September 4, 200719 yr Abercrombie should have been replaced with either Baker, Volstad, or Gaby Hernandez.
September 4, 200719 yr Abercrombie should have been replaced with either Baker, Volstad, or Gaby Hernandez. Reggie deserved his promotion (not saying they didnt)
September 5, 200719 yr Baker should be getting the majority of the starts the rest of the season. Completely ridiculous. Don't know why other than a couple folks here like him for whatever reason. His offensive numbers weren't all that great and he fizzled the last month or so. Whoever was called up is not likely to get alot of playing time anyways, and my guess is the team felt Hoover was the best option to do a temporary fill-in just in case we run into another scenario that played out on Sunday. I don't even think Baker is in the long term plans. Hayes seems to have that slot filled. He has been selected to play in the AFL this winter.
September 5, 200719 yr Abercrombie should have been replaced with either Baker, Volstad, or Gaby Hernandez. I like the idea of shutting down Volstadt and Gaby. Hoover wasn't a bad choice and we really don't need 4 catchers on the team. However much Reggie is disliked by alot of our posters dosen't hide the fact he actually deserved this call up. If for nothing else just to see how he reacts to it and see if we need to cut ties there.
September 5, 200719 yr Baker should be getting the majority of the starts the rest of the season. Completely ridiculous. Don't know why other than a couple folks here like him for whatever reason. His offensive numbers weren't all that great and he fizzled the last month or so. Whoever was called up is not likely to get alot of playing time anyways, and my guess is the team felt Hoover was the best option to do a temporary fill-in just in case we run into another scenario that played out on Sunday. I don't even think Baker is in the long term plans. Hayes seems to have that slot filled. He has been selected to play in the AFL this winter. Baker hit .300 in the AFL last year Baker hit .285/.360/.430 he killed righties And, is this what you call fizzling in the last month or so?..... .386/.438/.545 in 44ab oh and he had to deal with pleurisy for nearly 3 weeks in June and it just so happens he hit .196 that month Apparently though, he isn't a "Beinfest guy".... so who knows with him anymore
September 5, 200719 yr What's a Beinfest guy? someone who Beinfest takes a personal liking too and can get away with stuff, or gets better treatment
September 5, 200719 yr Apparently though, he ***Baker*** isn't a "Beinfest guy".... so who knows with him anymore Well he must be someone's guy in the FO because they went out and traded/picked him up twice in two years. I don't know if it's Fleming, Hill or whoever but someone pulled the trigger on those moves. Could it be he was/is in Dean Treanor's doghouse? You would think that if Treanor, who from everything I've read is the consummate FO guy, had lobbied for his callup, it would have happened. It does get curiouser and curiouser.
September 5, 200719 yr What's a Beinfest guy? someone who Beinfest takes a personal liking too and can get away with stuff, or gets better treatment Do Beinfest guys share certain qualities? (Probably what I meant to begin with) Like a Moneyball guy for example.
September 5, 200719 yr Apparently though, he ***Baker*** isn't a "Beinfest guy".... so who knows with him anymore Well he must be someone's guy in the FO because they went out and traded/picked him up twice in two years. I don't know if it's Fleming, Hill or whoever but someone pulled the trigger on those moves. Could it be he was/is in Dean Treanor's doghouse? You would think that if Treanor, who from everything I've read is the consummate FO guy, had lobbied for his callup, it would have happened. It does get curiouser and curiouser. All I know is that Treanor and the FO aren't getting along right now.... don't be surprised if Treanor isn't joining the big club
September 5, 200719 yr What's a Beinfest guy? someone who Beinfest takes a personal liking too and can get away with stuff, or gets better treatment Do Beinfest guys share certain qualities? (Probably what I meant to begin with) Like a Moneyball guy for example. I don't think you can pinpoint a Beinfest guy by stats alone... I don't think there is one quality he must have I think it's more of an underdog type... I dunno how to say it
September 5, 200719 yr What's a Beinfest guy? someone who Beinfest takes a personal liking too and can get away with stuff, or gets better treatment Do Beinfest guys share certain qualities? (Probably what I meant to begin with) Like a Moneyball guy for example. I don't think you can pinpoint a Beinfest guy by stats alone... I don't think there is one quality he must have I think it's more of an underdog type... I dunno how to say it A player who plays above and beyond his abilities? Crap that's all we need, a bunch of David Ecksteins and Darin Erstads on the team.
September 6, 200719 yr Baker should be getting the majority of the starts the rest of the season. Completely ridiculous. Don't know why other than a couple folks here like him for whatever reason. His offensive numbers weren't all that great and he fizzled the last month or so. Whoever was called up is not likely to get alot of playing time anyways, and my guess is the team felt Hoover was the best option to do a temporary fill-in just in case we run into another scenario that played out on Sunday. I don't even think Baker is in the long term plans. Hayes seems to have that slot filled. He has been selected to play in the AFL this winter. Baker hit .300 in the AFL last year Baker hit .285/.360/.430 he killed righties And, is this what you call fizzling in the last month or so?..... .386/.438/.545 in 44ab oh and he had to deal with pleurisy for nearly 3 weeks in June and it just so happens he hit .196 that month Apparently though, he isn't a "Beinfest guy".... so who knows with him anymore Sorry. Quick scanned the stats and just looked at September numbers. My fault on that remark. Regardless...The team seems really high on Hayes. And this call up is just for an insurance policy. Treanor is going to get every opportunity there is to try to nail down that catcher's job for next year. Baker has been given opportunities to nail down at least a back up catcher role and hasn't been able to do so. Don't follow the kid that much (or minor leagues for that matter) so I can only presume it's his defense or the way he handles pitchers that leaves something to be desired. There is evidently some reason Hoover got the call rather than him other than he's "not a Beinfest guy." That just dosen't make sense seeing the history of his travels. All said and done it dosen't really matter except to those that didn't get what they wanted and want to rant a bit about it. He isn't here, he isn't going to be here, and it remains to be seen if he will even be here for ST next year.
September 6, 200719 yr Baker should be getting the majority of the starts the rest of the season. Completely ridiculous. Don't know why other than a couple folks here like him for whatever reason. His offensive numbers weren't all that great and he fizzled the last month or so. Whoever was called up is not likely to get alot of playing time anyways, and my guess is the team felt Hoover was the best option to do a temporary fill-in just in case we run into another scenario that played out on Sunday. I don't even think Baker is in the long term plans. Hayes seems to have that slot filled. He has been selected to play in the AFL this winter. Baker hit .300 in the AFL last year Baker hit .285/.360/.430 he killed righties And, is this what you call fizzling in the last month or so?..... .386/.438/.545 in 44ab oh and he had to deal with pleurisy for nearly 3 weeks in June and it just so happens he hit .196 that month Apparently though, he isn't a "Beinfest guy".... so who knows with him anymore Sorry. Quick scanned the stats and just looked at September numbers. My fault on that remark. Regardless...The team seems really high on Hayes. And this call up is just for an insurance policy. Treanor is going to get every opportunity there is to try to nail down that catcher's job for next year. Baker has been given opportunities to nail down at least a back up catcher role and hasn't been able to do so. Don't follow the kid that much (or minor leagues for that matter) so I can only presume it's his defense or the way he handles pitchers that leaves something to be desired. There is evidently some reason Hoover got the call rather than him other than he's "not a Beinfest guy." That just dosen't make sense seeing the history of his travels. All said and done it dosen't really matter except to those that didn't get what they wanted and want to rant a bit about it. He isn't here, he isn't going to be here, and it remains to be seen if he will even be here for ST next year. What opportunity has he had to nail down the backup catcher role? There is absolutely nothing wrong with his defense and he catches/calls a good game. This isn't just my opinion, I have heard this from various people including Gary Tuck (catching guru with the club). And what is "the history of his travels"? He's been with 2 teams in his career. I like Brett Hayes alot.... but he has done absolutely nothing (save for 65 FSL at bats) with the bat to show he is even worthy of being a 3rd catcher with a team.
September 7, 200719 yr Baker should be getting the majority of the starts the rest of the season. Completely ridiculous. Don't know why other than a couple folks here like him for whatever reason. His offensive numbers weren't all that great and he fizzled the last month or so. Whoever was called up is not likely to get alot of playing time anyways, and my guess is the team felt Hoover was the best option to do a temporary fill-in just in case we run into another scenario that played out on Sunday. I don't even think Baker is in the long term plans. Hayes seems to have that slot filled. He has been selected to play in the AFL this winter. Baker hit .300 in the AFL last year Baker hit .285/.360/.430 he killed righties And, is this what you call fizzling in the last month or so?..... .386/.438/.545 in 44ab oh and he had to deal with pleurisy for nearly 3 weeks in June and it just so happens he hit .196 that month Apparently though, he isn't a "Beinfest guy".... so who knows with him anymore Sorry. Quick scanned the stats and just looked at September numbers. My fault on that remark. Regardless...The team seems really high on Hayes. And this call up is just for an insurance policy. Treanor is going to get every opportunity there is to try to nail down that catcher's job for next year. Baker has been given opportunities to nail down at least a back up catcher role and hasn't been able to do so. Don't follow the kid that much (or minor leagues for that matter) so I can only presume it's his defense or the way he handles pitchers that leaves something to be desired. There is evidently some reason Hoover got the call rather than him other than he's "not a Beinfest guy." That just dosen't make sense seeing the history of his travels. All said and done it dosen't really matter except to those that didn't get what they wanted and want to rant a bit about it. He isn't here, he isn't going to be here, and it remains to be seen if he will even be here for ST next year. What opportunity has he had to nail down the backup catcher role? There is absolutely nothing wrong with his defense and he catches/calls a good game. This isn't just my opinion, I have heard this from various people including Gary Tuck (catching guru with the club). And what is "the history of his travels"? He's been with 2 teams in his career. I like Brett Hayes alot.... but he has done absolutely nothing (save for 65 FSL at bats) with the bat to show he is even worthy of being a 3rd catcher with a team. Opportunity to nail down a back up role would be ST and how open that position was this past Spring. History of his travels means he was picked up twice by us. Meaning the theory of him not being a Beinfest guy is out the window. Admin has the final say and when he was brought back, that just destroys the theory that it must be because Admin dosen't like him as to why Hoover was brought up over him. I did say I don't really know what Baker's catching skills are. I don't watch AAA games. Nor do I follow the minors very closely. I never intended tto mean Hayes should have been brought up. Hayes will be playing in the AFL this season. Simply meant and stated that the team seems to have more interest in Hayes over Baker for the long term. It could be the team felt they owed more to Hoover than they do to Baker and brought him up as a thank you. We have done that before. I really have no idea. And I think it is irrelevant to wah-wah over one player being brought up over another player for a position that is simply for an emergency situation. Such as Olivo starting, being replaced by Treanor in the final inning or 2, getting hurt in a collision at home and not being able to catch after that. Sound familiar? I doubt Hoover gets a start if neither current catcher gets hurt before the final couple of weeks are over. I think Matt is going to get the majority of the starts to see if he can continue at the pace he is at now. Whoever the 3rd catcher is, he is just going to make certain the bench dosen't collect any dust. But hey. If you feel that strongly about it then give Admin a call or email. Be sure to drop some names of all your contacts. Maybe once he sees who is complaining he will change his mind. Good luck with that.
September 7, 200719 yr Stop talking about things you have no clue about. We traded for Baker on March 30th....so that gave him all of what, 3 days to win a spot? But hey. If you feel that strongly about it then give Admin a call or email. Be sure to drop some names of all your contacts. Maybe once he sees who is complaining he will change his mind. Good luck with that. Wow, aren't you a sweaty bag of douche
September 8, 200719 yr Stop talking about things you have no clue about. We traded for Baker on March 30th....so that gave him all of what, 3 days to win a spot? But hey. If you feel that strongly about it then give Admin a call or email. Be sure to drop some names of all your contacts. Maybe once he sees who is complaining he will change his mind. Good luck with that. Wow, aren't you a sweaty bag of douche Nice. No reason to start with the name calling. You have plenty of folks here that really think you are some kind of inside info guru. Live with the fact I am not one of them. I gave plenty of reasons why I think Baker did not get the call. Continue with your on line temper tantrum because they didn't do what you wanted them to do if that is what pleases you. This conversation is over. At least on my part. Go ahead and get your last word in.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.