December 9, 200421 yr I don't know. I really don't like the idea of putting Cabs back in right... 630354[/snapback] Too many people are overblowing the effect of Cabs playing right field. He was a liability in both LF and RF. We all know that he more than makes up for it with the bat. He's still learning outfield, he's been playing in the infield his whole life, he's only going to get better. With that arm he's better suited for right field any way. 630367[/snapback] Yeah, but he has publicly said that he doesn't feel comfortable out there. You can see the difference the way he breaks on a ball when he's in LF vs RF. He's looked pretty awful in RF. In LF, he's looked decent... The one good thing about having him in RF is his arm. He definitely has the arm to play out there. 630376[/snapback] It takes time to learn new positions. He said that he had a harder time reading the ball from the right side of the field, and that's understandable he's been playing on the left side his whole life. These things take time to develop and I'm sure we would've seen improvement if Cabrera had continued to play RF for the remainder of the season.
December 9, 200421 yr Would be a great addition. .262 BA 23 homeruns 76 rbis Move Conine back to outfield Tino plays first Bench ENC and then trade him for whomever we can get who is cheap. 630291[/snapback] Enc can put up those numbers. I like Tino, but at this stage of his career why is he an upgrade over Enc?
December 9, 200421 yr I don't know. I really don't like the idea of putting Cabs back in right... 630354[/snapback] Too many people are overblowing the effect of Cabs playing right field. He was a liability in both LF and RF. We all know that he more than makes up for it with the bat. He's still learning outfield, he's been playing in the infield his whole life, he's only going to get better. With that arm he's better suited for right field any way. 630367[/snapback] If you saw him play right field you'd never make that statement. That's not meant as a shot Fran, but alot of us who were at games, especially those here who sit in the upperdeck and got to watch plays unfold were apalled at how poorly he reacted to balls hit at him or to his right. It was painful to watch him out there. He looked like a deer caught in the headlights. For whatever reason he didn't seem to have the same reaction in left. I don't know if he saw leftfield as an extension of third base, or what, but he appeared much more comfortable there. 630387[/snapback] I'm not going to argue that he didn't look worse in right field because he did, but it's not like he was a gold glover in left either. He made plenty of bad plays out there too. I think you will find that the number of games where the outcome of the game was effected by his defense were few and far between. (I can think of one off the top of my head, but he lost the ball in the sun in that game, so I'm not sure if that counts.) Where ever we put him he's going to have more of an impact on the game with his bat than he will with his lack of defense.
December 9, 200421 yr The Atlanta game where he lost the ball in the sun. The Astros game where he just misjudged the ball I think, or he fell down, because he started to back up and then tried to break in on it hard and fast. And I can't think of others off the top of my head.
December 9, 200421 yr Would be a great addition. .262 BA 23 homeruns 76 rbis Move Conine back to outfield Tino plays first Bench ENC and then trade him for whomever we can get who is cheap. 630291[/snapback] Enc can put up those numbers. I like Tino, but at this stage of his career why is he an upgrade over Enc? 630400[/snapback] Tino got on base at a .362 clip to Enc's .299. Tino hits for more power with the 23 homers, and the .461 slugging percentage. To Enc's 16 homers and .405 slugging percentage. I'd say Tino is a significant upgrade.
December 9, 200421 yr The Atlanta game where he lost the ball in the sun. I mentioned that one. That had more to do with his lack of sunglasses than his lack of defensive skills though.
December 9, 200421 yr Well Fran I was going to defend Enc & say it's pretty unlikely he's gonna hit .236 again, and that Tino's 37 and his bat is slowing down.... but wtf, I can't defend Enc. I still wouldn't say Tino's a significant upgrade, but I'll admit he's a more polished hitter.
December 9, 200421 yr I have nothing against Tino but you look at the payroll escalation and one has to come to the conclusion that a Dellucci makes more sense to the Fish than Martinez. He's six years younger, make one tenth what Tino made in 2004, and both hit a home run approximately once every 19.5 at bats. Martinez only plays first base while Dellucci has played all three outfield positions. Admittedly, without knowing enough about either player to draw any hard and fast conclusions, one would have to think it would be easier for the 31 year old Dellucci to learn first base than the 37 year old Martinez to learn to platoon in the outfield. As long as Cliff Floyd isn't invited to the Marlins reunion party I'll be happy.
December 9, 200421 yr I have nothing against Tino but you look at the payroll escalation and one has to come to the conclusion that a Dellucci makes more sense to the Fish than Martinez. He's six years younger, make one tenth what Tino made in 2004, and both hit a home run approximately once every 19.5 at bats. Martinez only plays first base while Dellucci has played all three outfield positions. Admittedly, without knowing enough about either player to draw any hard and fast conclusions, one would have to think it would be easier for the 31 year old Dellucci to learn first base than the 37 year old Martinez to learn to platoon in the outfield. As long as Cliff Floyd isn't invited to the Marlins reunion party I'll be happy. 630440[/snapback] Dellucci put up those numbers for 1 year in one of the top 5 most hitter friendly parks in the majors. Martinez has been doing it for 14 years.
December 9, 200421 yr In both cases, we're talking about lefty "pop" that is going to end up having more flyouts than in previous seasons simply because Pro Player is really tough on lefties. Tino or Delluci is really kind of depressing if we're pegging either as our left-handed answer, but Tino certainly brings more intangiables to the table. But remember, Pro Player really kills lefties (right center just isn't fair, lol) so having a righty heavy lineup is fine by me. We need to focus on getting the best hitters for our budget, not just focus on left/right.
December 9, 200421 yr Bringing in Tino wouldn't be a bad idea, but they need to take care of Enc, and I can't imagine an easy scenario for the Marls to dispose themselves of his contract.
December 9, 200421 yr Enc's not going to do crap this year. He hasn't since 2000. No one is going to trade for him, whether he's starting or coming off the bench, without picking up a prospect or other player. Start the guys that allow to win, not the guys with the most experience and bloated contracts.
December 9, 200421 yr I think Martinez is headed to NY. I think the only reason Marlins were mentioned is because he's from Florida and Tampa Bay allready ran him out of town.
December 9, 200421 yr The sad part of all of this remains the fact that as a supposed contender, the Marls lefthanded bat options should not be guys like Delluci (unproven and with somewhat inflated numbers) or Tino, who is one of my favorite yankees from the 90s, but is clearly well past his prime.
December 9, 200421 yr Would be a great addition. .262 BA 23 homeruns 76 rbis Move Conine back to outfield Tino plays first Bench ENC and then trade him for whomever we can get who is cheap. 630291[/snapback] Good idea... trade Enc for some bullpen help or another bat or w/e the hell we can get for him....i like the l ineup with tino instead of enc alot better
December 9, 200421 yr But remember, Pro Player really kills lefties (right center just isn't fair, lol) so having a righty heavy lineup is fine by me. We need to focus on getting the best hitters for our budget, not just focus on left/right. 630496[/snapback] I agree.
December 9, 200421 yr The only way the Marlins are going to be able to trade Encarnacion is if they are willing to eat probably $3.5 million (or even more) of his contract. Until he proves he is 100% healthy and capable of regaining his 2003 form he is virtually untradeable. I suspect Enc is with us at least until the mid-season trade deadline. I think he's getting a bum wrap but it would be helpful if his spot in the lineup were available.
December 10, 200421 yr Oh and by the way encarnacion aint that bad but he is overpayed cant argue with that. would like to move him but if he stays we still got a good team
December 10, 200421 yr y put willingham at 1st when we got stokes why not just call him up 631058[/snapback] Because Willingham is a better prospect. Stokes just has power.
December 10, 200421 yr y put willingham at 1st when we got stokes why not just call him up 631058[/snapback] Stokes isnt even close to being ready
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.