Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Maybin sent to AAA

Featured Replies

Well, us "Bonifacio haterz" are looking pretty good, at the moment.

 

congratulations. the leadoff hitter on [y]our favorite club sucks and you called it.

 

So when we're right, this is what you're gonna comeback with?

"I'm right because I agree with the FO."

 

I agree that this is intellectually lazy. However, I haven't seen anyone say this but you.

 

Here is the OP you replied to, you'll notice it says nothing along lines of "i'm right because":

 

This is the right move.

 

Getting Boner out of the lineup is also the right move. One of these will not happen.

 

And before someone (bronco) comes in spouting a bunch of crap about "Boners showing a willingness to work hard and improve and blah blah blah", how do we know each and every one of these guys who is struggling isn't doing that? They are major leaguers? Why are some people willing to give Boni the benefit of the doubt in this regard?

 

I'm not even picking on Bonifacio. I think Uggla and Cody need time off too.

Because the FO and Coaching staff are doing it as well, and they generally have a more complete picture of what each player can do or is doing.

 

BTW, anyone know who is getting the call up to take his spot?

 

The issue at hand was the notion of a 'benefit of the doubt'. A fan who bestows this upon their teams FO is not intellectually lazy, they are simply optimistic. So I see the comment of "oh and the FO is never wrong :rolleyes: " as, essentially, trying to argue with optimism, which just sort of rubs me the wrong way.

If anyone is the Golden Boy it's Bonifacio(ut). He continues to suck, and yet he's still leading off.

The issue at hand was the notion of a 'benefit of the doubt'. A fan who bestows this upon their teams FO is not intellectually lazy, they are simply optimistic. So I see the comment of "oh and the FO is never wrong :rolleyes: " as, essentially, trying to argue with optimism, which just sort of rubs me the wrong way.

 

So you've really never seen someone say "Well I'm going to go ahead and take their word for it over yours"?

 

You have, because you just said something along those lines like 4 posts ago.

 

That is intellectually lazy. That is basically saying "Since I agree with the FO, this discussion doesn't need to happen because they have to be right by default."

 

If anything, the Boner Experience has been a first hand look at how boneheaded our FO can be at times. If anything, deferring to them has about a 50-50 chance of being the wrong move.

 

 

And the OP wasn't giving the FO the benefit of the doubt, he was giving Boner the benefit of the doubt solely because the FO was. That is intellectually lazy.

If anyone is the Golden Boy it's Bonifacio(ut). He continues to suck, and yet he's still leading off.

 

 

BOOM!

I don't think sending Maybin down over Bonifacio has anything to do with the Marlins having more faith in him. I think it has more to do with the fact Maybin still has the potential to develop into the player he is/was projected to possibly end up being while Bonifacio isn't really expected to be much more than he already is. Maybe I am wrong in this, but that is the way I see it.

 

There is also the fact that we traded Willingham and Olsen for Bonifacio - two players we could use right now. Hell, the Marlins already called up Coghlan - some may say rushed Coghlan - to fill the void and on top of that have him playing leftfield! If Bonifacio is sent down, it throws the Marlins in even more disarray.

 

Add on top of that the team playing another game of pitching musical chairs now that the team's rotation consists of Nolasco, Johnson, Volstad, Fill-in-the-blank, and Fill-in-the-blank and you get the picture.

I don't think sending Maybin down over Bonifacio has anything to do with the Marlins having more faith in him. I think it has more to do with the fact Maybin still has the potential to develop into the player he is/was projected to possibly end up being while Bonifacio isn't really expected to be much more than he already is. Maybe I am wrong in this, but that is the way I see it.

 

I absolutely could not agree more with this. But when there are people saying Boner has outperformed Maybin, well that's flat out not true.

 

If anything, he's had more negative value because of the added PAs from leading off.

So when we're right, this is what you're gonna comeback with?

 

This post really says it all.

 

Maybe you should bump the Erick's World thread so everyone can know how right you are.

 

Sorry for the pithiness, but I honestly don't care and have no comeback prepared.

That is basically saying "Since I agree with the FO, this discussion doesn't need to happen because they have to be right by default."

 

Keep making up sentences and putting them in quotes. :thumbup

 

I never try to silence people around here. Post whatever you want. I may chose to side with Fredi Gonzalez, though.

So when we're right, this is what you're gonna comeback with?

 

This post really says it all.

 

Maybe you should bump the Erick's World thread so everyone can know how right you are.

 

Sorry for the pithiness, but I honestly don't care and have no comeback prepared.

 

What does this post say?

 

Your point is that we shouldn't argue about this, and just trust the front office at all times. The front office CAN be WRONG, y'know?

 

Every front office gets it wrong, at some point.

 

There is no such thing as perfect.

 

For every right Beinfest has made (there have been plenty), there have been some wrongs (such as overrating speed this offseason with Bonifaciout).

That is basically saying "Since I agree with the FO, this discussion doesn't need to happen because they have to be right by default."

 

Keep making up sentences and putting them in quotes. :thumbup

 

I never try to silence people around here. Post whatever you want. I may chose to side with Fredi Gonzalez, though.

 

Wow.

 

Try rereading it. When I put "That is basically saying", it means that that is what is implied in posting that. If you disagree with my interpretation of that, that's fine, but don't call it making up. You're better than that.

That is basically saying "Since I agree with the FO, this discussion doesn't need to happen because they have to be right by default."

 

Keep making up sentences and putting them in quotes. :thumbup

 

I never try to silence people around here. Post whatever you want. I may chose to side with Fredi Gonzalez, though.

 

 

So you think Fredi Gonzalez last 2 lineups have been correctly put together? Really?

If anyone is the Golden Boy it's Bonifacio(ut). He continues to suck, and yet he's still leading off.

BOOM!

 

Haha score one more for team Erick! :thumbup

 

My calling Maybin "Golden Boy" only is meant to reflect how much people around here (and the fans in general) love him. He is a highly rated prospect, so its only fair that this would be the case. It is just ironic considering how much everyone wanted him leading off. I'll admit, I did too. But I chose not to make a big deal out of it at the time because this is baseball and anything can happen (even EB doing an brief Ichiro impression).

 

Anyhow, I agree with PBC's analysis. EB obviously does not have the same high ceiling as Maybin.

So you think Fredi Gonzalez last 2 lineups have been correctly put together? Really?

 

Well, just looking at today's lineup, you've got Wes Helms on the roster making .9 million, Wes Helms, getting playing time, and Wes Helms batting clean up. I'd say there are 3 mistakes right there.

That is basically saying "Since I agree with the FO, this discussion doesn't need to happen because they have to be right by default."

 

Keep making up sentences and putting them in quotes. :thumbup

 

I never try to silence people around here. Post whatever you want. I may chose to side with Fredi Gonzalez, though.

 

Wow.

 

Try rereading it. When I put "That is basically saying", it means that that is what is implied in posting that. If you disagree with my interpretation of that, that's fine, but don't call it making up. You're better than that.

 

Don't worry, I read it. I resent people taking my post and then incorrectly paraphrasing it. Even if they put the word basically in there.

 

Here's a good example:

 

 

Your point is that we shouldn't argue about this, and just trust the front office at all times.

 

Yea, I said that. :rolleyes:

If anyone is the Golden Boy it's Bonifacio(ut). He continues to suck, and yet he's still leading off.

BOOM!

 

Haha score one more for team Erick! :thumbup

 

My calling Maybin "Golden Boy" only is meant to reflect how much people around here (and the fans in general) love him. He is a highly rated prospect, so its only fair that this would be the case. It is just ironic considering how much everyone wanted him leading off. I'll admit, I did too. But I chose not to make a big deal out of it at the time because this is baseball and anything can happen (even EB doing an brief Ichiro impression).

 

Anyhow, I agree with PBC's analysis. EB obviously does not have the same high ceiling as Maybin.

 

Except that to a similarly sized portion of the fan base, Boner is just as much the Golden Boy and Maybin just as much the whipping boy. You apparently have Broncobob's posts ignored or else you would notice it sometime.

I don't think sending Maybin down over Bonifacio has anything to do with the Marlins having more faith in him. I think it has more to do with the fact Maybin still has the potential to develop into the player he is/was projected to possibly end up being while Bonifacio isn't really expected to be much more than he already is. Maybe I am wrong in this, but that is the way I see it.

 

I absolutely could not agree more with this. But when there are people saying Boner has outperformed Maybin, well that's flat out not true.

 

If anything, he's had more negative value because of the added PAs from leading off.

 

If there is no improvement in Bonifacio's performance, the my guess is the Marlins will do one of the following things: 1) Move Coghlan to 3B or platoon him with Bonifacio and have an OF of Hermida, Amezaga, and Ross 2) Leave Coghlan in LF with Ross and Hermida and have some kind of hodgepodge at 3B with Bonifacio/Helms/Amezaga 3) Call up Gaby to play 1B and move Cantu back to 3B.

 

None of these options are particularly appealing to me. Which is why Bonifacio has a long leash. But even the Marlins have to have a limit to their patience.

f*** it. Not worth it.

 

 

At some point though players have to be held accountable for their play, right? Wes Helms, Cody Ross, Uggla, Amezaga, and Boner can't keep going out there and being sub replacement level players without losing some playing time. If it means more PT for guys with even less potential than them just to light a fire under their asses, so be it. I hate the idea of Carroll playing more, but if Cody can't even OBP what maybin and Boner have, we can't keep him out there until he proves he can turn it around, and the same goes for all of those guys.

 

note, not that Carroll has done anything to prove he deserves a shot, this is more about making a point at this point in time. Sending Maybin down was making a point, let's not let it end there.

If anyone is the Golden Boy it's Bonifacio(ut). He continues to suck, and yet he's still leading off.

BOOM!

 

Haha score one more for team Erick! :thumbup

 

My calling Maybin "Golden Boy" only is meant to reflect how much people around here (and the fans in general) love him. He is a highly rated prospect, so its only fair that this would be the case. It is just ironic considering how much everyone wanted him leading off. I'll admit, I did too. But I chose not to make a big deal out of it at the time because this is baseball and anything can happen (even EB doing an brief Ichiro impression).

 

Anyhow, I agree with PBC's analysis. EB obviously does not have the same high ceiling as Maybin.

 

Maybin had the better spring, and we put him in the 8th spot. That is why everyone here wanted him leading off. It also had something to do with how amazing he did last September in the leadoff spot. Baker and Maybin dominated last year, and it should have been like that this year.

 

But then Bonifacio(ut) comes along. He takes the leadoff spot because the FO is convinced he can steal first base. Now we are stuck with him leading off because the FO doesn't want to be wrong. This is why we all bash Boner. Well, that's why I do, at least.

Maybin had the better spring, and we put him in the 8th spot. That is why everyone here wanted him leading off. It also had something to do with how amazing he did last September in the leadoff spot. Baker and Maybin dominated last year, and it should have been like that this year.

 

But then Bonifacio(ut) comes along. He takes the leadoff spot because the FO is convinced he can steal first base. Now we are stuck with him leading off because the FO doesn't want to be wrong. This is why we all bash Boner. Well, that's why I do, at least.

 

I don't think this is the main reason. A lack of an obviously better option would have to be a bigger reason.

 

In spite of Maybin's (marginally) better spring, maybe the coaches noticed a lack of maturity at the plate in Maybin (or an inability to hit curves). Speculative, sure, but here we are a month into the season and he's already in AAA. Its hard to argue that they were wrong to not lead off with him.

 

Sure, its also hard to argue that EB leading off is close to ideal. But for now we're gonna keep trying to make it work.

 

Bob-bob's point about more changes coming is well taken. Many guys in our lineup need to start turning it around.

f*** it. Not worth it.

 

 

At some point though players have to be held accountable for their play, right? Wes Helms, Cody Ross, Uggla, Amezaga, and Boner can't keep going out there and being sub replacement level players without losing some playing time. If it means more PT for guys with even less potential than them just to light a fire under their asses, so be it. I hate the idea of Carroll playing more, but if Cody can't even OBP what maybin and Boner have, we can't keep him out there until he proves he can turn it around, and the same goes for all of those guys.

 

note, not that Carroll has done anything to prove he deserves a shot, this is more about making a point at this point in time. Sending Maybin down was making a point, let's not let it end there.

 

Barring a trade, I think the Marlins are committed to an OF with Ross and Hermida. I don't see them moving them anytime this season unless a trade happens. They committed to that when they traded Willingham and put faith in Maybin putting up strong enough numbers to stay around.

If anyone is the Golden Boy it's Bonifacio(ut). He continues to suck, and yet he's still leading off.

BOOM!

 

Haha score one more for team Erick! :thumbup

 

My calling Maybin "Golden Boy" only is meant to reflect how much people around here (and the fans in general) love him. He is a highly rated prospect, so its only fair that this would be the case. It is just ironic considering how much everyone wanted him leading off. I'll admit, I did too. But I chose not to make a big deal out of it at the time because this is baseball and anything can happen (even EB doing an brief Ichiro impression).

 

Anyhow, I agree with PBC's analysis. EB obviously does not have the same high ceiling as Maybin.

 

 

Why "Golden Boy?" I haven't seen anyone on here saying that he's had a good year. When Fredi hits him 2nd, people on the gamethreads have been going as crazy as when they see Bonifacio(ut) leading off.

 

Seriously?

 

The only point being made about Maybin, at the moment, is that it's not fair to send him down, while Bonifacio(ut) is still here, LEADING OFF, despite being attrocious since the 1st week of the season.

 

Also, the reason people wanted Maybin to leadoff at the beginning of the year was not just because he was a "highly rated prospect" but also because Maybin did well last September.

 

Obviously, he still has some things to learn. The same things Bonifacio(ut) should be learning.

 

If you ask me, they did send the right guy down. Maybin has more potential, and is definitely part of the long-term here.

Maybin had the better spring, and we put him in the 8th spot. That is why everyone here wanted him leading off. It also had something to do with how amazing he did last September in the leadoff spot. Baker and Maybin dominated last year, and it should have been like that this year.

 

But then Bonifacio(ut) comes along. He takes the leadoff spot because the FO is convinced he can steal first base. Now we are stuck with him leading off because the FO doesn't want to be wrong. This is why we all bash Boner. Well, that's why I do, at least.

 

I don't think this is the main reason. A lack of an obviously better option would have to be a bigger reason.

 

In spite of Maybin's (marginally) better spring, maybe the coaches noticed a lack of maturity at the plate in Maybin (or an inability to hit curves). Speculative, sure, but here we are a month into the season and he's already in AAA. Its hard to argue that they were wrong to not lead off with him.

 

Sure, its also hard to argue that EB leading off is close to ideal. But for now we're gonna keep trying to make it work.

 

Bob-bob's point about more changes coming is well taken. Many guys in our lineup need to start turning it around.

 

Bull Sh!t. If Maybin is sent down for his bad play, Bonifacio(ut) should at least get benched for his horrid play.

Why "Golden Boy?" I haven't seen anyone on here saying that he's had a good year. When Fredi hits him 2nd, people on the gamethreads have been going as crazy as when they see Bonifacio(ut) leading off.

 

Seriously?

 

The only point being made about Maybin, at the moment, is that it's not fair to send him down, while Bonifacio(ut) is still here, LEADING OFF, despite being attrocious since the 1st week of the season.

 

Also, the reason people wanted Maybin to leadoff at the beginning of the year was not just because he was a "highly rated prospect" but also because Maybin did well last September.

 

Obviously, he still has some things to learn. The same things Bonifacio(ut) should be learning.

 

If you ask me, they did send the right guy down. Maybin has more potential, and is definitely part of the long-term here

 

I'm not talking about since the season started, as people have been understandably skeptical since then. Maybin was hyped and adored by Marlins fans from the moment he arrived from Detroit.

 

That being said, the great Sept that Maybin had is fairly comparable to the great start EB got off to. Neither should be completely discounted, but obviously neither is sustainable.

Maybin had the better spring, and we put him in the 8th spot. That is why everyone here wanted him leading off. It also had something to do with how amazing he did last September in the leadoff spot. Baker and Maybin dominated last year, and it should have been like that this year.

 

But then Bonifacio(ut) comes along. He takes the leadoff spot because the FO is convinced he can steal first base. Now we are stuck with him leading off because the FO doesn't want to be wrong. This is why we all bash Boner. Well, that's why I do, at least.

 

I don't think this is the main reason. A lack of an obviously better option would have to be a bigger reason.

 

In spite of Maybin's (marginally) better spring, maybe the coaches noticed a lack of maturity at the plate in Maybin (or an inability to hit curves). Speculative, sure, but here we are a month into the season and he's already in AAA. Its hard to argue that they were wrong to not lead off with him.

 

Sure, its also hard to argue that EB leading off is close to ideal. But for now we're gonna keep trying to make it work.

 

Bob-bob's point about more changes coming is well taken. Many guys in our lineup need to start turning it around.

 

How was Maybin's spring "marginally" better than Boner's?

 

.315/.378/.425/.803 Maybin.

.279/.326/.395/.721 Boner.

 

It was just better. No qualifier needed.

 

It's impossible to argue that Boner leading off is anything but putrid. He's got a pitcher's line since his first 5 games (people seem to be ignoring this.) ~.400 OPS is not a major league regular, let alone a guy you give the most ABs to.

 

There's no logical reason to keep trying to make it work. He's done absolutely nothing outside of 5 good games to deserve anything more than Amezaga's role.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.