January 24, 200620 yr http://www.emediawire.com/releases/2006/1/emw336307.htm Fleeing Fish: MLN Sports Zone Examines Florida Marlins' Possible Move Where will the Florida Marlins go? Vegas sounds so sexy. San Antonio wants the MLB. Where can they really go? Perhaps not far, MLN Sports Zone ( http://www.mlnsportszone.com ) suggests. Miami, FL (PRWEB) January 23, 2006 -- Last month, Florida Marlins owner Jeffrey Loria broke the news that the team, with a checkered existence in Miami since 1993, was given permission by the Commissioner of Baseball, Bud Selig, to explore the option of moving out of South Florida. To put out the unwelcome mat further, the Marlins conducted a fire-sale of high-dollar player contracts in December, 2005 that rivals the big sell-off that former fish owner H. Wayne Huizenga engineered after the club?s first World Series win in 1998. That infamous plug-pulling sent the team into a community relations tailspin with fans in the Marlins? school that has affected the club?s following to this day. Low regular season attendance predates the 1998 World Series run, though. It has been the perpetual lament of the club since 1994, when Huizenga began militating for a separate baseball park in the Dolphin-dominated South Florida sports market. With great fanfare, the Marlins announced that they had received permission from the Commissioner to look around for another place to play. The local press, which seizes on bad Marlins news like a donut addict locked in a Krispy Kreme, said good riddance and began screaming all of the usual rumors about towns where the Marlins might go. Las Vegas, Portland (OR), and San Antonio have been floated through the major league press. Las Vegas is the most romantic of the choices. Big gambling and hotel outfits take a piece of the action out of anything entertainment on the Strip. Hotels, shows, restaurants and tawny strip malls full of brand shops are either directly owned or the companies are their landlords. Baseball?s much-prized Federal anti-trust exemption means that the casinos can?t have a direct or even traceable indirect participation in the stadium or the club. If it doesn?t line big gambling?s pockets, it?s not a big win for Sin City. Portland, Oregon built a new stadium, PGE Park, in 2000 to house the Padres? AAA Pacific Coast League franchise, the Portland Beavers. In late 2004, the team, teetering on insolvency, was taken over by the Pacific Coast League. The league found a new ownership group. The city completed negotiations with the new owners for a lease on the park that runs through 2010. The Marlins were rebuffed by the Mayor on a recent visit. No one is going to tear down a multi-million dollar park that has been a political hot potato in a market that has been very soft on professional baseball. San Antonio has made some noise about becoming a major league market. A small population market and proximity to major league clubs like Houston and the Texas Rangers make it a Class AA Texas League town, not an MLB city. Look, Don?t Pack Commissioner Selig gave the Marlins permission to investigate a move, but the most likely scenario is that MLB will get more involved in finding a home for the Marlins in a part of South Florida that has the kind of population demographics that will sustain the club better than Miami. Nearby North Broward and Palm Beach counties are more affluent. A shorter commute to the long season of games would be expected to boost season ticket numbers. Buzz at the Winter meetings off the record was consistent: The sentiment is that the Marlins should try to work out their problems and stay in the South Florida market. Should they move, though, the likely candidates would be high-drawing Triple-A baseball markets, like Sacramento or Memphis. Both have issues that would make a move difficult, though. Indianapolis has broad drawing power and is a sports town, but a big bill to keep the Colts housed and happy would mean that putting together a stadium deal in Florida would still be easier. For the Marlins to succeed anywhere, some of their community relations habits will have to improve. The team fields championship clubs, that, according to their math, should be enough to command less Rodney Dangerfield-like respect. It?s not the World Series rings that make the daily payroll. It?s the long home season that the Marlins have to deliver. Both the Expos and the Marlins have fallen under repeated criticism in that department. An autograph signing last Spring was blown off to much fan criticism. This and other miscues will make fence mending as important a component of the Marlins? operations plans as stadium building.
January 24, 200620 yr Ok I like the idea, but this guy has no idea about the politics involved. Broward/PB are not options. It has to be in Miami, or nowhere.. Unless something ridiculous happens.
January 24, 200620 yr Ok I like the idea, but this guy has no idea about the politics involved. Broward/PB are not options. It has to be in Miami, or nowhere.. Unless something ridiculous happens. I was just abou to say the same thing. Not to mention the fact that the Marlins greatest fan potential lies in Dade-County where all the baseball-crazy Latin people are. Sure, Broward and Palm Beach counties are more affluent, but there are jus tmore ppl in Dade.
January 24, 200620 yr Ok I like the idea, but this guy has no idea about the politics involved. Broward/PB are not options. It has to be in Miami, or nowhere.. Unless something ridiculous happens. I was just abou to say the same thing. Not to mention the fact that the Marlins greatest fan potential lies in Dade-County where all the baseball-crazy Latin people are. Sure, Broward and Palm Beach counties are more affluent, but there are jus tmore ppl in Dade. actually palm beach has more season ticket holders then dade by like 2-1. But you are right it has to be dade but for a different reason. Palm beach isnt going to build them a stadium, they are more concerned with the near to last in the country school system.
January 24, 200620 yr Ok I like the idea, but this guy has no idea about the politics involved. Broward/PB are not options. It has to be in Miami, or nowhere.. Unless something ridiculous happens. I was just abou to say the same thing. Not to mention the fact that the Marlins greatest fan potential lies in Dade-County where all the baseball-crazy Latin people are. Sure, Broward and Palm Beach counties are more affluent, but there are jus tmore ppl in Dade. actually palm beach has more season ticket holders then dade by like 2-1. But you are right it has to be dade but for a different reason. Palm beach isnt going to build them a stadium, they are more concerned with the near to last in the country school system. Every public school I have attended in Palm Beach County is an A school...
January 24, 200620 yr Ok I like the idea, but this guy has no idea about the politics involved. Broward/PB are not options. It has to be in Miami, or nowhere.. Unless something ridiculous happens. I was just abou to say the same thing. Not to mention the fact that the Marlins greatest fan potential lies in Dade-County where all the baseball-crazy Latin people are. Sure, Broward and Palm Beach counties are more affluent, but there are jus tmore ppl in Dade. actually palm beach has more season ticket holders then dade by like 2-1. But you are right it has to be dade but for a different reason. Palm beach isnt going to build them a stadium, they are more concerned with the near to last in the country school system. Every public school I have attended in Palm Beach County is an A school... That doesn't prove his point is wrong.
January 24, 200620 yr The man also forgot to metion Charlotte. I think after South Fla this is the best option(Simply because of Las Vegas gambling money)
January 24, 200620 yr Ok I like the idea, but this guy has no idea about the politics involved. Broward/PB are not options. It has to be in Miami, or nowhere.. Unless something ridiculous happens. I was just abou to say the same thing. Not to mention the fact that the Marlins greatest fan potential lies in Dade-County where all the baseball-crazy Latin people are. Sure, Broward and Palm Beach counties are more affluent, but there are jus tmore ppl in Dade. actually palm beach has more season ticket holders then dade by like 2-1. But you are right it has to be dade but for a different reason. Palm beach isnt going to build them a stadium, they are more concerned with the near to last in the country school system. Every public school I have attended in Palm Beach County is an A school... That doesn't prove his point is wrong. Of course not, but I wouldn't say that Palm Beach County is filled with troubled schools. In fact I'd like to see where is says PBC has the second to worst school system in the nation, 'cause I highly doubt that.
January 24, 200620 yr This article states that "low regular season attendance" has always been a problem for the Marlins. This adds to the false belief that 10,000 people per game was always the norm. The reality is that attendance only really took a dive after 1998. Not making excuses for the past few years, it should have been at least 25% better, but this misconception of fans never supporting the Marlins is wrong. In the 1997 World series season, we averaged close to 30,000. Not great by ST. Louis or Boston or Yankee standards (note that it is good by Met standards) but equal to the Atlanta Braves and many other teams including more than this past season champions White Sox, in the great sports city of Chicago. So when ripping Marlins fans, who endured the unprecedented dismantling in 1998, the stripping of the all-star game and the constant threats of relocation or contraction and a new dismantiling-it is just unfair to paint the picture that the Marlins were never supported. Too many people, management, MLB, politicians etc have all had an equal hand in lowering the fan base. Unfortunately the national media (and New York media) love to bash S. Florida and the sports fans down here. Look in the mirror, the lousy sports fans down here are the ones who love baseball but do not go to the games because they think they are great fans but just happen to be REd Sox or Yankee fans. Unfortunately for them, they do not add to the attendance at their favorite teams park either-since they live here. Yet they take credit for that. You are more responsible for the problems here than any credit or chest pumping you seek for the attendance in other cities.
January 24, 200620 yr At moments like this I like to tell the story of following a couple with two young kids in tow up the steps during the third or fourth rain delay of the night and soaking wet, the wife turns to her husband and says "This is the LAST Marlins game you're dragging us to...". What really isn't needed here is for newbies to tell the Marlins most loyal fans (members here at mb.com) they need to "look in the mirror" or to ignore the cumulative effect the weather and the nature of PPS has had on attendance over the last decade. There are a myriad of reasons why attendance is what it is, from demographic to atmospherical and dozens in between. No one can argue that attendance has fallen off in the last decade but to ignore the "why" is just silly. One only has to look at weekend attendance and very strong tv ratings figures for 2005 to see that there is more than hope, there is a strong following that can be cultivated in the right environment.
January 24, 200620 yr Palm Beach and Broward counties may not be willing to work with the Marlins for a stadium at this point, but it is certainly unwarranted to say that building a park there would be a mistake. Besides the number of affluent people residing in the two counties, they certainly have the population to support a major league team. The combined population of Palm Beach (1.2 million) and Broward (1.7 million) counties are equivalent or higher than many fairly successful MLB markets (such as Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Oakland, etc.). That, of course, is before you add any of Miami-Dade's numbers into the mix. Additionally, having a stadium in Miami-Dade inevitably alienates many residents of Central and Northern Palm Beach County, which are both located 60+ miles from Dolphins Stadium. Putting a stadium somewhere in Broward County (perhaps in a centrally located area, such as near the BankAtlantic Center/Sawgrass Mills) would, in my opinion, do a lot to reach out to fans from West Palm Beach, Palm Beach Gardens, Jupiter, etc. Being in the geographic center of the tri-county area (unlike the current locale) just seems to make sense, at least from a transportation/geography viewpoint. I'm not necessarily advocating a Broward location as the best option (and I know very little about the politics in Broward, and if it could even happen), but I feel that such sites should be explored as possibilities.
January 24, 200620 yr The local press, which seizes on bad Marlins news like a donut addict locked in a Krispy Kreme, said good riddance and began screaming all of the usual rumors about towns where the Marlins might go. :notworthy Sentence of the article. Saying a stadium in Miami-Dade is going to alienate WPB fans isn't fair. Why? Dolphins Stadium is a few miles from the Broward-Miami-Dade county line. Hialeah Heights is nearly the same distance to the MD-B County line.
January 24, 200620 yr The local press, which seizes on bad Marlins news like a donut addict locked in a Krispy Kreme, said good riddance and began screaming all of the usual rumors about towns where the Marlins might go. :notworthy Sentence of the article. Saying a stadium in Miami-Dade is going to alienate WPB fans isn't fair. Why? Dolphins Stadium is a few miles from the Broward-Miami-Dade county line. Hialeah Heights is nearly the same distance to the MD-B County line. Ya and they can just take the Sawgrass to 75, anyway. Much less traffic than 95
January 24, 200620 yr Being in the geographic center of the tri-county area (unlike the current locale) just seems to make sense, at least from a transportation/geography viewpoint. I'm not necessarily advocating a Broward location as the best option (and I know very little about the politics in Broward, and if it could even happen), but I feel that such sites should be explored as possibilities. You simply can not build a stadium in an area that is inaccessible by readily available and affordable public transit. And you certainly can't away from the area where the region's work force will be at when they're considering going to the ballpark. This is as true as it is now as it was when suburbanites wouldn't attend the inner city stadiums in the late 50s and 60s. Everything - the ability to attract consistent attendees (season ticket holders) and walk-up crowds to interesting the support of private investors and municipalities to forging long lasting and profitable ventures between the club, city and businesses - revolves around baseball in an urban setting. You lose that, you lose everything. Now one might say you can create an urban setting, but whatever community you intend to build will not be self-sustaining. It must draw on a larger population, who want to visit the community's attractions. And transportation-wise, a location south of Dolphins Stadium is preferred. The southbound routes will be going against the stream of PM rush hour traffic, limiting the increased travel time for those in the north, while awarding those to the south less distance, in more than one way, to the stadium.
January 24, 200620 yr Everything - the ability to attract consistent attendees (season ticket holders) and walk-up crowds to interesting the support of private investors and municipalities to forging long lasting and profitable ventures between the club, city and businesses - revolves around baseball in an urban setting. There is absolutely nothing urban about Dolphins stadium...why not re-visit the possibilities of having a stadium near downtown Ft.Lauderdale, another urban setting that has seen explosive residential growth over the past several years?
January 24, 200620 yr Everything - the ability to attract consistent attendees (season ticket holders) and walk-up crowds to interesting the support of private investors and municipalities to forging long lasting and profitable ventures between the club, city and businesses - revolves around baseball in an urban setting. There is absolutely nothing urban about Dolphins stadium...why not re-visit the possibilities of having a stadium near downtown Ft.Lauderdale, another urban setting that has seen explosive residential growth over the past several years? When Broward and/or Palm Beach county agree to contribute the approximately $250 million that ultimately Miami-Dade (and whatever municipal entity participates) will, then Ft Lauderdale or WPB or Sawgrass might become alternative sites to consider. But last I've read neither county has offered so much as a penny towards keeping the Marlins in South Florida and as such doesn't have a seat at the table, and justifiably so. If I lived in PBC or Broward I'd be lobbying my local officials to work WITH Miami-Dade to find a site all parties could live with and through the creation of some tri-county sports authority or other mechanism, work for it's approval in Tallahassee, and be willing to share in the costs. It's nice that the Marlins have so many fans in Broward and PBC but it's irrelevant to the debate so long as those counties contribute zero towards keeping the Marlins in the region.
January 24, 200620 yr I'm with you on the area around Dolphins Stadium. From what I recall from my visits there, I did nothing but head back to the place I was staying. Although I believe that plan is contingent on building a retail shopping around the stadium, but there's been suggestions from county officials that it will not work as well as Huizenga has been promising and it's not really well situated to draw people to. Hialeah is a bit better. Both are better than Fort Lauderdale. FTL is too far north and cuts you off from attracting nearly all of Dade County, which offers a substantial amount of the region's population and some of its most loyal Marlins fans. Let's be blunt, a sizable amount of the population you'd be trying to court to FTL are Yankees fans and senior citizens. [edit: not that they are not loyal Marlins fans in Broward and Palm Beach counties, it's their neighbors who don't share the same feeling.]
January 25, 200620 yr If only we could have had that space where the Office Depot Center is (or whatever it's called now)
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.