April 14, 200719 yr Beinfest to me, is the best GM in all of pro sports. I challenge anyone to find me a better GM. Terry Ryan, easily. Terry Ryan is a good GM and if you think he is the best you are entitled to your opinion. However, to say he is easily the best is very debatable. After all, his rotation consists of Boof Bonser, Ramon Ortiz, Carlos Silva, and Sydney Ponson!! Yes, I know that he has studs in Santana, Morneau, Mauer, and Hunter, but the rotation is proof that he is not "easily" the best. For me personally, I'll take Beinfest over Ryan. You're crazy. Terry Ryan built the Twins into a consistent division winner with his guys. He got Santana, Castillo, Mauer, Morneau, Liriano, Nathan, Bonser, Hunter, etc. Beinfest has built the two most underachieving teams in Marlins history with his guys, has convincingly won or broken even on two trades since the beginning of 2006 (Pierre, Beckett/Lowell) and been reamed everywhere else. Until Beinfest wins consistently with "his" team, not just bits and pieces intermixed with the second best player in baseball (whom he didn't sign, and given the way he's doing his job internationally, never would have) Ryan gets the nod, and it's not just a slim margin, either. Just for reference, see how the two do when put head to head, I think you'll find it under: Castillo, Luis re: Bowyer, Travis. You make some good points. Like I said, you are entitled to your opinion. I think Ryan is a very good GM. I just personally prefer Beinfest. Maybe I'm just being a homer. I will say that judging a winner out of that Castillo v Bower trade is unfair. Bowyer blew out his shoulder and is still in rehab. Anyone can get hurt in sports. That's just the nature of the beast. Also, I believe the Alfonseca trade in which we received the D-train has worked out quite well for us. As for international players, I do believe Vanden Hurk is an international signing. Lets see how he pans out. I also think that for all of those wonderful players that you pointed out, it's a tragedy that the Twins rotation sucks as bad as it does. There is absolutely no excuse for that.
April 14, 200719 yr Beinfest to me, is the best GM in all of pro sports. I challenge anyone to find me a better GM. Terry Ryan, easily. Terry Ryan is a good GM and if you think he is the best you are entitled to your opinion. However, to say he is easily the best is very debatable. After all, his rotation consists of Boof Bonser, Ramon Ortiz, Carlos Silva, and Sydney Ponson!! Yes, I know that he has studs in Santana, Morneau, Mauer, and Hunter, but the rotation is proof that he is not "easily" the best. For me personally, I'll take Beinfest over Ryan. You're crazy. Terry Ryan built the Twins into a consistent division winner with his guys. He got Santana, Castillo, Mauer, Morneau, Liriano, Nathan, Bonser, Hunter, etc. Beinfest has built the two most underachieving teams in Marlins history with his guys, has convincingly won or broken even on two trades since the beginning of 2006 (Pierre, Beckett/Lowell) and been reamed everywhere else. Until Beinfest wins consistently with "his" team, not just bits and pieces intermixed with the second best player in baseball (whom he didn't sign, and given the way he's doing his job internationally, never would have) Ryan gets the nod, and it's not just a slim margin, either. Just for reference, see how the two do when p ut head to head, I think you'll find it under: Castillo, Luis re: Bowyer, Travis. When you say "underachieving", that implies that the team had talent but didn't get the job done on the field. It seems to me like that is the fault of the manager, not the GM.
April 14, 200719 yr Beinfest really hasn't done enough for everyone to call him a great GM. He won a world series, but most of the players were Dombrowski's guys. Sure, last sure he showed a certain level of greatness by fielding a decent team for ~$14 million, but he has yet to field a playoff team with his players.
April 14, 200719 yr Beinfest to me, is the best GM in all of pro sports. I challenge anyone to find me a better GM. Terry Ryan, easily. Terry Ryan is a good GM and if you think he is the best you are entitled to your opinion. However, to say he is easily the best is very debatable. After all, his rotation consists of Boof Bonser, Ramon Ortiz, Carlos Silva, and Sydney Ponson!! Yes, I know that he has studs in Santana, Morneau, Mauer, and Hunter, but the rotation is proof that he is not "easily" the best. For me personally, I'll take Beinfest over Ryan. You're crazy. Terry Ryan built the Twins into a consistent division winner with his guys. He got Santana, Castillo, Mauer, Morneau, Liriano, Nathan, Bonser, Hunter, etc. Beinfest has built the two most underachieving teams in Marlins history with his guys, has convincingly won or broken even on two trades since the beginning of 2006 (Pierre, Beckett/Lowell) and been reamed everywhere else. Until Beinfest wins consistently with "his" team, not just bits and pieces intermixed with the second best player in baseball (whom he didn't sign, and given the way he's doing his job internationally, never would have) Ryan gets the nod, and it's not just a slim margin, either. Just for reference, see how the two do when p ut head to head, I think you'll find it under: Castillo, Luis re: Bowyer, Travis. When you say "underachieving", that implies that the team had talent but didn't get the job done on the field. It seems to me like that is the fault of the manager, not the GM. Not when that's the MO for 2 straight seasons with basically the same "stale" talent, plus a complete disregard for addressing an area of weakness on those two teams (the bullpen, specifically middle relief).
April 14, 200719 yr Beinfest to me, is the best GM in all of pro sports. I challenge anyone to find me a better GM. Terry Ryan, easily. Terry Ryan is a good GM and if you think he is the best you are entitled to your opinion. However, to say he is easily the best is very debatable. After all, his rotation consists of Boof Bonser, Ramon Ortiz, Carlos Silva, and Sydney Ponson!! Yes, I know that he has studs in Santana, Morneau, Mauer, and Hunter, but the rotation is proof that he is not "easily" the best. For me personally, I'll take Beinfest over Ryan. You're crazy. Terry Ryan built the Twins into a consistent division winner with his guys. He got Santana, Castillo, Mauer, Morneau, Liriano, Nathan, Bonser, Hunter, etc. Beinfest has built the two most underachieving teams in Marlins history with his guys, has convincingly won or broken even on two trades since the beginning of 2006 (Pierre, Beckett/Lowell) and been reamed everywhere else. Until Beinfest wins consistently with "his" team, not just bits and pieces intermixed with the second best player in baseball (whom he didn't sign, and given the way he's doing his job internationally, never would have) Ryan gets the nod, and it's not just a slim margin, either. Just for reference, see how the two do when put head to head, I think you'll find it under: Castillo, Luis re: Bowyer, Travis. You make some good points. Like I said, you are entitled to your opinion. I think Ryan is a very good GM. I just personally prefer Beinfest. Maybe I'm just being a homer. I will say that judging a winner out of that Castillo v Bower trade is unfair. Bowyer blew out his shoulder and is still in rehab. Anyone can get hurt in sports. That's just the nature of the beast. Also, I believe the Alfonseca trade in which we received the D-train has worked out quite well for us. As for international players, I do believe Vanden Hurk is an international signing. Lets see how he pans out. I also think that for all of those wonderful players that you pointed out, it's a tragedy that the Twins rotation sucks as bad as it does. There is absolutely no excuse for that. Well Matt Garza is in AAA right now and he should be a very good starter. Don't forget they had that Liriano guy who unfortunately blew out his arm. As for the Alfonseca trade, didn't Beinfest want a catcher from the Cubs instead? I give him credit for getting Willis anyway, but I seem to recall him originally wanting a catcher (and yes I know we got Jorgensen, and no he wasnt the catcher we wanted) That Castillo trade was absolutely botched. No ifs, ands, or buts about it.
April 14, 200719 yr it's a tragedy that the Twins rotation sucks as bad as it does. There is absolutely no excuse for that. :blink: Beinfest to me, is the best GM in all of pro sports. I challenge anyone to find me a better GM. Terry Ryan, easily. Terry Ryan is a good GM and if you think he is the best you are entitled to your opinion. However, to say he is easily the best is very debatable. After all, his rotation consists of Boof Bonser, Ramon Ortiz, Carlos Silva, and Sydney Ponson!! Yes, I know that he has studs in Santana, Morneau, Mauer, and Hunter, but the rotation is proof that he is not "easily" the best. For me personally, I'll take Beinfest over Ryan. You're crazy. Terry Ryan built the Twins into a consistent division winner with his guys. He got Santana, Castillo, Mauer, Morneau, Liriano, Nathan, Bonser, Hunter, etc. Beinfest has built the two most underachieving teams in Marlins history with his guys, has convincingly won or broken even on two trades since the beginning of 2006 (Pierre, Beckett/Lowell) and been reamed everywhere else. Until Beinfest wins consistently with "his" team, not just bits and pieces intermixed with the second best player in baseball (whom he didn't sign, and given the way he's doing his job internationally, never would have) Ryan gets the nod, and it's not just a slim margin, either. Just for reference, see how the two do when put head to head, I think you'll find it under: Castillo, Luis re: Bowyer, Travis. You make some good points. Like I said, you are entitled to your opinion. I think Ryan is a very good GM. I just personally prefer Beinfest. Maybe I'm just being a homer. I will say that judging a winner out of that Castillo v Bower trade is unfair. Bowyer blew out his shoulder and is still in rehab. Anyone can get hurt in sports. That's just the nature of the beast. Also, I believe the Alfonseca trade in which we received the D-train has worked out quite well for us. As for international players, I do believe Vanden Hurk is an international signing. Lets see how he pans out. I also think that for all of those wonderful players that you pointed out, it's a tragedy that the Twins rotation sucks as bad as it does. There is absolutely no excuse for that. Well Matt Garza is in AAA right now and he should be a very good starter. Don't forget they had that Liriano guy who unfortunately blew out his arm. As for the Alfonseca trade, didn't Beinfest want a catcher from the Cubs instead? I give him credit for getting Willis anyway, but I seem to recall him originally wanting a catcher (and yes I know we got Jorgensen, and no he wasnt the catcher we wanted) That Castillo trade was absolutely botched. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. Yep, we wanted a catcher but took Willis instead (I seem to recall money was an issue there, too *cough Milledge* since Clement was getting a decent salary).
April 15, 200719 yr You can make the point that Beinfest is a good GM. You can make the point that Beinfest is not as good of a GM. You can not make the point that Beinfest is a bad GM. (Although some people try)
April 15, 200719 yr Author I don't see how some of you marginalize the success Beinfest has had by simply saying that he had plenty of talent already...Take a look at the job Dombrowski did after '97. I think we all feel Dombrowski was a great GM, but I seem to remember fielding a team with lots of holes for a couple of years after our championship. Anyone remember Todd Dunwoody, Tony Saunders, Brian Meadows, Ryan Dempster, Jesus Sanchez, or Kevin Orie? The fact is, it took a while for us to recover from our fire sale in 1997. Remember how long we used the "they're young" excuse? After our most recent fire sale , we didn't really miss a beat. You can't marginalize the tremendous job of finding young ML ready players that, almost unanimously, have been successful thus far. Do you really think prospects are supposed to have an 80% success rate in the Majors? Take a look around baseball if you really believe that. Anyone who says Beinfest is average is wrong - I mean it's almost undebateable. You can't fault him for operating under the constraints laid out by our ownership. So he didn't get us a closer or a centerfielder....who exactly was he supposed to get? A veteran for $10 million per year, or take a flyer on a retread? Maybe he thought money could be spent more wisely, and that whatever retreads were out there were not worth bringing in. If you look at the results thus far it's hard to complain with the route we took. De Aza, even if he tails off at the plate a bit, is exactly what we needed in CF. He is head and shoulders above anything we threw out there last year defensively, and he has that "Juan Pierre" element at the plate. The bullpen looks absolutely fantastic; even though Julio has struggled, we have 4 potential replacements on our staff. How many teams have that luxury...much less teams that operate on the budget constraints we're under.
April 15, 200719 yr What Beinfest accomplished with the "market correction" was just amazing in fact almosr godly. Beinfest is at the very best of his field
April 15, 200719 yr I don't see how some of you marginalize the success Beinfest has had by simply saying that he had plenty of talent already...Take a look at the job Dombrowski did after '97. I think we all feel Dombrowski was a great GM, but I seem to remember fielding a team with lots of holes for a couple of years after our championship. Anyone remember Todd Dunwoody, Tony Saunders, Brian Meadows, Ryan Dempster, Jesus Sanchez, or Kevin Orie? The fact is, it took a while for us to recover from our fire sale in 1997. Remember how long we used the "they're young" excuse? After our most recent fire sale , we didn't really miss a beat. You can't marginalize the tremendous job of finding young ML ready players that, almost unanimously, have been successful thus far. Do you really think prospects are supposed to have an 80% success rate in the Majors? Take a look around baseball if you really believe that. Anyone who says Beinfest is average is wrong - I mean it's almost undebateable. You can't fault him for operating under the constraints laid out by our ownership. So he didn't get us a closer or a centerfielder....who exactly was he supposed to get? A veteran for $10 million per year, or take a flyer on a retread? Maybe he thought money could be spent more wisely, and that whatever retreads were out there were not worth bringing in. If you look at the results thus far it's hard to complain with the route we took. De Aza, even if he tails off at the plate a bit, is exactly what we needed in CF. He is head and shoulders above anything we threw out there last year defensively, and he has that "Juan Pierre" element at the plate. The bullpen looks absolutely fantastic; even though Julio has struggled, we have 4 potential replacements on our staff. How many teams have that luxury...much less teams that operate on the budget constraints we're under. There are no players contributing greatly to our success now aside from Hanley and Sanchez that came directly from the tear down. Jacobs is a fine secondary player but let's see where he is in 2 years. Willingham and Cabrera were Dombrowski draftees. The rest of the players came from elsewhere, mostly the draft...and looking at Olsen's outing today, JJ's 2007 thus far and Hermida's myriad injuries, the jury's still out on the three highest profile major league Beinfest draft picks that have made it to the show. And even then, it's completely arguable that Beinfest dealt away superior trade value players this year than Dombrowski had to deal in '97. Brown was a player in his walk year and he got us Derrek Lee. Leiter was another guy in his walk year and he brought back AJ Burnett. Alou was an albatross of a contract and he unloaded him for just contract relief, same can't be said for Delgado as we're still paying him. Sheffield was the highest paid player in baseball and he got us, eventually, a player who would go on to hit 30 HR's for us (Preson Wilson) all while not having to pay a penny of his salary. Dombrowski did a fantastic job getting value back for his players in the sell-off, Beinfest didn't as we've illustrated above, when trading a talent like Josh Beckett, anything less than a Hanley Ramirez would be an unquestioned failure.
April 15, 200719 yr Author There are no players contributing greatly to our success now aside from Hanley and Sanchez that came directly from the tear down. Jacobs is a fine secondary player but let's see where he is in 2 years. Willingham and Cabrera were Dombrowski draftees. The rest of the players came from elsewhere, mostly the draft...and looking at Olsen's outing today, JJ's 2007 thus far and Hermida's myriad injuries, the jury's still out on the three highest profile major league Beinfest draft picks that have made it to the show. And even then, it's completely arguable that Beinfest dealt away superior trade value players this year than Dombrowski had to deal in '97. Brown was a player in his walk year and he got us Derrek Lee. Leiter was another guy in his walk year and he brought back AJ Burnett. Alou was an albatross of a contract and he unloaded him for just contract relief, same can't be said for Delgado as we're still paying him. Sheffield was the highest paid player in baseball and he got us, eventually, a player who would go on to hit 30 HR's for us (Preson Wilson) all while not having to pay a penny of his salary. Dombrowski did a fantastic job getting value back for his players in the sell-off, Beinfest didn't as we've illustrated above, when trading a talent like Josh Beckett, anything less than a Hanley Ramirez would be an unquestioned failure. Why are you limiting Beinfest to only the players he acquired via the fire sale? It doesn't makes sense to give him no credit for guys like Willis, Uggla, De Aza, Olsen, Johnson, Hermida, etc. Are we arguing who did a better job at conducting a fire sale or are we arguing whether Beinfest is a good GM? Just to argue your point...who did Dombrowski acquire via fire sale that was important to our success? AJ Burnett was nothing more than an injury prone pitcher who produced average results. Sure he had a ton of ability, but where have the results ever been with him? Preston Wilson? When was he ever a factor on our team? He was a very flawed player with good power. If he was as good as you hinted at I wonder why he wasn't exactly in high demand when he was on the market last year. Braden Looper was a good reliever, but never the closer prospect we had hoped for. Brad Penny was a pretty good pitcher, nothing more. Lee is a very good player, but it took him 6 years to realize his potential. Jacobs right now is a better player than Lee was after a year. It seems a bit unfair to give credit to DD for guys that have gotten 10 years to realize their potential, while some of Beinfest's guys haven't even played a game in the majors yet. That said, Beinfest got us Hanley, Sanchez, Jacobs, and a pretty good group of minor leaguers that may or may not pan out. Even if none of the other minor leaguers pan out, you can make a pretty good case that the current major leaguers alone are comparable to Dombrowski's group. Also, I fail to see how Beinfest had better players to unload. Didn't Dombrowski have Leiter, Brown, CJ (while he was considered very good), Robb Nen, Bobby Bonilla, Gary Sheffield, Moises Alou, Egar Renteria, Jeff Conine and probably more I'm forgetting. Compare that to Josh Beckett, Mike Lowell, Carlos Delgado, Paul Loduca, and Juan Pierre. I don't see how you can say Beinfest had more to work with. I don't get why you have a hard time giving Beinfest credit. The man has done a remarkable job, and anyone in baseball would tell you that. The rational you are giving just doesn't make a lot of sense. Your arguments don't make are pretty baseless.
April 15, 200719 yr There are no players contributing greatly to our success now aside from Hanley and Sanchez that came directly from the tear down. Jacobs is a fine secondary player but let's see where he is in 2 years. Willingham and Cabrera were Dombrowski draftees. The rest of the players came from elsewhere, mostly the draft...and looking at Olsen's outing today, JJ's 2007 thus far and Hermida's myriad injuries, the jury's still out on the three highest profile major league Beinfest draft picks that have made it to the show. And even then, it's completely arguable that Beinfest dealt away superior trade value players this year than Dombrowski had to deal in '97. Brown was a player in his walk year and he got us Derrek Lee. Leiter was another guy in his walk year and he brought back AJ Burnett. Alou was an albatross of a contract and he unloaded him for just contract relief, same can't be said for Delgado as we're still paying him. Sheffield was the highest paid player in baseball and he got us, eventually, a player who would go on to hit 30 HR's for us (Preson Wilson) all while not having to pay a penny of his salary. Dombrowski did a fantastic job getting value back for his players in the sell-off, Beinfest didn't as we've illustrated above, when trading a talent like Josh Beckett, anything less than a Hanley Ramirez would be an unquestioned failure. Why are you limiting Beinfest to only the players he acquired via the fire sale? It doesn't makes sense to give him no credit for guys like Willis, Uggla, De Aza, Olsen, Johnson, Hermida, etc. Are we arguing who did a better job at conducting a fire sale or are we arguing whether Beinfest is a good GM? Just to argue your point...who did Dombrowski acquire via fire sale that was important to our success? AJ Burnett was nothing more than an injury prone pitcher who produced average results. Sure he had a ton of ability, but where have the results ever been with him? Preston Wilson? When was he ever a factor on our team? He was a very flawed player with good power. If he was as good as you hinted at I wonder why he wasn't exactly in high demand when he was on the market last year. Braden Looper was a good reliever, but never the closer prospect we had hoped for. Brad Penny was a pretty good pitcher, nothing more. Lee is a very good player, but it took him 6 years to realize his potential. Jacobs right now is a better player than Lee was after a year. It seems a bit unfair to give credit to DD for guys that have gotten 10 years to realize their potential, while some of Beinfest's guys haven't even played a game in the majors yet. That said, Beinfest got us Hanley, Sanchez, Jacobs, and a pretty good group of minor leaguers that may or may not pan out. Even if none of the other minor leaguers pan out, you can make a pretty good case that the current major leaguers alone are comparable to Dombrowski's group. Also, I fail to see how Beinfest had better players to unload. Didn't Dombrowski have Leiter, Brown, CJ (while he was considered very good), Robb Nen, Bobby Bonilla, Gary Sheffield, Moises Alou, Egar Renteria, Jeff Conine and probably more I'm forgetting. Compare that to Josh Beckett, Mike Lowell, Carlos Delgado, Paul Loduca, and Juan Pierre. I don't see how you can say Beinfest had more to work with. I don't get why you have a hard time giving Beinfest credit. The man has done a remarkable job, and anyone in baseball would tell you that. The rational you are giving just doesn't make a lot of sense. Your arguments don't make are pretty baseless. 1) I limited it to the firesale because that was the crux of your argument, that Beinfest should not be questioned because we rebounded after the sell off unlike '98. 2) I have a real hard time having a credible discussion with you if you truly believe that Jacobs is better than Lee in his Marlins tenure. I've reiterated this point many times, Jacobs was the worst regular first baseman in baseball last year...dead last in OPS, bottom 4 for fielding percentage, and the only player to be that bad in both categories in either league that qualified for a batting title. 3) Make a case that what Beinfest acquired was as good as what Dombrowski acquired. Go ahead, I dare you. PS: Beinfest had a hell of a lot more to unload. Our best players from the '97 team either had absurdly large contracts (Sheff, Alou, Bonilla) or were in their walk years (Brown, Leiter) in either case, what the team is willing to give you is way down. Beinfest was unloading quality players in a market place that was going crazy. Beckett would get around $9 million from the acquiring team over two years if they play the arbitration game, that's less than what AJ Burnett would receive in one year from the deal he would go on to sign. Luis Castillo would make less than Mark Grudzelanik and be a superior player and LoDuca offerred contractual stability to a market that was going out of control to offer money to a Molina. At least realize the climate before mouthing off, please. And even with Delgado, after allowing themselves to be reamed lube-free, the Marlins still agreed to pay salary (and this is with no less than 5 teams expressing interest: Mets, White Sox, Orioles, Rangers and the Yankees-to reroute him to Chicago), something dealin' Dave never needed to do.
April 15, 200719 yr Preston Wilson? When was he ever a factor on our team? He was a very flawed player with good power. If he was as good as you hinted at I wonder why he wasn't exactly in high demand when he was on the market last year. Not to pick out just one point but Preston wasn't in high demand LAST YEAR because he is no longer the player he was from 1999-2001, let alone 2003
April 15, 200719 yr Author There are no players contributing greatly to our success now aside from Hanley and Sanchez that came directly from the tear down. Jacobs is a fine secondary player but let's see where he is in 2 years. Willingham and Cabrera were Dombrowski draftees. The rest of the players came from elsewhere, mostly the draft...and looking at Olsen's outing today, JJ's 2007 thus far and Hermida's myriad injuries, the jury's still out on the three highest profile major league Beinfest draft picks that have made it to the show. And even then, it's completely arguable that Beinfest dealt away superior trade value players this year than Dombrowski had to deal in '97. Brown was a player in his walk year and he got us Derrek Lee. Leiter was another guy in his walk year and he brought back AJ Burnett. Alou was an albatross of a contract and he unloaded him for just contract relief, same can't be said for Delgado as we're still paying him. Sheffield was the highest paid player in baseball and he got us, eventually, a player who would go on to hit 30 HR's for us (Preson Wilson) all while not having to pay a penny of his salary. Dombrowski did a fantastic job getting value back for his players in the sell-off, Beinfest didn't as we've illustrated above, when trading a talent like Josh Beckett, anything less than a Hanley Ramirez would be an unquestioned failure. Why are you limiting Beinfest to only the players he acquired via the fire sale? It doesn't makes sense to give him no credit for guys like Willis, Uggla, De Aza, Olsen, Johnson, Hermida, etc. Are we arguing who did a better job at conducting a fire sale or are we arguing whether Beinfest is a good GM? Just to argue your point...who did Dombrowski acquire via fire sale that was important to our success? AJ Burnett was nothing more than an injury prone pitcher who produced average results. Sure he had a ton of ability, but where have the results ever been with him? Preston Wilson? When was he ever a factor on our team? He was a very flawed player with good power. If he was as good as you hinted at I wonder why he wasn't exactly in high demand when he was on the market last year. Braden Looper was a good reliever, but never the closer prospect we had hoped for. Brad Penny was a pretty good pitcher, nothing more. Lee is a very good player, but it took him 6 years to realize his potential. Jacobs right now is a better player than Lee was after a year. It seems a bit unfair to give credit to DD for guys that have gotten 10 years to realize their potential, while some of Beinfest's guys haven't even played a game in the majors yet. That said, Beinfest got us Hanley, Sanchez, Jacobs, and a pretty good group of minor leaguers that may or may not pan out. Even if none of the other minor leaguers pan out, you can make a pretty good case that the current major leaguers alone are comparable to Dombrowski's group. Also, I fail to see how Beinfest had better players to unload. Didn't Dombrowski have Leiter, Brown, CJ (while he was considered very good), Robb Nen, Bobby Bonilla, Gary Sheffield, Moises Alou, Egar Renteria, Jeff Conine and probably more I'm forgetting. Compare that to Josh Beckett, Mike Lowell, Carlos Delgado, Paul Loduca, and Juan Pierre. I don't see how you can say Beinfest had more to work with. I don't get why you have a hard time giving Beinfest credit. The man has done a remarkable job, and anyone in baseball would tell you that. The rational you are giving just doesn't make a lot of sense. Your arguments don't make are pretty baseless. 1) I limited it to the firesale because that was the crux of your argument, that Beinfest should not be questioned because we rebounded after the sell off unlike '98. 2) I have a real hard time having a credible discussion with you if you truly believe that Jacobs is better than Lee in his Marlins tenure. I've reiterated this point many times, Jacobs was the worst regular first baseman in baseball last year...dead last in OPS, bottom 4 for fielding percentage, and the only player to be that bad in both categories in either league that qualified for a batting title. 3) Make a case that what Beinfest acquired was as good as what Dombrowski acquired. Go ahead, I dare you. PS: Beinfest had a hell of a lot more to unload. Our best players from the '97 team either had absurdly large contracts (Sheff, Alou, Bonilla) or were in their walk years (Brown, Leiter) in either case, what the team is willing to give you is way down. Beinfest was unloading quality players in a market place that was going crazy. Beckett would get around $9 million from the acquiring team over two years if they play the arbitration game, that's less than what AJ Burnett would receive in one year from the deal he would go on to sign. Luis Castillo would make less than Mark Grudzelanik and be a superior player and LoDuca offerred contractual stability to a market that was going out of control to offer money to a Molina. At least realize the climate before mouthing off, please. And even with Delgado, after allowing themselves to be reamed lube-free, the Marlins still agreed to pay salary, something dealin' Dave never needed to do. 1) I said we are playing better baseball sooner after our fire sale - not that Beinfest did a better job than Dombrowski. 2) Again, you are having a hard time with your reading comprehension. I said that Jacobs is better now than Lee was at this point in his Marlins career. The point is that you are evaluating Beinfest's players after a year, while DD's group has had 10 years to mature. Lee was on the verge of being sent back down to work on his swing in his second and third years if I remember correctly. Jacobs can at least handle himself on the ML level. 3) OK, your 'dare' is so enticing (I love it when you act all macho)..(1) Sanchez last year showed more than AJ ever did - i.e. talent + an ability to pitch. (2) Wilson was a role player; Jacobs, at worst, will be what Wilson is. (3) Lee is obviously a great player now, but it only took 6 or 7 years to get there. Hanley is an all-star caliber player already - and he's a SS. I forgot Penny came from the Mantei trade, and that Lowell was acquired by a prospect, so neither count for Dombrowski's fire sale. Who does that leave? Looper? (4) We'll say Sanchez is a Looper better than A.J. I think they are pretty comparable, and that's without factoring in some promising minor leaguers acquired. P.S. Nice try...So coincidental that these "market conditions" make your case so concrete. If the '97 team was so unappealing based on market conditions, how did Dombrowski get what he got? Magic? It would be one thing if DD was getting no-name prospects that turned into gold, but he wasn't - he was getting top prospects just like Beinfest. Let's not pretend DD had no bargaining chips. Your rationalization is pretty far-fetched.
April 15, 200719 yr Derrek Lee was 22, Mike Jacobs was 25 (2) Wilson was a role player; Jacobs, at worst, will be what Wilson is. Preston Wilson was alot more than a role player. He was 2nd in ROY voting, was a 30/30 man and was one of our primary run producers.
April 15, 200719 yr Author Derrek Lee was 22, Mike Jacobs was 25 Ok, let me clear this up. I used Lee and Jacobs as an example to show that it's unfair to compare Beinfest's players now with DD's 10 years after the fact. Lee was not very good for 2 years or so. If we were evaluating him after 2 years we would have certainly missed out on giving DD his due credit. My point is that we COULD be doing the same by evaluating Beinfest's players after two years and comparing them with DD's players after 10. It's not apples to apples...that was the point I was making. In no way am I saying that Jacobs will/may turn into what Lee has become.
April 15, 200719 yr There are no players contributing greatly to our success now aside from Hanley and Sanchez that came directly from the tear down. Jacobs is a fine secondary player but let's see where he is in 2 years. Willingham and Cabrera were Dombrowski draftees. The rest of the players came from elsewhere, mostly the draft...and looking at Olsen's outing today, JJ's 2007 thus far and Hermida's myriad injuries, the jury's still out on the three highest profile major league Beinfest draft picks that have made it to the show. And even then, it's completely arguable that Beinfest dealt away superior trade value players this year than Dombrowski had to deal in '97. Brown was a player in his walk year and he got us Derrek Lee. Leiter was another guy in his walk year and he brought back AJ Burnett. Alou was an albatross of a contract and he unloaded him for just contract relief, same can't be said for Delgado as we're still paying him. Sheffield was the highest paid player in baseball and he got us, eventually, a player who would go on to hit 30 HR's for us (Preson Wilson) all while not having to pay a penny of his salary. Dombrowski did a fantastic job getting value back for his players in the sell-off, Beinfest didn't as we've illustrated above, when trading a talent like Josh Beckett, anything less than a Hanley Ramirez would be an unquestioned failure. . Why are you limiting Beinfest to only the players he acquired via the fire sale? It doesn't makes sense to give him no credit for guys like Willis, Uggla, De Aza, Olsen, Johnson, Hermida, etc. Are we arguing who did a better job at conducting a fire sale or are we arguing whether Beinfest is a good GM? Just to argue your point...who did Dombrowski acquire via fire sale that was important to our success? AJ Burnett was nothing more than an injury prone pitcher who produced average results. Sure he had a ton of ability, but where have the results ever been with him? Preston Wilson? When was he ever a factor on our team? He was a very flawed player with good power. If he was as good as you hinted at I wonder why he wasn't exactly in high demand when he was on the market last year. Braden Looper was a good reliever, but never the closer prospect we had hoped for. Brad Penny was a pretty good pitcher, nothing more. Lee is a very good player, but it took him 6 years to realize his potential. Jacobs right now is a better player than Lee was after a year. It seems a bit unfair to give credit to DD for guys that have gotten 10 years to realize their potential, while some of Beinfest's guys haven't even played a game in the majors yet. That said, Beinfest got us Hanley, Sanchez, Jacobs, and a pretty good group of minor leaguers that may or may not pan out. Even if none of the other minor leaguers pan out, you can make a pretty good case that the current major leaguers alone are comparable to Dombrowski's group. Also, I fail to see how Beinfest had better players to unload. Didn't Dombrowski have Leiter, Brown, CJ (while he was considered very good), Robb Nen, Bobby Bonilla, Gary Sheffield, Moises Alou, Egar Renteria, Jeff Conine and probably more I'm forgetting. Compare that to Josh Beckett, Mike Lowell, Carlos Delgado, Paul Loduca, and Juan Pierre. I don't see how you can say Beinfest had more to work with. I don't get why you have a hard time giving Beinfest credit. The man has done a remarkable job, and anyone in baseball would tell you that. The rational you are giving just doesn't make a lot of sense. Your arguments don't make are pretty baseless. 1) I limited it to the firesale because that was the crux of your argument, that Beinfest should not be questioned because we rebounded after the sell off unlike '98. 2) I have a real hard time having a credible discussion with you if you truly believe that Jacobs is better than Lee in his Marlins tenure. I've reiterated this point many times, Jacobs was the worst regular first baseman in baseball last year...dead last in OPS, bottom 4 for fielding percentage, and the only player to be that bad in both categories in either league that qualified for a batting title. 3) Make a case that what Beinfest acquired was as good as what Dombrowski acquired. Go ahead, I dare you. PS: Beinfest had a hell of a lot more to unload. Our best players from the '97 team either had absurdly large contracts (Sheff, Alou, Bonilla) or were in their walk years (Brown, Leiter) in either case, what the team is willing to give you is way down. Beinfest was unloading quality players in a market place that was going crazy. Beckett would get around $9 million from the acquiring team over two years if they play the arbitration game, that's less than what AJ Burnett would receive in one year from the deal he would go on to sign. Luis Castillo would make less than Mark Grudzelanik and be a superior player and LoDuca offerred contractual stability to a market that was going out of control to offer money to a Molina. At least realize the climate before mouthing off, please. And even with Delgado, after allowing themselves to be reamed lube-free, the Marlins still agreed to pay salary, something dealin' Dave never needed to do. 1) I said we are playing better baseball sooner after our fire sale - not that Beinfest did a better job than Dombrowski. 2) Again, you are having a hard time with your reading comprehension. I said that Jacobs is better now than Lee was at this point in his Marlins career. The point is that you are evaluating Beinfest's players after a year, while DD's group has had 10 years to mature. Lee was on the verge of being sent back down to work on his swing in his second and third years if I remember correctly. Jacobs can at least handle himself on the ML level. 3) OK, your 'dare' is so enticing (I love it when you act all macho)..(1) Sanchez last year showed more than AJ ever did - i.e. talent + an ability to pitch. (2) Wilson was a role player; Jacobs, at worst, will be what Wilson is. (3) Lee is obviously a great player now, but it only took 6 or 7 years to get there. Hanley is an all-star caliber player already - and he's a SS. I forgot Penny came from the Mantei trade, and that Lowell was acquired by a prospect, so neither count for Dombrowski's fire sale. Who does that leave? Looper? (4) We'll say Sanchez is a Looper better than A.J. I think they are pretty comparable, and that's without factoring in some promising minor leaguers acquired. P.S. Nice try...So coincidental that these "market conditions" make your case so concrete. If the '97 team was so unappealing based on market conditions, how did Dombrowski get what he got? Magic? It would be one thing if DD was getting no-name prospects that turned into gold, but he wasn't - he was getting top prospects just like Beinfest. Let's not pretend DD had no bargaining chips. Your rationalization is pretty far-fetched. I love when it devolves to name calling, I really know that's when I've won. Here's the thing, playing better baseball means jack sh*t. Did we have a winning record last season? No? OK, great, moving on. Second point, since I find it moronic to even put Jacobs in the same category, I'll be brief...Jacobs was toiling away in the minors at 22 (Lee's age in his first season with us). Jacobs age last year? 25. Lee's line that year .282/.346/.474 and the year before that he posted .281/.368/.507. Thirdly, "why are we just limiting it to the fire-sale" (or was that not your argument). Dombrowski's gems that shone post-firesale: Miguel Cabrera, Josh Willingham, Josh Beckett, Brad Penny, Luis Castillo, AJ Burnett, Derrek Lee, Cliff Floyd, Preston Wilson, Mike Lowell, Alex Gonzalez and Ryan Dempster. All of them all-stars with the exception of Willingham, Beckett (who won some sort of award) and Burnett (who threw a no-hitter, since that qualifies Anibal to be "more qualified" than AJ). And of them, Cabrera, Castillo and Lowell were multiple consecutive All-Stars. Beinfest's All-Stars: Willis, Uggla (neither drafted/internationally signed by this franchise and only Willis was a multiple All-Star, but not consecutive). That resume speaks pretty much for itself. Finally, if you can't rationalize the difference between a market place awash with cash and bereft of talent like was the case heading into the '06 season and the market place heading into '98 (when a $65 million contract was good for tops in baseball) I truly have no chance of reaching you. The Marlins were disassembling a team that was top-5 in payroll. That means there could be only a handfull of suitors (remember, revenue sharing was in no way shape or form as comprehensive as it is now). The fact that Dombrowski was able to unload massive contracts, get talent back for most of them and not have to pay a singe cent was far more impressive than Beinfest who unloaded incredibly desireable players on affordable contracts (the Royals and Twins for christ's sake were in on some of our guys) and the one big money guy we had to move, we ended up taking inferior talent AND paying his deal...that may not seem like a big deal, but the money we're paying the Mets this season is about 1/10 of our total onfield payroll and represents the 4th highest payout to any player on the roster.
April 15, 200719 yr Author I love when it devolves to name calling, I really know that's when I've won. ok - well here's another win for you...you are a pompous ass. Add that to your trophy case. Here's the thing, playing better baseball means jack sh*t. Did we have a winning record last season? No? OK, great, moving on. So a better record is not better unless you have a winning season? You learn something new everyday... Second point, since I find it moronic to even put Jacobs in the same category, I'll be brief...Jacobs was toiling away in the minors at 22 (Lee's age in his first season with us). Jacobs age last year? 25. Lee's line that year .282/.346/.474 and the year before that he posted .281/.368/.507. That's nice...but I never contended Jacobs was better at the same age, or never implied that he was the better player. You incorrectly inferred that. Thirdly, "why are we just limiting it to the fire-sale" (or was that not your argument). Dombrowski's gems that shone post-firesale: Miguel Cabrera, Josh Willingham, Josh Beckett, Brad Penny, Luis Castillo, AJ Burnett, Derrek Lee, Mike Lowell, Alex Gonzalez and Ryan Dempster. All of them all-stars with the exception of Willingham, Beckett (who won some sort of award) and Burnett (who threw a no-hitter, since that qualifies Anibal to be "more qualified" than AJ). And of them, Cabrera, Castillo and Lowell were multiple consecutive All-Stars. Beinfest's All-Stars: Willis, Uggla (neither drafted/internationally signed by this franchise and only Willis was a multiple All-Star, but not consecutive). That resume speaks pretty much for itself. This is pretty disingenuous to even bring up on your part. Is it fair to compare the players DD compiled in 10 years or so, and have had extra time to mature since he's been gone, to guys that Beinfest has acquired - the bulk of which are still making their way through the minors? I guess Beinfest is a piece of trash for not growing 10 all stars in 3 years... a real piss poor job by our GM. Finally, if you can't rationalize the difference between a market place awash with cash and bereft of talent like was the case heading into the '06 season and the market place heading into '98 (when a $65 million contract was good for tops in baseball) I truly have no chance of reaching you. The Marlins were disassembling a team that was top-5 in payroll. That means there could be only a handfull of suitors (remember, revenue sharing was in no way shape or form as comprehensive as it is now). The fact that Dombrowski was able to unload massive contracts, get talent back for most of them and not have to pay a singe cent was far more impressive than Beinfest who unloaded incredibly desireable players on affordable contracts (the Royals and Twins for christ's sake were in on some of our guys) and the one big money guy we had to move, we ended up taking inferior talent AND paying his deal...that may not seem like a big deal, but the money we're paying the Mets this season is about 1/10 of our total onfield payroll and represents the 4th highest payout to any player on the roster. There was obviously a market - those teams were not bidding against themselves. If the market for those players was as bleak as you suggest, how did DD snare top talent? To accept your view of the market, these teams were basically dumb and drastically overpaid for the players because there was no demand. Sorry, but that is a bit unbelievable to me. Being young and cheap is generally a plus, but it all depends on who's out there, how bad you want the player, and who you're bidding against. It's obvious that there was a demand for the players pawned off after the '97 series, no matter what the 'market conditions' were.
April 15, 200719 yr See, here's the thing, you're not even making sense any more. One minute it's that Beinfest did a better job than Dombrowski no question, now the comparision's not fair because time is an issue. You can't have it both ways, and you can't keep retracting and qualifying statements, it really undermines any credibility you wish to add to your position. My point all along has been, and remains, that during the "great Beinfest renaissance" of '03-'05, our best players, by and large, were all Dombrowski's guys. And our best player now is a Dombrowski guy. Moreover, the manner in which we have been stocked with talent by Beinfest is far more underwhelming than what Dombrowski did. Even in the deals that Dombrowski made that didn't pay off, like the Robb Nen deal, he still got 1st round talent back (Joe Fontenot anyone?). It was only down the line that the trade went bad, it wasn't an immediate head slam into the desk like some of Beinfest's questionable moves that as soon as one year later we can say we categorically lost on. Finally, Beinfest has been here for 5 seasons, this is his 6th. He's had plenty of time to draft sign and develop players. In that span he's drafted, developed or signed (internationally) zero All-Stars. Zero. At some point, small money clubs need to build through the draft too, and Beinfest's really left his ability there to be questionable. I'm not saying every GM has to be perfect, but he's yet to draft and develop one above average major leaguer (although Olsen shows hope along with Hermida). The two teams that Beinfest had his biggest imprint on (2004 and 2005) were underachieving headaches. The 2003 team featured 5 out of our 8 starting position players from Dombrowski and 3 starting pitchers out of 6 (Beckett, Burnett, Penny). Does that make him a slam-dunk genious or even convincingly above average? I don't think it's reasonable to conclude, given the evidence.
April 15, 200719 yr Say what you will about the Julio and Luis trade.. but we have Uggla and this trade with the Mets to get Owens and Lindstrom has the potential to be a MAJOR steal.
April 15, 200719 yr Author See, here's the thing, you're not even making sense any more. One minute it's that Beinfest did a better job than Dombrowski no question, now the comparision's not fair because time is an issue. You can't have it both ways, and you can't keep retracting and qualifying statements, it really undermines any credibility you wish to add to your position. Please go back and read what I wrote - because you are totally misrepresenting it. The primary issue we are debating is whether Beinfest is a good GM. To support my argument, I said that his team has performed better more quickly post fire sale than did DD's - a GM that is highly regarded by almost all. That was the extent of my comparison - I never once used the phrase 'no question,' if I remeber correctly I said the acquired players were comparable - then I made a comparison for you. I haven't retracted anything...you just keep on misrepresenting my statements. At least give me the courtesy of taking what I say at face value. Don't morph it into something that makes me sound ridiculous. My point all along has been, and remains, that during the "great Beinfest renaissance" of '03-'05, our best players, by and large, were all Dombrowski's guys. And our best player now is a Dombrowski guy. Ok, I'm going to jumble what you wrote a bit to prove a point.... The two teams that Beinfest had his biggest imprint on (2004 and 2005) were underachieving headaches. The 2003 team featured 5 out of our 8 starting position players from Dombrowski and 3 starting pitchers out of 6 (Beckett, Burnett, Penny). Does that make him a slam-dunk genious or even convincingly above average? I don't think it's reasonable to conclude, given the evidence. Based on the above two quotes, it looks like you are faulting Beinfest for getting players that underachieved during 'the great Beinfest renaissance' as you call it, then you say those same players were mostly Dombrowski's. You are arguing out of both sides here. Is your stance that the underachievers on those squads were Beinfest's and the overacheivers were DD's? I don't get it. Moreover, the manner in which we have been stocked with talent by Beinfest is far more underwhelming than what Dombrowski did. Even in the deals that Dombrowski made that didn't pay off, like the Robb Nen deal, he still got 1st round talent back (Joe Fontenot anyone?). It was only down the line that the trade went bad, it wasn't an immediate head slam into the desk like some of Beinfest's questionable moves that as soon as one year later we can say we categorically lost on. Finally, Beinfest has been here for 5 seasons, this is his 6th. He's had plenty of time to draft sign and develop players. In that span he's drafted, developed or signed (internationally) zero All-Stars. Zero. At some point, small money clubs need to build through the draft too, and Beinfest's really left his ability there to be questionable. I'm not saying every GM has to be perfect, but he's yet to draft and develop one above average major leaguer (although Olsen shows hope along with Hermida). You are framing the issue again. When you strictly look at drafted, signed, or developed, you conveniently get to leave out Uggla, Willis, etc. Also, you know how baseball works, it's not like football where draft picks make immediate impacts. To expect a handful of all stars that were drafted/developed is crazy. Even his first year draft picks would be hard pressed to be making an impact yet - I think Tankersley, Olsen, and Johnson are all from the early years, in fact. Give some of the young guys time before we say he hasn't grown any all stars. It's basically impossible to have expected him to have done so already - and it's not like we don't have plenty of guys with that kind of potential.
April 15, 200719 yr You are framing the issue again. When you strictly look at drafted, signed, or developed, you conveniently get to leave out Uggla, Willis, etc. There is no "etc" it's Uggla and Willis. That's it. Those are the only Beinfest players that developed here that became all-stars. As for the rest, I say 2004 and 2005 were predominantly his because he actively pared down the roster of Dombrowski guys because of service time issues and extended Castillo and Lowell, conscientously making them "Beinfest guys." There's no if ands or buts about it, 2004 and 2005 were Beinfest's teams. He either traded for or signed the catcher, first-baseman, second-baseman, third-baseman, centerfielder and right-fielder, plus 3 of our 5 starting pitchers (I exclude Penny). The 2003 team was the Dombrowski frame-work with a Beinfest touch, by 2004, Beinfest had his own 4 year plan in motion a plan that he blew up two years in.
April 15, 200719 yr Swift that is an interesting perspective that really had me thinking. I see your pont but the balance that this club has and it's pitching depth is a tribute to the Beinfest organization. Cabrera is a Dombrowski find and I fully agree the Marlins' organization has not excelled in tapping the International Talent Pool (unless you consider Vanden Hurk) There is some aspects of Beinfest that may be considered slightly flawed but the same could be said of Dombrowski. No Beinfest has not found a Cabrera-like player but there is little to argue that Beinfest's moves have been for the most part 100% right on (except the Castillo Trade of course) Dombrowski knows how to build a winning ballclub but so does Beinfest. We have been fotunate to have both
April 16, 200719 yr I'm sorry.. but the restrictions LB has faced and yet still field a quality product is unbelievable. He found his loophole for winning yet being at the bottom of payroll: Take your chance with either a 1 year deal or a heavily backloaded contract.. if its a backloaded mutli-year deal, sell it off for youngsters after a short period. Rinse and repeat with a bunch of young SPs in between. Its the way to do business and there is NO doubt in my mind Admin Beinfest is at the top of the GM crop. No doubt in my mind at all.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.