Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Duke Lacrosse In Trouble

Featured Replies

  • Author

Also, a point on that DA I forgot to talk about is how he is up for re-election this year. Could anything better have fallen into his lap then this? He is going on the media shows and convicting the entire team and University. I mean it's like something out of a movie. What better way to pimp your campaign then going hardline afer these guys. Going after members of a the sports team for the jewel of the city he represents with a case that is just perfect for the city of Durham which is predominantly black. A white team accused of attacking a black woman. It fell into his lap and his is milking it for all it's worth and is putting himself out there in fishnet stockings and a mini skirt for all the media to get a ride on. Pretty sick.

 

 

 

While I certainly agree he has not been professional in his handling of the case as far as the media, I am also getting the impression you think this is a farce and there is no merit to the claim. It seems like there is a lot of evidence to support that a rape did happen and the DNA tests should be out shortly to provide more insight, but until then I think it is pretty naive to ignore a persons claim because of their occupation and the campaign year for the DA. I highly doubt he is just going after the Duke Lacrosse team because of their skin color compared to that of the victim.

 

There just seems to be a lot of evidence to collaborate the victims story:

 

If the state crime lab's DNA analysis proves inconclusive or doesn't provide a match for any of the athletes, Nifong has said he'll have other evidence.

 

"If the only thing that we ever have in this case is DNA, then we wouldn't have a case," Nifong said Wednesday.

 

According to a search warrant served at the lacrosse players' home, investigators were looking for DNA evidence, pieces of blue bathroom carpet, cameras or videotapes that could contain photos or footage from the party, and even broken artificial nails from the accuser.

 

According to the application required for the court order seeking DNA samples from the team, at least one of those pieces of evidence was found.

 

"The victim's four red polished fingernails were recovered inside the residence consistent to [the accuser's] version of the attack. She claimed she was clawing at one of the suspect's arms in an attempt to breath [sic] while being strangled. During that time the nails broke off," the police statement said.

 

Earlier this week, university president Richard Brodhead suspended the highly ranked team from play until the school learns more about the accusations. But Cheshire said Nifong and police have created a mob mentality that has tainted the men "before the evidence has all come out in a way that they will never recover."

 

Nifong's office did not return calls from The Associated Press on Thursday seeking a response to that criticism.

 

English professor Melissa Malouf said she is one of those prepared for the DNA tests to prove inconclusive.

 

"I don't think the DNA is the case," she said after speaking at an outdoor protest near Brodhead's office. "Guys can wear condoms."

 

According to the court order application, a nurse trained to treat rape victims and a physician who treated the woman said they witnessed symptoms consistent with sexual assault. The document also includes details of a search of the house where the woman said she was raped for about a half-hour.

 

On Thursday, Nifong told ESPN that on the night in question, the two women were paid $400 each to perform at what they thought would be a bachelor party for about five people. The women met for the first time that night, and when they arrived at the house, there were more than 40 young men inside. The accuser told investigators the men became aggressive and loud.

 

Officers who searched the house later recovered the woman's makeup bag, cell phone and a stack of $20 bills consistent with the woman's statement that $400 in cash was taken from her purse after the attack, the police statement said.

 

Police have also searched a second home occupied by lacrosse team members, but documents describing the location or what investigators found have been sealed by court order, prosecutors and police said.

 

There seems to be a lot of consistencies from the story to the evidence found and released so far. While it could be made up, at this point it looks highly doubtful and it would have to be a great setup and scam for her to think this scheme out and pull it off to this extent.

Definitely don't think that at all. If it is true, I hope they throw the book at the a**hole(s) who did it.

 

That said, I am trying to show a different side of the story that has not been shown at all by him or the national media, which I find pretty sick.

 

If the DNA comes up with no match, allow me to buy the eggs to throw at the face of the media and the DA.

  • Author

Definitely don't think that at all. If it is true, I hope they throw the book at the a**hole(s) who did it.

 

That said, I am trying to show a different side of the story that has not been shown at all by him or the national media, which I find pretty sick.

 

If the DNA comes up with no match, allow me to buy the eggs to throw at the face of the media and the DA.

 

 

 

Permission granted.

This all comes down to the DNA tests. If there's no match, then none of the other details matter...at least as far as the lacrosse players are concerned. Maybe she got raped by someone else...but if they don't get a match from the lacrosse players, it wasn't by them.

 

I don't think the results are going to come back inconclusive. It sounds like the police have very solid DNA evidence obtained from the victim.

 

The idea that the DA is going to make a case even if there is no match is ludicrous.

 

I do have to wonder why he's trying to back himself out of that corner he created for himself. Is he truly worried there won't be a match?

  • Author

Wow, these players are just a bunch of class acts. From CNNSI.com:

 

Police find lacrosse e-mail

Message sent by Duke player soon after alleged rape

 

DURHAM, N.C. (AP) -- Hours after an exotic dancer was allegedly raped by members of the Duke University lacrosse team, a player apparently sent an e-mail saying he wanted to invite more strippers to his dorm room, kill them and skin them. It was not clear whether the message was serious or a joke.

 

Investigators did not return calls seeking comment about the nature of the e-mail. But a lawyer for the player who purportedly wrote it said the content suggests his client is innocent.

 

"While the language of the e-mail is vile, the e-mail itself is perfectly consistent with the boys' unequivocal assertion that no sexual assault took place that evening," said attorney Robert Ekstrand. The e-mail "demonstrates that its writer is completely unaware that any act or event remotely similar to what has been alleged ever occurred."

 

No charges have been filed in the case, which has roiled the campus and the community and led the school to suspend the lacrosse team from play.

 

The e-mail, according to an application for a search warrant of the player's dorm room, was sent from his Duke e-mail account just before 2 a.m. on March 14. Police said investigators received a copy from a confidential source, though they later won a court order seeking access to the account.

 

In the e-mail, addressed "To whom it may concern," the player says he has "decided to have some strippers over" to his dorm room, "however there will be no nudity."

 

"I plan on killing the bitches as soon as the walk in and proceding to cut their skin off," the author of the e-mail says, adding in vulgar terms that he would find the act sexually satisfying.

 

The e-mail was signed with what police said is the player's jersey number.

 

The warrant for the player's room was made public on Wednesday. In it, police provide a detailed timeline of the alleged attack and some additional details of their investigation. The warrant also adds conspiracy to commit murder as one of the crimes police are investigating.

 

The dancer, a student at a nearby university, has told police she was raped at the party by three men who restrained and choked her in a bathroom.

 

Investigators have collected DNA from 46 of the 47 team members. The team's lone black member did not provide a sample because the dancer, who is black, said her attackers were white. A spokeswoman for the state attorney general's office said Wednesday the analysis has not been completed.

 

The lacrosse team's co-captains have denied that anyone was sexually assaulted at the party, as have attorneys for the players.

 

According to the warrant, the alleged victim told police she believes the players used false names and falsely claimed to be members of Duke's baseball and track teams. A team captain and resident of the house where the party took place told police he used an alias when hiring the dancers at the party, the warrant states.

 

District Attorney Mike Nifong has said that he is "pretty confident that a rape occurred," but that he does not expect to file charges until next week.

 

Wow, this guy just exudes innocence! :plain

Yeah.

 

That's just... Weird.

 

What a depraved mind.

 

While that statement doesn't make the dude guilty, it does make him a sick f***. And any jury who hears that, if admissable for character, will be skeptical that these are nice young boys they're dealing with.

Yeah.

 

That's just... Weird.

 

What a depraved mind.

 

While that statement doesn't make the dude guilty, it does make him a sick f***. And any jury who hears that, if admissable for character, will be skeptical that these are nice young boys they're dealing with.

 

Exactly my thoughts. Even someone to kid with that, frunk (which he probably was) is disgusting. I don't know anything that would find that funny.

 

That in no way means that a rape occurred.

 

The Fan likes to get his anti-Duke/Dook (lolz) jollies in through this though so it isn't suprising he'd put that little comment in.

It doesn't make him guilty. But his lawyer has to be related to the Iraqi Information Minister to say that it makes him innocent.

 

 

It's irrelevant as evidence for the rape itself. However, that being said, if they want to portray these kids character's then this COULD be used to show they're not "Mr. Innocent" in the matter.

 

Where does it say, "I raped this chick"?

 

I repeat there is NO correlation between this email and the rape. The idiot didn't give anything away.

It doesn't make him guilty. But his lawyer has to be related to the Iraqi Information Minister to say that it makes him innocent.

 

 

It's irrelevant as evidence for the rape itself. However, that being said, if they want to portray these kids character's then this COULD be used to show they're not "Mr. Innocent" in the matter.

 

Where does it say, "I raped this chick"?

 

I repeat there is NO correlation between this email and the rape. The idiot didn't give anything away.

 

Are you disagreeing with me? I can't tell. If you are, I think you misinterpreted what I said...because I happen to agree with you.

It doesn't make him guilty. But his lawyer has to be related to the Iraqi Information Minister to say that it makes him innocent.

 

 

It's irrelevant as evidence for the rape itself. However, that being said, if they want to portray these kids character's then this COULD be used to show they're not "Mr. Innocent" in the matter.

 

Where does it say, "I raped this chick"?

 

I repeat there is NO correlation between this email and the rape. The idiot didn't give anything away.

 

Are you disagreeing with me? I can't tell. If you are, I think you misinterpreted what I said...because I happen to agree with you.

 

I guess I am.

  • Author

Yeah.

 

That's just... Weird.

 

What a depraved mind.

 

While that statement doesn't make the dude guilty, it does make him a sick f***. And any jury who hears that, if admissable for character, will be skeptical that these are nice young boys they're dealing with.

 

Exactly my thoughts. Even someone to kid with that, frunk (which he probably was) is disgusting. I don't know anything that would find that funny.

 

That in no way means that a rape occurred.

 

The Fan likes to get his anti-Duke/Dook (lolz) jollies in through this though so it isn't suprising he'd put that little comment in.

 

 

Everyone who is not "pro-Duke" is "anti-Duke" to you. You are a homer and Duke can do no wrong in your eyes. Coming from a person who takes a shot at UM every chance you get, you have a lot of room to talk about people who are "anti" and take shots. Get. Over. Your. Self.

The stories in the press the past couple days have forced me to sort or re-evaluate my position on this thing. I still find it hard to believe that no sexual assault took place based solely on the actions of the police. But it now appears that the supposed victim has told some lies over the course of this investigation. The question is how many and how extensive are those lies. I still feel everything rests on the DNA. Neither side has much of a case if the DNA does not support their claims.

  • Author

The stories in the press the past couple days have forced me to sort or re-evaluate my position on this thing. I still find it hard to believe that no sexual assault took place based solely on the actions of the police. But it now appears that the supposed victim has told some lies over the course of this investigation. The question is how many and how extensive are those lies. I still feel everything rests on the DNA. Neither side has much of a case if the DNA does not support their claims.

 

 

agreed.

The DNA results came in, and none of the 46 players were a match. This was released by the players lawyers, not the DA so we'll have to wait for that.

 

This could turn against the "dancer" very quickly

they are reporting it all over espn.

 

 

now if they kids are proven to be innocent do they sue ESPN, the unniversity, etc?

they are reporting it all over espn.

 

 

now if they kids are proven to be innocent do they sue ESPN, the unniversity, etc?

 

 

Does that lady go to the slammer?

The black community will not like this.

  • Author

The DNA results came in, and none of the 46 players were a match. This was released by the players lawyers, not the DA so we'll have to wait for that.

 

This could turn against the "dancer" very quickly

 

 

 

Very damaging to the DA case. With all the talking the DA did before hand, I would not be shocked to see charges still but the court of public opinion might have swayed very heavily in the other direction.

 

This part swayed me and now I hope the girl gets the book thrown at her. I think false rape accusations should be subject to the same punishments as rapes, in my mind they are equally as bad and just as sick and hopefully will prevent many in the future if the punishment criteria were to be raised:

 

Cheshire said even if the alleged attackers used a condom, it's likely there would have been some DNA evidence found suggesting an assault took place. He said in this case, the report states there was no DNA on her to indicate that she had sex of any type recently.

 

"The experts will tell you that if there was a condom used they would still be able to pick up DNA, latex, lubricant and all other types of things to show that -- and that's not here," Cheshire said.

That pretty much does it for me. I rushed to judgment and was completely wrong, evidently.

 

I still can't see what this woman was after...why she did this, how much of this was planned, what could she possibly be thinking. How could she be so dumb as to think she could get away with this, and yet at the same time rather cleverly plan certain aspects of this? If indeed any of it was planned. Maybe she just stumbled through it all step by step.

 

Why did the players stonewall the investigators?

 

I don't understand any of this.

 

But if the DNA does not match, the DA has no case. This sh*t will probably get thrown out of court if he even tries to prosecute. Unless the "victim" ID'd three of the players, he doesn't even know who to go after. And it would be pretty tough to prove that three lacrosse players raped the woman without leaving any DNA.

 

Another thing I don't understand is that on the one hand we have police reports stating that the evidence from the rape kit was consistent with her story that she was sexually assaulted. And now this Cheshire guy is saying this new report from the DNA people said there was no evidence to indicate she had sex of any type recently.

 

Whatever. All of this is hurting my brain.

 

Despite the fact that I now look like a moron, I'm very happy there was no DNA match. Hopefully, this means people owe my school and all those kids a big f***ing apology. And hopefully the Durham community can pull itself together.

The biggest mistake everyone made was to jump to conclusions right off the bat. It wouldnt make any more sense to jump to the other conclusion that she made it up and she wasnt raped when their DNA wasnt present. The use of a condom is still a viable theory..I think. All she said was that she was raped and that they did it. As far as the use of condom still leaving traces, dont forget that its their defense attorney saying this. So it isnt proven yet. One clear conclusion is that the DA looks like a total fool right now.

 

All that said, their case is probably gone since there is DNA, it didnt match them, and it could be that she had sex with someone else.

 

Probably the most important thing and telling thing:

 

Stan Goldman, who teaches criminal law, evidence and criminal procedure at Loyola Law School in Los Angeles, said the DNA results don't mean that Nifong can't go forward with the case -- but the test results make a successful prosecution much harder.

 

"Isn't the absence of DNA evidence, given the way the victim has described the crime, in and of itself almost enough to raise a reasonable doubt?" he said. "That's all the defense has to do."

 

 

 

If Im a juror, based on what I know...I dont convict these kids. But Im not yet convicting her of making it up.

Why did the players stonewall the investigators?

 

I don't understand any of this.

 

Thats the thing that got me so mad, they did say something...they just said nothing happened and everyone assumed they were lying through their teeth. The media presented it that they were all silent. Everyone of their attorneys said that they said nothing that they had been accused of actually took place. The media was horrific during this whole thing.

 

I feel bad for coach Pressler who had to fall on his own sword in this whole thing just because of the pressure in the media and not because he was the cause of any of these problems. Sad.

 

Hopefully in the future, the media doesn't give all the credibility to the alleged victim right off the bat and damns the alleged attackers before charges or more evidence comes out.

 

The media and alot of other people who attacked without knowledge owes Duke University a big apology.

I believe I read somewhere that there is video of the stripper arriving at the party with bruises. If this infact is true then she would have no chance to prove anything IMO.

I feel bad for coach Pressler who had to fall on his own sword in this whole thing just because of the pressure in the media and not because he was the cause of any of these problems. Sad.

 

 

I agree with you on some stuff, but not on this. Because even if there was no sexual assault, there was still a very loud and obnoxious house party with plenty of underage drinking, racially insensitive comments for the neighbors to hear, and, of course, the hiring of two strippers.

 

The coach has to take responsibility for some of that, for allowing his team to develop that kind of culture. I don't know if he would've been fired, but at the very least he would have received a stern reprimand. I don't think the phrase "fall on his own sword" necessarily applies here, not if you're making him out to be some kind of poor victim in all this.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.