Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

FanFest 2007

Featured Replies

I'm hardly wrong. Given the Pujols 7 million dollar precedent and average salay increases, it will be much harder (given the nature of arbitration) to prove that a similar player is worth less than an already established pay-scale for an equally accomplished player.

I'm hardly wrong. Given the Pujols 7 million dollar precedent and average salay increases, it will be much harder (given the nature of arbitration) to prove that a similar player is worth less than an already established pay-scale for an equally accomplished player.

 

They're not equal. Pujols outperformed Miggy after 3 seasons.

I'm hardly wrong. Given the Pujols 7 million dollar precedent and average salay increases, it will be much harder (given the nature of arbitration) to prove that a similar player is worth less than an already established pay-scale for an equally accomplished player.

 

They're not equal. Pujols outperformed Miggy after 3 seasons.

I agree with TSwift. Doing a quick search from '04 to '06 the average salary jumped 16% from $2,327k to $2,699k. The '07 salaries are obviously going through the roof so if you assume a 12% increase in '07 (conservative estimate) then average salaries from '04 to '07 have jumped 30% meaning that Pujols' $7 million salary in '04 would be equivalent to $9.1 million in '07. Although Pujols' first 3 years were obviously better thamn Miguel's first 3 years I think Miguel should win the case and get his $7.4 million.

Arbitration position statements are not solely based on salary comparisons, but on statistical analysis in relation to salary. Furthermore, the statistical comparison is not made with only one player, but with several players of with similar statistical, financial, and experience factors.

 

Without having read Cabrera's report, I'm sure he's being compared to players of similar experience and timeframe (and not necessarily Pujols). There may be references to last year's arbitration awards as well.

 

I've seen how these things are drafted, and TSwift25, you're off base when trying to determine how the arbitrator will rule.

Arbitration position statements are not solely based on salary comparisons, but on statistical analysis in relation to salary. Furthermore, the statistical comparison is not made with only one player, but with several players of with similar statistical, financial, and experience factors.

 

Without having read Cabrera's report, I'm sure he's being compared to players of similar experience and timeframe (and not necessarily Pujols). There may be references to last year's arbitration awards as well.

 

I've seen how these things are drafted, and TSwift25, you're off base when trying to determine how the arbitrator will rule.

 

Fine, then take the ban-bet I proposed.

 

If I'm wrong, I'll go away for a month. Same to you, and 2003 if he's up for it.

Fine, then take the ban-bet I proposed.

 

If I'm wrong, I'll go away for a month. Same to you, and 2003 if he's up for it.

 

I'm sorry, but I graduated from kindergarten a long ass time ago. This isn't a case of "I'll be your friend, I won't be your friend."

 

I don't care one way or another and I've never staked my reputation on anything. I have simply presented to you that an arbitration position statement is based on statistics and comparative studies of other similarly situated players. I've never said that Cabrera will be the 6.7 or the 7.4, all I've said is that both sides come to those numbers with a heavy emphasis on statistical output of the player and a comparison of similarly situated players on the basis of experience. And I've said all this based on my review of ACTUAL position statements that are not public record, but because I used to work for the firm that handled all of the arbitration cases for the Marlins and Expos and I saw all the reports that were on our system.

I realized that this was a FanFest forum that invited us all to share our experiences and pictures.

 

I actually ended up going and it was not that crowded as in years past. My kids and I even survived the 11:00 autograph line getting tickets to all three lines and wrapping that up in no time.

 

Here are the pics of "Little SoFlaFish" and "Even Littler SoFlaFish" enjoying themselves:

 

 

Little SoFlaFish and Mitre

 

 

Little SoFlaFish & Even Littler SoFlaFish with the 1997 World Series Trophy

 

 

The "little ones" at Dontrelle Willis's locker

 

 

Even Littler SoFlaFish swinging for the RF wall (bear in mind, he's 3yrs old)

 

 

Little SoFlaFish & Even Littler SoFlaFish practicing their 7th inning rally from inside the dugout!

 

 

Dontrelle Willis announcing post-season plans during the 12:00 Town Hall Meeting.

 

Now we're looking forward to Saturday and Monday when the three of us head up to Jupiter for "Pitchers & Catchers Reporting." That's usually where the kids get their treasure trove of autographs. Each year we buy the new team card set and they see how many players they can get. We didn't do the Marlins last season (for obvious reasons), but we had great success with the Cardinals. After that, the countdown begins for March 4 and our appearance as the "Honorary Bat Kid" at RDS!

(SoFlaFish @ Feb 13 2007, 1:09 PM)

Now we're looking forward to Saturday and Monday when the three of us head up to Jupiter for "Pitchers & Catchers Reporting."

 

Is Saturday the first "practice" day open to the public? I thought it was Sunday?

Is Saturday the first "practice" day open to the public? I thought it was Sunday?

 

Feb. 17 (my b-day) is "Pitchers & Catchers" report. I've been going to the first day of reporting now since 2003, and they're there on the first day.

 

you gotta make your kid a lefty hitter, dude!

 

Actually, I wanted to make him a lefty pitcher with a change-up by the age of 10, but unfortunately, the left handed gene my mother-in-law carries did not work its way to my kids.

Is Saturday the first "practice" day open to the public? I thought it was Sunday?

 

Feb. 17 (my b-day) is "Pitchers & Catchers" report. I've been going to the first day of reporting now since 2003, and they're there on the first day.

My dad's b-day is the 17th too. Happy early birthday to you.

SoFlaFish, your kids are adorable! Thanks for sharing the pics.

 

I would share mine but... :whistle

Am I wrong?

 

No, you're not wrong. It's arbitration, not litigation. The arbitrator examines the briefs and any potential argument presented by either side. Then it is one or the other. The arbitrator is bound by the American Arbitration Association ("AAA") rules and procedures, as well as any other rules and procedures outlined in the Collective Bargaining Agreement.

 

This comes from the AAA: In addition to contractual grievance arbitration, the Basic Agreement between the Major League Baseball Players Association and the owners provides for arbitration of salary disputes. While these arbitrations are basically a form of labor arbitration, an arbitrator is not permitted to fashion remedies or write opinions. The Basic Agreement requires "last best offer" arbitration, in which both the team and the player involved submit their last offers to an arbitrator, who must pick one of the submitted figures. While this can at times produce what appear to be unusual results, the nature of this system induces the participants to bargain in good faith and results in a high percentage of settlements.

I think TSwift is taking a more practical approach to the thought process an arbitration panel will use when it has to pick "one or the other." And, to a certain agree, I agree with TSwift. Under normal circumstances (litigation or regular arbitration before the AAA), I would think the burden would be on the player - having rejected the club's offer - to demonstrate that the club's offer was unreasonable AND that the player's counter-offer is fair. Essentially, it appears to be a two-pronged test. This is difficult for the player to overcome when the club introduces sufficient evidence that, even if the player has submitted a reasonable offer, that the club's initial offer was reasonable and in line with what similar players have received. Basically, under this approach, it is not which offer is the fairest, but whether the player was unreasonable in rejecting the club's initial offer.

 

However, I think the baseball rules seem to be more of a "which offer is more fair" analysis. Considering that the Marlins' offer, which is itself a record, suggests that Cabs is worthy of such a high figure, I would think the practical burden of persuasion shifts to the Marlins to show Cabs' desired salary is too high. And, I do not think the Marlins can win that argument. In a way, the Marlins have conceded that Cabs' number does not fall within a group of players, but actually is above every player in the same position. As long as Cabs' figure is reasonable for his age/years in arbitration/position, etc., how can the Marlins prevail? $7.4 seems in line with what Pujols received, inflation adjusted.

 

I am not sure if this is the process, so keep the pitchforks away. I would love for someone to explain to me how it works. I actually do have some experience with the AAA and arbitration in general, but the AAA's general process is very different than the one used by MLB. First, the arbitrators aren't secret. In fact, the parties spend a lot of time choosing/striking/removing arbitrators. It is the one forum that you can actually (if you know what you're doing) select a person with the kind of experience you believe is necessary to resolve a dispute. However, I have no idea how the MLB process works, and it seems like the clubs rarely lose (hence, perhaps not the fairest forum for the players).

I would think the burden would be on the player - having rejected the club's offer - to demonstrate that the club's offer was unreasonable AND that the player's counter-offer is fair. Essentially, it appears to be a two-pronged test. This is difficult for the player to overcome when the club introduces sufficient evidence that, even if the player has submitted a reasonable offer, that the club's initial offer was reasonable and in line with what similar players have received. Basically, under this approach, it is not which offer is the fairest, but whether the player was unreasonable in rejecting the club's initial offer.

 

However, I think the baseball rules seem to be more of a "which offer is more fair" analysis. Considering that the Marlins' offer, which is itself a record, suggests that Cabs is worthy of such a high figure, I would think the practical burden of persuasion shifts to the Marlins to show Cabs' desired salary is too high. And, I do not think the Marlins can win that argument. In a way, the Marlins have conceded that Cabs' number does not fall within a group of players, but actually is above every player in the same position. As long as Cabs' figure is reasonable for his age/years in arbitration/position, etc., how can the Marlins prevail? $7.4 seems in line with what Pujols received, inflation adjusted.

Your first paragraph is what the situation is. The Marlins are respecting Cabrera, and SFX is being completely unreasonable to how the arbitration system works. They are doing it for other reasons. It's a system designed to help the player not be underpaid, and if the offer is fair and reasonable, there is no sense granting even more. Especially for this case cause this will set a new precedent in hearings being the new 'largest' deal and will shift arbitration strategy as players are now $2.5-$5 more expensive in years 4-6 then what they should be. That's a big deal. SFX is making this an issue so they outwardly show Cabrera when payday comes, you will be represented by sharks. And really, I don't have a problem with that, but it doesn't mean the Marlins offer was unreasonable or low balling him. Further, if SFX truly told Cabrera to skip fanfest over this, that's awful. I don't know if I necessarily believe that, but that's absurd if so.

 

What I bolded is key. They haven't conceded that at all. They are merely giving him a realistic salary bump, and inflation is accounted for because flat out, Cabrera is simply not as good as Pujols. A better player to compare him to his Teixiera, who got $6.4 (in a 2 year deal, where'd you expect he's given more money in year 4 to sign off on a lower year 5 rate making the figure potentially lower by a few hundred thousand). Cabrera has a slightly better statistical resume then him if we're looking at OPS, K rates I believe, age, and of course WS, but not having the 40 HR numbers are going to kill Miggy in these hearings more then likely. The Marlins are a cheap franchise, but this was an extremely fair and competitive offer. They've taken care of Dontrelle with fair deals for 2 years, and they are doing the same thing to Cabrera now. I'll be stunned if they lose this.

"...The Marlins are respecting Cabrera, and SFX is being completely unreasonable to how the arbitration system works. They are doing it for other reasons. It's a system designed to help the player not be underpaid, and if the offer is fair and reasonable, there is no sense granting even more. Especially for this case cause this will set a new precedent in hearings being the new 'largest' deal and will shift arbitration strategy as players are now $2.5-$5 more expensive in years 4-6 then what they should be. That's a big deal. SFX is making this an issue so they outwardly show Cabrera when payday comes, you will be represented by sharks. And really, I don't have a problem with that, but it doesn't mean the Marlins offer was unreasonable or low balling him. Further, if SFX truly told Cabrera to skip fanfest over this, that's awful. I don't know if I necessarily believe that, but that's absurd if so."

Lou, I agree on every point from top to bottom.

 

I couldn't have said it better myself. The only thing that doesn't ring true is a third party claim posted here that no one in SFX even knew where Cabrera was last week. When I heard that, I just :banghead thinking how silly and ridiculous that was. If it were true, a week before arbitration, they should be fired tomorrow

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.