May 13, 200620 yr Losman: 28-32 :plain Holcomb's winning that starting job, that'll move us up a few spots. :thumbup Ugh, I hope not - it would only move us up to the 24-28 range. If Holcomb wins the job, that means 5-11 to 9-7 next year and no shot to grab a decent QB in the draft (since if he loses the job Losman will ultimately be unfairly, IMO, judged as a failure). The best result for the future of the Bills franchise is that Losman or Nall wins the job and establishes themselves as a good QB of the future while putting up enough numbers to give the Bills at least a one game better record than last year. Even if Losman/Nall suck, the Bills get a top 5 pick and the opportunity to draft an impact QB that hopefully is not product of the system Brady Quinn. And Trent Green is a product of the system. Any above average QB (which Green admittedly is) could put up similar if not better numbers in his system. He's a borderline top-10 QB at best, though I'm not gonna chastize anyone for ranking him #10. While as much as I hate the ESPN hype that builds him up to one of the top 5 QB's in the league, Mike Vick should probably be at right at the bottom of the top 10 QB considerations. The dude wins with gawd-awful WR's (and admittedly gawd-awful intermediate range accuracy), so that needs to be considered when judging him. Personally I'd rather have him for the next five years than QB's like Delhomme, Bulger, or Culpepper, though maybe thats a different judgement system. Either way, I'm willing to argue the point.
May 13, 200620 yr As far as actual performance, I'd put Eli right outside the top 10. In terms of potential production in the offense he plays in, he's in the top 5.
May 14, 200620 yr Culpepper is 5th. As far as Mike Vick is concerned, he shouldn't be a quarterback in the NFL. He's got a canon, but his accuracy is just terrible, and he doesn't come close to making good decisions.
May 14, 200620 yr As far as passing ability Vick is in the bottom 5 of the league. Yes, but as a QB he is probably middle of the pack.
May 14, 200620 yr I'd disagree FeLo, since passing is the biggest part of a QB's game. So, if he is a deficient passer he is a deficient QB.
May 14, 200620 yr Is there any question? Culpepper is the #1 because he is now a Miami Dolphin and will win many Superbowls with us. :thumbup
May 15, 200620 yr Is there any question? Culpepper is the #1 because he is now a Miami Dolphin and will win many Superbowls with us. :thumbup lol, your a bigger homer then.... well... the user homer. :plain and laughable :lol
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.