August 18, 200818 yr A salary floor would hurt us more than anything because all it would do is force us to over inflate the salaries of the players we have. That is a flat out awful suggestion. And Adam Dunn would be an awesome baseball player anywhere he played. A 50 at bat sample size doesn't change that.
August 19, 200818 yr Even if the economics of baseball were to increase revenue sharing or somehow be more friendly to small market teams, the Marlins wouldn't be in much better position than they are. It would merely help teams like Pittsburgh, with a new revenue-generating stadium, or Minnesota, with a supportive fan base, or Milwaukee with both. We have neither. The answer is to make Marlins a team in which an investment in a good player actually nets some benefit to the team's owner.
August 19, 200818 yr Even if the economics of baseball were to increase revenue sharing or somehow be more friendly to small market teams, the Marlins wouldn't be in much better position than they are. It would merely help teams like Pittsburgh, with a new revenue-generating stadium, or Minnesota, with a supportive fan base, or Milwaukee with both. We have neither. The answer is to make Marlins a team in which an investment in a good player actually nets some benefit to the team's owner. I some times wonder if you are a front office plant, as there is no way you can actually believe half of the stuff you say.
August 19, 200818 yr Even if the economics of baseball were to increase revenue sharing or somehow be more friendly to small market teams, the Marlins wouldn't be in much better position than they are. It would merely help teams like Pittsburgh, with a new revenue-generating stadium, or Minnesota, with a supportive fan base, or Milwaukee with both. We have neither. The answer is to make Marlins a team in which an investment in a good player actually nets some benefit to the team's owner. I think you have it all wrong. :confused
August 19, 200818 yr I believe the Marlins will try to sign all their arbitration eligible players and then try to trade some of them to be replaced with minor leaguers or with the player they received in the trade. It is very attractive to other teams to have a player's salary already determined before they trade for him, and this will benefit the Marlins in the trade. I personally don't have a clue what the front office will do over the winter, but we need better defense, less strike outs and more speed. I hope we get rid of Jacobs and Hermida. I have a feeling they're as good as they're going to get and that's not good enough to take us anywhere. Willingham will probably hurt his back again soon and is a poor left fielder. Uggla's fantastic offensive first half does not make up for the second half he is having. Horrible OBP and too many K's. Our minor league options: Gaby Sanchez (1B), Chris Coghaln (2B), John Raynor(LF), Dallas Mc Pherson(3B), Robert Andino (2B) Maybin is not ready yet. Trade for: catcher, CF and RF The good news: Our starting pitching should be in great shape.
August 19, 200818 yr Fanfish, I was sure how to read what you wrote - are you suggesting Maybin won't be ready in 2009 (?) since the thrust of your post was about transactions that take place in the off-season leading up to 2009.
August 19, 200818 yr You blame the payroll, you may as well not even bother with this team, because they are never going to spend the money that other teams do. yup. thats all that needs to be said
August 19, 200818 yr Even if the economics of baseball were to increase revenue sharing or somehow be more friendly to small market teams, the Marlins wouldn't be in much better position than they are. It would merely help teams like Pittsburgh, with a new revenue-generating stadium, or Minnesota, with a supportive fan base, or Milwaukee with both. We have neither. The answer is to make Marlins a team in which an investment in a good player actually nets some benefit to the team's owner. I think you have it all wrong. :confused Explain why. Don't start with this "an owner should spend"/"they owe it to us/city"/"it's bad PR" crap. That's been MLB baseball since oh about forever. Explain why there's any reason for someone to invest in a poor fan base, unresponsive market and stadium with a crap lease.
August 20, 200818 yr Name another team in an unsupportive market and a crap stadium lease. Name me another team that makes more $$ than what it spends on its payroll before it sells a single ticket, who's owner uses his own "salary" to help show a loss in the books, a team that gets multiple millions from revenue sharing, TV contracts, and MLB.com-and an owner he simply refuses to put it back into the team. There is no way the marlins arent extremely profitiable. The system set up makes them money makers. Their payroll could be doubled what it currently is and they would still be very far ahead. Yes the attendance and lease suck, but that doesnt stop the team from being extremely profitable from MLB wellfare alone. And I know this wont be popular, but I too dont think the state should put up money for a stadium. Not until Loria shows he is willing to keep a team together. Giving Hanely a big contract but flat out refusing to put a no trade clause in there doesn't help his cause. And not until Loria shows his books to an independent third party, to see once and for all that this franchise is destitute, which he wont do because there is simply no way that is the case.
August 20, 200818 yr This team's small payroll makes it a lot tougher to improve at our weak positions, which might have made the difference between our team making or missing the playoffs (see CF and C). I find it very interesting how badly our offense has performed since the trade deadline passed.
August 20, 200818 yr Name another team in an unsupportive market and a crap stadium lease. Name me another team that makes more $ than what it spends on its payroll before it sells a single ticket, who's owner uses his own "salary" to help show a loss in the books, a team that gets multiple millions from revenue sharing, TV contracts, and MLB.com-and an owner he simply refuses to put it back into the team. There is no way the marlins arent extremely profitiable. The system set up makes them money makers. Their payroll could be doubled what it currently is and they would still be very far ahead. Yes the attendance and lease suck, but that doesnt stop the team from being extremely profitable from MLB wellfare alone. And I know this wont be popular, but I too dont think the state should put up money for a stadium. Not until Loria shows he is willing to keep a team together. Giving Hanely a big contract but flat out refusing to put a no trade clause in there doesn't help his cause. And not until Loria shows his books to an independent third party, to see once and for all that this franchise is destitute, which he wont do because there is simply no way that is the case. You don't have a single fact to back one thing up you say...over and over and over and over and over...
August 20, 200818 yr Giving Hanely a big contract but flat out refusing to put a no trade clause in there doesn't help his cause. Really? I'm not a big Loria fan either...but I'm thrilled Hanley Ramirez did not get a no-trade clause. No-trade clauses are the stupidest thing, in sports. Nothing's a guarantee, and every no-trade clause is a risk. Plus, if the organization feels like they want to move a guy to get better value...they should absolutely have that power. No-trade clauses are stupid.
August 20, 200818 yr Name another team in an unsupportive market and a crap stadium lease. Name me another team that makes more $ than what it spends on its payroll before it sells a single ticket, who's owner uses his own "salary" to help show a loss in the books, a team that gets multiple millions from revenue sharing, TV contracts, and MLB.com-and an owner he simply refuses to put it back into the team. There is no way the marlins arent extremely profitiable. The system set up makes them money makers. Their payroll could be doubled what it currently is and they would still be very far ahead. Yes the attendance and lease suck, but that doesnt stop the team from being extremely profitable from MLB wellfare alone. And I know this wont be popular, but I too dont think the state should put up money for a stadium. Not until Loria shows he is willing to keep a team together. Giving Hanely a big contract but flat out refusing to put a no trade clause in there doesn't help his cause. And not until Loria shows his books to an independent third party, to see once and for all that this franchise is destitute, which he wont do because there is simply no way that is the case. You don't have a single fact to back one thing up you say...over and over and over and over and over... Umm, how much do they make from revenue sharing? From MLB.com? From local media contracts? Roughly $20 million each right around? Divide that by 3 and you have the payroll, without selling a single ticket. Neither you or rFerry have facts, you just wait until someone posts and tells them they are wrong. That is your modus operandi, even though your arguments-as far as Loria goes-routinely lack anything resembling substance.
August 20, 200818 yr Oh, please...it just gets so boring after a while listening to this garbage from you. You haters, you liars, you come you go, the style is always the same, guilty until proven innocent. Neither MLB (the other owners or mgmt), the city or county would be making the investment in time or energy they have here if a shred of your insanity were true. Eventually you'll slither away and some other crackpot will take your place, with the same baseless accusations and rhetoric. It's frankly embarrassing to see shills like you thinking they can infect this messageboard again and again.
August 20, 200818 yr The county, state, MLB, etc. have done what they have in spite of Loria, who has gone out of his way to offer up as little as possible to the project. And you still havent answered how a team that earns 10s of millions from multiple sources before even selling a ticket and fields a payroll that is at best a third of that is somehow losing money.
August 20, 200818 yr Even if the economics of baseball were to increase revenue sharing or somehow be more friendly to small market teams, the Marlins wouldn't be in much better position than they are. It would merely help teams like Pittsburgh, with a new revenue-generating stadium, or Minnesota, with a supportive fan base, or Milwaukee with both. We have neither. The answer is to make Marlins a team in which an investment in a good player actually nets some benefit to the team's owner. I think you have it all wrong. :confused Explain why. Don't start with this "an owner should spend"/"they owe it to us/city"/"it's bad PR" crap. That's been MLB baseball since oh about forever. Explain why there's any reason for someone to invest in a poor fan base, unresponsive market and stadium with a crap lease. What I meant was, you have no idea what you are talking about when you say "crappy fan base". Let me start out by stating a basic fact most Marlins fans know. That is that they rank 7th out of 30 in the MLB in total TV audience. Now I'll give you a list as to why the Marlins have such dismal attendance. 1. Every other game has a chance of a rain delay. 2. South Florida is one of the hottest markets that has an MLB team, which means very few people attend afternoon games. 3. The Marlins have no tradition whatsoever, unlike many other MLB teams who have been around for several decades. 4. Maybe only a couple thousand seats face home plate at Dolphin stadium. This causes (at least for me) neck problems. 5. The Marlins arguably have one of the worst owners in the MLB, if not the worst. He has an "annual tradition" of trading away the best players on the team for prospects. 6. As a follow up to number 5, trading away the best players means the Marlins have very low expectations for the season, which means the Marlins sell very few season tickets. Those are just a few that I came up with on the spot. The list can go on and on and on. If you still don't believe the Marlins have/will have a supportive fan base, lets look at the other teams in South Florida. 1. The Dolphins are one of the most popular teams in the NFL. 2. The Heat have finished in the Top 5 in attendance in the NBA for the past three or four years. 3. Last season, the Panthers finished 25th in attendance, and finished 19th out of 30 in TV ratings. That was also when they had a terrible season. Just imagine what those figures will be like when they are near the top. Not to mention, this is South Florida, where hockey is no where near as popular as in the Northeast. If you think the Marlins don't deserve a new stadium, then I think you're crazy. South Florida is a great market and deserves a baseball team, whether you think so or not.
August 20, 200818 yr Jimmy, Name me another team that makes more $$ than what it spends on its payroll before it sells a single ticket --- Uhh, every team. That's kind of the point. The Marlins don't have the extra revenue sources - large media contracts, advertising, licensing/sponsoring deals. For the Marlins to break even (or profit as they have a right to), they know they must keep expenses, such as payroll, low. And that's before a single ticket sold. We know where the Marlins rank when that comes in play. But it hits hardest when those few come through the gates with a lease that restricts shares of gameday revenues. Who's owner uses his own "salary" to help show a loss in the books --- No proof. No credible accusation. Nothing at all. It's very common for the owner and business' finances to be connected. However, what you suggest often makes little sense considering the tax rates on personal income vs. business or capital gains. And what you suggests would cause a huge uproar among the minority owners. A team that gets multiple millions from revenue sharing, TV contracts, and MLB.com-and an owner he simply refuses to put it back into the team. --- No proof. The spirit of revenue sharing was for improvements but those stretch from anything from new free agents to resigning players to amateur signing bonuses to coaching and scouting salaries to ballpark improvements. The possibilities are endless and do not always show on the field as clearly as they do on the balance sheet. There is no way the marlins arent extremely profitiable. --- No proof. In fact, nearly every one suggests they are not. Even Loria's detractors say the Marlins are in bad shape. Forbes estimates the team profited an average of $6 million per year (before taxes, depreciation, amortization and interest) during the Loria era. With excessive losses in 2003-5 and wild profits in 2007-8. The trend suggests that the only way the Marlins can be profitable is with a crap payroll. The system set up makes them money makers. --- The system makes them a major league franchise rather than without owners and contracted. More than any other team, the Marlins rely on revenue sharing because the stadium revenues and media contracts are well below average. That $6 million figure estimated by Forbes includes revenue sharing. So, assuming ~$25 million in revenue sharing transfers (Marlins got $20 in 2003, likely more since higher league-wide revenues and Expos moving), essentially the Marlins have lost $20 million each year during the Loria era. Without that system, no one would want to own the financial sinkhole that would be the Marlins. Their payroll could be doubled what it currently is and they would still be very far ahead. --- No proof. No one can determine that by the Marlins themselves. However, to what purpose does doubling the payroll serve? What free agents want to come here or players want to stay knowing that the team is in bad shape and constant flux? There's little to no stability. You can't expect the owners to make an investment when Delgado, LoDuca, Encarnacion, Lowell, Leiter, Benitez, etc. not only failed to noticeably increase attendance or complete stadium negotiations but also win many games. There's no incentive. Yes the attendance and lease suck, but that doesnt stop the team from being extremely profitable from MLB wellfare alone. --- No proof. And quite laughable on its face. You're looking at just the revenues and ignoring that gameday revenues are the largest percentage a team makes. Not only are the Marlins' restrained, their media contracts are below average. Use some basic logic. How does a team profit if they're revenues are low unless also their expenses are also low? MLB welfare? You realize that the MLB welfare system was designed by the owners and passed with an overwhelming majority vote. It's a support system, not a pot of gold. And I know this wont be popular, but I too dont think the state should put up money for a stadium. --- That's fine if you have that opinion. But realize that's a deal killer for MLB. Every franchise in MLB has won major concessions from local municipalities whether it was a low-rent stadium (essentially everywhere), infrastructure (NYC), land (SF), tax breaks, financing, etc. Not until Loria shows he is willing to keep a team together. --- As a fan, I object. Only when the team should be kept together. Like 2003 when there was a credible attempt to, and maybe 2004 when there was promise on all fronts. But good riddance to the likes of Mike Lowell, Juan Encarnacion and Mike Jacobs. And if we can get some value from Dan Uggla, Cliff Floyd and Carlos Delgado, then good. Giving Hanely a big contract but flat out refusing to put a no trade clause in there doesn't help his cause. --- Yet it helps him cover his and the team's butt if they can not afford the deal in the future. Every team is bound by certain limitations, the Marlins just happen to be more severe than most. There's no point in placing even more limitations on the club. And not until Loria shows his books to an independent third party, to see once and for all that this franchise is destitute, which he wont do because there is simply no way that is the case. --- He won't. He doesn't have to. And MLB would throw a fit.
August 20, 200818 yr Let me start out by stating a basic fact most Marlins fans know. That is that they rank 7th out of 30 in the MLB in total TV audience. Which means ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! It's the media contracts that count. Also, no one wants to hear your excuses for why people don't attend games. We've heard them. We have that thread every week. I am a loyal Marlins fan. Been so since the mid-90s. I'm looking forward to many more years in South Florida at a new ballpark. While I may be skeptical if it will be as much as success as some say, I contend it is needed to return MLB - real MLB - back to South Florida. Right now, Huizenga/Henry/Loria/anyone has no incentive to trust the market or its fan base.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.