Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Maybin sent to AAA

Featured Replies

Sure, its also hard to argue that EB leading off is close to ideal. But for now we're gonna keep trying to make it work.

Bull Sh!t. If Maybin is sent down for his bad play, Bonifacio(ut) should at least get benched for his horrid play.

 

Maybe. But where's the bull sh!t? Cuz I said we're gonna keep trying to make it work? Talk to Fredi about that one.

 

I would not mind seeing Hermida leading off at all. But I dont think we can take EB out of the lineup yet. Unless you wanna start Helms, Gload, or Amezaga. IMO these are not much better options.

Why "Golden Boy?" I haven't seen anyone on here saying that he's had a good year. When Fredi hits him 2nd, people on the gamethreads have been going as crazy as when they see Bonifacio(ut) leading off.

 

Seriously?

 

The only point being made about Maybin, at the moment, is that it's not fair to send him down, while Bonifacio(ut) is still here, LEADING OFF, despite being attrocious since the 1st week of the season.

 

Also, the reason people wanted Maybin to leadoff at the beginning of the year was not just because he was a "highly rated prospect" but also because Maybin did well last September.

 

Obviously, he still has some things to learn. The same things Bonifacio(ut) should be learning.

 

If you ask me, they did send the right guy down. Maybin has more potential, and is definitely part of the long-term here

 

I'm not talking about since the season started, as people have been understandably skeptical since then. Maybin was hyped and adored by Marlins fans from the moment he arrived from Detroit.

 

That being said, the great Sept that Maybin had is fairly comparable to the great start EB got off to. Neither should be completely discounted, but obviously neither is sustainable.

 

 

When we got Maybin, we had just traded our franchise player, and Maybin was 1 of 2 top 10 prospects (along with Miller) in all of baseball.

 

Of course we're going to get excited over that potential (that he still has, btw).

 

Forgive us, but Bonifacio(ut)'s minor league #'s didn't really leave the realists any reason to be optimistic. And he hasn't exactly showed much improvement. He still K's a lot, and he still doesn't draw many walks.

 

I said from Day 1, that Bonifacio(ut) would be ok with me...as a utility guy off the bench.

I've also stated several times that he would improve our defense...and he has done that, as well.

 

Say what you want, but it is what it is. Right now, Bonifacio(ut) looks like nothing more than a utility player, as the "haterz" said he would be b/c bottom line is...you can't steal 1B.

 

And Maybin gave people reason to be optimistic last year, as well. Not only did he outplay Bonifacio(ut) in Spring Training, as has been said, but his September in the big leagues + an .831 .OPS in AA at the age of 21 gave people a good reason for optimism.

Sure, its also hard to argue that EB leading off is close to ideal. But for now we're gonna keep trying to make it work.

Bull Sh!t. If Maybin is sent down for his bad play, Bonifacio(ut) should at least get benched for his horrid play.

 

Maybe. But where's the bull sh!t? Cuz I said we're gonna keep trying to make it work? Talk to Fredi about that one.

 

I would not mind seeing Hermida leading off at all. But I dont think we can take EB out of the lineup yet. Unless you wanna start Helms, Gload, or Amezaga. IMO these are not much better options.

 

Well, actually, the other option is Coghlan plays 3B. And you go with an outfield of Amezaga vs RHP and Carroll vs LHP (Hit for better contact in his MiLB career against lefties) or Gload for a few starts and see if it can't stick.

 

Right now, we're in a bit of a tough spot because of Cody and Uggla not hitting. If they get it going, we'll be ok. But you say you can't take EB out of the lineup. Yes you can. It's been said so many times, but he has ~.400 OPS since those first 5 games. There's nobody on the bench that won't improve on that. Nobody. He's completely lost right now, and I don't give a sh*t how many people want to say "he looks better out there". He doesn't. He looks as overmatched as Maybin did, he just didn't happen to flail at so many sliders to make it so obvious.

How was Maybin's spring "marginally" better than Boner's?

 

.315/.378/.425/.803 Maybin.

.279/.326/.395/.721 Boner.

 

It was just better. No qualifier needed.

 

Marginal simply because of the sample size. Maybin had 13 less ABs, got 1 less hit and 2 more BBs.

 

It's impossible to argue that Boner leading off is anything but putrid. He's got a pitcher's line since his first 5 games (people seem to be ignoring this.) ~.400 OPS is not a major league regular, let alone a guy you give the most ABs to.

 

There's no logical reason to keep trying to make it work. He's done absolutely nothing outside of 5 good games to deserve anything more than Amezaga's role.

 

The underlined portion is really pretty heavy-handed, IMO. Talk about over-stating your case. It may not be putrid because there is a lack of better options. He may not deserve anything more than Amezaga's role, but does that mean that Amezaga deserves his role?

 

I do not want to ignore how bad EB has been since his great start, but apparently some want to ignore his great start by constantly citing his numbers since then. Sure, it represents a disturbing trend but you can't take away those early ABs where he was playing well. A fluke? Maybe. But it's not like they didnt happen.

How was Maybin's spring "marginally" better than Boner's?

 

.315/.378/.425/.803 Maybin.

.279/.326/.395/.721 Boner.

 

It was just better. No qualifier needed.

 

Marginal simply because of the sample size. Maybin had 13 less ABs, got 1 less hit and 2 more BBs.

 

It's impossible to argue that Boner leading off is anything but putrid. He's got a pitcher's line since his first 5 games (people seem to be ignoring this.) ~.400 OPS is not a major league regular, let alone a guy you give the most ABs to.

 

There's no logical reason to keep trying to make it work. He's done absolutely nothing outside of 5 good games to deserve anything more than Amezaga's role.

 

The underlined portion is really pretty heavy-handed, IMO. Talk about over-stating your case. It may not be putrid because there is a lack of better options. He may not deserve anything more than Amezaga's role, but does that mean that Amezaga deserves his role?

 

I do not want to ignore how bad EB has been since his great start, but apparently some want to ignore his great start by constantly citing his numbers since then. Sure, it represents a disturbing trend but you can't take away those early ABs where he was playing well. A fluke? Maybe. But it's not like they didnt happen.

 

The great start is ignored b/c when you put it together with what he's done since...it's still mediocrity, at best. At least offensively, it is.

 

Also...regarding not taking him out of the lineup, you certainly can.

 

You can put Coghlan at 3B, and you don't even have to move Hermida b/c Ross Gload has experience in RF. And for what it's worth, Ross Gload is doing something that not many Marlins are doing, at the moment. Having great AB's & getting on base.

Well, actually, the other option is Coghlan plays 3B. And you go with an outfield of Amezaga vs RHP and Carroll vs LHP (Hit for better contact in his MiLB career against lefties) or Gload for a few starts and see if it can't stick.

 

This smells comparably putrid to me. If not more so. At some point it will come to giving more young guys a chance. I do not think much of Carroll or Amezaga at the plate, though. Have not seen much from Coghlan but there is reason to be intrigued/optimistic.

 

--------

 

Erick, I agree with your last post. I am definitely not trying to say we don't have good reason to be optimistic about Maybin. I hope no one is giving up on him yet.

Writing it off by saying it is "heavy-handed" is ignoring the truth. Even if you take his numbers as a whole including the 5 game stretch, he's the worst lead off hitter in baseball. That is putrid. There's no way a .594 is the best we can do because a good majority of AAA players could manage that.

 

And someone is undoubteldy going to come in and say judging a leadoff hitter by OPS isn't fair. Fine. .292 OBP. Still the worst leadoff hitter in baseball. We are f***ing Dusty Baker-ing our season away just because we don't want to "clog the bases" by putting guys who don't make outs on base.

 

I hate to bring up a bad word, but how much would having a guy like Dallas McPherson at least as an option change our tune on Boner?

Well, actually, the other option is Coghlan plays 3B. And you go with an outfield of Amezaga vs RHP and Carroll vs LHP (Hit for better contact in his MiLB career against lefties) or Gload for a few starts and see if it can't stick.

 

This smells comparably putrid to me. If not more so. At some point it will come to giving more young guys a chance. I do not think much of Carroll or Amezaga at the plate, though.

 

Oh, it likely would be just as bad. But you know what Boner is giving you, and it's not worth not taking a chance.

Writing it off by saying it is "heavy-handed" is ignoring the truth. Even if you take his numbers as a whole including the 5 game stretch, he's the worst lead off hitter in baseball. That is putrid. There's no way a .594 is the best we can do because a good majority of AAA players could manage that.

 

And someone is undoubteldy going to come in and say judging a leadoff hitter by OPS isn't fair. Fine. .292 OBP. Still the worst leadoff hitter in baseball. We are f***ing Dusty Baker-ing our season away just because we don't want to "clog the bases" by putting guys who don't make outs on base.

 

I hate to bring up a bad word, but how much would having a guy like Dallas McPherson at least as an option change our tune on Boner?

 

 

You do know what types of posts this is going to bring, right?

 

People will complain about how horrible he is, defensively, even though he wasn't, really. Then they will say "well, if Dallas is so good, why isn't he up in the big leagues?"

 

Dallas McPherson & Eulogio De La Cruz will always bring those types of posts.

I mean, at least McPherson would give us some flexibility. I understand where DD is coming from in saying that we have no clearly better options. Right now, is there anyone who doesn't think McDallas could give us >.600 OPS?

Writing it off by saying it is "heavy-handed" is ignoring the truth. Even if you take his numbers as a whole including the 5 game stretch, he's the worst lead off hitter in baseball. That is putrid. There's no way a .594 is the best we can do because a good majority of AAA players could manage that.

 

And someone is undoubteldy going to come in and say judging a leadoff hitter by OPS isn't fair. Fine. .292 OBP. Still the worst leadoff hitter in baseball. We are f***ing Dusty Baker-ing our season away just because we don't want to "clog the bases" by putting guys who don't make outs on base.

 

I hate to bring up a bad word, but how much would having a guy like Dallas McPherson at least as an option change our tune on Boner?

 

I'm not writing off anything. I agree that EB is struggling, I just cringe a little when I see things like "it is impossible to argue that...".

 

As far as feeling sorry about Dallas, I think if Gaby were healthy he would be an even better option.

 

Also, I agree with Erick that our best option with EB outa the lineup is Coghlan at 3B and Gload at corned OF. But this is hardly mouth-watering. No one has mentioned defense, either. IMO EB has been our best defensive IF this season. Not stellar, but still better than Hanley I think.

Writing it off by saying it is "heavy-handed" is ignoring the truth. Even if you take his numbers as a whole including the 5 game stretch, he's the worst lead off hitter in baseball. That is putrid. There's no way a .594 is the best we can do because a good majority of AAA players could manage that.

 

And someone is undoubteldy going to come in and say judging a leadoff hitter by OPS isn't fair. Fine. .292 OBP. Still the worst leadoff hitter in baseball. We are f***ing Dusty Baker-ing our season away just because we don't want to "clog the bases" by putting guys who don't make outs on base.

 

I hate to bring up a bad word, but how much would having a guy like Dallas McPherson at least as an option change our tune on Boner?

 

I'm not writing off anything. I agree that EB is struggling, I just cringe a little when I see things like "it is impossible to argue that...".

 

As far as feeling sorry about Dallas, I think if Gaby were healthy he would be an even better option.

 

Also, I agree with Erick that our best option with EB outa the lineup is Coghlan at 3B and Gload at corned OF. But this is hardly mouth-watering. No one has mentioned defense, either. IMO EB has been our best defensive IF this season. Not stellar, but still better than Hanley I think.

 

The fact Coghlan was called up & they had him playing the OF means that just like us...the Marlins are thinking about their offense, at the moment. Fredi even said he was willing to sacrifice a couple miscues, defensively, if it meant more offense.

 

This is, partially, Fredi's fault, as well. The last 2 lineups he's put together have been bad (and no, I'm not playing the result).

Also, I agree with Erick that our best option with EB outa the lineup is Coghlan at 3B and Gload at corned OF. But this is hardly mouth-watering. No one has mentioned defense, either. IMO EB has been our best defensive IF this season. Not stellar, but still better than Hanley I think.

 

I would argue with that. Cantu in my mind has been the most valuable glove on the infield this year, injured wrist and all. Bonifacio has been very solid, however. It is going off on a tangent, but who'd have thunk Cantu of all people would end up probably saving more runs on the infield up to this point this season than anyone else.

Also, I agree with Erick that our best option with EB outa the lineup is Coghlan at 3B and Gload at corned OF. But this is hardly mouth-watering. No one has mentioned defense, either. IMO EB has been our best defensive IF this season. Not stellar, but still better than Hanley I think.

 

I would argue with that. Cantu in my mind has been the most valuable glove on the infield this year, injured wrist and all. Bonifacio has been very solid, however. It is going off on a tangent, but who'd have thunk Cantu of all people would end up probably saving more runs on the infield up to this point this season than anyone else.

 

 

Not really surprising considering Cantu showed those skills last year, while playing 1B.

 

The one who's really improved, defensively, is Hanley.

I'm not writing off anything. I agree that EB is struggling, I just cringe a little when I see things like "it is impossible to argue that...".

 

As far as feeling sorry about Dallas, I think if Gaby were healthy he would be an even better option.

 

Also, I agree with Erick that our best option with EB outa the lineup is Coghlan at 3B and Gload at corned OF. But this is hardly mouth-watering. No one has mentioned defense, either. IMO EB has been our best defensive IF this season. Not stellar, but still better than Hanley I think.

 

I'm not feeling sorry about Dallas. I'm feeling sorry that we have no better options and he would at least give us another option. If Gaby were healthy, I'm not nessecarily sure he gives us a definite better option than McPherson but at least if we had McPherson (not questioning this move, by the way, since he had no intention of playing a back up role) we'd have another way to go.

 

As for defense:

 

Cantu: -1 runs saved

Uggla: -1

Hanley: 5

Bonifacio: 2

Hermida: 1

Maybin:-1

Ross:-2 (RF), 1 (CF)

Carroll: 1 (LF)

Amezaga: 2 (SS), 2 (CF)

Helms: 1 (1B), 1 (3B)

Gload: 0 (1B), 1 (RF)

 

Of course it's a small sample size, but I don't think i'm alone in thinking Hanley's finally living up to his full potential on both sides of the ball right now. He's playing like a man on fire, imo.

I would argue with that. Cantu in my mind has been the most valuable glove on the infield this year, injured wrist and all. Bonifacio has been very solid, however. It is going off on a tangent, but who'd have thunk Cantu of all people would end up probably saving more runs on the infield up to this point this season than anyone else.

 

Cantu has been quick and solid with the lefty hot corner plays, but his picks have had me slapping my head often. We have many inconsistent IFs and a different 1B who is better at dealing with balls in the dirt could have saved some Es.

 

And he clearly does not have the athleticism to make those aggressive range plays that EB (sometimes) makes look easy.

I would argue with that. Cantu in my mind has been the most valuable glove on the infield this year, injured wrist and all. Bonifacio has been very solid, however. It is going off on a tangent, but who'd have thunk Cantu of all people would end up probably saving more runs on the infield up to this point this season than anyone else.

 

Cantu has been quick and solid with the lefty hot corner plays, but his picks have had me slapping my head often. We have many inconsistent IFs and a different 1B who is better at dealing with balls in the dirt could have saved some Es.

 

And he clearly does not have the athleticism to make those aggressive range plays that EB (sometimes) makes look easy.

 

 

After the Mike Jacobs experience, Jorge Cantu looks like Gold Glove.

From what I've seen, Boner's biggest weakness is on reacting to poorly hit balls and bunts in front of him. He has allowed quite a number of bunt base hits because he's never had to charge in on a ball like that playing 2B.

Hanley has been spectacular. I still think he needs to take a more fundamental approach in the field to be a great defensive player, though.

 

He thinks his athleticism allows him to be a little cavalier, IMO, and he still has considerable room for improvement (on D). But I am not going to argue that Hanley has not been great this season, both sides.

 

 

 

edit: sorry for D-Railing the thread (sick pun) and good night

I honestly feel like our defense has been pretty good this season.

 

People are always going to get on Hermida because he'll have some mental lapses, but he's really only had one bad game and has been steady other wise. Ross should improve as well, and Maybin being our worst defensive player says a lot about how our team defense has improve.

it was clearly a bad move to pick Emilio Bonifacio over Dallas this spring, and the sad part is since they did that Dallas didn't get to play for a long period, and had to then spend 2 weeks rushing himself into playing shape, and had a minor set back with the giants.

 

He looks like he will ready soon tho, and expect the Giants to bring him up quick! The Marlins ruined this season for that guy had they done right by the guy who lead the entire franchise in HR last year, and given him a real shot at the 3rd base job this spring, and let him play in the bigs this season I'm sure things would be looking a lot nicer right now.

 

We would have the left handed power hitter we badly need, and Emilio would be in the role he was born for! PINCH RUNNER!

 

In AAA because honestly he's terrible in the majors even as a pinch runner! He can't steal even as fast as he is the guy is a terrible base stealer, and having Dallas in the line up would have at least balanced out the line up.

 

All that having EB in the line up do is give us an auto out! The guy is horrid, and will soon be shipped out to AAA along with his Strike out buddy.

 

Hey isn't Alejandro De Aza in AAA?

it was clearly a bad move to pick Emilio Bonifacio over Dallas this spring, and the sad part is since they did that Dallas didn't get to play for a long period, and had to then spend 2 weeks rushing himself into playing shape, and had a minor set back with the giants.

 

He looks like he will ready soon tho, and expect the Giants to bring him up quick! The Marlins ruined this season for that guy had they done right by the guy who lead the entire franchise in HR last year, and given him a real shot at the 3rd base job this spring, and let him play in the bigs this season I'm sure things would be looking a lot nicer right now.

 

We would have the left handed power hitter we badly need, and Emilio would be in the role he was born for! PINCH RUNNER!

 

In AAA because honestly he's terrible in the majors even as a pinch runner! He can't steal even as fast as he is the guy is a terrible base stealer, and having Dallas in the line up would have at least balanced out the line up.

 

All that having EB in the line up do is give us an auto out! The guy is horrid, and will soon be shipped out to AAA along with his Strike out buddy.

 

Hey isn't Alejandro De Aza in AAA?

Haha.

Dallas lost. Get over it. There was no place on the bench for another 3B or a pinch-hitter that strikes out often. He was let go.

Dude kills AAA pitching. Never the majors. Best of luck to him, but the Marlins picked the better (or least worst depending your perspective) of the two.

Well, right now mcdallas' never hitting MLB pitching career ops is about 150 points higher than what bonifacio Is giving us.

 

I'm sorry I brought it up though, because this is a tired discussion. Was just saying it wouldvr been nice to have another option, that's all.

Well, right now mcdallas' never hitting MLB pitching career ops is about 150 points higher than what bonifacio Is giving us.

 

I'm sorry I brought it up though, because this is a tired discussion. Was just saying it wouldvr been nice to have another option, that's all.

Emilio: .244 / .299 / .321

McDallas: .245 / .298 / .458

 

Another option would be nice. Would have been nice back in March too. But Sanchez wasn't ready yet (though maybe soon). McDallas was never the heir apparent some people thought he was.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.