November 30, 200619 yr do you think that the devil rays would be intrested in maybe we give them ricky nolasco mike jacobs and reggie abercrombie for rocco baldelli or carl crawfords? i think this would make a good trade for both teams because we need a centerfielder and rocco baldelli is pretty good and is pretty young and also isnt that expensive he seems like he would be a wonderfull fit with us. and the devil rays need a power first baseman capable of 40 homeruns and .300 batting and jacobs could become that. we can move willingham to catcher where he is better and then put olivo in first base where he played last year pretty good and cody ross can go in left field where he can show us what hes made of. the devil rays can have nolasco as there number 1 or 2 starter and use abercrombie in centerfield where they had baldelli before he got trade to the fish. everyones problems are solved and all we will need is a closer when this deal gets done and we can get that from anywahere because we always find one and if we dont we have randy messenger who throws hard he just needs some more experience. so i feel pretty good about the new season. what do you guys think? if we dont get centerfield from deveil rays do you think we can get willy taveras or maybe go after joey gathright again? would the astros trade us willy taveras for one of our young starters straight up or would it take more? i wouldnt want to give them dontrelle willis i think we can get more than that for dontrelle willis maybe even a catcher and a centerfield. input from you guys? my name is james. :mischief
November 30, 200619 yr Reggie is worthless Hammer cant catch(I wish) Olivo at 1st(lolol) Willy Taveras is bleh next.
November 30, 200619 yr Reggie is worthless Hammer cant catch(I wish) Olivo at 1st(lolol) Willy Taveras is bleh next. Well said! :thumbup
November 30, 200619 yr The only time Mike Jacobs is close to 40 HR is when we intentionally walk Pujols or Howard
November 30, 200619 yr first welcome to the boards dude 2nd alot of folks have talked about baldelli or crawford before but they will not come cheaply.
November 30, 200619 yr How about this deal? The Marlins trade Ricky Nolasco, Sergio Mitre, and Reggie Abercrombie for Baldelli. I believe the Rays have Wigginton at first who posted better numbers than Jacobs. Even if we were to trade Jacobs, who would replace him at first. Definitely not Willingham or Olivo. We would need to sign a free agent, which we don't have much money for. We would only be able to afford a Daryle Ward or Ryan Klesko-like free agent. The only way I trade Jacobs is for a possible closer and/or top young catcher (for example Gerald Laird). I would love to see the Marlins get Baldelli since he would be a long-term, inexpensive solution to our CF problem.
November 30, 200619 yr REGGIE ABERCROMBIE IS WORTHLESS. and since when is Gerald Laird young?... or top? and if you want Rocco, you need to give up some talent :banghead
November 30, 200619 yr Welcome to the boards. I would suggest lurking around a while before you start posting regularly, just so you are up on the discussions going on before you do post. Baldelli & Crawford have been discussed ad nauseum here. I did say I would stay away from this discussion, but since you're new, I'll give you my short version: Both will probably be prohibitively expensive considering this is TB we are talking about. They will want a lot. Even suggesting Nolasco + Jacobs for one of them straight up is "optimistic" I suppose. Beyond that though, I have my doubts if either would be worth that price. Crawford isn't really a CF, and he rarely plays the position. If all we want is to force a corner OF into CF we could just put Hermida there and platoon Cody & Borchard in RF. Baldelli would be great if he stayed healthy. However for him that's a bigger if than most. He played in under 100 games last season for TB and has an injury history. Not saying I wouldn't want him if nothing else was a concern, but saying that for what Tampa would ask, I would want a player as good as Baldelli in whom I felt relatively secure would be playing over 130. Just my opinion, not going to argue anyone on it.
November 30, 200619 yr i think the fact that no one mentioned messenger as closer is suprising consider he may not be on the team
November 30, 200619 yr do you think that the devil rays would be intrested in maybe we give them ricky nolasco mike jacobs and reggie abercrombie for rocco baldelli or carl crawfords? i think this would make a good trade for both teams because we need a centerfielder and rocco baldelli is pretty good and is pretty young and also isnt that expensive he seems like he would be a wonderfull fit with us. and the devil rays need a power first baseman capable of 40 homeruns and .300 batting and jacobs could become that. we can move willingham to catcher where he is better and then put olivo in first base where he played last year pretty good and cody ross can go in left field where he can show us what hes made of. the devil rays can have nolasco as there number 1 or 2 starter and use abercrombie in centerfield where they had baldelli before he got trade to the fish. everyones problems are solved and all we will need is a closer when this deal gets done and we can get that from anywahere because we always find one and if we dont we have randy messenger who throws hard he just needs some more experience. so i feel pretty good about the new season. what do you guys think? if we dont get centerfield from deveil rays do you think we can get willy taveras or maybe go after joey gathright again? would the astros trade us willy taveras for one of our young starters straight up or would it take more? i wouldnt want to give them dontrelle willis i think we can get more than that for dontrelle willis maybe even a catcher and a centerfield. input from you guys? my name is james. :mischief sorry, don't think it would happen. Beinfest hasn't given up on Jacobs and this trade would cost us much more. Makes no sense for Tampa Justin Gatlin for centerfield. Now I would love to see that...with the roids he has done he could steal 190 bases and hit 75 homers
December 1, 200619 yr Welcome to the boards. I don't get involved in the trade ideas presented on these boards, until Beinfest becomes a member. Him and his staff are the only trade thoughts that count. For you, I would recommend less time spent on hypothetical trade thoughts and some more time on some sites devoted to grammar. Maybe one day you'll be a GM and you can have a capital idea, but it's never going to happen if you write like a 10 year old. My apologies if you're under 10, and my sympathy if you're over 14.
December 1, 200619 yr Welcome to the boards. I don't get involved in the trade ideas presented on these boards, until Beinfest becomes a member. Him and his staff are the only trade thoughts that count. For you, I would recommend less time spent on hypothetical trade thoughts and some more time on some sites devoted to grammar. Maybe one day you'll be a GM and you can have a capital idea, but it's never going to happen if you write like a 10 year old. My apologies if you're under 10, and my sympathy if you're over 14. Ouch, Pierre! give the guy a break!
December 1, 200619 yr Welcome to the boards. I don't get involved in the trade ideas presented on these boards, until Beinfest becomes a member. Him and his staff are the only trade thoughts that count. For you, I would recommend less time spent on hypothetical trade thoughts and some more time on some sites devoted to grammar. Maybe one day you'll be a GM and you can have a capital idea, but it's never going to happen if you write like a 10 year old. My apologies if you're under 10, and my sympathy if you're over 14. What a way to welcome someone.
December 1, 200619 yr Welcome to the boards. I don't get involved in the trade ideas presented on these boards, until Beinfest becomes a member. Him and his staff are the only trade thoughts that count. For you, I would recommend less time spent on hypothetical trade thoughts and some more time on some sites devoted to grammar. Maybe one day you'll be a GM and you can have a capital idea, but it's never going to happen if you write like a 10 year old. My apologies if you're under 10, and my sympathy if you're over 14. What a way to welcome someone. WOW WEEE LOL, what a warm welcome, LMAO!
December 1, 200619 yr The rays have a ton of position projects, and any one of them could move or move somebody else to first base. I don't think Jacobs has the value that everybody thinks he might have, at least for a team like the D-Rays.
December 1, 200619 yr Does anyone think Nolasco, Jacobs and Petit would get it done for Baldelli? Not a chance! Give it up Guys... Baldelli will not be a Marlin this season!
December 1, 200619 yr Does anyone think Nolasco, Jacobs and Petit would get it done for Baldelli? If it happens, I suspect this is very similar to what would get it done
December 1, 200619 yr Does anyone think Nolasco, Jacobs and Petit would get it done for Baldelli? If it happens, I suspect this is very similar to what would get it done If that is the case I hope the FO jumps all over that. Personally I think Nolasco is better than many give him credit for but if we get a HEALTHY Baldelli for that package I think its a good move.
December 1, 200619 yr Call me naive but I keep reading Beinfest saying good things about Jacobs and talking about 2007, and I admit to be someone who thinks Nolasco has the chance to be a very successful pitcher at the ML level, so as much as I'd like to have Baldelli, and have for a long time, I don't think a 3-1 or a trade somwhere around this cast of players works to the Marlins advantage unless a legitimate corner outfielder or a first base capable player comes back as well, and even then I'm not so hot on it. Admin pulls the string on the deal and I'm in, but I'm not going to rally around this trade as a must-do for 2007. Right now, with the team we have, warts and all, even with Amezaga in centerfield and huge question mark for a bullpen, we are much more competitive vis a vis our divisional/wildcard chances than Tampa Bay is in the AL East. In fact, with the Yankees and Red Sox (and let's not forget the Jays) doing their things, the addition of Nolasco and Jacobs will do nothing to improve the D'Rays chances in 2007 and beyond. They're screwed. Cy Young could come down and throw 300 perfect innings and still wouldn't get the Rays any closer to third place than they are now. Frankly I think it's an awful situation, speaks volumes about the need for a real, hard, spending cap (yeah, yeah and a floor too) because let's face it's hopeless being in the AL East if you're anybody but Boston, New York and on a good day, Toronto. That's what I think gets in the way of intelligent trading with TB.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.