Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Is it ok to blame it on the payroll?

Featured Replies

I have to be honest, when things go wrong for the Fish, I do have a tendency to bitch and moan about baseball's economic structure. Is that fair, or should we just root for what we have, and accept that its going to be this way?

 

Personally, I've always thought the payrolls in baseball were a huge problem. I felt like that back in 1997 even, because I could see the writing on the wall then. Certain teams were inflating their payrolls by huge amounts, even the Marlins to some extent, and with no cap, there was no stopping teams from buying every player out there. I can't even imagine the NBA or the NFL operating without a cap.

 

There is a reason a baseball player has the highest salary of any of the 3 major sports leagues, even while obviously MLB is not the #1 sport.

It's too late for a salary cap but I think a salary floor would be a good idea. Let the $kankee$ and Red$ox pay as much as they want but force the Marlins to spend at least $50 million to stay competitive. I think that would work.

Teams with low payroll can still compete if they have good scouts and a good GM like we do. However, it would be nice to able able to add a star player here and there to help our current team and put them over the top. It also would have been nice to keep a player like Miggy.

Also, one can't help but wonder how good this team would be if they operated like a normal MLB franchise and had at least a middle of the pack payroll with the great GM and talent scouts.

You blame the payroll, you may as well not even bother with this team, because they are never going to spend the money that other teams do.

  • Author

You blame the payroll, you may as well not even bother with this team, because they are never going to spend the money that other teams do.

 

OK I guess I should just close my browser and change the channel, no more Marlins for me ever again. lol.

 

Seriously, is it not OK to vent on aspects of the game you don't like but accept it at the same time? Are you telling me that every Marlins fan NEVER blames the payroll, they're all just loyal fans of the game who don't care at all? Its possible to care and still be a fan at the same time, you know.

Teams with low payroll can still compete if they have good scouts and a good GM like we do. However, it would be nice to able able to add a star player here and there to help our current team and put them over the top. It also would have been nice to keep a player like Miggy.

I agree with you. The payroll situation hurts when we can't add pieces that would make a difference. Clearly it is not necessary to have the Yankees' payroll to be successful but our payroll has gone ridiculously low. We are much too far beneath every other team and of course that hurts us.

The Yankees have built up their cash wad, their fanbase, their millions of dollars. Why shouldn't they be allowed to spend their money as they like? Baseball is a business and its not a real good idea to cap rewards for success. Other teams are essentially saying "We suck at running our fanchise, someone please give us a free ride!" How about running your franchise better? Its not IMPOSSIBLE to compete with other markets, you just have to be SMART about it.

The Yankees have built up their cash wad, their fanbase, their millions of dollars. Why shouldn't they be allowed to spend their money as they like? Baseball is a business and its not a real good idea to cap rewards for success. Other teams are essentially saying "We suck at running our fanchise, someone please give us a free ride!" How about running your franchise better? Its not IMPOSSIBLE to compete with other markets, you just have to be SMART about it.

 

 

+1 :notworthy

I forget most of the time what the payroll is. I'm not sure when I look at how many signings blow up in the faces of so many front offices every year that even a $40 million payroll would have changed where we are today.

 

Would I have done some things differently? Sure. But since I have about 5% of the information and back story the front office has I have to defer to them.

 

Dallas McPherson isn't up here for a reason. Dan Uggla isn't on the DL (or coming off it) for a reason. They didn't just wake up one morning and decide to screw Justin Miller and send him packing, especially with Waechtner on the DL. You have to think it had more to do with his slider being flat as a pancake more than anything else.

 

If you want to make an argument the front office is incompetent you can but you do so at the risk of looking ridiculous when all the facts are in. They take the data they have and do the best they can with it. Sometimes things work and sometimes they don't.

 

I'm willing to bet that if the FO had any indication it would take Uggla this long to recover they would have DLed him before the ASG but they didn't and we all know why - because Phil Garner played every single position player he had in 2006 and left Uggla on the bench in humilation, and Clint Hurdle let Uggla know that wouldn't be the case in 2008 (even though it blew up in Uggla's face).

 

There's an old saying, "The road to hell is paved with good intentions".

 

We are where we are. We have six weeks left. We finish with three games in NYC vs the Mets. I'm not throwing in the towel and I don't think anyone ought to be either.

 

Oh, did I mention Billy Wagner's pitching arm is so stiff after throwing 20 pitches today in rehab the scuttlebut is he may be done for the season? Sh*t happens. Stay tuned.

  • Author

I forget most of the time what the payroll is. I'm not sure when I look at how many signings blow up in the faces of so many front offices every year that even a $40 million payroll would have changed where we are today.

 

Would I have done some things differently? Sure. But since I have about 5% of the information and back story the front office has I have to defer to them.

 

Dallas McPherson isn't up here for a reason. Dan Uggla isn't on the DL (or coming off it) for a reason. They didn't just wake up one morning and decide to screw Justin Miller and send him packing, especially with Waechtner on the DL. You have to think it had more to do with his slider being flat as a pancake more than anything else.

 

If you want to make an argument the front office is incompetent you can but you do so at the risk of looking ridiculous when all the facts are in. They take the data they have and do the best they can with it. Sometimes things work and sometimes they don't.

 

I'm willing to bet that if the FO had any indication it would take Uggla this long to recover they would have DLed him before the ASG but they didn't and we all know why - because Phil Garner played every single position player he had in 2006 and left Uggla on the bench in humilation, and Clint Hurdle let Uggla know that wouldn't be the case in 2008 (even though it blew up in Uggla's face).

 

There's an old saying, "The road to hell is paved with good intentions".

 

We are where we are. We have six weeks left. We finish with three games in NYC vs the Mets. I'm not throwing in the towel and I don't think anyone ought to be either.

 

Oh, did I mention Billy Wagner's pitching arm is so stiff after throwing 20 pitches today in rehab the scuttlebut is he may be done for the season? Sh*t happens. Stay tuned.

 

I dunno what Uggla coming back from injury early has to do with the Yankees having 10 times our payroll. I'm just saying its a little bit frustrating to watch guys who are absolutely ideal at their positions like Derrek Lee, Edgar Renteria, Josh Beckett and Kevin Brown go on to have wonderful productive careers elsewhere, while we struggle to find a prospect that comes close to what they gave us every time, just so we can spend less money.

If these guys made what they deserve to make, then our payroll would be much bigger than it is. Also, since we have proven that we can win with a small payroll, Im not really bothered by it.

No, it's not.

 

At the end of the day, Loria gets more through revenue sharing from the big market teams than he has spent on this team.

 

...and payroll means very little. Just look at the Tigers...or even the Yankees. It's not about how much money you spend, but rather how you spend it.

 

I'm just thankful for good scouts, and a good GM, that have kept this team competitive, despite a dreadful payroll.

 

Blaming it on payroll, would be like feeling sorry for the organization. And I'm not a big Jeffrey Loria fan, to do that...

The payroll plays a huge part. We wouldn't be sticking with Hermida, Willingham, and Jacobs if it didn't. Hopefully next year we will sign them via arbitration and then trade them for whatever we can get. They have had their chance to prove they can be relied upon, and they have failed. And if Uggla continues to strugle....we need to re-think his future with the Marlins as well.

  • Author

Here is my issue for those saying who cares about the payroll.

 

First of all, your scouts aren't ALWAYS going to be better than the other teams scouts. And if thats your main defense, its a pretty lame one.

 

Second, if we were to just have a normal sized payroll, we could replace Jacobs with Texiera, Willingham with Dunn, and fill out our bullpen in the offseason, and be World Series contenders next year. Instead we will have to wait on more prospects to grow up.

 

Have I accepted its going to be like this at least til we get a new stadium? Obviously, or I wouldn't be a Marlins fan.

 

Am I envious we can't just buy whoever we want like the Yankees or Red Sox? No, I think they run their ballclubs terribly (well much moreso the Yankees).

 

Do I wish we could just spend enough to keep the players we really want? YES!!!! But we can't even do that, in most cases. God forbid they ever have to trade Hanley.

The yankees have ten times the payroll we have, but last time i checked we beat them in the world series in 03. Payroll dont mean sh!t.

 

although, i voted its not fair lol. i just wanna see the marlins go after one big named free agent because ive never seen them do so.

  • Author

The yankees have ten times the payroll we have, but last time i checked we beat them in the world series in 03. Payroll dont mean sh!t.

 

If payroll truly meant nothing, why are the teams with high payrolls consistently over .500 every year, while the ones without, aren't?

 

The playoffs and World Series, anyone who is hot can win. That is why the Wild Card winner has done it so many times. But in order to maintain success year in and year out, you have to spend money.

 

Even though they almost never got hot at the right time, the Braves are a perfect example of a team who has done a great job scouting, but still willing to spend the money it takes to keep a competitive team together year in and year out.

Here is my issue for those saying who cares about the payroll.

 

First of all, your scouts aren't ALWAYS going to be better than the other teams scouts. And if thats your main defense, its a pretty lame one.

 

Second, if we were to just have a normal sized payroll, we could replace Jacobs with Texiera, Willingham with Dunn, and fill out our bullpen in the offseason, and be World Series contenders next year. Instead we will have to wait on more prospects to grow up.

 

Have I accepted its going to be like this at least til we get a new stadium? Obviously, or I wouldn't be a Marlins fan.

 

Am I envious we can't just buy whoever we want like the Yankees or Red Sox? No, I think they run their ballclubs terribly (well much moreso the Yankees).

 

Do I wish we could just spend enough to keep the players we really want? YES!!!! But we can't even do that, in most cases. God forbid they ever have to trade Hanley.

 

Did you figure all this out on your PlayStation?

  • Author

Here is my issue for those saying who cares about the payroll.

 

First of all, your scouts aren't ALWAYS going to be better than the other teams scouts. And if thats your main defense, its a pretty lame one.

 

Second, if we were to just have a normal sized payroll, we could replace Jacobs with Texiera, Willingham with Dunn, and fill out our bullpen in the offseason, and be World Series contenders next year. Instead we will have to wait on more prospects to grow up.

 

Have I accepted its going to be like this at least til we get a new stadium? Obviously, or I wouldn't be a Marlins fan.

 

Am I envious we can't just buy whoever we want like the Yankees or Red Sox? No, I think they run their ballclubs terribly (well much moreso the Yankees).

 

Do I wish we could just spend enough to keep the players we really want? YES!!!! But we can't even do that, in most cases. God forbid they ever have to trade Hanley.

 

Did you figure all this out on your PlayStation?

 

Do you even have a reply besides a sarcastic remark? Please, share with me some of your baseball knowledge, since I seem to be so lacking. Oh I'm sorry, because I suggested a roster move that could improve the ballclub, I'm just a stupid fan that makes video game trades to improve the ballclub. Like thats so much different than someone saying, "If the starters stay healthy and Maybin and Coghlan develop into All-Stars, we're World Series contenders!".

 

The difference being, my suggestion involves the front office taking a chance and spending some cash. Oh heavens no! A 40-50 million payroll, still among the lowest in baseball, whatever will we do?

The yankees have ten times the payroll we have, but last time i checked we beat them in the world series in 03. Payroll dont mean sh!t.

 

If payroll truly meant nothing, why are the teams with high payrolls consistently over .500 every year, while the ones without, aren't?

 

Because teams like the Royals and Pirates are run by idiots or stiffs who refuse to spend money.

 

Now you can look at small market teams with continual success, like the Twins and Athletics.

 

Obviously, have a lot of money to throw around HELPS. But as you notice, the teams with higher payrolls are also owned by people completely dedicated to winning. Who were the Angels before their current ownership? Case in point.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.