January 18, 200719 yr Reed has a sliver of potential. He could be a poor mans Juan Pierre with twice the defense someday... I dont think the problem is the defense, I think the problem is actually hitting the ball with his bat, not even putting the ball in play, just hitting it would be a major breakthrough. I don't know, I'd be a liar if I said otherwise, and I don't think it's just that he was playing in the PCL, he did after all hit .303 in AAA last season. From what I saw of him last season, his problem at the major league level appeared to be he was overcome with fear. Scared sh*tless to be blunt. It may well be we are underestimating him having watched him melt down in the majors last season. I think those couple of pickoffs didn't help matters any either. I for one hope he's over it and comes into camp a new man.
January 18, 200719 yr Reed could not bunt sufficiently, or hit a curve-ball, well, ever. The altitude of the parks in the PCL, I would suspect, help compensate for the breaking-ball problem, and the bunting issue does not translate into stats if you can still hit singles. I would be substantially shocked if Reed shows up as anything more than a 4th or 5th outfield candidate, although I would love to see more given his more than capable defense.
January 18, 200719 yr Reed could not bunt sufficiently, or hit a curve-ball, well, ever. The altitude of the parks in the PCL, I would suspect, help compensate for the breaking-ball problem, and the bunting issue does not translate into stats if you can still hit singles. I would be substantially shocked if Reed shows up as anything more than a 4th or 5th outfield candidate, although I would love to see more given his more than capable defense. I think you're more than half right. He couldn't do ANYTHING right last season in the bigs - hit, bunt, steal, anything. I actually felt sorry for the kid to have worked his whole life to get here and then fall flat on his face in such an embarrassing way. It's one thing to come up and hit .220. I can't even think of a word to describe awful his performance was. Maybe he's just is a AAA player, but he was sooooo bad you have to think it was more than that.
January 19, 200719 yr I dunno about fear...He's just a terrible offensive baseball player. Yet he continually hits near or above .300 in the minor leagues? He obviously isn't terrible, and altittude has nothing to do with him as a hitter (just like it had nothing to do with Juan Pierre). I consider Eric Reed every bit as much a contender for the CF job in ST as I would Alex Sanchez. Hell, Reed hit better in the minors than Sanchez did, yet Sanchez is nearly a .300 career hitter in the majors and is hitting .350 in winter league ball now... You NEVER know sometimes.
January 19, 200719 yr I dunno about fear...He's just a terrible offensive baseball player. Yet he continually hits near or above .300 in the minor leagues? He obviously isn't terrible, and altittude has nothing to do with him as a hitter (just like it had nothing to do with Juan Pierre). I consider Eric Reed every bit as much a contender for the CF job in ST as I would Alex Sanchez. Hell, Reed hit better in the minors than Sanchez did, yet Sanchez is nearly a .300 career hitter in the majors and is hitting .350 in winter league ball now... You NEVER know sometimes. in beinfest i trust...dont do anything dumb with that oodles of pitching
January 19, 200719 yr I dunno about fear...He's just a terrible offensive baseball player. Yet he continually hits near or above .300 in the minor leagues? He obviously isn't terrible, and altittude has nothing to do with him as a hitter (just like it had nothing to do with Juan Pierre). I consider Eric Reed every bit as much a contender for the CF job in ST as I would Alex Sanchez. Hell, Reed hit better in the minors than Sanchez did, yet Sanchez is nearly a .300 career hitter in the majors and is hitting .350 in winter league ball now... You NEVER know sometimes. like it or not plenty of non-ML players can hit 300ish in the minors (especially hitter friendly PCL). Plenty...and they still have no shot to be even below average MLers. He played in the most friendly hitters league in pro baseball and still couldnt hit for any power or OBP % besides singles and a few inside the park homers. Altitude isnt the only factor but large outfieldsas well. Your optimism (read delusional homerism) is admirable though.
January 19, 200719 yr I dunno about fear...He's just a terrible offensive baseball player. Yet he continually hits near or above .300 in the minor leagues? He obviously isn't terrible, and altittude has nothing to do with him as a hitter (just like it had nothing to do with Juan Pierre). I consider Eric Reed every bit as much a contender for the CF job in ST as I would Alex Sanchez. Hell, Reed hit better in the minors than Sanchez did, yet Sanchez is nearly a .300 career hitter in the majors and is hitting .350 in winter league ball now... You NEVER know sometimes. like it or not plenty of non-ML players can hit 300ish in the minors (especially hitter friendly PCL). Plenty...and they still have no shot to be even below average MLers. He played in the most friendly hitters league in pro baseball and still couldnt hit for any power or OBP % besides singles and a few inside the park homers. Altitude isnt the only factor but large outfieldsas well. Your optimism (read delusional homerism) is admirable though. But, again, Sanchez barely hit .250 in AA last year yet he's had plenty of success at the Major League level. They're practically the same player, and I wouldn't be suprised if Reed came into ST and shocked Fredi Gonzalez to the point of winning the CF job on Opening Day.
January 19, 200719 yr Reed has a sliver of potential. He could be a poor mans Juan Pierre with twice the defense someday... Most of us don't even want a rich man's Juan Pierre currently. I dunno about fear...He's just a terrible offensive baseball player. Yet he continually hits near or above .300 in the minor leagues? He obviously isn't terrible, and altittude has nothing to do with him as a hitter (just like it had nothing to do with Juan Pierre). I consider Eric Reed every bit as much a contender for the CF job in ST as I would Alex Sanchez. Hell, Reed hit better in the minors than Sanchez did, yet Sanchez is nearly a .300 career hitter in the majors and is hitting .350 in winter league ball now... You NEVER know sometimes. like it or not plenty of non-ML players can hit 300ish in the minors (especially hitter friendly PCL). Plenty...and they still have no shot to be even below average MLers. He played in the most friendly hitters league in pro baseball and still couldnt hit for any power or OBP % besides singles and a few inside the park homers. Altitude isnt the only factor but large outfieldsas well. Your optimism (read delusional homerism) is admirable though. But, again, Sanchez barely hit .250 in AA last year yet he's had plenty of success at the Major League level. They're practically the same player, and I wouldn't be suprised if Reed came into ST and shocked Fredi Gonzalez to the point of winning the CF job on Opening Day. Sanchez is much more of a capable hitter than Reed. Reed looked entirely overmatched against ML pitching. Just because they both lack power doesn't mean that they will get the same results.
January 19, 200719 yr Reed has a sliver of potential. He could be a poor mans Juan Pierre with twice the defense someday... Most of us don't even want a rich man's Juan Pierre currently. I dunno about fear...He's just a terrible offensive baseball player. Yet he continually hits near or above .300 in the minor leagues? He obviously isn't terrible, and altittude has nothing to do with him as a hitter (just like it had nothing to do with Juan Pierre). I consider Eric Reed every bit as much a contender for the CF job in ST as I would Alex Sanchez. Hell, Reed hit better in the minors than Sanchez did, yet Sanchez is nearly a .300 career hitter in the majors and is hitting .350 in winter league ball now... You NEVER know sometimes. like it or not plenty of non-ML players can hit 300ish in the minors (especially hitter friendly PCL). Plenty...and they still have no shot to be even below average MLers. He played in the most friendly hitters league in pro baseball and still couldnt hit for any power or OBP % besides singles and a few inside the park homers. Altitude isnt the only factor but large outfieldsas well. Your optimism (read delusional homerism) is admirable though. But, again, Sanchez barely hit .250 in AA last year yet he's had plenty of success at the Major League level. They're practically the same player, and I wouldn't be suprised if Reed came into ST and shocked Fredi Gonzalez to the point of winning the CF job on Opening Day. Sanchez is much more of a capable hitter than Reed. Reed looked entirely overmatched against ML pitching. Just because they both lack power doesn't mean that they will get the same results. When did I say because they lack power they will get the same results? Of course Sanchez is more proven... BUT, they are both practically the same player. Small, contact, speedy, top-of-the-order lefites. Sanchez makes better contact, they could both possibly get on base just the same, except Reed is a fantastic centerfielder while Sanchez is mediocre at best... I still think the job is very up in the air.
January 19, 200719 yr I dunno about fear...He's just a terrible offensive baseball player. Yet he continually hits near or above .300 in the minor leagues? He obviously isn't terrible, and altittude has nothing to do with him as a hitter (just like it had nothing to do with Juan Pierre). I consider Eric Reed every bit as much a contender for the CF job in ST as I would Alex Sanchez. Hell, Reed hit better in the minors than Sanchez did, yet Sanchez is nearly a .300 career hitter in the majors and is hitting .350 in winter league ball now... You NEVER know sometimes. Altitude makes curve-balls curve less. Eric Reed could not hit a curve-ball last season. Therefore, I'd say it's safe to conclude that altitude played a bit of a factor in his AAA numbers.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.