August 18, 200818 yr Author The yankees have ten times the payroll we have, but last time i checked we beat them in the world series in 03. Payroll dont mean sh!t. If payroll truly meant nothing, why are the teams with high payrolls consistently over .500 every year, while the ones without, aren't? Because teams like the Royals and Pirates are run by idiots or stiffs who refuse to spend money. Now you can look at small market teams with continual success, like the Twins and Athletics. Obviously, have a lot of money to throw around HELPS. But as you notice, the teams with higher payrolls are also owned by people completely dedicated to winning. Who were the Angels before their current ownership? Case in point. That is all I'm saying. If people don't understand that, they're missing the point. Is it the be-all end-all? Obviously not or we don't win a WS in 2003. But its a factor, one that a lot of people are just far too quick to dismiss. I guess since its not really an option for our team, its easier for some not to even consider it. EDIT: No need for us to spend like the Yankees. But if we could just spend 40-50 million a year (still near the bottom of the league), we could keep pretty much any can't miss players (like Hanley), while still grooming prospects and other role players as well. If our payroll was 40 million, instead of debating whether to trade Uggla, we could be debating whether to trade Coghlan for another impact position player or reliever.
August 18, 200818 yr The yankees have ten times the payroll we have, but last time i checked we beat them in the world series in 03. Payroll dont mean sh!t. If payroll truly meant nothing, why are the teams with high payrolls consistently over .500 every year, while the ones without, aren't? Because teams like the Royals and Pirates are run by idiots or stiffs who refuse to spend money. Now you can look at small market teams with continual success, like the Twins and Athletics. Obviously, have a lot of money to throw around HELPS. But as you notice, the teams with higher payrolls are also owned by people completely dedicated to winning. Who were the Angels before their current ownership? Case in point. That is all I'm saying. If people don't understand that, they're missing the point. Is it the be-all end-all? Obviously not or we don't win a WS in 2003. But its a factor, one that a lot of people are just far too quick to dismiss. I guess since its not really an option for our team, its easier for some not to even consider it. EDIT: No need for us to spend like the Yankees. But if we could just spend 40-50 million a year (still near the bottom of the league), we could keep pretty much any can't miss players (like Hanley), while still grooming prospects and other role players as well. If our payroll was 40 million, instead of debating whether to trade Uggla, we could be debating whether to trade Coghlan for another impact position player or reliever. not even 40 more like 25-30 mill if we play our cards right
August 18, 200818 yr Payroll has nothing to do with the decision about whether to keep Uggla or not. Quite frankly the only guy one this team who deserved the contract was Hanley, and he got it. The front office is right on the mark so far. None of these other guys have proven it.
August 18, 200818 yr Payroll has nothing to do with the decision about whether to keep Uggla or not. to the marlins FO yes it is it soehow always is about money
August 18, 200818 yr Author Payroll has nothing to do with the decision about whether to keep Uggla or not. Quite frankly the only guy one this team who deserved the contract was Hanley, and he got it. The front office is right on the mark so far. None of these other guys have proven it. lol. Uggla is going to have to be paid. The Marlins probably do not want to pay him what he will get through arbitration. They have a cheaper but unproven guy waiting in the wings (Coghlan). Payroll has EVERYTHING to do with whether we keep Uggla. If we could afford it, he WOULD be on the team next year, almost guaranteed. He may not be the long term second baseman, but we wouldn't just cut our ties with him either. Payroll limitations are what makes us even have to consider Coghlan right now, not play on the field.
August 18, 200818 yr I forget most of the time what the payroll is. I'm not sure when I look at how many signings blow up in the faces of so many front offices every year that even a $40 million payroll would have changed where we are today. Would I have done some things differently? Sure. But since I have about 5% of the information and back story the front office has I have to defer to them. Dallas McPherson isn't up here for a reason. Dan Uggla isn't on the DL (or coming off it) for a reason. They didn't just wake up one morning and decide to screw Justin Miller and send him packing, especially with Waechtner on the DL. You have to think it had more to do with his slider being flat as a pancake more than anything else. If you want to make an argument the front office is incompetent you can but you do so at the risk of looking ridiculous when all the facts are in. They take the data they have and do the best they can with it. Sometimes things work and sometimes they don't. I'm willing to bet that if the FO had any indication it would take Uggla this long to recover they would have DLed him before the ASG but they didn't and we all know why - because Phil Garner played every single position player he had in 2006 and left Uggla on the bench in humilation, and Clint Hurdle let Uggla know that wouldn't be the case in 2008 (even though it blew up in Uggla's face). There's an old saying, "The road to hell is paved with good intentions". We are where we are. We have six weeks left. We finish with three games in NYC vs the Mets. I'm not throwing in the towel and I don't think anyone ought to be either. Oh, did I mention Billy Wagner's pitching arm is so stiff after throwing 20 pitches today in rehab the scuttlebut is he may be done for the season? Sh*t happens. Stay tuned. I dunno what Uggla coming back from injury early has to do with the Yankees having 10 times our payroll. I'm just saying its a little bit frustrating to watch guys who are absolutely ideal at their positions like Derrek Lee, Edgar Renteria, Josh Beckett and Kevin Brown go on to have wonderful productive careers elsewhere, while we struggle to find a prospect that comes close to what they gave us every time, just so we can spend less money. I agree, although I have to point out that we flipped Kevin Brown for Derrek Lee, and flipped Josh Beckett for Hanley. That didn't work out so badly.
August 18, 200818 yr Yes you are lacking and yes iIwill share with you. You want to sign players who have to outperform their 2009 contracts by 150% to make it worth signing them. Adam Dunn, $13 million, his entire career in the National League, approx 50 at bats at Dolphin Stadium in the last four years - homeruns - *one*. I could have gone back through his entire career to see how many he hit here by after *one* in four years I don't need to do much more research. Even if he gets less than last year, say $ 9million instead of $13, is he worth it to the Marlins? Of course not. In order for his contract to bring value to this team he has to outperform that contract. If he hits 32 hrs (so far) with half his games played in the bandbox of all bandbox stadiums in Cincy and he he hits *one* here in four years, how many does he have to hit here (when he isn't striking out at a rate of 170 times a season) to make that $9 million pay off for the Marlins? The answer? It will never be enough. Mark Texiera, 29 next season, great player, makes $12.5 million this season. Free agent next. Cashing in big time. Let's say conservatively $15 million for five years. $75 million. Think Gary Matthews Jr. He was going to be the answer to the Angels problems in CF. Signed for 5 years at the top of his game. This season he's hitting .220-ish and playing part-time. Think Juan Pierre (who I love) signed at the top of his game and 100%+ value. Carl Pavano. AJ Burnett. Even Derrek Lee. You think those 17 homeruns (let's give him 22+/- for 2008) would be worth $13+ million to the Marlins? They're barely worth it to the Cubs and they sell out every game. If the Cubs could replace Lee is with a good glove 1B man with 15-18 homeruns for $400,000 a year they'd do it in a heartbeat. You are looking at players and a) expecting that they will always have great seasons and b) be worth what they're paid. That is a longshot. The chances are if you look at similar players signed over the last few years, neither will outperform their contracts, especially Dunn, who is a .211/.298 waiting to happen. The Marlins are not a team that can afford, literally or figuratively, players who underperform their contracts. And more and more, a lot of other teams are learning the same lesson. You are making a false leap of faith. If we pay MT $15 million a year, he will produce, he will stay healthy, the sun will come up in the morning and the birds will sing and all will be right with the world. A team like the Angels can afford to deal with MT being out for eight weeks with a torn hamstring, the Marlins, and most MLB teams can't, not with $15 mil per on the line. You also don't seem to respect the money. You are more than willing to spend someone elses $20 million because it isn't yours. Are you starting to get the picture? If you want to spend $20 million and pray for the best possible outcome. You don't put it into one or maybe 1 1/2 players. You trade for a guy who is entering his arb years with the credentials to pay him $ 5million next season, another guy you sign for three years $20 million, etc. I'm sorry if you think I am a jerk but I bet you didn't spend one second looking at Adam Dunn's numbers or how he's performed here at Dolphin Stadium, where he would be playing 81 games next season if you had your way. or the trends in his numbers. You want to propose trades, I'm all for it but use your head, look at some stats, try to figure out who has the chance of giving you more than your money's worth not a couple of guys who, for different reasons, have great names but don't fit, or even if they potentially did who have to have back to back career years to make it worthwhile.
August 18, 200818 yr Author Yes you are lacking and yes iIwill share with you. You want to sign players who have to outperform their 2009 contracts by 150% to make it worth signing them. Adam Dunn, $13 million, his entire career in the National League, approx 50 at bats at Dolphin Stadium in the last four years - homeruns - zero. I could have gone back through his entire career to see how many he hit here by after zero in four years I don't need to do much more research. Even if he gets less than last year, say $ 9million instead of $13, is he worth it to the Marlins? Of course not. In order for his contract to bring value to this team he has to outperform that contract. If he hits 32 hrs (so far) with half his games played in the bandbox of all bandbox stadiums in Cincy and he he hits zero here in four years, how many does he have to hit here (when he isn't striking out at a rate of 170 times a season) to make that $9 million pay off for the Marlins? The answer? It will never be enough. Mark Texiera, 29 next season, great player, makes $12.5 million this season. Free agent next. Cashing in big time. Let's say conservatively $15 million for five years. $75 million. Think Gary Matthews Jr. He was going to be the answer to the Angels problems in CF. Signed for 5 years at the top of his game. This season he's hitting .220-ish and playing part-time. Think Juan Pierre (who I love) signed at the top of his game and 100%+ value. Carl Pavano. AJ Burnett. Even Derrek Lee. You think those 17 homeruns (let's give him 22+/- for 2008) would be worth $13+ million to the Marlins? They're barely worth it to the Cubs and they sell out every game. If the Cubs could replace Lee is with a good glove 1B man with 15-18 homeruns for $400,000 a year they'd do it in a heartbeat. You are looking at players and a) expecting that they will always have great seasons and b) be worth what they're paid. That is a longshot. The chances are if you look at similar players signed over the last few years, neither will outperform their contracts, especially Dunn, who is a .211/.298 waiting to happen. The Marlins are not a team that can afford, literally or figuratively, players who underperform their contracts. And more and more, a lot of other teams are learning the same lesson. You are making a false leap of faith. If we pay MT $15 million a year, he will produce, he will stay healthy, the sun will come up in the morning and the birds will sing and all will be right with the world. A team like the Angels can afford to deal with MT being out for eight weeks with a torn hamstring, the Marlins, and most MLB teams can't, not with $15 mil per on the line. You also don't seem to respect the money. You are more than willing to spend someone elses $20 million because it isn't yours. Are you starting to get the picture? If you want to spend $20 million and pray for the best possible outcome. You don't put it into one or maybe 1 1/2 players. You trade for a guy who is entering his arb years with the credentials to pay him $ 5million next season, another guy you sign for three years $20 million, etc. I'm sorry if you think I am a jerk but I bet you didn't spend one second looking at Adam Dunn's numbers or how he's performed here at Dolphin Stadium, where he would be playing 81 games next season if you had your way. or the trends in his numbers. You want to propose trades, I'm all for it but use your head, look at some stats, try to figure out who has the chance of giving you more than your money's worth not a couple of guys who, for different reasons, have great names but don't fit, or even if they potentially did who have to have back to back career years to make it worthwhile. Dunn and Texiera were just 2 examples, I'm not dead set on getting either guy (and you could tear apart any FA acquisition like that if you really felt like it). You totally misunderstood me, the point was that we could spend just a little bit of money and still be at a below average payroll but be ready to compete next year, and it would be less of a gamble than hoping and praying that some prospects will pan out. Dunn and Texiera were placeholders, pick any 2 guys you would like to get in free agency that raises our payroll to 40 million instead, including our own players. The rest of your post is just saying what we already know, that we are a cash strapped franchise that has to be smart about its moves to put together a good team. Wouldn't it be nice if for a change, instead of picking just the right prospects, and lucking into a guy having a breakout year, we could spend some money for a guy that is a bit more of a sure thing to improve the ballclub? Sometimes counting on youth gets you a year like 2006 or 2003. More often than not, it looks like 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2007. And its not as if you pay a guy and then he becomes untradable, there is almost always a New York or a Boston looking to take away your overpaid players at the deadline once they come up with an injury.
August 18, 200818 yr I didn't misunderstand anything you said, you just want to walk away from what you said like you never said it. Those were your guys, not mine. I'm not looking to tear apart your ideas or anything like that. What you missed is the suggestion you have the ability to come up with better ideas if you just do a little research before you offer up ones like those. I seldom post without checking Cots and stats on ESPN or elsewhere because it's so easy to do so. If you don't know what Cot's is, it's the definitive baseball contract database ( http://mlbcontracts.blogspot.com/ ) it's a great resource. It has every MLB contract, service time, etc. Don't leave home without it.
August 18, 200818 yr Author I didn't misunderstand anything you said, you just want to walk away from what you said like you never said it. Those were your guys, not mine. I'm not looking to tear apart your ideas or anything like that. What you missed is the suggestion you have the ability to come up with better ideas if you just do a little research before you offer up ones like those. I seldom post without checking Cots and stats on ESPN or elsewhere because it's so easy to do so. If you don't know what Cot's is, it's the definitive baseball contract database ( http://mlbcontracts.blogspot.com/ ) it's a great resource. It has every MLB contract, service time, etc. Don't leave home without it. OK, I'm sorry I'm not such a baseball nerd that I don't look up every players splits when playing at DS before I consider them as an option for my ballclub. They were offhand suggestions to make the point that we could improve the payroll only to average to improve the ballclub, not my #1 wishlist for the ballclub. I don't even like Dunn! The only guy I really wanted was Texiera (even mentioned it at the deadline). The only reason I used Dunn in my example was because I couldn't think of another outfielder off the top of my head, and don't have a website with list of outfield free agents in my favorites. The point is, you can spend just a small amount more, still have a low payroll, and increase your odds of competing rather than continuing to gamble with unrpoven prospects (although I realize its not going to happen at least until we get a stadium). So continue to attack a point I never intended to defend if it makes you feel better.
August 18, 200818 yr Payroll has nothing to do with the decision about whether to keep Uggla or not. Quite frankly the only guy one this team who deserved the contract was Hanley, and he got it. The front office is right on the mark so far. None of these other guys have proven it. lol. Uggla is going to have to be paid. The Marlins probably do not want to pay him what he will get through arbitration. They have a cheaper but unproven guy waiting in the wings (Coghlan). Payroll has EVERYTHING to do with whether we keep Uggla. If we could afford it, he WOULD be on the team next year, almost guaranteed. He may not be the long term second baseman, but we wouldn't just cut our ties with him either. Payroll limitations are what makes us even have to consider Coghlan right now, not play on the field. No, the reason we are considering Coghlan is because Uggla has major, major flaws in his game, and signing him to a deal would be bad for the health of the team. Not only does he have major flaws, but he doesn't really make any effort to correct those flaws. He's also not a smart ball player by any means. Coghlan may not be that great of a player, but Uggla sure isn't a complete player. He's about as one dimensional as they come.
August 18, 200818 yr Author Payroll has nothing to do with the decision about whether to keep Uggla or not. Quite frankly the only guy one this team who deserved the contract was Hanley, and he got it. The front office is right on the mark so far. None of these other guys have proven it. lol. Uggla is going to have to be paid. The Marlins probably do not want to pay him what he will get through arbitration. They have a cheaper but unproven guy waiting in the wings (Coghlan). Payroll has EVERYTHING to do with whether we keep Uggla. If we could afford it, he WOULD be on the team next year, almost guaranteed. He may not be the long term second baseman, but we wouldn't just cut our ties with him either. Payroll limitations are what makes us even have to consider Coghlan right now, not play on the field. No, the reason we are considering Coghlan is because Uggla has major, major flaws in his game, and signing him to a deal would be bad for the health of the team. Not only does he have major flaws, but he doesn't really make any effort to correct those flaws. He's also not a smart ball player by any means. Coghlan may not be that great of a player, but Uggla sure isn't a complete player. He's about as one dimensional as they come. Thats why Coghlan is the long term answer. In the short term, including next year, Uggla is clearly the better option, and if we could spend the money to keep him (at least in the short term), we would, without question.
August 18, 200818 yr Yes, but on the other hand, if you know that Uggla isn't going to be around, you have to trade him while his value is highest.
August 18, 200818 yr holy sh*t just found out Coughlin has speed and can bat 300 hes the future 2 hitter but i still wanna give uggla 1 more year
August 18, 200818 yr Author Yes, but on the other hand, if you know that Uggla isn't going to be around, you have to trade him while his value is highest. Well that is if we knew Coghlan really was the answer. We don't though... and if Coghlan ends up a bust, we wind up like most other teams at second base, with a guy who is probably a mediocre hitter that can at least field the position. At least with Uggla, you are guaranteed excellent power and production from a normally weak position. And I wouldn't say its so cut and dry that Uggla is not the long term answer... but for our purposes, with our payroll restrictions, yeah, he probably won't be around that long, and yeah, in that case we should trade him at peak value.
August 18, 200818 yr Yes, but on the other hand, if you know that Uggla isn't going to be around, you have to trade him while his value is highest. Well that is if we knew Coghlan really was the answer. We don't though... and if Coghlan ends up a bust, we wind up like most other teams at second base, with a guy who is probably a mediocre hitter that can at least field the position. At least with Uggla, you are guaranteed excellent power and production from a normally weak position. And I wouldn't say its so cut and dry that Uggla is not the long term answer... but for our purposes, with our payroll restrictions, yeah, he probably won't be around that long, and yeah, in that case we should trade him at peak value. that would be alfredo or dino
August 18, 200818 yr The one thing that worries me about coghlan is his defense. Uggla isnt a gold glover, but he has been good. Coghlan isnt a good defender, he's terrible actually.
August 18, 200818 yr The one thing that worries me about coghlan is his defense. Uggla isnt a gold glover, but he has been good. Coghlan isnt a good defender, he's terrible actually. ahh shitters thats not in his scouting report would you say worse than jacobs defense or go through legs and makes easy plays looks dificult but hey if hes bad at defense he fits in with every1 else in the infield at times
August 18, 200818 yr The one thing that worries me about coghlan is his defense. Uggla isnt a gold glover, but he has been good. Coghlan isnt a good defender, he's terrible actually. ahh shitters thats not in his scouting report would you say worse than jacobs defense or go through legs and makes easy plays looks dificult but hey if hes bad at defense he fits in with every1 else in the infield at times its up there with jacobs. Last time i checked he had 16 errors.
August 18, 200818 yr The one thing that worries me about coghlan is his defense. Uggla isnt a gold glover, but he has been good. Coghlan isnt a good defender, he's terrible actually. ahh shitters thats not in his scouting report would you say worse than jacobs defense or go through legs and makes easy plays looks dificult but hey if hes bad at defense he fits in with every1 else in the infield at times its up there with jacobs. Last time i checked he had 16 errors. ok thats where most of our infielders are right now thats a reason to keep uggs 1 more yea we can give Chris Coghlan another year in the mionors to work and that and hopefully hes good to go
August 18, 200818 yr The one thing that worries me about coghlan is his defense. Uggla isnt a gold glover, but he has been good. Coghlan isnt a good defender, he's terrible actually. ahh shitters thats not in his scouting report would you say worse than jacobs defense or go through legs and makes easy plays looks dificult but hey if hes bad at defense he fits in with every1 else in the infield at times its up there with jacobs. Last time i checked he had 16 errors. ok thats where most of our infielders are right now thats a reason to keep uggs 1 more yea we can give Chris Coghlan another year in the mionors to work and that and hopefully hes good to go So we're going to pay the 7 or 8 million dollars in arbitration money to Uggla, only to keep him for one more year?
August 18, 200818 yr The one thing that worries me about coghlan is his defense. Uggla isnt a gold glover, but he has been good. Coghlan isnt a good defender, he's terrible actually. ahh shitters thats not in his scouting report would you say worse than jacobs defense or go through legs and makes easy plays looks dificult but hey if hes bad at defense he fits in with every1 else in the infield at times its up there with jacobs. Last time i checked he had 16 errors. ok thats where most of our infielders are right now thats a reason to keep uggs 1 more yea we can give Chris Coghlan another year in the mionors to work and that and hopefully hes good to go So we're going to pay the 7 or 8 million dollars in arbitration money to Uggla, only to keep him for one more year? yes sign him the 3 years 15 mil he wants and trade him in year 2 idk why but i just want to see what he really can do when hes matured
August 18, 200818 yr yes sign him the 3 years 15 mil he wants and trade him in year 2 idk why but i just want to see what he really can do when hes matured He probably wants a little more...but I guess that could work.
August 18, 200818 yr yes sign him the 3 years 15 mil he wants and trade him in year 2 idk why but i just want to see what he really can do when hes matured He probably wants a little more...but I guess that could work. yea like 20 mill is what he wants but that wont matter if we deal him the next year
August 18, 200818 yr yes sign him the 3 years 15 mil he wants and trade him in year 2 idk why but i just want to see what he really can do when hes matured He probably wants a little more...but I guess that could work. yea like 20 mill is what he wants but that wont matter if we deal him the next year The thing is, I dont think Loria would want to pay Uggla the 7 or 8 mil for next season, which is why I think this is his last year as a Marlin.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.