June 11, 200323 yr ok here we go for real this time.... C- Johnson 1B- Conine 2B- Castillo SS- Renteria (although Gonzalez might pass continuing to play like this) 3B- Lowell LF- Floyd CF- Wilson RF- Sheffield SP1- Brown SP2- Burnett SP3- Dempster SP4- Rapp RP- Harvey
June 11, 200323 yr Not trying to start a fight here, but how can anyone be legit and pick Harvey over Nen for RP? Harvey pitched only 1 real year here. That year was great but the other 2 years he was a Marlin were wastes. Nen had 4 great years here where his ERA was never over a 3.89. In fact here were his stats: SEASON TEAM W L ERA G GS CG SHO SV SVO IP H R ER HR HBP BB SO 1994 Florida Marlins 5 5 2.95 44 0 0 0 15 --- 58.0 46 20 19 6 0 17 60 1995 Florida Marlins 0 7 3.29 62 0 0 0 23 --- 65.2 62 26 24 6 1 23 68 1996 Florida Marlins 5 1 1.95 75 0 0 0 35 --- 83.0 67 21 18 2 1 21 92 1997 Florida Marlins 9 3 3.89 73 0 0 0 35 --- 74.0 72 35 32 7 0 40 81
June 11, 200323 yr Being different and choosing an unworthy candidate are different. If you want to be different, shave you head. But if we are trying to honestly choose who we really think should be the best in team history, pick who is most deserving. I'm not trying to be mean or anything, just honest.
June 11, 200323 yr How is Bryan Harvey 'unworthy'.... Maybe not as good a candidate, but hardly unworthy. Choosing someone who never saved a game for this team would be 'unworthy' But Harvey was simply dominating in 93. Nen really only had one dominating year which was 96.
June 11, 200323 yr ok josh...since we want to be picky.... why choose livan? he only had really half a good year as a marlin.
June 11, 200323 yr WildCard... Some people are just different and like to be difficult. You will never change them and thats why society usual shuns them. They usually were picked on as kids, not given enough attention or were always just plain old outcasts. You are young but will learn in time who some of these people are.
June 11, 200323 yr Adam, I picked Livan because he is probably the second biggest reason we won the World Series, and that counts to me more than anything.
June 11, 200323 yr nen had a better sustained career as a marlin. nen never had a year as dominating as harvey. take your pick.
June 11, 200323 yr but yet he really only had one good half a year... you should probably put moises as your left fielder then as well.
June 11, 200323 yr but yet he really only had one good half a year... you should probably put moises as your left fielder then as well.
June 11, 200323 yr I take Nen over Harvey, because he was here longer and did better while he was here. And while you're at it, why not Piazza at Catcher?
June 11, 200323 yr the topic for this thread is "Marlins All-Time Team"-Your Choice... so who cares if Harvey is picked over Nen or if Paul Bako over CJ.... who f***in cares?
June 11, 200323 yr OK, I would definately care if someone picked Bako over CJ... But the point is you're right...
June 11, 200323 yr I dont think Piazza is a reasonable analogy, even though I think youre trying to exaggerate. Piazza was here for a week, Harvey had a dominating season on a team that wasnt too good. I think he set the record for getting a save or win in 70% of the Marlins wins that year. Harvey actually finished 8th in the Cy Young voting and 14th in the MVP voting in 1993. And what happened to Harvey after 93, did he get injured or something? He had 45 saves in 93, then 6 in 94 with only 12 appearances, then pitched in one game in 95.
June 11, 200323 yr the topic for this thread is "Marlins All-Time Team"-Your Choice... so who cares if Harvey is picked over Nen or if Paul Bako over CJ.... who f***in cares? Correct ALL-TIME TEAM. This is not a best year team. It is a team based upon who was the best at that position for the Marlins during their career, or what they did for the Marlins. Not something based upon one goods season that accomplished nothing. Harvey pitched for the Marlins in three seperate years, yet he only had one good, productive year. Yet he is your choice for all-time Marlins relief pitcher over someone who had a great 4 years here? Doesn't make sense or add up.
June 11, 200323 yr that may be true.... but you need to respect people's opinions whether you agree with them or not
June 12, 200323 yr that may be true.... but you need to respect people's opinions whether you agree with them or not Spare me the 3rd grade teacher lesson. I accecpt your choice, but I really can't respect it. It just does not make sense for the topic and I have a hard time believing you truly think Harvey is the Marlins best RP of all-time.
June 12, 200323 yr that may be true.... but you need to respect people's opinions whether you agree with them or not Spare me the 3rd grade teacher lesson. I accecpt your choice, but I really can't respect it. It just does not make sense for the topic and I have a hard time believing you truly think Harvey is the Marlins best RP of all-time. Im sorry you feel that way.
June 12, 200323 yr that may be true.... but you need to respect people's opinions whether you agree with them or not Spare me the 3rd grade teacher lesson. I accecpt your choice, but I really can't respect it. It just does not make sense for the topic and I have a hard time believing you truly think Harvey is the Marlins best RP of all-time. Im sorry you feel that way. Uh huh........ :whistle
June 12, 200323 yr C: Charles Johnson 1B: Jeff Connine 2B: Luis Castillo SS: Edgar Renteria 3B: Mike Lowell LF: Mouises Alou CF: Preston Wilson RF: Gary Sheffield SP1: Kevin Brown SP2: Al Leiter SP3: A.J. Burnett SP4: Ryan Dempster RP: Robb Nen
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.