December 1, 200619 yr Call me naive but I keep reading Beinfest saying good things about Jacobs and talking about 2007 Well would you expect something else out of a GM's mouth?
December 1, 200619 yr Call me naive but I keep reading Beinfest saying good things about Jacobs and talking about 2007 Well would you expect something else out of a GM's mouth? First of all it's just my opinion, but my feeling is until Beinfest says something contrary to what he did as recently as (I think) this week, I'm taking the guy at his word. Things change everyday, I know that but as much as I'm open to anything that makes the team better, I value the cummulative value of both players more than I do their loss to simply get back Rocco. The operative word above is "I". That's how "I" see it. If someone else sees it differently, be my guest (and that was not pointed at you Ramp, but generally).
December 1, 200619 yr Call me naive but I keep reading Beinfest saying good things about Jacobs and talking about 2007 Well would you expect something else out of a GM's mouth? First of all it's just my opinion, but my feeling is until Beinfest says something contrary to what he did as recently as (I think) this week, I'm taking the guy at his word. Things change everyday, I know that but as much as I'm open to anything that makes the team better, I value the cummulative value of both players more than I do their loss to simply get back Rocco. The operative word above is "I". That's how "I" see it. If someone else sees it differently, be my guest (and that was not pointed at you Ramp, but generally). Oh, I know. And you opinion is a valid one. I just don't expect to see Beinfest or any GM make a derogatory comment towards a guy on his team that he may or may not be looking to trade
December 1, 200619 yr Ramp, let me rant for a second. I think the virtual media blackout/ignoring the Marlins has left all of us kind of sitting on pins and needles and we all are sort of suffering from cabin fever (Jonesing for baseball), we're all (including me) just a little too sensitive for our own goods. Every day I read the Kansas City Star or this e-paper or that and guess what there's coverage of the hometown team but here we're left to fight over NYC rumprs about Dontrelle and who should be packaged for Baldelli because there is almost nothing else to discuss. Now we are discussing what Admin Beinfest's motives are in a one line comment about Jacobs. Now granted you're closer to things than most but it has come down to that, we analyze and reanalyze even the smallest comment as if world peace was at stake. It sucks. Rants over. lololol
December 1, 200619 yr I'm not sure what exactly you are ranting over. No GM is going to say something bad about a player that he may or may not be trading.
December 1, 200619 yr I fully understand what Marlins2003 is trying to say. What motive does Tampa Bay have at making a trade like this? Getting rid of Rocco to get a promising 1st baseman and promising starting pitcher would mean what to them? The only way they are going to be competitive is if they were bought out and allowed to spend $200 million on building a team. In the meantime, what keeps fans in the stands up there... Players that the fans have grown attached to.. This is why I don't really see them getting rid of Rocco or Carl Crawford, for that matter... Their front office may see it completely different than I do, but they basically play every year to sell tickets, cause they sure as hell know that they aren't getting anywhere near the postseason. As for this proposed trade, I have concerns with Baldelli's health anyways. If we're getting rid of players of Jacobs and Nolasco's caliber, we better be damn sure we're getting someone who can play an entire season and be an impact player in return. Just my opinion...
December 1, 200619 yr If they are ever going to be successful they need pitching, pitching is what can carry a team. As for talking good about a player, another possibility for that is talking up the value of the player that you are rumored to be shopping as well.
December 1, 200619 yr :banghead (Don't tell anyone but I was "ranting" about something only barely related to Ramp's remark, rather the general state of the board. We're like animals in the wild eating their young because there's no other food for thought)
December 1, 200619 yr Does anyone think Nolasco, Jacobs and Petit would get it done for Baldelli? If it happens, I suspect this is very similar to what would get it done imo thats overpaying for baldelli....the three of them will all be descent mlb players and all have potential to get a little bit better....all that for baldelli who aint no andruw jones meh
December 2, 200619 yr The Devil Rays have an extremely smart front office. I expect good things from them in the future if they keep running their team the way that they have for the last couple of years.
December 2, 200619 yr Does anyone think Nolasco, Jacobs and Petit would get it done for Baldelli? If it happens, I suspect this is very similar to what would get it done imo thats overpaying for baldelli....the three of them will all be descent mlb players and all have potential to get a little bit better....all that for baldelli who aint no andruw jones meh I also agree here your going to give up a young decent 1st basement an ok starting pitcher who's cheap and Petit a young pitcher who like the other two players have a chance of being good for an ok Cf who has had alot of ingury problems
December 2, 200619 yr I think the Marlins should go after Sammy Sosa to play center. The Marlins are known to rejuvenate players. and also, the good thing about getting him is that he's a free agent, so we wouldn't have to give up any of our pitching.
December 3, 200619 yr I wonder if Nolasco and Mitre could get us BJ Upton I would assume the answer by the Devil Rays would be HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
December 3, 200619 yr I wonder if Nolasco and Mitre could get us BJ Upton I would assume the answer by the Devil Rays would be HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA Pettit and Nolasco?
December 3, 200619 yr The idea of trading two major league pitchers, one of whom, a rookie, won more games* than any Devil Rays pitcher in the last three years save one who equaled his mark back in 2005, for a troubled BJ Upton whose value has fallen from the top of the Fab 50 to nowhere to be seen in three short years, is indeed laughable. The time to trade with DRays is mid-spring training and not before. Let them waddle around in their own excrement for a few months with nothing but surplus players to show for all their previous trades and then take the pick of the litter, maybe Young, maybe Dukes, maybe Baldelli, maybe Upton. Right now there is no market for Upton. I can't find one story in the last month linking Upton to any particular team having an interest, only stories that reiterate what everybody already knows, not only is Upton about to lose his infield spot to either Guzman or someone else, there is no room for him in an already crowded outfield where he would be playing with zero major or minor league experience. You (the collective "you") can be infatuated with the BJ Upton's of the world and you can read all the dribble coming out of Tampa Bay (wait until you read tomorrow's papers) about how he's the next superstar on the horizon but the truth is he failed miserably at third base in 2006, offensively and defensively, there is nowhere for him to go in the Rays organization because there's no position open to him and because he's being squeezed from above by better already major league capable players (Baldelli, Crawford) and from beneath by Young, Dukes and a plethora of new wannabes major leaguers working their way through the DRay's minor league system. Unfair? Perhaps. Does he deserve better? We all do, it's a rough world out there. But the fact is he isn't worth one Ricky Nolasco, nevermind Nolasco plus another pitcher, not while that franchise is in the situation it is. *the last time a DRays pitcher won more than 11 games in a season was Victor Zambrano in 2003. He won 12. --------- On a completely different subject, and unrelated to my comments above other than it is about last season's centerfielder, Alfredo Amezaga, he's hitting .357 in the Mexican Pacific League playing 3b-SS-2B.
December 3, 200619 yr --------- On a completely different subject, and unrelated to my comments above other than it is about last season's centerfielder, Alfredo Amezaga, he's hitting .357 in the Mexican Pacific League playing 3b-SS-2B. I might be one of the few supporters of Alfredo but I think hes good enough to be a starter and very good bat of the bench all he needs to do is start hitting Left handed pitchers.
December 3, 200619 yr what about marlon byrd, todd hollandsworth, jerry hairston, willie harris, jay payton, maybe a home town discount from shannon stewart (like real home town).
December 3, 200619 yr I still think the Marlins will not sign a current starting major leaguer to play center field (or even a part-time player like "eeeeeek" Todd Hollandsworth) but rather look for a low service time, meaning with some part-time major league experience, a fourth or fifth outfielder blocked on his current team, and older meaning 25+ such as Willits, Costa or Maier (and there are several others out there, I don't pretend to know who will be Beinfest's ultimate choice and I'm ignoring Tampa Bay for the moment) who can be acquired for one or more of the Marlins top ten pitching prospects and perhaps a Mitre or Messenger (someone to contribute this season and someone who can contribute in the future).
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.