July 27, 200521 yr How this must have gone down: Littlefield: "Yeah, Admin, Mark Redman, but it's going to cost you Jeremy Hermida." *click* L'field: "Hello? Hello?" Jeez, what the hell is in the water up there in Pittsburgh? 875356[/snapback] Anyone else see the irony in the fact that while some are saying "you don't traade AJ unless you get Arroyo+Hanley Ramirez or Contreras+Marte+McCarthy", you also hear "Hermida for Redman? What'r you - nuts?"? :blink:
July 27, 200521 yr AJ is in another class compared to Redman though dude. I agree with you that the fish are asking for alot for him. But Redman is well not a very good pitcher. He is a solid number 4-5 guy. But AJ is a 1-2 guy on anyone's staff. Even the Yankee's or redsox.
July 27, 200521 yr Redman has won one of his last seven starts. 1-4 and a 6.00 ERA in July pretty much says it all.
July 27, 200521 yr The same could be said for A.J. 876436[/snapback] When did AJ lose six games in a row like Redman did before his last win? Even Mark Redman would say he's no AJ Burnett,
July 27, 200521 yr How this must have gone down: Littlefield: "Yeah, Admin, Mark Redman, but it's going to cost you Jeremy Hermida." *click* L'field:? "Hello?? Hello?" Jeez, what the hell is in the water up there in Pittsburgh? 875356[/snapback] Anyone else see the irony in the fact that while some are saying "you don't traade AJ unless you get Arroyo+Hanley Ramirez or Contreras+Marte+McCarthy", you also hear "Hermida for Redman? What'r you - nuts?"? :blink: 876255[/snapback] the difference is places like boston and chicago have deep farms and can afford to lose some valuable guys. our farm is very thin, especially with hitting prospects. so, yeah, it is laughable to give up hermida b/c he's the only guy who will have a significant impact with his bat any time soon
July 27, 200521 yr The Marlin Man Posted Today, 03:20 PM QUOTE(Flight#24 @ Jul 27 2005, 9:14 AM) QUOTE(TSwift25 @ Jul 26 2005, 5:39 PM) How this must have gone down: Littlefield: "Yeah, Admin, Mark Redman, but it's going to cost you Jeremy Hermida." *click* L'field: "Hello? Hello?" Jeez, what the hell is in the water up there in Pittsburgh? Anyone else see the irony in the fact that while some are saying "you don't traade AJ unless you get Arroyo+Hanley Ramirez or Contreras+Marte+McCarthy", you also hear "Hermida for Redman? What'r you - nuts?"? the difference is places like boston and chicago have deep farms and can afford to lose some valuable guys. our farm is very thin, especially with hitting prospects. so, yeah, it is laughable to give up hermida b/c he's the only guy who will have a significant impact with his bat any time soon No I believe its the same thing. Burnett is a good pitcher but he is still very overrated. Ask yourself what has Burnett ever proved other than he has good stuff? gets hurt frequently, and is inconsistent? He is not worth Ramirez, Arroyo or McCarthy, Anderson, Marte. Some of you are not being realistic.
July 27, 200521 yr cubangm, if you ever become a gm, i hope you will have learned that W-L record is the worse, absolute worse way to judge a pitcher, please look at burnetts career WHIP, ERA and K/9 innings ratio. yes, burnett is worth that package if not more. and if you dont see the difference in a deep farm system giving away a couple top guys and a shallow farm system giving away it's only hitting star.....well....then.....i just dont know what to say, the difference should be obvious. it's a matter of value
July 27, 200521 yr The Marlin Man Posted Today, 03:41 PM ? cubangm, if you ever become a gm, i hope you will have learned that W-L record is the worse, absolute worse way to judge a pitcher, please look at burnetts career WHIP, ERA and K/9 innings ratio. yes, burnett is worth that package if not more. and if you dont see the difference in a deep farm system giving away a couple top guys and a shallow farm system giving away it's only hitting star.....well....then.....i just dont know what to say, the difference should be obvious. it's a matter of value I never go by wins or losses and don't look much into that stat. I go by W.H.I.P, K, ERA, and AVG. I was reffering to Burnett as overrated cause he is always hurt or bother by somthing and that fact that he is inconsistent. He is not a bulldog out there. He gets rattled easily. Fact is right now he is a #3 with potential to be a ACE. Also if you would look at ERA, K's,a nd W.H.IP and batting average you would see Willis ain't that good either. Just cause he has the wins doesn't make him a ACE.
July 27, 200521 yr well, no one mentioned willis. so i guess you are just trying to start a seperate conversation. and burnett hasn't missed a start since coming back from TJS (someone can correct me if i'm wrong here). he never complains of any kind of soreness or injury. saying he's not a bull dog and gets rattled easily is rather subjective, doesn't take away from his value or effectivness as a pitcher. look, my point is that having AJ for 4-5 years is well worth the packages being discussed if not more. that's it. if you dont want AJ's numbers for 4-5 years then you are nuts
July 27, 200521 yr The Marlin Man Posted Today, 03:55 PM well, no one mentioned willis. so i guess you are just trying to start a seperate conversation. and burnett hasn't missed a start since coming back from TJS (someone can correct me if i'm wrong here). he never complains of any kind of soreness or injury. saying he's not a bull dog and gets rattled easily is rather subjective, doesn't take away from his value or effectivness as a pitcher. look, my point is that having AJ for 4-5 years is well worth the packages being discussed if not more. that's it. if you dont want AJ's numbers for 4-5 years then you are nuts Yes nobody mention Willis I mention him cause many people think he is great which in fact he is not. Above average yes but great no way. I go by W.H.I.P, ERA, BAV, and K's. Im pretty sure Burnett has been either on the DL or has had starts push backs cause of pain, discomfort, or precaution. Me saying he's not a bulldog and gets rattled is my opinion but take a look at him after a batter hits a homerun off him or the defense makes a error. 75% of the times he gets pulled or doesn't do well. Why would the Red Sox give up Ramirez, or the White Sox give us a \package as \when Burnett hans't proven much and will be a free agent after the season looking for big money. I like A.J and his stats but we have have won championships without him and I don't believe he have a good enough team to make the playoff's. I rather get Arroyo and Sanchez and still compete this year and be better off for the future.
July 27, 200521 yr burnett missed 1 start the end of last year, but it was so late it didnt really matter. 1 start this year so far only for something minor. Otherwise he has pitched through everything and been rather good. He is worthy of a 2 in most staffs with how he is this year. But he has the potential to be an ace. Also power pitching is what wins in the playoffs.
July 27, 200521 yr If memory serves right Burnett has only missed 2 or 3 starts since coming back from TJ surgery, and they were all related to the surgery, an inflamed elbow. Your right he might not be a bulldog, but as far as a patient of TJ surgery he came back somewhat quickly, and complications will arise. I would hardly call Burnett injury prone, he had the TJ surger and has missed a start here and there due to complications from it.
July 27, 200521 yr I hold my own word, I WOULD give up Hermida for bay, I WOULD give up olsen or hermida for redman, and I'd definately trade both for Odalis Perez. 875275[/snapback] Your right, everyone is entitled to their opinion, it's just some people's opinions are not very intelligent. 875293[/snapback] :lol :lol :lol How ironic. 875300[/snapback] :confused What is ironic? 876133[/snapback] He said that because you cracked on someone's intelligence and your post had English mistakes. It is "you're right." Also, "everyone" is singular and "their" is plural. "He/she" would go with "everyone." "Their" would have worked if you typed "people are entitled to their..."
July 29, 200521 yr the prob is you guys fall in love with baseball players, I DONT, Mark Redman is what we need. Hermida for right now means jack to me, I want to win now!
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.