May 12, 200620 yr I saw this topic before elsewhere and it normally gives a good debate on whom ranks where for QB's in the NFL. Where would your teams starting QB rank if they are fully healthy compared to the rest of the NFL.
May 12, 200620 yr And where would you rate him if he was still on the Vikings, or any team besides Miami?
May 12, 200620 yr I'd put Leftwich somewhere in the middle of the pack. Carson Palmer who I also like, probably ranks about 5th in my book.
May 12, 200620 yr Carson, Manning, Brady, Brees, Hasselback, Delhomme, Leftwhich, Roethlisberger, Bulger and Trent Green to round out my top ten.
May 12, 200620 yr Your nuts Buckeye if you don't put McNabb in your top 10.....Palmer is more like bottom of that top 10 if that's the order.....
May 12, 200620 yr Your nuts Buckeye if you don't put McNabb in your top 10.....Palmer is more like bottom of that top 10 if that's the order..... So, because I don't consider McNabb a top ten QB then you're going to put Palmer in the bottom ten? Good. What do I care? It's my opinion. You don't like it, make your own list. Doesn't make what you said anymore relevant to the issue.
May 12, 200620 yr Your nuts Buckeye if you don't put McNabb in your top 10.....Palmer is more like bottom of that top 10 if that's the order..... So, because I don't consider McNabb a top ten QB then you're going to put Palmer in the bottom ten? Good. What do I care? It's my opinion. You don't like it, make your own list. Doesn't make what you said anymore relevant to the issue. umm.....I was just pointing out that Carson Palmer isn't the 3rd best QB and your top 10 lacked McNabb....that is all.
May 12, 200620 yr Carson had four more touchdowns than Peyton and only two more interceptions. I'm moving him up to first now. McNabb falls somewhere near the bottom, mainly due to the fact that he didn't play the complete season and I don't think he's as good as the other guy's on the list. Maybe two years ago, but he didn't do enough last year to justify being put on this list. Best part is the only reason you're bitching is because I didn't mention "your" guy.
May 12, 200620 yr the question above was if your QB was fully healthy, where does he fit?? Yup, fully healthy McNabb would still be 12th on my list right below Roethlisberger. *shrugs*
May 13, 200620 yr Carson, Manning, Brady, Brees, Hasselback, Delhomme, Leftwhich, Roethlisberger, Bulger and Trent Green to round out my top ten. The only two I have a problem with are Bulger and Trent Green. Why if I may ask, are those two on there?
May 13, 200620 yr Carson, Manning, Brady, Brees, Hasselback, Delhomme, Leftwhich, Roethlisberger, Bulger and Trent Green to round out my top ten. The only two I have a problem with are Bulger and Trent Green. Why if I may ask, are those two on there? Trent Green should be. Bulger, meh.
May 13, 200620 yr Carson, Manning, Brady, Brees, Hasselback, Delhomme, Leftwhich, Roethlisberger, Bulger and Trent Green to round out my top ten. The only two I have a problem with are Bulger and Trent Green. Why if I may ask, are those two on there? Trent Green has an awesome arm. Period. Bulger, you might be right. He didn't have his best season last season, but if I need someone throw the damn ball I'm still taking him.
May 13, 200620 yr Top 10: Peyton Manning Tom Brady Carson Palmer Ben Roethlisburger Donovan McNabb Matt Hasselback Daunte Culpepper Jake Delhomme Drew Brees Eli Manning
May 13, 200620 yr Losman: 28-32 :plain Holcomb's winning that starting job, that'll move us up a few spots. :thumbup
May 13, 200620 yr I guess I'll make my top 10. Brady Manning Brees McNabb Roethlisberger Delhomme Palmer Favre Green Culpepper
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.