March 29, 200620 yr The type of players they are or project to be, I would estimate they are both on the same career path, each entering their peak seasons. Speedy contact hitters typically start their careers more productive and lose ground on other types in the traditional 27-32 peak age range. Church has a .300 average in the minors, that's without time in the California league or the 100 more at bats at AAA Gathright has had. When you consider their power then and projected power, Church is a surer bet to keep his average up as he faces better pitchers and fielders. Church has had very respectable and encouraging walk an strikeout rates throughout the minors. While he has struck 25% in the majors and Gathright 20% of the time, Gathright's major league walk rate is half of that of Church's. Church is an outstanding defender. He has both the range and arm necessary for centerfield, where by your own admission, Gathright will be a below-average defender. I'm dismissing your stolen base argument out of hand, because from everything I've read in action, it means close to diddlysquat. And Church is a smart baserunner who will add his own share, without distracting both the pitcher and batter. Neither are going to be stars, but Church projects to provide better production for his team until they reach free agency. Did Church score a 45 on the wonderlic test also? Pecota rates him as a league average defender for a corner spot. Don't know why he is outstanding all of a sudden. Reed and Aguila would out field him. And if Church is so good, why isn't he playing in THE NATIONALS outfield? Not saying he wouldn't be a starter for us, but I don't want to give up any value for him. Pinto/Reed is fine if that is all you are thinking, but not worth one of the 6-7 SP. Church is not the next Jason Lane.
March 29, 200620 yr Did Church score a 45 on the wonderlic test also? Pecota rates him as a league average defender for a corner spot. Don't know why he is outstanding all of a sudden. Reed and Aguila would out field him. And if Church is so good, why isn't he playing in THE NATIONALS outfield? Not saying he wouldn't be a starter for us, but I don't want to give up any value for him. Pinto/Reed is fine if that is all you are thinking, but not worth one of the 6-7 SP. Church is not the next Jason Lane. http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/C/ryan-church.shtml http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/L/jason-lane.shtml Well if you look at minor league stats I would say they are very similar. I don't know about Pecota but baseball america rated him as the best defensive OF in the system in 2004 and they say he has a strong arm. (Though I wouldn't say outstanding but surely average to above average) Why isn't Church playing for the Nationals? I think its because Soriano, Guillen, and Watson who they believe steals bases and will be more productive.(They also have Bryd) I guess what determines what you be willing to give up is who you feel is the better player, which I feel is Church. So if it takes Olsen, Nolasco, or Johnson to acquire Gathright I would much rather offer the same deal to the Nationals for Church. Not trying to start another argument like the one in the Williangham thread but I strongly believe Church is the better player and I can defend that.
March 29, 200620 yr Church isn't in the Nationals' outfield because Bowden is an egotistical a**hole who signs reclamation projects and troubled players to be awarded with praise when and if they succeed. Church serves no purpose to Bowden, thus, serves no purpose to the Nationals in Bowden's mind. Frank has always been higher on Byrd, Watson and Godwin for whatever reason. Perhaps I am hyping his defensive abilities. While Church was ranked the best outfield defender in both arm and range of the Nats by Baseball America, he's no gold glover in centerfield. From what I saw he is better than Wilkerson, Watson, Wilson (who isn't?), Pierre (oh yeah, that's who) and Aguila. Never seen Gathright in extended action to make a judgement about him. FWIW, both are par when it comes to Zone Rating at CF with Church posting much worse at LF (something that doesn't gel with his experience in CF and RF). Still, Church projects to have the better bat. And you can not make a legitimate claim that Church is any worse a centerfielder than Gathright. Gathright's been noted as a terrible negative or zero-sum defender by PECOTA his entire professional career. I ask you if Gathright projects to be a long-term option or better stopgap centerfielder, why has his organization never viewed him as a regular centerfielder until he reached the majors?
March 29, 200620 yr Peter Gammons opined today on Boog's show that the problem was in fact with Robinson and not Bowden, who he said a few weeks ago was touting Church as an all-star in the making.
March 29, 200620 yr Baseball america rated him as the best defensive OF in the system in 2004 and they say he has a strong arm. (Though I wouldn't say outstanding but surely average to above average) Not trying to start another argument like the one in the Williangham thread but I strongly believe Church is the better player and I can defend that. Being rated tops in the system, doesn't mean you are any good. For all we know, the entire Nationals system could have defensive nightmares. I think it's fair to say, he can probably hold his own defensively, but he isn't going to confuse anyone for a premier defender. I could make the same argument for Gathright, it's all what you're looking for. You like to see more power, I think Gathright's OBP and SB abilities translate. We can preemptively agree to disagree on this. And in general, I'd be happy with either, for the right player/pitcher in trade. Which is the most important part. It's more important with what we give up to get them. Still, Church projects to have the better bat. And you can not make a legitimate claim that Church is any worse a centerfielder than Gathright. Gathright's been noted as a terrible negative or zero-sum defender by PECOTA his entire professional career. I ask you if Gathright projects to be a long-term option or better stopgap centerfielder, why has his organization never viewed him as a regular centerfielder until he reached the majors? If we are talking OPS, Church has the better bat, but a lot of Gathright's value is derived from stealing bases. You hate these so I can plainly see why you like one over the other. It's just a stylistic thing in crafting a lineup here. I think Gathright will hit for a much higher average then Church, and while he won't walk at the same rate, it'll still be respectable enough where he will out OBP Church, which matters a lot to me. I make no arguments saying Gathright is better then anyone defensively. All I am saying is, reports have said he has improved level to level, and his range (speed) should somewhat make up for defiencies in arm strength. He's not as bad as advertised. That's all. Why has Church's organization put him in AAA, where Gathright is starting in CF opening day for a franchise with much more outfield and offensive depth? It works both ways.
March 29, 200620 yr Alot of OF depth doesnt mean they are all ready. Baldelli will drop kick him out of CF when hes fully ready to. And once again, Gathright misplays fly balls. All the speed dont mean anything if you cant judge a pop fly, and dont have the arm to make up for the mistake.
March 30, 200620 yr Being rated tops in the system, doesn't mean you are any good. For all we know, the entire Nationals system could have defensive nightmares. I think it's fair to say, he can probably hold his own defensively, but he isn't going to confuse anyone for a premier defender. That was my point, he can more than hold his own defensively. Though if he is the best defense prospect in a organization he is also likely to be a better defender than Joey Gathright who baseball america has this to say about him: "His arm strength and accuracy are below average" So yea I would say he is better than Joey Gathright defensively though not a premium defender. Church arm strength is another plus he has on Gtahright. I could make the same argument for Gathright, it's all what you're looking for. You like to see more power, I think Gathright's OBP and SB abilities translate. We can preemptively agree to disagree on this. And in general, I'd be happy with either, for the right player/pitcher in trade. Which is the most important part. It's more important with what we give up to get them. I don't think you can honestly say that Gathright will put up a higher OBP than Church. In 2003 in 346 at bats Church walked 51 times and struck out 62(also hit .343) and even in spring training when he manage to hit only .200 he still walked more time sthan he struck out(10/7). Stats like this say he was more unlucky than bad in spring training. I believe you have said you project Gathright to have a OBP around .340. Last year Church put up a .353 OBP even though he was hurt and never got regular playing time. Power like the stolen bases are not even close. Note to the people not convince: Church can pup up a low to mid .800 OPS in 2006 with regular playing time. If we are talking OPS, Church has the better bat, but a lot of Gathright's value is derived from stealing bases. You hate these so I can plainly see why you like one over the other. It's just a stylistic thing in crafting a lineup here. I think Gathright will hit for a much higher average then Church, and while he won't walk at the same rate, it'll still be respectable enough where he will out OBP Church, which matters a lot to me. I make no arguments saying Gathright is better then anyone defensively. All I am saying is, reports have said he has improved level to level, and his range (speed) should somewhat make up for defiencies in arm strength. He's not as bad as advertised. That's all. No arguing here Joey Gathright main value is SB, but if Church has a higher OPS and OBP I think that means he is getting on 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and across home as much if not more times than Gathright. Now one argue Gathright speed messes up the opposing pitcher concentration, while true it also effects the batters approach and concentration in the box. Minor League, Major League, and plate discipline averages suggest that if Gathright truely out hits Church when it comes to batting average it will only be by a couple of point (.1-.12 I'll say) and Church power more than makes up for the difference. See OBP on top. Why has Church's organization put him in AAA, where Gathright is starting in CF opening day for a franchise with much more outfield and offensive depth? It works both ways. I think the answers are Frank Robinson being the Nationals manager, Bowden Gm and his spring training numbers. As for Gathright in most Devil Rays message boards I have gone to they say he is likely going to the bench and if he happens to start in CF its because Rocco is DH because his hamstring is sore. Just my .02 cents, I don't want to start another argument here. I just want the readers to compare and see for themselves who is better or who would they rather have.
March 30, 200620 yr Peter Gammons opined today on Boog's show that the problem was in fact with Robinson and not Bowden, who he said a few weeks ago was touting Church as an all-star in the making. That's P.T. Bowden for you. He's shameless.
March 30, 200620 yr Last time I checked OPS had the best coorelation with winning out of all offensive stats, but hey, that's just straight regression. I honestly do not know how you can project Gathright to be the better contact hitter. Gathright's 20-point lead in batting average (.317-.297) is inflated due to his California League and AAA stints. We both know that you can't measure batting average by itself. Power and line drive rate tell a player's ability to hit solidly. Walk and strike out rates tell a player's ability to connect properly. Church not only has better power, but walks at a greater rate and strikes out only a bit more than Gathright. Gathright's more prone to regress as he faces better pitchers and defenses than Church. If stolen bases are that important, I would like to hear your claim against the countless studies we've surely both read. Do the Devil Rays really have the quality CF options we think they have? Baldelli's health is scary. Crawford's not that great in the field and Hollins not great with the bat. BJ or Dukes maybe in a few years. Gomes is a corner player. Ignoring the possibility their GM may be an idiot or self-serving jerk, why move a notoriusly terrible minor leaguer outfielder who had spent half of his time at corner outfield to centerfield as he came closer to the major league level? By the stats, it surely wasn't because he was improving on defense.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.