Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

How about this deal

Featured Replies

Carlos Gomez, Fernando Martinez, Mike Pelfrey, Carlos Beltran, and cash for Johan Santana? Beltran replaces Hunter and they get three very good prospects in Gomez, Martinez, and Pelfrey could develop into the Twins future 3rd starter..

the only reason they cant keep Santana is that they cant afford him.. what makes you think they can take on Beltran's massive salary?

Carlos Gomez, Fernando Martinez, Kevin Slowey, Carlos Beltran, and cash for Johan Santana? Beltran replaces Hunter and they get three very good prospects in Gomez, Martinez, and Slowey.

 

 

You do realize that Kevin Slowey plays for the Minnesota Twins, and the rule in baseball states that a team cannot trade a player from another team to the team that he already plays on, right? For instance, the White Sox can't offer Hanley Ramirez in a package deal for Cabrera.

 

Confusing, I know, but just thought I'd let you know.

  • Author

the only reason they cant keep Santana is that they cant afford him.. what makes you think they can take on Beltran's massive salary?

Mets pay for most of his salary? idk I forgot about that, I heard Santana wants to leave if Hunter leaves.

  • Author

Carlos Gomez, Fernando Martinez, Kevin Slowey, Carlos Beltran, and cash for Johan Santana? Beltran replaces Hunter and they get three very good prospects in Gomez, Martinez, and Slowey.

 

 

You do realize that Kevin Slowey plays for the Minnesota Twins, and the rule in baseball states that a team cannot trade a player from another team to the team that he already plays on, right? For instance, the White Sox can't offer Hanley Ramirez in a package deal for Cabrera.

 

Confusing, I know, but just thought I'd let you know.

oh sh*t I was looking at the wrong roster on bm.

Santana isn't going to cost anyone that much anyway.

 

The Twins are asking the Yankees for Phil Hughes, Melky Cabrera and Austin Jackson. That's not some minor coup, but Cabrera is an average major league CF and AJax has only hit well for 4 months in his entire career. Hughes is/was obviously regarded as the best pitching prospect in baseball, but regardless, it's not nearly what some were claiming that the Twins would demand for Santana (Hughes, Joba Chamberlain, Jose Tabata and Jeff Marquez).

 

I think at the end of the day, you're going to see someone end up with him for a package like the following: Alan Horne, Jeff Marquez, Melky Cabrera and Austin Jackson. I genuinely believe secondary prospects are going to be enough to get a deal done. The Dodgers, Angels and Yankees have a ton of these, and I'd put them as the frontrunners for his services.

 

No one is going to be able to rationalize giving away (again, in the Yankees case) Phil Hughes or (Red Sox case) Clay Buchholz for 250K, who will both probably pitch to around a mid 3-ERA this year or better, to earn the right to sign Johan Santana to the richest contract ever for a pitcher. If any organization does this, they're simply not well-run or have lost their f***ing minds.

 

And I believe you meant Mulvey, not Slowey. You weren't that far off.

still not sure why teams or anyone likes Melky Cabrera

 

he sucks

I love Santana as much as anyone, but he is on a downward trend. The HR total he gave up this year should be a big red flag for a lot of teams before they fork over a ton of coin.

 

I hope the Sox stay the hell away.

I don't know what's worse...

 

 

 

living with the fact that I heckled Joe Kennedy...

 

or

 

being the author of this thread....

I don't know what's worse...

 

 

 

living with the fact that I heckled Joe Kennedy...

 

or

 

being the author of his thread....

:lol

I love Santana as much as anyone, but he is on a downward trend. The HR total he gave up this year should be a big red flag for a lot of teams before they fork over a ton of coin.

 

I hope the Sox stay the hell away.

 

It's hard to dispute that he's had a four-year downward trend as just about every statistical category concurs with this theory.

 

However, anyone who gets him is getting an ace for the next two years. Keep in mind he's coming down from Pedro Martinez-esque dominance to simply being one of the games top 5 starters. I find it hard to believe he won't give someone at least a 3.4 ERA or below next year and the year after.

 

It's not worth the price tag, but it's not my money, and for teams who work on seemingly unlimited budgets, it's really irrelevant whether he's worth 25 million or not.

 

Is he going to be a great pitcher over the entire length of the rumored 6 year deal? It's doubtful, but you're getting an absolute stud for at least the next year or two who you'll be more than happy to go to battle with in game 7 of any playoff series. His decline is a decline from super-human levels. I seriously doubt he'll ever become worse than a 3 in the AL, his decline won't reach those levels, not over the next six years. He's too good.

 

I'd take him on my team anyday, particularly if the price tag can be worked down to secondary prospects only (as I suspect).

Carlos Gomez, Fernando Martinez, Kevin Slowey, Carlos Beltran, and cash for Johan Santana? Beltran replaces Hunter and they get three very good prospects in Gomez, Martinez, and Slowey.

 

 

Why would you do this?

I think putting him at Pedro levels is pretty generous (although I suspect you were just putting that name in there as a comparison) as his 2004 season is the only thing that approached Pedro's level (again, he wasn't at it, he just approached).

 

I would only acquire Santana if I knew he was going to sign an extension with me once the trade went through. That would have to be part of the deal. I don't even want to leave the chance of leaving my dick out flapping in the wind as he leaves your team after one year after you've given up a bunch of prospects.

 

If the Sox could do a deal without giving up Ellsbury or Buchholz (Lowrie + Bowden + etc. + etc.), I'd do it without think about it. If they can't, they need to step away. They've shown they can win it all as constructed and I fully expect them to be better next year, Santana or no Santana.

I think putting him at Pedro levels is pretty generous (although I suspect you were just putting that name in there as a comparison) as his 2004 season is the only thing that approached Pedro's level (again, he wasn't at it, he just approached).

 

I would only acquire Santana if I knew he was going to sign an extension with me once the trade went through. That would have to be part of the deal. I don't even want to leave the chance of leaving my dick out flapping in the wind as he leaves your team after one year after you've given up a bunch of prospects.

 

If the Sox could do a deal without giving up Ellsbury or Buchholz (Lowrie + Bowden + etc. + etc.), I'd do it without think about it. If they can't, they need to step away. They've shown they can win it all as constructed and I fully expect them to be better next year, Santana or no Santana.

 

Pedro was only a comparison in to how far superior he was to his competition over a period. No one has put up Pedro's numbers before in the history of baseball (factoring in the eras).

 

Santana has a full NTC and the speculation is he won't agree to any trade unless an extension is worked out with the team he's going to. He wants security in the deal just as much as the team acquiring him does. Rumor is they're pushing for about 6 years/150 million. A hefty tag that only a select few teams can meet. This is why the Twins are going to get absolutely screwed talent-wise in any deal. Their hands are already tied.

 

I'm not sure the Sox have the B-level prospects to compete in a trading war with the likes of the Angels, Dodgers and Yankees. If they offered Ellsbury they certainly could get a deal done, but while they have 2 elite prospects that match up with anyone, they simply aren't that deep. I find it hard to believe they'd part with him (though IMO, they should if it nets Santana, and Ellsbury is THE major centerpiece with 1-2 fringe prospects). Buchholz should be absolutely untouchable though, and I suspect he is. I really don't see the Sox as suitors unless they part with one of the two and I don't think they're dumb enough to have that happen. I just don't see them winning (or wanting to win) a B-prospect bidding war with the Angels, Dodgers or Yankees.

 

They're too smart and well-run an organization to have that happen. The farm system would be almost entirely barren.

 

Santana would make them undeniable, Patriots-type favorites to win the World Series next year if Santana was acquired, however.

lmao

Mets laugh.

 

no way we trade the best CF in the game, in his prime.

 

 

edit: mulvey you mean?

No one respond to this.

lmao

Mets laugh.

 

no way we trade the best CF in the game, in his prime.

 

 

edit: mulvey you mean?

ROFL

Carlos Gomez, Fernando Martinez, Kevin Slowey, Carlos Beltran, and cash for Johan Santana? Beltran replaces Hunter and they get three very good prospects in Gomez, Martinez, and Slowey.

 

 

You do realize that Kevin Slowey plays for the Minnesota Twins, and the rule in baseball states that a team cannot trade a player from another team to the team that he already plays on, right? For instance, the White Sox can't offer Hanley Ramirez in a package deal for Cabrera.

 

Confusing, I know, but just thought I'd let you know.

Fantastic.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.