Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

McPherson signs

Featured Replies

...not really

 

we'd be better off with Emilio there.

 

the guy has put up a mid-.600 OPS two years running.

 

Emilio could do that, and play better defense.

 

If Wes could put up a mid.700 OPS, with his defense, yeah he'd be a fine third baseman. But in over his last 500+ ABs, he's had a ~.650 OPS.

...not really

 

we'd be better off with Emilio there.

 

the guy has put up a mid-.600 OPS two years running.

 

Emilio could do that, and play better defense.

 

If Wes could put up a mid.700 OPS, with his defense, yeah he'd be a fine third baseman. But in over his last 500+ ABs, he's had a ~.650 OPS.

 

I still like him on the roster. Going into the season with only Cantu as a veteran corner IF would be worrisome IMO, especially given his poor defense.

 

We have a solid defensive corner IF vet and a solid bat corner IF vet. Plus lots of young talent. This is a good thing. Thats (at least part of) the point that Pan made, and I agree. Lotta options, who knows how it will play out, but I dont think one of them necessarily has to be shipped out.

Still gonna have to battle Bonifacio for a roster spot. I'd give Emilio the slight edge because of his defensive abilities.

100% incorrect.

 

McPherson is a lock. Bonifacio can be optioned to AAA.

 

This.

 

Dallas could be huge for us off the bench, if he's willing to take that role. A power lefty bat off the bench is a huge asset, and its the type of bat we are seriously lacking. He's also the best option within the organization to take over at third if Gaby doesn't pan out at first.

 

My guess is Bonifacio will be a September call up. Once we decline to give Amezaga arby in 2010, Bonifacio steps in as the replacement.

Wrong.

 

And you were questioning someone else for lack of reasoning?

What has been the theme of this offseason? Defense. Bonifacio is a much better defensive player than McPherson. It's amazing how much love McPherson gets just because he hit a bunch of home runs in a pure hitter's league. The guy has done nothing to prove he can even stay healthy for a full season let alone be an affective infielder or hit at the major league level.

I wasn't aware that Emilio had done any of that either.

 

The "love" dallas get is so distraughtly blown out of proportion by his antagonists.

 

For all that he hasn't "proved", he has a career .816 MLB OPS against RHP. And that's all any of the Dallas "lovers" are looking for, a solid OPS against RHP. For all that he hasn't "proved", he has shown to be an average 3b defensively.

 

Nobody expects Dallas to come up and hit 40 HRs with a 1.000+ OPS. So stop acting like they do.

I wasn't aware that Emilio had done any of that either.

 

The "love" dallas get is so distraughtly blown out of proportion by his antagonists.

 

For all that he hasn't "proved", he has a career .816 MLB OPS against RHP. And that's all any of the Dallas "lovers" are looking for, a solid OPS against RHP. For all that he hasn't "proved", he has shown to be an average 3b defensively.

 

Nobody expects Dallas to come up and hit 40 HRs with a 1.000+ OPS. So stop acting like they do.

A career .955 FP is average?

Just like Cantu last spring, there's a bunch of players who have something to "prove" and some will while others won't.

 

McPherson, Bonifacio, maybe Sanchez and after last season's benching perhaps even Hermida, not to mention the dozen or so fringe players all of whom have high hopes of making their way onto a major league roster are going to fight it our for the few available roster spots truly up for grabs this spring.

 

I like the competition and seeing who rises and who falls. Maybe McPherson was smart enough to take a couple thousand balls in left field this off-season, or DLC has gotten his head straight after being thrown to the wolves last summer, I for one am excited about spring training and seeing what a healthy Dallas McPherson is really all about.

A career .955 FP is average?

 

You're choice to look at such an inane statistic.

Also, using your logic, Emilio is a poor defensive player.

 

.959 career FP

 

You've stated Dallas has proven nothing with the bat at the MLB level (although he has) and that he's a poor defensive player because of his fielding percent. And yet Emilio has 4 thousandth of a point advantage in FP. Somehow his .629 MLB OPS and .959 FP is Emilio proving himself at the major league level, and yet Dallas's supperior numbers are the exact opposite? Your "logic" just makes no sense.

We have about 5 corner infielders, and...3 outfielders? There's gotta be a trade upcoming. Especially when you consider we have "The Great" :rolleyes: Wes Helms for not 1...but 2 years.

Also, using your logic, Emilio is a poor defensive player.

 

.959 career FP

 

You've stated Dallas has proven nothing with the bat at the MLB level (although he has) and that he's a poor defensive player because of his fielding percent. And yet Emilio has 4 thousandth of a point advantage in FP. Somehow his .629 MLB OPS and .959 FP is Emilio proving himself at the major league level, and yet Dallas's supperior numbers are the exact opposite? Your "logic" just makes no sense.

Like RF better? Bonifacio is three full points better at just as if not a more physically demanding position.

You just completely missed my point.

 

Emilio is a better defensive player. I was never saything he wasn't.

 

I was saying that Dallas is an average defensive third baseman. You're saying that he isn't, and I was proving that your "proof" was inane and filled with holes.

 

(RF is a god awful statistic aswell)

(RF is a god awful statistic aswell)

Probably the next best way to judge defense after +/-. And since I don't have access to +/-, I use it a lot.

 

And if you'd show me where I said that McPherson was an awful defensive player or a worse hitter than Emilio, I'd appreciate it.

 

McPherson has certainly done more offensively. My reasoning for saying that Bonifacio has a slight advantage was because of the fact that he is better defensively and that has been the focus of our offseason dealings. Not to mention the fact we got 30+ home run production out of our starting 3B last season.

(RF is a god awful statistic aswell)

Probably the next best way to judge defense after +/-. And since I don't have access to +/-, I use it a lot.

 

And if you'd show me where I said that McPherson was an awful defensive player or a worse hitter than Emilio, I'd appreciate it.

 

McPherson has certainly done more offensively. My reasoning for saying that Bonifacio has a slight advantage was because of the fact that he is better defensively and that has been the focus of our offseason dealings. Not to mention the fact we got 30+ home run production out of our starting 3B last season.

 

 

You said Bonifacio was MUCH BETTER than McPherson defensively...and that the "love" for McPherson here is ridiculous b/c of his 1 year in Albuquerque. You sure made him sound close to terrible.

 

As for "not to mention the fact we got 30+ HR production out of our starting 3B last season" is quite hypocritical, considering sticking Cantu at 3B for a full year now goes AGAINST your "defense" argument.

(RF is a god awful statistic aswell)

Probably the next best way to judge defense after +/-. And since I don't have access to +/-, I use it a lot.

 

And if you'd show me where I said that McPherson was an awful defensive player or a worse hitter than Emilio, I'd appreciate it.

 

McPherson has certainly done more offensively. My reasoning for saying that Bonifacio has a slight advantage was because of the fact that he is better defensively and that has been the focus of our offseason dealings. Not to mention the fact we got 30+ home run production out of our starting 3B last season.

 

 

You said Bonifacio was MUCH BETTER than McPherson defensively...and that the "love" for McPherson here is ridiculous b/c of his 1 year in Albuquerque. You sure made him sound close to terrible.

 

As for "not to mention the fact we got 30+ HR production out of our starting 3B last season" is quite hypocritical, considering sticking Cantu at 3B for a full year now goes AGAINST your "defense" argument.

How does it go against my statement about defense? We've got the offensive guy in Cantu and the defensive guy in Bonifacio to spell or even platoon with him. Not sure what you mean here.

(RF is a god awful statistic aswell)

Probably the next best way to judge defense after +/-. And since I don't have access to +/-, I use it a lot.

 

And if you'd show me where I said that McPherson was an awful defensive player or a worse hitter than Emilio, I'd appreciate it.

 

McPherson has certainly done more offensively. My reasoning for saying that Bonifacio has a slight advantage was because of the fact that he is better defensively and that has been the focus of our offseason dealings. Not to mention the fact we got 30+ home run production out of our starting 3B last season.

 

 

You said Bonifacio was MUCH BETTER than McPherson defensively...and that the "love" for McPherson here is ridiculous b/c of his 1 year in Albuquerque. You sure made him sound close to terrible.

 

As for "not to mention the fact we got 30+ HR production out of our starting 3B last season" is quite hypocritical, considering sticking Cantu at 3B for a full year now goes AGAINST your "defense" argument.

How does it go against my statement about defense? We've got the offensive guy in Cantu and the defensive guy in Bonifacio to spell or even platoon with him. Not sure what you mean here.

 

Cantu starting at 3B everyday makes the defense worse...that's my point. Bonifacio can't platoon at a corner infield spot, b/c Bonifacio can't hit.

(RF is a god awful statistic aswell)

Probably the next best way to judge defense after +/-. And since I don't have access to +/-, I use it a lot.

 

And if you'd show me where I said that McPherson was an awful defensive player or a worse hitter than Emilio, I'd appreciate it.

 

McPherson has certainly done more offensively. My reasoning for saying that Bonifacio has a slight advantage was because of the fact that he is better defensively and that has been the focus of our offseason dealings. Not to mention the fact we got 30+ home run production out of our starting 3B last season.

 

 

You said Bonifacio was MUCH BETTER than McPherson defensively...and that the "love" for McPherson here is ridiculous b/c of his 1 year in Albuquerque. You sure made him sound close to terrible.

 

As for "not to mention the fact we got 30+ HR production out of our starting 3B last season" is quite hypocritical, considering sticking Cantu at 3B for a full year now goes AGAINST your "defense" argument.

How does it go against my statement about defense? We've got the offensive guy in Cantu and the defensive guy in Bonifacio to spell or even platoon with him. Not sure what you mean here.

 

Cantu starting at 3B everyday makes the defense worse...that's my point. Bonifacio can't platoon at a corner infield spot, b/c Bonifacio can't hit.

Close to a career .700 OPS against RHP in the majors. Again, McPherson is better offensively but Bonifacio can get the job done and his defense is ten times better. Not sure why you think he "can't hit".

Close to a career .700 OPS against RHP in the majors.

 

 

And that's what you want from a corner infield spot? A .685 .OPS isn't worthy of a platoon spot at any position, much less an offensive-oriented position.

And that's what you want from a corner infield spot? A .685 .OPS isn't worthy of a platoon spot at any position, much less an offensive-oriented position.

Even while the other guy's OPSing .800+?

And that's what you want from a corner infield spot? A .685 .OPS isn't worthy of a platoon spot at any position, much less an offensive-oriented position.

From a backup or platoon partner while the other guy is OPSing .800+?

 

 

There's a difference between a backup and a platoon partner.

If you want a platoon, it would be a better idea to put in the guy with an .800+ .OPS against right handed pitching, no?

 

There's a reason why there aren't too many 3B around the league with a .685 .OPS.

 

Having speed and defense is a good thing, but not worthy of sacrificing such a differential in offensive production.

And that's what you want from a corner infield spot? A .685 .OPS isn't worthy of a platoon spot at any position, much less an offensive-oriented position.

From a backup or platoon partner while the other guy is OPSing .800+?

 

 

There's a difference between a backup and a platoon partner.

If you want a platoon, it would be a better idea to put in the guy with an .800+ .OPS against right handed pitching, no?

 

There's a reason why there aren't too many 3B around the league with a .685 .OPS.

 

Having speed and defense is a good thing, but not worthy of sacrificing such a differential in offensive production.

By the way, just to point out, we're basing this guy's offensive self around 192 major league at bats. And to remind you, we gave up Willingham and Olsen to get him. Don't you think he should be given the benefit of the doubt over a guy who's only real area of contribution is one we are rich in already as evident by how many homers we hit last year and the trading of Jacobs?

 

Since when are we conventional anyways? I don't give a sh*t if our power comes from third base, left field, catcher or from section 410, as long as we have some. Making Bonifacio the backup second baseman or platoon partner to Cantu over McPherson isn't going to halt our overall power production, not to mention he'll make us better in what was a huge problem area last year, defense.

 

Maybe I'm alone in my opinion and if I am, that's fine with me.

And that's what you want from a corner infield spot? A .685 .OPS isn't worthy of a platoon spot at any position, much less an offensive-oriented position.

From a backup or platoon partner while the other guy is OPSing .800+?

 

 

There's a difference between a backup and a platoon partner.

If you want a platoon, it would be a better idea to put in the guy with an .800+ .OPS against right handed pitching, no?

 

There's a reason why there aren't too many 3B around the league with a .685 .OPS.

 

Having speed and defense is a good thing, but not worthy of sacrificing such a differential in offensive production.

By the way, just to point out, we're basing this guy's offensive self around 192 major league at bats. And to remind you, we gave up Willingham and Olsen to get him. Don't you think he should be given the benefit of the doubt over a guy who's only real area of contribution is one we are rich in already as evident by how many homers we hit last year and the trading of Jacobs?

 

Since when are we conventional anyways? I don't give a sh*t if our power comes from third base, left field, catcher or from section 410, as long as we have some. Making Bonifacio the backup second baseman or platoon partner to Cantu over McPherson isn't going to halt our overall power production, not to mention he'll make us better in what was a huge problem area last year, defense.

 

No, I'm not really basing it on 192 at bats; I was just using your criteria to be nice.

Fact is, Bonfacio had a .702 .OPS in his minor league career. By comparison, McPherson's minor league .OPS = .966. Just b/c we got him (Bonifacio) for Olsen and Willingham doesn't mean anything. There are good trades and there are bad trades, and this just so happens to be a bad trade. Look at stats, scouting reports, etc. All lead you to believe that Bonifacio, at best, will be nothing more than a utility player. Best case scenario is that he becomes our next Amezaga.

And that's what you want from a corner infield spot? A .685 .OPS isn't worthy of a platoon spot at any position, much less an offensive-oriented position.

From a backup or platoon partner while the other guy is OPSing .800+?

 

 

There's a difference between a backup and a platoon partner.

If you want a platoon, it would be a better idea to put in the guy with an .800+ .OPS against right handed pitching, no?

 

There's a reason why there aren't too many 3B around the league with a .685 .OPS.

 

Having speed and defense is a good thing, but not worthy of sacrificing such a differential in offensive production.

By the way, just to point out, we're basing this guy's offensive self around 192 major league at bats. And to remind you, we gave up Willingham and Olsen to get him. Don't you think he should be given the benefit of the doubt over a guy who's only real area of contribution is one we are rich in already as evident by how many homers we hit last year and the trading of Jacobs?

 

Since when are we conventional anyways? I don't give a sh*t if our power comes from third base, left field, catcher or from section 410, as long as we have some. Making Bonifacio the backup second baseman or platoon partner to Cantu over McPherson isn't going to halt our overall power production, not to mention he'll make us better in what was a huge problem area last year, defense.

 

No, I'm not really basing it on 192 at bats; I was just using your criteria to be nice.

Fact is, Bonfacio had a .702 .OPS in his minor league career. By comparison, McPherson's minor league .OPS = .966. Just b/c we got him (Bonifacio) for Olsen and Willingham doesn't mean anything. There are good trades and there are bad trades, and this just so happens to be a bad trade. Look at stats, scouting reports, etc. All lead you to believe that Bonifacio, at best, will be nothing more than a utility player. Best case scenario is that he becomes our next Amezaga.

The fact that he was an average MiLB hitter in his early 20s means absolutely nothing to me. As for scouting reports, depending on your source, they're nothing more than (un)educated guesses. I remember reading a scouting report on Hanley that said he would never become a good hitter because of the shoulder problems he had early in his career.

 

The trade means nothing? So you'd throw two good players at a division rival in return for a 24-year-old and then just say "Oh well, we made a bad trade" before the guy even takes the field for you?

 

Come on.

I can't let myself believe that we gave up both Olsen and Willingham for a backup. I believe he will contribute much more than he is being given credit for.

 

As for his lack of offense, I'm ok w/ that. This team can use his defensive prowess. I remember having Lowell, Gonzalez, and Castillo in our infield. Damn, that was nice to have those gloves behind our pitchers. Would be nice to head in that direction once again.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.