Explain your vote please.

First of all, both will stat because Redmond cannot play that many games and Castro can't play all 162.

 

I would like to see Red catch 25% of the games and Ramon play 75%

Castro because he is a better player. He might hit 25 homers which is something redmond cant do.

Yes, but Redmond will get to balls that would be to the backstop on Castro.

castro has the potential to be really good

 

give him a chance

Red is the best Sunday catcher in all of baseball

 

Give it to Castro till he proves he can't handle it, but I know that Red can't be our starter for the whole season if we want to make the playoffs. If Castro doesn't live up to his billing, I'm thinking a Kendall or LoDuca trade may be in order...

let Red own him up some lefties...

 

Ramon will get about 120 games

I'd start Castro 5 days a week, and Red the other two.

The one and only "The PIMP" should start.

castro. no doubt. and i think hes got a better arm behind the plate too

Redmond, because he is better defensively and offensively. Not as much power, but better contact.

Redmond, because he is better defensively and offensively. Not as much power, but better contact.

marlins dont need more contact in the lineup. they have plenty. castro provides power which they need to make up for some of the losses

I'd like to see Castro start a majority of the games with Redmond getting the start enough to keep Ramon fresh.

This has been beaten to death. Is it even a question worthy of debate?

Castro, he has more pop and alot of potential.