March 29, 200620 yr Duke's lacrosse team suspended pending DNA results ESPN.com news services DURHAM, N.C. -- About a third of the members of the Duke men's lacrosse team -- embroiled in a rape investigation that caused the school to suspend the team from playing -- have been previously charged with misdemeanors stemming from drunken and disruptive behavior in the past three years, according to court documents quoted in Tuesday's editions of the Raleigh News and Observer. Fifteen of the 47 members of the team have been charged with offenses ranging from underage alcohol possession, violating open container laws, loud noise and public urination, according to the News and Observer. The paper said that most of those charges were resolved in deals with prosecutors that allowed the players to escape criminal convictions. Duke protest AP Photo/Sara D. Davis Demonstrators listen to Duke University president Richard Brodhead on Tuesday evening. On Tuesday, Duke University's president suspended the school's highly ranked lacrosse team from play until school administrators learn more about allegations that several team members raped an exotic dancer at an off-campus party. "In this painful period of uncertainty, it is clear to me, as it was to the players, that it would be inappropriate to resume the normal schedule of play," president Richard Brodhead said Tuesday. Brodhead met with students Wednesday morning to discuss the incident in a forum closed to reporters, Duke spokesman Geoffrey Mock said. "It was a meeting at which the students could share their thoughts about the topic," Mock said. He did not know how many attended but said the meeting was open to all students. A woman told police she and another dancer were hired to perform March 13 at a private party in an off-campus home. The dancer, a student at North Carolina Central University, told police she was pulled into a bathroom, beaten, choked and raped by three men. No one has been charged. Police took DNA samples with a cheek swab from 46 of the lacrosse team's 47 players last week. The 47th player, the only black member of the team, did not have to provide DNA because the dancer said her attackers were white. The dancer is black. "I needed to have the information about who will be charged," said District Attorney Mike Nifong said. "I feel pretty confident that a rape occurred." Brodhead said team captains notified athletic director Joe Alleva on Tuesday that players wanted to stay off the field until the DNA results came back from a crime lab. In a statement, the captains predicted the DNA testing would clear the players of wrongdoing. The case has roiled the campus and raised racial tensions. It has also heightened antagonism between the affluent students at Duke, which costs about $43,000 a year, and the city of Durham, which has a large population of poor people and is about evenly divided between white and black. "The circumstances of the rape indicated a deep racial motivation for some of the things that were done," Nifong said. "It makes a crime that is by its nature one of the most offensive and invasive even more so." Nifong said the team members are standing together and refusing to talk with investigators, and he warned he may bring aiding-and-abetting charges against some of the players. A lawyer representing several lacrosse team members did not immediately return calls Tuesday. Angry over the team members' silence and the university's handling of the case, Durham residents have demonstrated on and off campus in the past few days. They rallied outside the house where the alleged attack occurred and gathered outside of Duke provost Peter Lange's home, where they banged on pots and pans until he emerged to answer questions. Lange said Monday that he believes "the students would be well-advised to come forward. They have chosen not to." Alleva had already forced the team to miss two games because of underage drinking and the hiring of dancers at the party. Duke, considered a national title contender before the season began, has a 6-2 record with five regular-season games to go. Information from The Associated Press is included in this report Wow, that is a lot of people with previous charges for one lacrosse team. I guess this continues to prove that no major program is totally clean, like it or not.
March 29, 200620 yr Yeah, I've been following this story since I read about it on DBR on Monday. Quite frankly, it's disgusting. Apparently, the team has decided as a group not to cooperate with the investigation. Now, this may or may not be due to their lawyer's advice...but it's still total BS. Some of these kids have to be innocent, and it's on them to step forward and tell the police what happened. The idea that one lawyer can represent the best interests of all 46 kids is ludicrous. The innocent kids need to get their own representation and stop this cover up bulls***. Until that happens, every one of these kids bears some responsibility for this rape, and if nothing changes soon, I would dismiss every last one of those a**holes from Duke. And as for the team captains claims that the DNA would clear them of wrongdoing? These kids are not only a**holes, but they're stupid as sh*t. If the police are collecting sperm samples then that means that there was sex of some kind going on. The only question is whether it was consentual or not. DNA can't prove whether or not a rape occurred, you morons...it can only show which males were involved. The only way the DNA testing can clear them of wrongdoing is if the DNA belongs to some other man. But that would mean the stripper was raped by some other guy and then for some reason decided to blame the Duke students...which is stupid as sh*t. And I did read somewhere that the evidence from the physical exam indicates that this was indeed a rape, and not consentual. The idiocy of that defense suggests to me that all of these a**holes are guilty as sin, and are desperately trying to buy time. Someone needs to show some courage and step forward or they all need to go.
March 30, 200620 yr As far as Duke being a "clean program", appearantly this has helped make alot of voices of the school heard...protests going on saying how bad things are on campus, as far as the way the athletes behave. My guess is Duke is quite dirty(prob like any big program), they just really got caught.
March 30, 200620 yr As far as Duke being a "clean program", appearantly this has helped make alot of voices of the school heard...protests going on saying how bad things are on campus, as far as the way the athletes behave. My guess hope is Duke is quite dirty(prob like any big program), and they just really got get caught. More factual way to present your post.
March 30, 200620 yr As far as Duke being a "clean program", appearantly this has helped make alot of voices of the school heard...protests going on saying how bad things are on campus, as far as the way the athletes behave. My guess is Duke is quite dirty(prob like any big program), they just really got caught. Don't judge the whole program based on one team, please. That's lame. And yes, if guilty, then it's up to the non-guilty to say "f*** you" to the criminals on the team and step forward.
March 30, 200620 yr The program is dirty now. But it's a little unfair to say it was dirty before this happened. According to the article above these are the prior convictions for members of the lacrosse team: underage alcohol possession violating open container laws loud noise public urination That's it. It's not so much a rap sheet as it is a To Do List for any male between the ages of 16 and 21. I've done all of those. The last one may sound a little shady, but sometimes you really have to go and one tree is as good as any other. Maybe the AD should've been a little harsher with these guys and held them to higher standards than the rest of the student body. But none of those things really should have served as a warning for the bulls*** that's going on now.
March 30, 200620 yr As far as Duke being a "clean program", appearantly this has helped make alot of voices of the school heard...protests going on saying how bad things are on campus, as far as the way the athletes behave. My guess is Duke is quite dirty(prob like any big program), they just really got caught. You really going to gloat about this? Annnnyway, the vibe on campus is extremely strange right now. I think most of us are just kinda waiting for the test results to come back and going from there. I will say that from the very brief interactions I've had with some members of the lacrosse team and with what I've heard, the known confirmed facts in this case don't particularly surprise me, and I'd venture a guess that the majority of the campus probably shares that opinion. As for a third of the team being previously cited for various offenses, that's kind of a red herring. It's not like it's uncommon for a college kid anywhere to be cited for underage drinking. I don't know if I necessarily agree with your opinion on the nature of the protests, either: if that's the way that they're being portrayed nationally then it seems to be a twist on what's actually going on. The protests in question have really just focused on this particular case and two things in particular: 1) Trying to get members of the team to talk to the police 2) Misdirectedly going after the administration, which really can't do anything until more evidence is released. But it would be misconstruing the message to say that they are "saying how bad things are on campus, as far as the way the athletes behave." The negative stories have pretty much been limited to other incidents involving members of this one team.
March 30, 200620 yr Not gloating on anything. Just re-iterating what they were saying on ESPN, that Duke athletes are involved in alot of shady things and this incident, while tragic, has potentially done some good and paved the way for a "take back the night" campaign on campus. If this was the spark that lit the keg, then yes it does sound to me like athletes have been getting away with alot of stuff over on the Trinity College campus.
March 30, 200620 yr Not gloating on anything. Just re-iterating what they were saying on ESPN, that Duke athletes are involved in alot of shady things and this incident, while tragic, has potentially done some good and paved the way for a "take back the night" campaign on campus. If this was the spark that lit the keg, then yes it does sound to me like athletes have been getting away with alot of stuff over on the Trinity College campus. That event as are all the sexual assault awareness events this week were planned ahead of time, as ironically enough this is "Sexual Assault Prevention Week." However it's gotten more attention from people in Durham this year as a result of the incident. Also I thought it was bizarre just from my own perspective to be flipping through channels tonight and see my editor from the Chronicle (I'm a photographer there) on TV. And I read the ESPN article in question, I don't think it said anything to generalize a pattern of behavior among athletes or that they get away with everything. Dropping a charge of underage drinking is common practice for first offenders; if you take a class and do community service, the citation is wiped from your record (happened to a friend of mine last year). I'd also like to say that I've spoken with President Brodhead before and he's really a nice guy who's been put into a hell of a spot here. I wish that some of the people giving him a hard time would realize that those efforts are a little misdirected--he can't force anyone to do anything against the advice of their legal representation, nor would a separate investigation really do very much considering that the Durham police is all over this case and it's not like they're going to let it go away. Canceling the games indefinitely was obviously the right decision, and undoubtedly the school is going to wash its hands of the guilty party(ies) and let the legal system handle things from here.
March 30, 200620 yr I was wrong then, although I wasn't referring to an article. What I said is what Sportscenter(5 pm central time) made it seem like what was going on. I guess thats my bad for actually taking "journalism" on ESPN at face value. I apologize.
March 30, 200620 yr Yeah, I've been following this story since I read about it on DBR on Monday. Quite frankly, it's disgusting. Apparently, the team has decided as a group not to cooperate with the investigation. Now, this may or may not be due to their lawyer's advice...but it's still total BS. Some of these kids have to be innocent, and it's on them to step forward and tell the police what happened. The idea that one lawyer can represent the best interests of all 46 kids is ludicrous. The innocent kids need to get their own representation and stop this cover up bulls***. Until that happens, every one of these kids bears some responsibility for this rape, and if nothing changes soon, I would dismiss every last one of those a**holes from Duke. And as for the team captains claims that the DNA would clear them of wrongdoing? These kids are not only a**holes, but they're stupid as sh*t. If the police are collecting sperm samples then that means that there was sex of some kind going on. The only question is whether it was consentual or not. DNA can't prove whether or not a rape occurred, you morons...it can only show which males were involved. The only way the DNA testing can clear them of wrongdoing is if the DNA belongs to some other man. But that would mean the stripper was raped by some other guy and then for some reason decided to blame the Duke students...which is stupid as sh*t. And I did read somewhere that the evidence from the physical exam indicates that this was indeed a rape, and not consentual. The idiocy of that defense suggests to me that all of these a**holes are guilty as sin, and are desperately trying to buy time. Someone needs to show some courage and step forward or they all need to go. Youre right, it is a monumental conflict of interest on the lawyer's part. But it may be a situation where they are just waiting for the DA to file charges against specific persons(I think she said 3-4 guys raped her) and then they will get their own lawyer. The problem, as you point out, is that it makes the whole team look terrible when they don't even say what happend. It's pretty clear that someone had sex with her, consensual or not. So if you are one of the guys who did have sex with her, and you aren't making sure everyone knows that it was consensual, you're constructively denying it. Then when the DNA points the finger at you, people will ask why you didnt come out and say you had sex in the beginning. Of course the defense is going to be that you didn't want to destroy your future by saying you gangbanged a stripper. But this still makes you look bad because the cat is out of the bag. Seriously, the lawyer needs to tell the whole group that the "we didn't have sex" argument is about to fly out of the window and that those people who did have sex need to get their own lawyers. If Im one of the guys who did have sex with her, Im coming out now and saying we had sex, I was offensive to her, and she got mad. Look at Kobe. Im not saying that any of this is right, especially if they did rape her. But these guys are really stupid and clearly arrogant.
March 30, 200620 yr See, that's the thing, they're apparently not using the "we didn't have sex" argument as not saying anything at all. They're taking the good ol' Mafia "I dunno" approach. Which, to me is worse. Because it's the whole team doing it. Which means there's 3-4 rapist scumbags being protected by the rest of the team, who themselves are scumbags. What I wonder if what kind of person can WATCH a rape? I mean, who sits by and doesn't say something/do something? That's just disgusting and unforgiveable. I know in our high school these two guys didn't do anything while these two other guys raped this girl, and they got the book thrown at them as much as the rapists. And I don't know if I disagree with this. I hope they hold all these guys who were there and didn't do anything just as accountable. Because by staying silent they're almost condoning this crap and that's just as bad.
March 30, 200620 yr Well, I think whatever happened was said to have happened in a bathroom, presumably behind a closed door. So, it's possible that in a large, loud party where you're pretty damn drunk that you might not know that anything is going on in that bathroom. But somebody who wasn't directly involved has to know what happened. And it's that a**hole who needs to speak up.
March 30, 200620 yr Well, I think whatever happened was said to have happened in a bathroom, presumably behind a closed door. So, it's possible that in a large, loud party where you're pretty damn drunk that you might not know that anything is going on in that bathroom. But somebody who wasn't directly involved has to know what happened. And it's that a**hole who needs to speak up. yeah ive been at parties so big that i have no idea about things that went down that being said, someone else has to know what happened, and they need to speak up
March 30, 200620 yr This case really pisses me off, not because it is Duke, but the way it is being handled by a variety of different parties and its portrayal in the media. What ever happened to innocent until proven guilty? If this thing went to a trial I don't know how they would find a respectable jury in the state by the release of information and the damnation of the 46 players by the press. I've never seen so much belief put into the accusation of a potential rape victim then this girl. No one knows what actually happened but the ammount of assumption by the general public is pretty sick in itself considering zero criminal charges have been given out. I also don't understand how the potential victim has earned 100% credibility in the media. A woman from an escort service has been made out to be a saint and assumed to be absolutely truthful before anything has come out. I wouldn't be shocked at all to see this, like the Kobe case and alot of other acussed rape cases disolve as things become more and more clear during the investigation. I thought the 911 calls were a joke and the timing of them is really off to me. The DA in this case, Mike Nifong, is one of the most unprofessional people I have ever seen. He has been whoring himself to anyone that asks for an interview and coming out and saying that someone on the team is guilty, unbelieveable. I've never seen a more unprofessional DA in my life outside of that Jacko fiasco, he is almost undermining his investigation by himself. I think the Duke coach handled this poorly. As soon as he knew about the lewd conduct and the racial slur, suspensions and cancellations of Lacrosse activities should have commenced immediately. That would have definitely lessened the backlash for President Brodhead and the school considerably. The Players are retarded as hell as well to be in this type of situation at all, let alone during the season. People need to stop automatically throwing the players under the bus as well saying they haven't come forward, through their legal counsel they have vehemently denied that anything happened, and yet they are ripped on for that even though it could be true. The way these players and the University has been crucified is a joke. Also, this should probably be moved to the Bull Pen considering besides the accused playing a sport, it has nothing to do with sports.
March 30, 200620 yr Passion, I tried your viewpoint out for a little while and it just didn't suit me. While they are innocent by law until proven guilty, my brain is not a court of law, and in my view they are all guilty. If for nothing else, than for stonewalling the police in their investigation. But almost certainly for much more than that. For one thing, the police wouldn't be collecting sperm samples if they had nothing to test it against. Someone in that house had sex with that woman unless this is part of an elaborate hoax and she is some kind of criminal mastermind. There aren't too many masterminds at NCCU, though, so I highly doubt that's the case. The fact that the students have denied that sex of any kind occurred in that house suggests to me that they are guilty, that this transparent fabrication is their best defense. And I haven't seen any suggestions that this woman is a saint, nor I have I seen any reason to defame her character. We know nothing about her, but we do know there is some physical evidence to support her story. I'm sorry, man, but while I value and appreciate your opinion on this matter, I am not swayed. Something very bad happended in that house.
March 30, 200620 yr "J.J. Redick did it, they're just covering up for him." - Entire Maryland fanbase
March 30, 200620 yr Passion, I tried your viewpoint out for a little while and it just didn't suit me. While they are innocent by law until proven guilty, my brain is not a court of law, and in my view they are all guilty. If for nothing else, than for stonewalling the police in their investigation. But almost certainly for much more than that. For one thing, the police wouldn't be collecting sperm samples if they had nothing to test it against. Someone in that house had sex with that woman unless this is part of an elaborate hoax and she is some kind of criminal mastermind. There aren't too many masterminds at NCCU, though, so I highly doubt that's the case. The fact that the students have denied that sex of any kind occurred in that house suggests to me that they are guilty, that this transparent fabrication is their best defense. And I haven't seen any suggestions that this woman is a saint, nor I have I seen any reason to defame her character. We know nothing about her, but we do know there is some physical evidence to support her story. I'm sorry, man, but while I value and appreciate your opinion on this matter, I am not swayed. Something very bad happended in that house. Stonewalling their investigation, you mean the one with no criminal charges? Blame the defense team, I wouldn't say anything either before criminal charges were brought against me or others. There is no way she could have had sex with someone else in that time frame? How soon have we forgotten the Kobe situation? I do believe that she was called racial slurs and how better of a way to get back at a man then accusing him/them of rape? I'm just not going to put 100% faith into the accusations of a woman who was there to 'preform' sexually for a group of drunken men like the media has done.
March 30, 200620 yr Author Passion, I tried your viewpoint out for a little while and it just didn't suit me. While they are innocent by law until proven guilty, my brain is not a court of law, and in my view they are all guilty. If for nothing else, than for stonewalling the police in their investigation. But almost certainly for much more than that. For one thing, the police wouldn't be collecting sperm samples if they had nothing to test it against. Someone in that house had sex with that woman unless this is part of an elaborate hoax and she is some kind of criminal mastermind. There aren't too many masterminds at NCCU, though, so I highly doubt that's the case. The fact that the students have denied that sex of any kind occurred in that house suggests to me that they are guilty, that this transparent fabrication is their best defense. And I haven't seen any suggestions that this woman is a saint, nor I have I seen any reason to defame her character. We know nothing about her, but we do know there is some physical evidence to support her story. I'm sorry, man, but while I value and appreciate your opinion on this matter, I am not swayed. Something very bad happended in that house. Stonewalling their investigation, you mean the one with no criminal charges? Blame the defense team, I wouldn't say anything either before criminal charges were brought against me or others. There is no way she could have had sex with someone else in that time frame? How soon have we forgotten the Kobe situation? I do believe that she was called racial slurs and how better of a way to get back at a man then accusing him/them of rape? I'm just not going to put 100% faith into the accusations of a woman who was there to 'preform' sexually for a group of drunken men like the media has done. I think you are misunderstanding the stonewalling part of the investigation. While I agree they should not be volunteering information, they are going out of their way to play dumb and pretend they know nothing. Usually, if there is nothing to hide, then this would not be the tactic used. This leads to even more suspicion from the outside and as the saying goes, where there's smoke, there usually is fire. To me, it seems the reason charges have not been filed yet is because the DA is gathering evidence and making their case. In this country, you have to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt and it would be utterly stupid to bring charges until all of the evidence is sorted out. However, I would be shocked if at this point nobody is charged. Also, the police have said the rape kit showed that her story does indeed have some merit and a rape more than likely took place. I think it is fairly safe to assume that there is enough evidence to give her the benefit of the doubt in this case, especially since after meeting with the police and others, Duke has canceled their own season. Don't you think without any sufficient evidence to collaborate her story to an alarming degree, the university would not have made such a harsh ruling? Lastly, while nobody has said you should put in 100% faith of a woman's story who was there to strip, you also should not just write her claim off either because of her profession. While stripping is not the "classiest" of jobs, it would just be plain ignorant to assume she is lying because of what she does.
March 30, 200620 yr I got a theory... Keep in mind, THIS IS JUST A THEORY... Duke was supposed to play the Ohio State University in LaCrosse this weekend. Word has it, the Duke LaCrossers didn't want to have Passion bein' all, you know, conflicted. So, they came up with this RUSE (for lack of a better word). Duke is ducking Ohio State. Just a theory. :shifty
March 30, 200620 yr The Durham district attorney was interviewed by ESPN and I don't recall the exact words but it was something along the lines of "If they're so innocent, then why have they hired attorneys?" It's intolerable for a DA to say something like that, since when do only guilty people hire attorneys? When you're accused of something as serious as this, then it is only reasonable to hire an attorney to defend yourself and make sure your rights aren't being violated regardless of whether you're innocent or not. Mabye it never occured to him that the case is being handled like a witch hunt, not a criminal investigation.
March 30, 200620 yr Stonewalling their investigation, you mean the one with no criminal charges? Blame the defense team, I wouldn't say anything either before criminal charges were brought against me or others. There is no way she could have had sex with someone else in that time frame? How soon have we forgotten the Kobe situation? I do believe that she was called racial slurs and how better of a way to get back at a man then accusing him/them of rape? I'm just not going to put 100% faith into the accusations of a woman who was there to 'preform' sexually for a group of drunken men like the media has done. The DNA results won't be available until next week...I assume that means to the police as well as the public. This is probably why there haven't been any charges yet. I'm sure they had the victim go through a photo lineup, and if the DNA results match her selections, you can be sure there will be charges coming. They're not going to jump the gun before they have a chance to look at the most damning physical evidence available, though. You can come up with a million scenarios of how this was a revenge plot or something like that, and I'm saying while all those are possible, to me they are EXTREMELY unlikely...and I do mean extremely in the most extreme sense of the word. It would be an interesting to see a timeline of the various events that took place. I'm sure the police are working on that. The rape was reported at 1:22 AM. An hour before that there was another 911 call where two black women walking by were called the n-word. If the strippers were still in the house at that point, the chances of her having sex with someone else in that window are extremely slim. She would've had to plot all of this, have sex, drive to Kroger, which is about 10 minutes away, and be discovered by the security guard in less than an hour. If the strippers had already left by the time of the 1st 911 call, then anything is still possible...but, still, how unlikely? And if this was a revenge plot...to have the frame of mind to drive to Kroger instead of the police station? Because the obvious thing to do would be to march straight into the police station. So, how smart would you have to be to let some security guard come across you in an apparently traumatized state, and have him make the 911 call on your behalf? I don't think I'd have thought of that. And if this girl were indeed that smart, why would she be a stripper? See what I mean? The simplest explanation by far is that she's telling the truth. To get to a point where she's lying, you have to make several assumptions that really don't seem to fit. Of course, anything's possible. But I'm not buying any of it. And as far as the Kobe case goes...I never had an opinion on that one either way. That was pure he said/she said. Kobe immediately confessed to having sex, and there wasn't enough physical evidence to determine who was telling the truth. Here, there seems to be a lot more physical evidence, and you have a complete denial that there was any sex at all. These kids have backed themselves into a corner if what she's saying has any truth at all. Finally, I'm glad your able to be so open-minded and patient about all this. I can readily admit that your approach to the situation is more right than mine. But like I said, I tried it out for a little bit, and it just didn't work for me. If I turn out to be wrong about this, it will be one massive egg on my face...but I feel very strongly that won't be the case. I think I may far more disgusted about this for two reasons. One, I went to Duke, I love the institution, and I hate that this is the kind of sh*t that people will think about when they think about Duke...at least for the time being. It's just a massive blemish on the Duke name. And, two, I can remember sitting at home and rooting for these a**holes last year as I watched the NCAA Lacrosse Championship on ESPN. Now they just kind of make me sick. The Durham district attorney was interviewed by ESPN and I don't recall the exact words but it was something along the lines of "If they're so innocent, then why have they hired attorneys?" It's intolerable for a DA to say something like that, since when do only guilty people hire attorneys? When you're accused of something as serious as this, then it is only reasonable to hire an attorney to defend yourself and make sure your rights aren't being violated regardless of whether you're innocent or not. Mabye it never occured to him that the case is being handled like a witch hunt, not a criminal investigation. This is something I DO agree with you and Passion about. This DA needs to shut up; it's disgusting how he's trying to play the media, and some of it may backfire come trial time.
March 31, 200620 yr Well, charges usually don't get filed right away for higher up felony charges and above. DAs don't like to press charges for the most part unless they believe they can get a conviction. Until the DNA results are in, that's probably not the case since rape is such a difficult crime to prove. I don't know much about the case at this point so I'll reserve judgment until I read a little bit more.
March 31, 200620 yr Also, a point on that DA I forgot to talk about is how he is up for re-election this year. Could anything better have fallen into his lap then this? He is going on the media shows and convicting the entire team and University. I mean it's like something out of a movie. What better way to pimp your campaign then going hardline afer these guys. Going after members of a the sports team for the jewel of the city he represents with a case that is just perfect for the city of Durham which is predominantly black. A white team accused of attacking a black woman. It fell into his lap and his is milking it for all it's worth and is putting himself out there in fishnet stockings and a mini skirt for all the media to get a ride on. Pretty sick.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.