Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

FanFest 2007

Featured Replies

Here's a more annoying quote from that same article:

 

Cabrera is going through the arbitration process. His hearing is set for Friday in Arizona. Cabrera is seeking $7.4 million, while the Marlins are offering, $6.7 million.

 

"We're being very fair," Beinfest said. "It's business. I think both parties know if we can't reach a settlement that he has a right to have an arbitrator determine his salary. From our perspective, when you are talking about the accomplishments he has, it's a fair number. We'll see what happens."

 

And this is why I maintain that Beinfest is being a moron and I have no faith in his ability to build anything long term once we pass the point of simple talent evaluation. You're splitting hairs over $700,000!!!! Less than 1/10 the value of the contract. There's no conceivable way you can tell me that you're going to go into an arbitration hearing, sit down and explain to the three person panel that this guy should be the beneficiary of a raise in excess of 300% (or whatever ungodly amount he's receiving) but we're absolutely, positively drawing the line at that last 10%, especially when the person has the resume of Miguel Cabrera.

 

If we were talking about several millions apart, like say Cabrera asking for $8.5, then this line in the sand mentality is fine, but Beinfest is trying to fight a battle he can't possibly win. And that's just stupid, because as we saw with AJ Burnett, that arbitration meeting really breeds bad feelings...or does no one else see the alarming similarities, even down to the corny "we'll all leave together and head to spring training" comments.

 

Next time you call someone a moron take a look in the mirror first.

 

I believe it's one arbiter not three. And you're using AJ Burnett as an example??? OMG :whistle

 

If Cabrera's team doesn't come to their senses and agree to split the difference the Marlins will go in, say Miggy simply is the greatest thing since sliced bread, and walk out the winners. The Marlins, knowing they are going to be rebutted by SFX, will take the high road having no doubt picked the highest possible number they believe (and their consultants believe) the arbiter will agree to leaving Cabrera's newly hired henchmen looking impotent.

 

It was ridiculously selfish of SFX to keep Cabrera away from FanFest.

 

First of all, who says they kept Cabrera away from fan-fest? There's nothing to substantiate that, but keep on spinning.

 

Secondly, there's no way the Marlins win this case. I'll even do a ban bet with you on it.

 

It's absolutely inconceivable that you go in front of the panel and say "hey, he's worth this ungodly raise, but he's not worth that extra 10% and here's why" There's no case to be made there. If thie difference were greater and say the Marlins were offering $7 and Miggy was asking $9, then arbitration makes sense, but this is such an open and shut case it's not even funny. It's not as if there's a monetary value for RBI's, or batting average, it's simple common sense. When two sides are this close, and they insist on going to arbitration, the fact that they're dealing with such a special player getting an already unprecedent raise means it's overwhelmingly likely that the higher side is going to win.

 

As for AJ....I'm sure many don't remember, but Samson offered AJ a ride to arbitration, AJ declined, they trashed AJ at the hearing, and I believe the Marlins lost. The relationship deteriorated, but the Marlins figured that offering him a ride would make everything else OK. Hearing that the Marlins are offering Cabrera a ride, that they're heading to a useless hearing and that they're fully prepared to trash him just sets this up for a very bad ending.

 

In any case, back it up...ban bet.

And this is why I maintain that Beinfest is being a moron and I have no faith in his ability to build anything long term once we pass the point of simple talent evaluation. You're splitting hairs over $700,000!!!! Less than 1/10 the value of the contract. There's no conceivable way you can tell me that you're going to go into an arbitration hearing, sit down and explain to the three person panel that this guy should be the beneficiary of a raise in excess of 300% (or whatever ungodly amount he's receiving) but we're absolutely, positively drawing the line at that last 10%, especially when the person has the resume of Miguel Cabrera.

 

If we were talking about several millions apart, like say Cabrera asking for $8.5, then this line in the sand mentality is fine, but Beinfest is trying to fight a battle he can't possibly win. And that's just stupid, because as we saw with AJ Burnett, that arbitration meeting really breeds bad feelings...or does no one else see the alarming similarities, even down to the corny "we'll all leave together and head to spring training" comments.

Then you set a precedent for being bullied around and next year Cabrera will be even more expensive. It's stupid to give into demands even if he's awesome. $6.7 is more then Teix and Pujols got in year 4. It's an extremely generous offer, and even going with inflation he shouldn't get to $7.4. Beinfest and the FO are completely right on this one, and I doubt Cabrera will win this. I doubt they even split the difference and it'll come under $7 at most. This is just letting the Marlins know when the time comes, there will not be a discount and I have no problem with Cabrera and his people doing that. Like Beinfest says, it's business. Noting personal. Now if SFX instructed Cabrera not to go to fanfest, that's pretty effed up. Posturing for salary shouldn't keep you away from events. Hope that wasn't the case.

 

It's not about being bullied, it's about picking the right spots to fight.

 

If the Marlins had come in with Pujols' figure ($5.75 I believe) and wanted to fight tooth and nail on that figure relative to the $7.4, fine, it's reasonable, it's a fight you can win. But that's not what they're doing. They already shot the figure up high saying he's worth the $6.7. Now, sitting in front of the panel, there's no reasonable way to say all the right things about Cabrera for that hour they get, and then end up convincing the panel that the player does not deserve that final 10% of the contract.

 

It's such an insignificant amount relative to the contract that you can't say nice things about this guy and expect to win.

 

Oh, and Lou, since your words about splitting the difference indicate you don't understand the arbitration process, there are only two outcomes, the player's figure and the team's figure.

 

So, again, such an insignificant figure, the team already willing to set arbitration records for a first year player and the player's demand so very close to the team's...it's such an open and shut case.

Oh, and Lou, since your words about splitting the difference indicate you don't understand the arbitration process, there are only two outcomes, the player's figure and the team's figure.

 

So, again, such an insignificant figure, the team already willing to set arbitration records for a first year player and the player's demand so very close to the team's...it's such an open and shut case.

If there were only 2 outcomes, none of these contracts would be signed. Teams make deals all the time right up to the hearing, and that's what the comment was in relation too. Thanks for thinking I don't understand the process though.

 

Orioles agreed to terms with outfielder Corey Patterson on a one-year, $4.3 million contract.

Patterson, who asked for $4.6 million and was offered $4 million.

 

Pirates agreed to terms with second baseman Jose Castillo on a one-year, $1.9 million contract.

Castillo asked for $2.2 million and was offered $1.8 million

 

Diamondbacks agreed to terms with outfielder Eric Byrnes on a one-year, $4.575 million contract.

Byrnes asked for $5 million and was offered $4.25 million

 

Pirates agreed to terms with infielder Freddy Sanchez on a one-year, $2.75 million contract.

Sanchez asked for $3.1 million and was offered $2.15 million,

Oh, and Lou, since your words about splitting the difference indicate you don't understand the arbitration process, there are only two outcomes, the player's figure and the team's figure.

 

So, again, such an insignificant figure, the team already willing to set arbitration records for a first year player and the player's demand so very close to the team's...it's such an open and shut case.

If there were only 2 outcomes, none of these contracts would be signed. Teams make deals all the time right up to the hearing, and that's what the comment was in relation too. Thanks for thinking I don't understand the process though.

 

Orioles agreed to terms with outfielder Corey Patterson on a one-year, $4.3 million contract.

Patterson, who asked for $4.6 million and was offered $4 million.

 

Pirates agreed to terms with second baseman Jose Castillo on a one-year, $1.9 million contract.

Castillo asked for $2.2 million and was offered $1.8 million

 

Diamondbacks agreed to terms with outfielder Eric Byrnes on a one-year, $4.575 million contract.

Byrnes asked for $5 million and was offered $4.25 million

 

Pirates agreed to terms with infielder Freddy Sanchez on a one-year, $2.75 million contract.

Sanchez asked for $3.1 million and was offered $2.15 million,

 

I guess you also didn't know it's not team policy to negotiate after exchanging figures.

 

IN arbitration, where this IS going, there are only 2 outcomes.

I guess you also didn't know it's not team policy to negotiate after exchanging figures.

 

IN arbitration, where this IS going, there are only 2 outcomes.

I know that too, but I think everything is out the door when it comes to an all generational player. Are you really going to be shocked if they settle on $7 before the hearing?

I guess you also didn't know it's not team policy to negotiate after exchanging figures.

 

IN arbitration, where this IS going, there are only 2 outcomes.

I know that too, but I think everything is out the door when it comes to an all generational player. Are you really going to be shocked if they settle on $7 before the hearing?

 

Honestly, yes.

I attended the VIP Town Hall meeting at 1:30. They had Cody Ross, Mike Jacobs, Dan Uggla, Scott Olsen, Reggie, Messenger and Beinfest. When Beinfest was asked about the stadium he said that Samson is the stadium guy. Why, oh why?!

 

I'm with Swift on the Cabrera issue - pick your battles more effectively! There's no upside to needlessly creating bad blood with a player like Miggy. As for not being there, IMO, SFX didn't keep him away. He makes his own decisions and kept himself away.

Since no first year arbitration eligible player has ever made $6.7 or $7.4 million (and there is at least one who outperformed Miggy after three seasons and still got loss) then I'm not quite so sure why the arbitrator has to pick $7.4 million. Please explain. But do it well, please.

 

It seems to me that, at best, there's a 50% chance that the arbitrator will side with Miggy's figure. More likely than not the arbitrator will be unwilling to go to $7.4 because that's substantially higher than what Pujols got.

 

Just because it's a 10 percent difference doesn't mean that Miggy will win. The fact that the Marlins were willing to go this high in the first place (when they didn't have to) means that Miggy is more likely to seem unreasonable.

 

Regardless, in the end, if the arbitrator is convinced Miggy is worth $6.7 and not $7.4 million then that's what Miggy is going to get. Period. This is an arbitrator and he's supposed to only consider the merits of the respective arguments, and not that the Marlins are unwilling to go that extra 10%. An arbitrator is almost like a judge. He'll go by the rules.

I guess you also didn't know it's not team policy to negotiate after exchanging figures.

 

IN arbitration, where this IS going, there are only 2 outcomes.

I know that too, but I think everything is out the door when it comes to an all generational player. Are you really going to be shocked if they settle on $7 before the hearing?

 

Honestly, yes.

And I'll be just as surprised if Cabrera wins this. This kind of pay scale raise effects practically every first year arbitration case in baseball and basically all 4th year power hitters get an additional 500k a year in salary here on out at a minimum. Then this turns into a salary avalanche where everyone is up $1-2 mil in years 5 and 6, raising pre-free agency figures somewhere between $2.5-$5 million over years 4-6 depending on if you're a normal producer/superstar. And that is a lot of money. It would be really irresponsible for an arbiter to grant such a huge raise when the Marlins are already offering the largest contract ever, and it would only serve as further proof that only 10-12 teams in baseball can afford the top players after 5 years in the league. Further, it would just add fire to the strategy of buying out players arbitration because arbitration would cease being cost effective. This is a big deal. This is going to cause a huge shift in arbitration strategy if Cabrera wins, and not just for the Marlins. Hopefully it doesn't happen.

While it's true that in his 4th year Pujols "only" made $7 million and Miguel is asking for $7.4 million if I was Miguel I would look at the growth of MLB salaries from '04 to '07 and if the average salary has grown say 20% then Pujols' $7 million would be equivalent to $8.4 million in '07 MLB money and if that's the case then I can see the arbitrators going with Miguel's $7.4 million.

 

I think the most interesting arbitration case this season will be Zambrano's.

Hmmm... The only person who came up to us was someone asking us where we got our posters. :)

 

Pretty sure that was you and your guy I came up to on the 100 level. Don't know where I got the name from but I asked if you were Missy??? I blame it on my advanced age and a mild case of CRS. LOL I should have asked if you two were the ones I sent my tickets to for the autograph/photograph game. Sorry about the wrong name thing.

Actually I liked this FanFest better than last year. I thought it was nice to have the interactive games on the field. Last year the field was all tore up. And last year it was rainy. You couldn't ask for a more beautiful winter day in South Florida on Saturday. I think maybe they did alot more for the ones with VIP passes this year and it kind of shut out the others from some good times. Some of those areas where our passes got us there were quite a few players igning autographs and getting their pictures taken. I'm not into that sort of thing but I do like shaking hand with the guys and wishing them luck on the up coming year.

Things were spread out a bit more this year than in past years. And for the second year in a row there was no card show like there used to be on the 200 level.

Since no first year arbitration eligible player has ever made $6.7 or $7.4 million (and there is at least one who outperformed Miggy after three seasons and still got loss) then I'm not quite so sure why the arbitrator has to pick $7.4 million. Please explain. But do it well, please.

 

It seems to me that, at best, there's a 50% chance that the arbitrator will side with Miggy's figure. More likely than not the arbitrator will be unwilling to go to $7.4 because that's substantially higher than what Pujols got.

 

Just because it's a 10 percent difference doesn't mean that Miggy will win. The fact that the Marlins were willing to go this high in the first place (when they didn't have to) means that Miggy is more likely to seem unreasonable.

 

Regardless, in the end, if the arbitrator is convinced Miggy is worth $6.7 and not $7.4 million then that's what Miggy is going to get. Period. This is an arbitrator and he's supposed to only consider the merits of the respective arguments, and not that the Marlins are unwilling to go that extra 10%. An arbitrator is almost like a judge. He'll go by the rules.

 

Here's the simplist explanation I can give.

 

1) Pujols in his 4th year made $7 million. Index that amount for cost-of-living increases and inflation and you're pretty much at the $7.4 million.

 

Now the somewhat complicated way:

 

2) The Marlins are already admitting that Cabrera deserves record-breaking first time arbitration money. By coming to the table so high, the onus is on them to prove that the money should be kept low. Saying simply "it's a fair offer because we're already in uncharted territories" is not enough, they need to conclusively show that the line in the sand must be drawn at $6.7 million, that $7.4 is lavish and unnecessary. Until RBI and batting average have a conclusive dollar value, it's all subjective, and as I've said multiple times, providing a raise in excess of 300% yet refusing to budge on that last 10% is ridiculous. If the Marlins had set their figure far lower (say $5.75 million) they'd have a great chance of winning.

 

You have to understand, when the two sides are this close and already in agreement that the player is record setting special, the burden of proof shifts to the low-bidder. They have to prove that this is the highest that can reasonably expected, something that will be quite easy for the Cabrera camp to rebuff.

 

The Pujols precedent and the uncontrolled growth since that contract make this a slam dunk for Miggy's side.

I never thought they'd find a way to make the Mermaid outfits skimpier. :blink:

 

 

Nor did I, but I'm glad they did. :blink:

If the Marlins had set their figure far lower (say $5.75 million) they'd have a great chance of winning.

They would have a 0% chance of winning at $5.75.

Since no first year arbitration eligible player has ever made $6.7 or $7.4 million (and there is at least one who outperformed Miggy after three seasons and still got loss) then I'm not quite so sure why the arbitrator has to pick $7.4 million. Please explain. But do it well, please.

 

It seems to me that, at best, there's a 50% chance that the arbitrator will side with Miggy's figure. More likely than not the arbitrator will be unwilling to go to $7.4 because that's substantially higher than what Pujols got.

 

Just because it's a 10 percent difference doesn't mean that Miggy will win. The fact that the Marlins were willing to go this high in the first place (when they didn't have to) means that Miggy is more likely to seem unreasonable.

 

Regardless, in the end, if the arbitrator is convinced Miggy is worth $6.7 and not $7.4 million then that's what Miggy is going to get. Period. This is an arbitrator and he's supposed to only consider the merits of the respective arguments, and not that the Marlins are unwilling to go that extra 10%. An arbitrator is almost like a judge. He'll go by the rules.

 

Here's the simplist explanation I can give.

 

1) Pujols in his 4th year made $7 million. Index that amount for cost-of-living increases and inflation and you're pretty much at the $7.4 million.

 

Now the somewhat complicated way:

 

2) The Marlins are already admitting that Cabrera deserves record-breaking first time arbitration money. By coming to the table so high, the onus is on them to prove that the money should be kept low. Saying simply "it's a fair offer because we're already in uncharted territories" is not enough, they need to conclusively show that the line in the sand must be drawn at $6.7 million, that $7.4 is lavish and unnecessary. Until RBI and batting average have a conclusive dollar value, it's all subjective, and as I've said multiple times, providing a raise in excess of 300% yet refusing to budge on that last 10% is ridiculous. If the Marlins had set their figure far lower (say $5.75 million) they'd have a great chance of winning.

 

You have to understand, when the two sides are this close and already in agreement that the player is record setting special, the burden of proof shifts to the low-bidder. They have to prove that this is the highest that can reasonably expected, something that will be quite easy for the Cabrera camp to rebuff.

 

The Pujols precedent and the uncontrolled growth since that contract make this a slam dunk for Miggy's side.

 

I probably dislike this FO as much as you. However, keep in mind that by the Marlins giving in on Miguel's demand they are setting a higher floor for next year arbitration. So you maybe thinking in terms of 700K, but the Marlins and Cabrera are probably thinking in terms of present and future $$.

 

Anyway, I really think Cabrera is not on the FO long term plans (with a stadium or no stadium).

If the Marlins had set their figure far lower (say $5.75 million) they'd have a great chance of winning.

They would have a 0% chance of winning at $5.75.

 

It really says something that Lou and I are on the same page here.

 

People seem to think the Marlins just picked numbers out of the air. The Marlins have employed for years some of the best consultants in the business and have been pretty good at figuring what the top number the arbiters will go for.

 

The logic behind $5.75 being a better number than $6.7 boogles the mind. :banghead

Oh, and Lou, since your words about splitting the difference indicate you don't understand the arbitration process, there are only two outcomes, the player's figure and the team's figure.

 

So, again, such an insignificant figure, the team already willing to set arbitration records for a first year player and the player's demand so very close to the team's...it's such an open and shut case.

If there were only 2 outcomes, none of these contracts would be signed. Teams make deals all the time right up to the hearing, and that's what the comment was in relation too. Thanks for thinking I don't understand the process though.

 

Orioles agreed to terms with outfielder Corey Patterson on a one-year, $4.3 million contract.

Patterson, who asked for $4.6 million and was offered $4 million.

 

Pirates agreed to terms with second baseman Jose Castillo on a one-year, $1.9 million contract.

Castillo asked for $2.2 million and was offered $1.8 million

 

Diamondbacks agreed to terms with outfielder Eric Byrnes on a one-year, $4.575 million contract.

Byrnes asked for $5 million and was offered $4.25 million

 

Pirates agreed to terms with infielder Freddy Sanchez on a one-year, $2.75 million contract.

Sanchez asked for $3.1 million and was offered $2.15 million,

 

Right and wrong, Lou. You have the process down right, but the Marlins have never continued talks after a player has filed for arbitration. They talk right up to the last minute and then just leave it up to the arbitrators.

 

I guess you also didn't know it's not team policy to negotiate after exchanging figures.

 

IN arbitration, where this IS going, there are only 2 outcomes.

I know that too, but I think everything is out the door when it comes to an all generational player. Are you really going to be shocked if they settle on $7 before the hearing?

 

I would be totally shocked. SFX is playing hardball. They will not settle for less.

 

Hmmm... The only person who came up to us was someone asking us where we got our posters. :)

 

I'll be darned. Could swore that was you two. Oh well. But I still apologize for getting your name wrong, even if it was to the wrong person. LOL

People seem to think the Marlins just picked numbers out of the air. The Marlins have employed for years some of the best consultants in the business and have been pretty good at figuring what the top number the arbiters will go for.

 

The logic behind $5.75 being a better number than $6.7 boogles the mind. :banghead

 

I can assure you that the folks handling the Marlins side of the arbitration proceeding are some of the best in the business. I know this because I used to work for them. I actually got to read the Marlins arbitration position statement for A.J. Burnett. These documents are some of the most fascinating reads. There were other players reports as well that I read, but I remember A.J.'s the most.

 

The numbers are derived from detailed comparisons between similar players and similar points in their careers. There are trends that are examined as well as detailed game-to-game analyses! There are no personal attacks in the arbitration reports so there is no reason for a player to have his feelings hurt unless that player is ultra-sensative (i.e., A.J. Burnett). The arguments are solely statistically based.

Bill James suggested as much having been hired as an consultant for players and teams alike. But some players and agents for whatever reason(s) that the process was a humilating one and fosters contempt towards teams.

Since no first year arbitration eligible player has ever made $6.7 or $7.4 million (and there is at least one who outperformed Miggy after three seasons and still got loss) then I'm not quite so sure why the arbitrator has to pick $7.4 million. Please explain. But do it well, please.

 

It seems to me that, at best, there's a 50% chance that the arbitrator will side with Miggy's figure. More likely than not the arbitrator will be unwilling to go to $7.4 because that's substantially higher than what Pujols got.

 

Just because it's a 10 percent difference doesn't mean that Miggy will win. The fact that the Marlins were willing to go this high in the first place (when they didn't have to) means that Miggy is more likely to seem unreasonable.

 

Regardless, in the end, if the arbitrator is convinced Miggy is worth $6.7 and not $7.4 million then that's what Miggy is going to get. Period. This is an arbitrator and he's supposed to only consider the merits of the respective arguments, and not that the Marlins are unwilling to go that extra 10%. An arbitrator is almost like a judge. He'll go by the rules.

 

Here's the simplist explanation I can give.

 

1) Pujols in his 4th year made $7 million. Index that amount for cost-of-living increases and inflation and you're pretty much at the $7.4 million.

 

Now the somewhat complicated way:

 

2) The Marlins are already admitting that Cabrera deserves record-breaking first time arbitration money. By coming to the table so high, the onus is on them to prove that the money should be kept low. Saying simply "it's a fair offer because we're already in uncharted territories" is not enough, they need to conclusively show that the line in the sand must be drawn at $6.7 million, that $7.4 is lavish and unnecessary. Until RBI and batting average have a conclusive dollar value, it's all subjective, and as I've said multiple times, providing a raise in excess of 300% yet refusing to budge on that last 10% is ridiculous. If the Marlins had set their figure far lower (say $5.75 million) they'd have a great chance of winning.

 

You have to understand, when the two sides are this close and already in agreement that the player is record setting special, the burden of proof shifts to the low-bidder. They have to prove that this is the highest that can reasonably expected, something that will be quite easy for the Cabrera camp to rebuff.

 

The Pujols precedent and the uncontrolled growth since that contract make this a slam dunk for Miggy's side.

 

Why is the burden of persuasion on the low-bidder? Is this what you think or are there rules somewhere that say this?

People seem to think the Marlins just picked numbers out of the air. The Marlins have employed for years some of the best consultants in the business and have been pretty good at figuring what the top number the arbiters will go for.

 

The logic behind $5.75 being a better number than $6.7 boogles the mind. :banghead

 

I can assure you that the folks handling the Marlins side of the arbitration proceeding are some of the best in the business. I know this because I used to work for them. I actually got to read the Marlins arbitration position statement for A.J. Burnett. These documents are some of the most fascinating reads. There were other players reports as well that I read, but I remember A.J.'s the most.

 

The numbers are derived from detailed comparisons between similar players and similar points in their careers. There are trends that are examined as well as detailed game-to-game analyses! There are no personal attacks in the arbitration reports so there is no reason for a player to have his feelings hurt unless that player is ultra-sensative (i.e., A.J. Burnett). The arguments are solely statistically based.

Good stuff SFF. My concern is that all of these players have huge egos, and even the slightest thing against them probably tears them apart inside. That, and from what I heard, Cabs is a tool anyway lol.

Why is the burden of persuasion on the low-bidder? Is this what you think or are there rules somewhere that say this?

 

There is no "burden of persuasion" in arbitration. I have drafted many agreements which have an arbitration clause in them. There are two types of arbitration: (1) regular and (2) "baseball" (I kid you not, when drafting these multimillion dollar management agreements for resort properties, both sides always referred to it as "baseball style"). In "regular" arbitration, both sides can come up with figures (or positions) and the arbitrator, or arbitrator is free to pick either position, or a third "position" based on the arguments raised. "Baseball style" arbitration is hard and fast, the arbitrator is limited to choose between one or the other and has no discretion to go beyond that.

 

Trust me on this, these arbitration briefs are written out like any legal appellate argument and the amount of information that is disclosed is staggering. It is like reading a disertation presented by the Elias Sports Bureau. After reading the Marlins position paper on A.J. Burnett, their offer to him was more than fair.

 

The players agreed to this system, so if a player's feelings get hurt in the process, well then the problem is with the player, not the system. Nobody ever claims that the General Manager's feelings are hurt. Give me a break, these are 20-somethings that are getting paid to play a game, and then on top of that getting paid insane gobs of money to play a game.

Why is the burden of persuasion on the low-bidder? Is this what you think or are there rules somewhere that say this?

 

There is no "burden of persuasion" in arbitration. I have drafted many agreements which have an arbitration clause in them. There are two types of arbitration: (1) regular and (2) "baseball" (I kid you not, when drafting these multimillion dollar management agreements for resort properties, both sides always referred to it as "baseball style"). In "regular" arbitration, both sides can come up with figures (or positions) and the arbitrator, or arbitrator is free to pick either position, or a third "position" based on the arguments raised. "Baseball style" arbitration is hard and fast, the arbitrator is limited to choose between one or the other and has no discretion to go beyond that.

 

Trust me on this, these arbitration briefs are written out like any legal appellate argument and the amount of information that is disclosed is staggering. It is like reading a disertation presented by the Elias Sports Bureau. After reading the Marlins position paper on A.J. Burnett, their offer to him was more than fair.

 

The players agreed to this system, so if a player's feelings get hurt in the process, well then the problem is with the player, not the system. Nobody ever claims that the General Manager's feelings are hurt. Give me a break, these are 20-somethings that are getting paid to play a game, and then on top of that getting paid insane gobs of money to play a game.

 

I figured this much. But TSwift said the burden of persuasion is on the low bidder, which means it's always on the team. I wanted him to clarify.

 

I agree with you. The arbitrator will look at all the evidence and will pick one of the two bids based on what he feels is objectively most reasonable. So Miggy will present his side and the Marlins will present their side. The arbitrator will pick between the two. There is no presumption in favor of the high bid. No presumption in favor of anyone.

 

Am I wrong?

Am I wrong?

 

No, you're not wrong. It's arbitration, not litigation. The arbitrator examines the briefs and any potential argument presented by either side. Then it is one or the other. The arbitrator is bound by the American Arbitration Association ("AAA") rules and procedures, as well as any other rules and procedures outlined in the Collective Bargaining Agreement.

 

This comes from the AAA: In addition to contractual grievance arbitration, the Basic Agreement between the Major League Baseball Players Association and the owners provides for arbitration of salary disputes. While these arbitrations are basically a form of labor arbitration, an arbitrator is not permitted to fashion remedies or write opinions. The Basic Agreement requires "last best offer" arbitration, in which both the team and the player involved submit their last offers to an arbitrator, who must pick one of the submitted figures. While this can at times produce what appear to be unusual results, the nature of this system induces the participants to bargain in good faith and results in a high percentage of settlements.

Am I wrong?

 

No, you're not wrong. It's arbitration, not litigation. The arbitrator examines the briefs and any potential argument presented by either side. Then it is one or the other. The arbitrator is bound by the American Arbitration Association rules and procedures, as well as any other rules and procedures outlined in the Collective Bargaining Agreement.

 

So TSwift is wrong. Thank you for the info.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.