Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Cool blurb on Willingham

Featured Replies

c/o of baseballprospectus.com

 

Catchers: Real Prospects

 

Player WARP Upside Combined

1. Jarrod Saltalamacchia, C, ATL (21) 16.9 137.0 306.4

 

2. Josh Willingham, C, FLO (27) 15.3 126.2 279.3

 

3. Kenji Jojima, C, SEA (30) 14.0 94.7 234.9

4. Jeffrey Mathis, C, LAA (23) 14.0 86.3 226.1

5. Michael Napoli, C, LAA (24) 15.3 71.8 224.7

6. Ron Paulino, C, PIT (25) 16.1 59.4 220.4

7. Russell Martin, C, LAN (23) 16.3 52.3 215.4

8. Neil Walker, C, PIT (20) 14.0 60.9 200.6

 

9. Miguel Montero, C, ARI (22) 11.5 59.2 174.5

10. John Jaso, C, TBA (22) 12.0 49.6 169.2

11. Curtis Thigpen, C, TOR (23) 13.6 28.8 164.4

12. Jeffrey Clement, C, SEA (22) ** 9.2 59.6 152.0

13. Kelly Shoppach, C, CLE (26) 11.2 39.6 151.2

14. Brandon Snyder, C, BAL (19) 10.7 41.6 148.4

15. Taylor Teagarden, C, TEX (22) ** 9.4 39.8 133.4

16. Carlos Ruiz, C, PHI (27) 10.4 20.8 124.9

17. Justin Knoedler, C, SFN (25) 9.8 26.3 123.9

18. Eliezer Alfonzo, C, SFN (27) 9.6 26.8 122.7

19. Kurt Suzuki, C, OAK (22) 9.1 31.1 121.6

20. Francisco Hernandez, C, CHA (20) 9.9 21.3 120.6

21. Christopher Iannetta, C, COL (23) 8.6 30.0 116.1

22. George Kottaras, C, SDN (23) 8.3 28.3 111.0

23. Shawn Riggans, C, TBA (25) 7.6 29.4 105.4

 

** Fewer than 150 translated PA

Line breaks indicate ratings differences of at least 25 points

 

I recognize that these numbers, new as they are to all of us, will not mean very much in the abstract. But broadly speaking, it takes a combined rating of about 300 to attain the status of an elite, Top 20 prospect. By that definition, only Jarrod Saltalamacchia qualifies among backstops this year. Salty is a pretty well known commodity, and PECOTA doesn?t buck the consensus, finding a player who projects to hit 20-25 homers per season in the big leagues supported by .350ish on base percentages. The issue, apart from the de rigeur concern about a lack of foot speed, is that catcher almost certainly won?t be his position in the big leagues. Not only is there the Brian McCann problem, but both Saltalamacchia?s translations and reputation rate him as a poor defensive catcher, and he?s tall (6? 4?) for the position. I?d venture to guess that, if the prospect is a catcher, shortstop, or center fielder, the odds of him playing that position as a 27-year-old big leaguer are quite long unless he enjoys a truly premium defensive reputation.

 

Josh Willingham is an extreme representative of the Shane Victorino group of players: someone who is not so much a prospect as a player who could be an average-to-good major leaguer in the present tense, without further development. Statheads have been touting this sort of player for a long time. Along the way, we?ve made a few missteps. It?s nice to say that minor league statistics predict major league performance as well as major league statistics do, but it isn?t quite true. Certain statistical profiles--position players with extremely high walk rates unsupported by other skills, soft-tossing pitchers with poor strikeout numbers, players who have a "breakout" year when repeating a level--may reflect an ability to exploit weaker competition, rather than true big league talent. Willingham doesn?t really fit into any of these profiles. While his walk rates are high, they?re supported by abundant power, and while his contact skills are not good, his speed metrics come out surprisingly well. PECOTA has him posting the highest EqA of any National League catcher next year. I?m fairly comfortable that, on the question of players like Willingham, the scouting side of the aisle does have it wrong. But, to reiterate, the error is not so much in failing to define the commodity appropriately--nobody doubts that Willingham will hit his home runs and draw his walks in the big leagues, and not do much else--but in failing to put it into its proper context. It?s nice to talk about a player?s upside, but by definition, relatively few players will realize their upside. And sometimes, like in Michael Bourn?s case, that upside just isn?t all that exciting to begin with. By contrast, players who have already realized their upside are liable to be underrated, provided that upside means being an average-to-good big league regular, warts and all.

 

Awesome stuff. Pretty much every sane person who knows baseball already accepts that Willingham is a player ready to contribute at least at an average clip, which, to a team in this rebuilding phase, is incredibly important. I'm glad to have him as part of our long-term core, ideally at catcher, but at least at LF. We know that one of those positions will be covered with, at worst, an average bat, and likely an above average bat. That makes me happy.

15. Taylor Teagarden, C, TEX (22) ** 9.4 39.8 133.4

 

I still think it's a shame we passed on him with the pletora of picks we had before he was taken at 100, but isn't he out for the year? Hard to put someone who may not play until 2007 on the list.

I know this is slightly off topic, but what happened to Baker, the catcher we claimed from the A's?

 

We in effect sent him back to the A's. We cut him one day and re-signed with them next.

15. Taylor Teagarden, C, TEX (22) ** 9.4 39.8 133.4

 

I still think it's a shame we passed on him with the pletora of picks we had before he was taken at 100, but isn't he out for the year? Hard to put someone who may not play until 2007 on the list.

I believe he had TJ Surgery

I know this is slightly off topic, but what happened to Baker, the catcher we claimed from the A's?

 

We in effect sent him back to the A's. We cut him one day and re-signed with them next.

 

Thanks...I just thought it was odd with the high amount of catchers we had in camp, that we cut him.

I know this is slightly off topic, but what happened to Baker, the catcher we claimed from the A's?

 

We in effect sent him back to the A's. We cut him one day and re-signed with them next.

 

Thanks...I just thought it was odd with the high amount of catchers we had in camp, that we cut him.

 

 

Also our lack of catching depth

 

 

:plain :plain :plain

Olivo is all we needed lol. along with willingham to back him up and treanor as maybe a 3rd string if giradi wants to do that.

15. Taylor Teagarden, C, TEX (22) ** 9.4 39.8 133.4

 

I still think it's a shame we passed on him with the pletora of picks we had before he was taken at 100, but isn't he out for the year? Hard to put someone who may not play until 2007 on the list.

 

It would have been a wasted pick. With Boras as his agent...there was no way in hell the budget conscious Marlins would have been able to meet his demands. Passing was the right thing to do. Many other teams shared our sentiments as indicated by the spot he was ultimately drafted.

On the contrary the Marlins have never been shy about paying for amateur talent, and that was no truer this year when they opted for high school and undergraduates. I know this your pet issue and perhaps Boras is an ass and Teagarden isn't worth it, but your argument doesn't hold any water when it comes to the Marlins.

On the contrary the Marlins have never been shy about paying for amateur talent, and that was no truer this year when they opted for high school and undergraduates. I know this your pet issue and perhaps Boras is an ass and Teagarden isn't worth it, but your argument doesn't hold any water when it comes to the Marlins.

 

 

Fair enough...you're entitled to your opinion. My question then would be "why didn't the Marlins draft Teagarden?" He was obviously a first round talent who was passed over on numerous ocassions. If not for the fact his "signability" was in question why did the Marlins pass on Teagarden? You are correct in that the Marlins made a serious run at Hansen but were ultimately rebuffed, so there is precedent for them spending money on signable players. They were willing to spend on the others because they knew could get the deals done. In the case of Hansen they couldn't and in the case of Teagarden they obviously knew they couldn't.

 

Which part of this scenario do you dispute?

Your projection to your objections of Teagarden's worth vis-a-vis his and Boras' demands to the Marlins. Maybe they simply didn't want him or wanted someone else. Maybe they wanted to focus on pitching. Maybe they didn't think a catcher was a safe pick for the first round. Maybe they saw something in Teagarden or Marceuax, Volstad, Thompson, Hayes, West, et al that others who did not. There's no reason to believe the Marlins frowned upon their opportunity to sign Teagarden if they so desired.

It is rather disingenous to project your own thoughts upon the Marlins front office like that. It's like how nearly every trade someone objects to the players received and claim the Marlins weren't interested in getting back talent, because they don't see the players in the same light as the team. It's a narrow minded view that offers nothing to no one. You can't get a grip on a situation when you're only willing to consider one argument.

Disingenous? Geez...I'm just giving my opinion. I obviously have no working knowledge on the thought process on the Marlins front office. You make a valid point that there certainly might have been other factors in the Marlins deciding to pass on Teagarden. I for one tend to think that the salary demand of his agent was the overriding factor as to why the Marlins and every other team in MLB decided to pass on him in the first couple of rounds of the draft.

  • Author

So, anyway, one of the recently posted articles on mlb.com suggests the Marlins may pursue both a LFer and a CFer towards the end of the spring, once our pitching talent has been properly evaluated. That suggestion must assume that Willingham wins the catching job this spring.

 

Also, I think Willingham needs much more game experience at catcher than he's getting so far. I don't like this every other game rotation of Willingham/Wilson and Olivo/Treanor. Opinions?

That'll come. They need those other games to evaluate what other talent they have at the position, but it seems safe to say that if Willingham takes to catching, the team will keep him there even if Olivo is doing well.

If Hammer wins the catching job does it follow that Olivo would be kept as the backup & Treanor sent to the minors? I think Olivo catching 20 or 25% of the games would help keep Willingham fresh (put him in left field) and Olivo offers a little more pop than Treanor does.

Unless Olivo requests out of his contract to seek a better option, but that's extrememly unlikely. He'd have to hit like a monster and another team's starter would have to become injured.

  • Author

That'll come. They need those other games to evaluate what other talent they have at the position, but it seems safe to say that if Willingham takes to catching, the team will keep him there even if Olivo is doing well.

 

That sounds great to me. It's hugely tough to guage whether articles and comments by the media/coaches are accurate, prop pieces, or manipulated to give the target player confidence...or any number of other factors.

I'm going to catch a few games next week for spring break, so I should come back with a pretty good picture of who can hack it in the field and at the plate.

It almost seems like a dream that Willingham has a legit shot at being our starting catcher. The kid has been misused and held back for so long despite ready skills for almost 2 years now.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.