in value for the 09 trade deadline Huh? His value is easily at it's highest now than it will ever be. He is legitimately going to be one of the best hitters in the history of baseball (even though he was younger at 22 that couldn't yet be said), he's only 24-years-old, a four-time All-Star, the team that gets him has him a guaranteed two years, and two years to negotiate the perimiters of another $200+ contract. In the summer of '09 he won't be worth more than a top prospect and a marginal one. Right now he's worth three MLB-ready top prospects. The value of a player climbs when you think you can win a championship with his help.
-
Best Song By Decade
00 I'm Not A Girl, Not Yet A Woman - Britney Spears 90 Macerena - Los Del Rio 80 Der Kommissar - Falco 70 Kung Fu Fighting - Carl Douglas 60 Loco Motion - Little Eva 50 Doggie in the Window - Patti Page OK, OK, I'm joking
-
How big are these "ifs"?
I expect Willis to rebound nicely, he showed signs late last season and has a better pitching coach now. I have no idea what to expect from Olsen If Nolasco is healthy he will perform at better than a 4.5 ERA RVH will do fine Anibal may not be ready to play The team may very well keep Cabrera because he is only going to climb in value for the 09 trade deadline, and if he's lost weight he's a decent 3B Hermida will be the sh*t I think the big questions remains, what are we going to do about the gaping holes at CF and C
-
Chimp Beats Humans In Memory Game
How does the Chimp even understand what a sequence of numbers is? That depends on what you mean by 'understand'. Chimps have demonstrated reasoning, and order of numbers is merely a memory function. Arithmetic is not particularly challenging, it is the applications that are.
-
US: Iran nuclear weapons work halted in 2003
Except that the Administration has worked for sanctions at every turn and hasn't prepared for war with Iran. At least not beyond the normal preparations made by the Pentagon for every nation we could possibly fight. So they say.... That's not how they have been publicly acting. You and I must not be watching the same people then. When the Administration was threatening Iraq with war, we were moving troops. Every initiative by the US as regards Iran has been non-military, all the speculation about military action comes from pundits.