January 27, 200521 yr TALLAHASSEE -- If H. Wayne Huizenga insists on evicting the Florida Marlins, he could risk losing what's left of a $60 million tax break the state gave him 12 years ago to retrofit his football stadium to accommodate baseball. Senate President Tom Lee on Wednesday said Huizenga was given the 30-year, $2 million-a-year sales tax rebate to help make Dolphins Stadium, then known as Joe Robbie, a home field for his baseball team, the Marlins. Although Huizenga has since sold the Marlins, they continue to play in the stadium. Huizenga, however, has given the Marlins notice that they must move after the 2010 season when their lease expires. The issue comes to the fore as the Marlins have again begun a push for a $60 million tax rebate to help build a ballpark in downtown Miami. Some legislators have been reluctant to aid the team, which has been pleading for state help since 2000. Without a new stadium, the Marlins say they may be forced to leave the state. Lee, R-Brandon, said he told Marlins President David Samson this week that he would make an "honest effort" to help the team stay, but on Wednesday he insisted that "we're not going to pay twice." "A lot of people look at this as corporate welfare, and it's going to be hard enough to pass out of the Legislature," Lee said. "We don't need the liability of people standing up and saying, `We already paid once, how are we going to recover that money?'" The rebate law was passed by the Legislature in 1988 to help lure pro sports teams to Florida. Seven teams, including the Miami Heat and Florida Panthers, have benefited. But Ron Book, a lobbyist for Huizenga, said $62 million has already been spent on improving the stadium for a baseball team and a 2000 state audit has confirmed the expenditures. The state requires proof the money has been spent and the rebate stays with the venue, not the team. "I don't believe the Senate president was aware of what we spent in hard costs or of the audit," Book said. He said historically the Legislature has been reluctant to change the terms of such tax rebates in midstream. In 1997, Huizenga applied for a second tax rebate for the stadium on behalf of his Miami Dolphins, which was rejected by the state. Legislators made it clear at the time that they would not allow "double-dipping" -- one owner receiving two tax breaks for the same venue. Some legislators argue the Marlins, now owned by Jeffrey Loria, have already benefited from one rebate and should not get another, although Gov. Jeb Bush has called the team's situation "unique" and previously said he thought it should be granted a break "out of fairness." Marlins officials were unavailable for comment. The baseball team hopes to open a $420 million, 38,000-seat, retractable-roof ballpark next to the Orange Bowl by 2008. Miami-Dade County has agreed to contribute $138 million in hotel bed and sports facilities taxes and the city of Miami is willing to add $28 million in tourist development taxes. The state rebate is being sought to help cover $30 million in construction costs. The Marlins plan to contribute $192 million. http://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/local/sou...-home-headlines
January 27, 200521 yr I dont get it, if that money has already been spent on Pro Player, how would the rebate be spent double as Lee suggests? If it is true that the money went into Pro Player and the Marlins did play here for a number of years, then it seems legit to give it to a new stadium that is unrelated to pro player. They might have a point if the state was paying 2 million for future use to both Pro Player and the Marlins stadium. But as of right now, their point is moot because the money has been spent. That means this rebate should be a no brainer since this is EXACTLY what it was meant for.
January 27, 200521 yr I dont get it, if that money has already been spent on Pro Player, how would the rebate be spent double as Lee suggests? If it is true that the money went into Pro Player and the Marlins did play here for a number of years, then it seems legit to give it to a new stadium that is unrelated to pro player. They might have a point if the state was paying 2 million for future use to both Pro Player and the Marlins stadium. But as of right now, their point is moot because the money has been spent. That means this rebate should be a no brainer since this is EXACTLY what it was meant for. 669523[/snapback] And another thing... I'd like to see the receipts for the $62 mill spent on PPS. What a load of crapola! :mad
January 27, 200521 yr Here is what I think will happen. Current rebate given to Dolphins Stadium for Marlins will be changed to the Dolphins. Marlins will get a new rebate for the new Ballpark under the Marlins name. That way the current law doesn't need to be changed, Wayne gets the same money, and the Marlins get their money. This makes everyone (except Wayne) looks like winners.
January 27, 200521 yr Samson: We are on the cusp of announcing a local deal. Within the next month an announcement will be made.
January 27, 200521 yr Samson: We are on the cusp of announcing a local deal. Within the next month an announcement will be made. 670131[/snapback] Where did you hear/see that? I want to post it on the ballpark newspage. The deal should be finalized this month and announced in February.
January 27, 200521 yr Samson: We are on the cusp of announcing a local deal. Within the next month an announcement will be made. 670131[/snapback] Where did you hear/see that? I want to post it on the ballpark newspage. The deal should be finalized this month and announced in February. 670135[/snapback] It was CBS 4. WPLG and CBS 4 will do a report on the stadium at 6.
January 27, 200521 yr Samson: We are on the cusp of announcing a local deal. Within the next month an announcement will be made. 670131[/snapback] Where did you hear/see that? I want to post it on the ballpark newspage. The deal should be finalized this month and announced in February. 670135[/snapback] It was CBS 4. WPLG and CBS 4 will do a report on the stadium at 6. 670138[/snapback] Thanks
January 27, 200521 yr Here is the clip from CBS4 News http://capefish.blogspot.com/2005/01/marli...-finalized.html Video Link at the bottom of the page
January 28, 200521 yr "Book said it would be illegal for the state to seize money that a business relied upon to make its contractual decisions." This would only be true before a court law if Huizenga reasonably relied upon the subsidy in making its decisions. Meaning that if the money was specifically earmarked for baseball purposes (and it says so pretty clearly or explicitly in the law) and Huizenga used it for, say, football or other non-baseball related purposes then his reliance was unreasonable and therefore he would have to give back that portion. I don't know the specific language of the law, but if the law isn't sloppy then I think the state legislature would have a good case and would probably win. If this happened, then they could just transfer that money to the Marlins.
January 28, 200521 yr Author Here is the clip from CBS4 News http://capefish.blogspot.com/2005/01/marli...-finalized.html Video Link at the bottom of the page 670167[/snapback] Awesome :thumbup
January 29, 200521 yr "Book said it would be illegal for the state to seize money that a business relied upon to make its contractual decisions." This would only be true before a court law if Huizenga reasonably relied upon the subsidy in making its decisions. Meaning that if the money was specifically earmarked for baseball purposes (and it says so pretty clearly or explicitly in the law) and Huizenga used it for, say, football or other non-baseball related purposes then his reliance was unreasonable and therefore he would have to give back that portion. I don't know the specific language of the law, but if the law isn't sloppy then I think the state legislature would have a good case and would probably win. If this happened, then they could just transfer that money to the Marlins. 670315[/snapback] Reliance interest? Lawyer or law student? The problem is, couldnt Wayne just argue co-mingling of funds? DCfishfan makes a good point..Id also like to see the reciepts to prove he spent the money on the baseball end of the stadium. But youre right..if the law is too vague, Wayne would just fight it in court.
January 31, 200521 yr THEY CAN GIVE DELGADO $52 MILLION, BUT THEY CAN'T GET $60 MILLION TO START BUILDING THE STADIUM.
January 31, 200521 yr "Book said it would be illegal for the state to seize money that a business relied upon to make its contractual decisions." This would only be true before a court law if Huizenga reasonably relied upon the subsidy in making its decisions. Meaning that if the money was specifically earmarked for baseball purposes (and it says so pretty clearly or explicitly in the law) and Huizenga used it for, say, football or other non-baseball related purposes then his reliance was unreasonable and therefore he would have to give back that portion. I don't know the specific language of the law, but if the law isn't sloppy then I think the state legislature would have a good case and would probably win. If this happened, then they could just transfer that money to the Marlins. 670315[/snapback] Reliance interest? Lawyer or law student? The problem is, couldnt Wayne just argue co-mingling of funds? DCfishfan makes a good point..Id also like to see the reciepts to prove he spent the money on the baseball end of the stadium. But youre right..if the law is too vague, Wayne would just fight it in court. 671500[/snapback] What do you mean co-mingling of funds? I am sure some of his expenditure was explicitly to make the stadium viable for baseball, and some of it I am sure helped to make the stadium viable for both baseball and football. They should do an audit to find out exactly what he spent the money on. I don't think Huizenga could stop an audit - he may try to fight it in court, but he'd lose. Once the state determines how much Huizenga spent on the baseball end of the stadium, then it could decide whether or not to take the money away and give it to the Marlins. I'd be interested in reading the law itself to see what it says. Does anyone know the name of the law or the citation? I will post the exact language once I find out the name of the law or the citation.
January 31, 200521 yr THEY CAN GIVE DELGADO $52 MILLION, BUT THEY CAN'T GET $60 MILLION TO START BUILDING THE STADIUM. ::using indoor voice:: They are putting up $196 million on the stadium. They still need to use some money to field a competitive team and $196 is more than many other owners in other sports have put up for a new stadium. :plain Thanks, Matteao62 :thumbup
January 31, 200521 yr THEY CAN GIVE DELGADO $52 MILLION, BUT THEY CAN'T GET $60 MILLION TO START BUILDING THE STADIUM. ::using indoor voice:: They are putting up $192 million on the stadium. They still need to use some money to field a competitive team and $192 is more than many other owners in other sports have put up for a new stadium. :plain 673382[/snapback] its $196 million and its the 4th largest amount of money any ownership has put forth for the building of a new stadium. i say we contact our local congresspeople. what's the latest anyhoo
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.