Castillo - .435 AVG 0 HR 1 RBI 2 SB

Lowell - .273 AVG 1 HR 4 RBI 1 SB

Redman - 1 Win 1 Loss 2.93 ERA 15.1 IP 12 K

Penny - 1 Win 0 Losses 1.29 ERA 7 IP 4 K

Willis - 1 Win 0 Losses 1.29 ERA 7 IP 8 K

Brad Penny....

 

showed some heart this week

I went with Penny as well.

El D-Train

Brad Penny, because he pitched a great game and showed some big emotions as it went along

As happy as I was with Penny's job this week, Willis did it in front of a big crowd while facing Randy Johnson. The youngster had to have butterflies galore, but kept it together to produce another fine outing.

Dontrelle took this team to another level last week, he wins it in my mind.

Dontrelle took this team to another level last week, he wins it in my mind.

I agree wholeheartedly.

WILLIS! He defeated Randy Johnson on national TV, and in front of 37,500 fans. It's really rare for a rookie to step up to such a challenge. Additionally, Willis showed baseball that we're for real.

Dontrelle is the easy pick, but.............

 

Take a look at Redman. Two quality starts that both deserved to be wins.

dontrelle did well, but penny is starting to step up his game, he's turning the corner, gotta give it to him

I gave it to Penny while I still had the chance.

Wow, this was closer than I thought.

 

Willis still wins though

Dontrelle Willis is the Fish of the Week. Thanks for voting.